Excellent pizza! Great crust, sausage and pepperoni. I wish I had ordered extra cheese and sauce. Pickup and order online worked perfectly. read more

Take out order right on time! Pizza delicious! Crust was just right -- not too thick & soft to the pallet! Our favorite pizza by far!!! read more

Go to place for pizza !!! Recently ordered sheets and wings for a graduation celebration and it was hot, tasty and a crowd pleaser. The prices are reasonable and the team there are always great! Small front shop area, but as a takeaway place it's perfect. Thanks for bringing excellent pizza and wings that's not a chain to the area !!!! PS. Only one constructive feedback. Of the Four dozen wings we ordered, the hot were not hot. The mild was mild. The garlic parm and teriyaki were delicious. The hot just wasn't. Still tasty though. read more

Love a peace.I love how it tastes the sausage.The pepperoni, the sauce and I like how they do the crust for the piece is just right a little crispy.But soft and it's good.Excellent matter of fact read more

They have the best boneless wings!!!! This is the only place I have ordered boneless wings and you know they are fresh, not frozen. Great pizza, subs etc. Their staff is always super nice. read more

Best Pizza Ever! Service is outstanding and always on time. 5 Stars Period. Every meal has been cooked to perfection. I highly recommend everyone try this GEM located in Eastlake. read more

I am trying to eat at small businesses. I love meat lover's pizza. Ordered last weekend & was so sad to have the middle of the dough be raw. Had to cook the pizza on my skillet and then put it in the air fryer for a quick moment. Would not order the pizza. Wings were great, but the honey mustard sauce (which is my go-to) was too tangy, not like any homemade or store bought I have ever bought before. Would not recommend this place (especially with creating a password to order online...such a pain), but not too bad if you're in a pinch. read more

Only the best pizza in town! They don't mess around! Their delivery people are always kind and respectful. It's is the only pizzeria we order fast and delicious!!! read more

Good local pizza fast friendly service good prices. The only bad is the sauce is a bit sweet for me

Best pizza on the east side has the best sausage and sauce. I get it every time I'm around

D'Amicio's Pizzeria is the Best Pizza Around! Salads are Fresh and Delicious, Subs are Yummy. Our Families Favorite place for Pizza! Service is Outstanding and Exceptionally Friendly. Prices are Affordable. I would Recommend D'Amico's Pizzeria for the Excellent Quality in totality! read more

Delicious, affordable. First time trying tonight, got the Large Supreme style pizza and $13.99! Only reason for the one star deduction was due to that it was oily on the bottom. Had to place it on some napkins to soak it up. Just need to use thicker cardboard underneath not shiny wax paper. read more

D'Amico's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Eastlake, Ohio

First time trying this place. Excellent crust. I'm so sick of the crap the chains make. This is fresh. The two pizzas I got where special pizzas. Hawaiian is one of my favorites. Their version of it had BBQ sauce in place of the regular red sauce. I didn't know this or I wouldn't have gotten it but it's ok. I just never want BBQ sauce on my pizza. The chicken and waffles is exactly what it says. And I liked it because I'm a fat boy at heart. I'll be coming back again. Next time I will get traditional pies. Good za! read more

D'Amico's Pizzeria - Specialty pizza Hawaiian - Pizza Near Me - Eastlake, Ohio

See all

Very Good traditional style pizza! Crust, sauce, cheese and toppings, all very fresh and tasty! Our go-to pizza shop!

When we moved to Eastlake 3 years ago, we fell in love with the pizza and food. We ordered all the time. They last few times we have ordered including tonight have been terrible. We requested light sauce, extra cheese and well done. We didn't get any of those requests. The pizza was doughy, loaded with sauce and extra cheese only on one side. The wait was longer, but that wouldn't have mattered if the pizza was good. Very disappointing. read more

loved this pizza! my family and i enjoyed it at headlands beach. saucier pizza than I'm used to, but I still liked it a lot. good prices too! read more

D'Amico's Pizzeria - pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - Eastlake, Ohio

I'm relatively new to the area and no longer being close to my old pizzeria for delivery, I stumbled across this gem!! Pizza is really good! We ordered the thin crust pepperoni and my son who's a complete pizza snob, gobbled it right up!!! My only complaint is that their large pizza is only a ten cut pie and when you have a teenage boy, I was lucky to snag two pieces!! Definitely a keeper in our pizza rotation!! read more

Really like the food here. I've ordered at least six times from the online app. Out of the six times ordering, we've had issues with the correctness of our order five times. Let me start off by saying the pizza is some of the best I've had. The buffalo wing sauce and is very, very good. The reason kept ordering the wings was mostly due to the perfect buffalo flavor I really appreciate. The issue we've had (and as I read the reviews I'm not the only one) is that the person cooking the wings is unwilling to cook them "crispy". As simple as it sounds they will not do it! I went as far as sending a delivery back to the restaurant because they were just cooked to a soft cook when I explicitly requested, in writing ( there is an option for cooking instructions on the online app. ) to have them cooked crispy and explained in writing that the last three times they were not. The recipe also showed my request for my wings to cooked "Crispy". The delivery person was very accommodating and said no problem I'll be right back. I can't explain how befuddled I was when he returned with the crispy ordered wings and they were cooked the EXACT SAME WAY ! Soft and kinda gooey. That was the last time I've ever ordered from D'Amico's Pizzeria. It's a shame they can't understand how much that hurts their bottom line over the most simplest of requests. There are too many good places that actually cook to order for this to be acceptable. read more

Got two large, one topping pizzas for$18. Ordered double cheese and pepperoni (the two "staple" pizzas we always order to gauge how good a pizzeria is). They were great. Traditional style crust, perfectly crispy and chewy, generous amount of flavorful sauce, very generous amount of perfectly crispy and spicy pepperoni on the pepperoni pizza and good amount of tasty gooey cheese on the double cheese pizza. My 5 year old ate 3 slices of double cheese and my 3 year old daughter said "yummy" after each bite! It's also less than5 minutes from our house so we'll definitely be repeat customers. read more

See all

ugh, i've been wanting a good chicken parm for awhile, AND THIS WAS SO DELICIOUS. montana , the delivery driver was so pretty i regret not getting her snapchat or something because she was around my age ( just a little older) montana was the sweetest girl ever, and she delivered in a fast and timely manner! read more

D'Amico's Pizzeria - chicken parm sub , cheese fries - Pizza Near Me - Eastlake, Ohio

Great little family owned pizza joint, order a take out chicken and waffle pizza the other day for lunch, yes I said chicken and waffle pizza! I saw it on the menu and decided I had to try it, i was a little sceptical at first since its base was garlic sauce and i was unsure of how that would play with the sweet waffles and syrup drizzle. But in fact it was a nice touch, it was needed to cut the sweetness of the pizza. Over all the pizza was very good crust was crispy and the outside and soft and chew on the inside, toppings were plentiful but not over done. I did have a few issues which is why only 4 stars, some of the waffle pieces were chard, it took 30min to get a takeout pizza(I can only imagine how long delivery is) and lastly they should offer an option for either spicy chicken on the pizza or a spicy maple syrup(it could use a little heat for more depth of flavor). I will be back and will be recommending this place to try! read more

D'Amico's Pizzeria - Chicken and waffle pizza :) - Pizza Near Me - Eastlake, Ohio

Ordered Alice thin crust pizza tonight as I always do. This one was horrible not thin crust and tasted like and old mop. Not happy called Nathan and complained he really didn't care what I had to say and told me he would try to get it right next time. I have been a long term customer always great pizza Better than exceptional in the past but not happy this time let's get it together guys or us itinerary to change??? read more

D'Amico's Pizzeria - Ordered the luxe thin crust as I usually do this one is uncooked like eating a wet mop I called Nathan and complained he didn't care at all. - Pizza Near Me - Eastlake, Ohio

We had our rehearsal dinner here last October even though they don't do banquets. The food was exceptional and they went out of their way to fit all of us in such a small area while still making it so we weren't on top of each other. My favorite place for pizza in Ohio (I love in PA)! They were so friendly and hospitable! They still managed take out orders at the same time with smiles on their faces! Thanks again for a great evening before our wedding! read more

Was there Saturday ordered 24 wings asked them to be extra crispy,they were not even close. Barely cooked through. Ask them to deliver them,they did not. This place has gone down hill lately. Don't know what the issue is. read more

If I could give D'Amicos 10 stars I would. Not only is the quality of their food outstanding, their service is stellar. Mike (owner) is hands down the best in this business. We could all learn how to treat people from he and his crew! read more

The only reason why I did not give them 5 stars is because of the kids working there. The food is great but the kids working seem to not want to work. Even when you call to order they talk like they are bord and u cant even understand them. I think the manger should tell some of the kids to start acting like they want to work and not talk over the phone luke they have shit in there mouth. read more