This place is SO unassumming! My girl & I had passed by it several times during out weekend in…read moreCape May. But I was craving a breakfast sandwich so we came to check it out. WoW. From the outside you'd never know the treat that awaits you inside! Who knew there was an Orea flavored cream cheese? Or horseradish & cheddar? Or olive pimenta? Or bacon lox scallion? I kinda wish I would have discovered this place sooner so I could have sampled more of the flavors! Anyway, we both go the Lox w/Salmon/onions & capers with cream cheese on a bagel. And I couldn't finish it. I saved the second half for the next morning and it was still tasty! So, to summarize, you can choose your cream cheese and your bagel (everything bagel, wheat, plain, etc.). And of course they've got other items to choose from. Avocado toast was my second option. ...a hidden gem.

The service was absolutely amazing: friendly, attentive, and made us feel very welcome from the…read moremoment we walked in. The only downside was the food and coffee. We ordered toasted bagels, but they were barely toasted and tasted more like plain bagels. The coffee was unfortunately very disappointing as well. Even after adding half-and-half, I couldn't finish it because of the taste. The outstanding service is the reason I'd consider giving this place another try, and I hope they can improve the bagels and coffee because the staff truly deserves recognition.

Terrible service like god awful don't come here left 0 tip they came to my table onceread more

Great place right on the beach. Good for a quick snack while enjoying the ocean waves or a nice…read moremeal out of the sun. Caprese panini and chicken fingers were just what we were looking

As mention by somebody else, I have to agree that these NY bagels don't have the "bite" or texture…read morethey should: more like just a roll, so keep your expectations low. It is a very cute cafe but prices and value for the money is just crazy. My cream cheese bagel barely had any cream cheese on it. Staff was friendly and inside and outside seating was nice but I couldn't see taking the whole family here because it won't be cheap. Pro tip: don't get bagels in Wildwood if you're from north Jersey or New York; you will be disappointed.

I stopped in to get a plain bagel when it was really busy. The owner took me quickly and everything…read morewent well. My daughter enjoyed the bagel. Next time I'm down in Wildwood, I'm trying this place first!

I rarely leave negative reviews, especially when the customer service was good overall…read more Unfortunately, the quality of the food and drinks did not match the reputation of this cafe. The coffee was extremely disappointing. It tasted like someone rinsed out the coffee pot and poured that into my cup. The latte wasn't much better, an easy way to put it would be watered down milk. The sandwich was also disappointing. While the price was reasonable, the preparation was careless. The egg and cheese sandwich consisted of a little more than a slice of American cheese placed on the bread. They didn't event take the time to melt it. For a cafe with such a strong reputation, I expected much better, and I probably could've gotten better at a local gas station. Overall, while I appreciated the good customer service, the food and beverages fell far below expectations. Based on my experience, I would not recommend this place.

Don't let the 3.9 get you down. It's a smaller bistro-style place, with chalk-art-and green plant…read moredecor, creative drinks, and some great surprises. We got a banana chocolate latte, a dark caramel mocha (drink of the day) and a strawberry banana smoothie. All of these were great - my kids even liked the iced dark caramel chocolate latte. They sucked down the strawberry banana smoothie lickety split! Rolled in at noon, so got a chopped salad with chicken - great salad, fit with pickled onions and goat cheese which set it apart. Also got a fried chicken sandwich with cabbage and Whoa! This was SO GOOD! Don't miss it! For the kids, got the grilled cheese, but hold on, it's not just any grilled cheese: goat cheese, fig spread, and...I can't even remember what else - BEST grilled cheese I have EVER tasted! Staff was friendly and responsive and quick. Perfect for our little ones and us!

Haven't been here in a few years because the bagel quality was not consistent and we were burned…read morewith bad bagels several times. Today I grabbed a dozen out of convenience since this place is close by to us. Perhaps my timing was great as these bagels were steaming fresh out of the oven and delicious. They were so good, I'm going to give them another shot as maybe it's not my timing, but they've actually improved and got their bagels right.

I've left multiple reviews for Bagel Depot as I wasn't super impressed on my first visit, but then…read morehad good ones after that. This time is the opposite... my first visit of 2025 and it was absolutely awful. There was no line to wait in, so that was nice. The store was clean, as always, and the workers were very kind. But that's the end of the good experience. I got a toasted bagel with strawberry cream cheese and a blueberry muffin. I got the order to go and when I got to my office, I realized that the bagel was barely toasted. A hint of a toast, maybe. Along with that, the strawberry cream cheese was not mixed well at all. There were huge chunks of plain cream cheese in it. The muffin was horrendous. When I opened it, it didn't smell right, and I still tasted it and... no thanks. It was dry and tasted terrible.

Great bagels! Very soft and the breakfast sandwich is made with real eggs. Yum!…read more Coffee - pretty standard. I would just come here for the bagels.

Extensive wait, bagels didn't have any butter/cream cheese, fresh OJ is expensive but very goodread more

After seeing McCoy's bagel tray on facebook, I knew I needed to place an order. McCoy's bagel tray…read moreincludes your choice of 10 bagels and 3 cream cheeses. The bagels are all cut into smaller circles. This is the perfect breakfast for a group. I've ordered the tray a few times last summer & know I'll be ordering again next summer. Additionally everyone at McCoy's was great- they're super nice.

Showed up 9:50am. Business closed. No signs on the door stating when they are open. Highly…read moredisappointing as a group of us were going to try a new place. Verified on here and Google that they are open Tuesdays starting at 7am.

Busy place. Somewhat loud music but not anymore than any other cafe or restaurant. Lots of indoor…read moreseating available. Fast service. Dairy and non-dairy options. Somewhat limited non-caffeine options, but not none. The smoothies do not come with milk, they are just syrup and ice blended up. Most of the staff are quite nice. The cashier was unhelpful when I had an issue with my drink, but it was resolved by the manager swiftly and without complaint. Considering the possibility of rotating staff (and the cashiers young age) I'd say such an experience does not look poorly upon the establishment. Rather, the way management handled the issue looks favorably on them. We did not get ice cream so I cannot comment on it. It was expensive, and perhaps overpriced. However, this is wildwood in the summer, so everything is expensive. For those curious, I got the 4 Berry smoothie, which I was expecting to contain fruit and a dairy product. Instead it was ice and syrup. I tried to reach a resolution with the cashier by explaining the issue and asking for an alternative drink. The cashier declined and said I'd have to purchase a replacement. I stepped aside so I wouldn't hinder other customers and asked another staff member if a manager was present. They were, and when I explained my issue and we reached a resolution where part of my drink would be poured out and replaced by milk (I honestly didn't want to chance a different drink). By replacing 1/4 of the drink with milk, it improved the drink tremendously. The management also offered to make a new drink if I didn't like it, but I did so all is well. Overall: good experience, excellent food, great coffee, decent non-coffee options, possibly overpriced.

This coffee house also serves gourmet sandwiches! Firstly, I must mention the coffee is high…read morequality especially their Expresso. They have awesome cappuccinos & iced drinks as well as smoothies. Flavor shots are also available for preferred favs. Their frozen lemonades seem to be a pool/beach favorite as I see many of them being ordered. The prices are Coffee House (vs chain or fast service) level but the quality is worth it in my opinion. Now back to the sandwiches, I ordered one of the paninis of the day. It was Turkey, bacon & avocado. It was available on sourdough or multigrain with mayo or mustard. I love that options are offered not only because I have bread & condiment preferences but because you know it's being made fresh! The sandwich was delicious! The bread was bakery quality & all was beyond fresh & tasty.