First thing I noticed when I walked in here was the Calabria poster. That gets you an extra star in…read moremy book. As usual I tried a plain cheese . I also got white slice. Plain cheese was very good. A little flop but not too bad. Nice sauce and good cheese. The white slice was ok. A little too much ricotta but overall was decent. They had a great menu of Italian food. I noticed all the customers there ordered a bunch of things besides pizza. Everything looked good. I would go again.

For this area, pretty average (horrible food in this area). Compared against food spots in general,…read morenot good. Positive was fries were crispy even after sitting in container for 15 during my ride home. Pizza has some sort of really strong cheese flavor that is non typical and over powering.

A little bit of a hole in the wall but the reverse wings were sooo good. The wings were fresh and…read morecrispy. Blue cheese was delish. Pizza was fine.

The wings taksed like they were cooked in old oil, and now we have diarrhea. Eat with caution.read more

Coming on a Saturday might have not been a great idea. Service was great but she was busy. Only…read moreone waitress for a restaurant. The place is a warm cozy place. Since they were short staffed it did take awhile for the food to get to us. But it was well worth the wait. The bread is baked fresh on each order. We had Eggplant Parmesan with a side of Spaghetti, Meat Lasagna, and Spaghetti with the works. My wife likes her pasta cooked a little longer than most and we forgot to say anything beforehand. I think it was cooked perfect but she didn't. We will definitely stop here again when we come up here. I saw a few pizzas go by and they looked amazing so maybe next time.

Great informal neighborhood feeling. Old World European ambiance. Excellent wait staff. I had…read morespecial request for dietary needs which restaurant accommodated. High quality pasta and sauce. Can get quite busy.

Always good beer and good food. People are always super nice as well! Will be back for sure.read more

This is inside a vintage remodeled Post Office building and the entire space is vibey, inviting and…read morewell restored. Good food and wide selection of beer and wine. Enjoyed the locally brewed NY IPA's. Friendly and efficient service.

Omg it so good pizza come here fast cheap definitely order again very good order now 2nd best pizza…read moreplace in Horseheads and Elmira and Corning and Saracuse

New York style pizza that does not disappoint Reasonably…read morepriced Best in the area at this time

Delivery always on time, driver courteous, prices reasonable and food excellent, hours convenient​read more

OMG !! Best pizza around!! The variety is unbelievable. There's like 15 different choices of pizza…read moreto choose from, If you're a pizza lover then this is the place to go.

Very good pizza,as close to Brooklyn pizza you can get up here. Their sandwiches are very good as…read morewell. Highly recommend. Excellent service as well.

Great NY style slices! Not much to choose from at the Mall, but there is still pizza!read more

The staff is VERY unfriendly.....Stopped in there a few times, and they are rude..Dont want to…read morewait on you, They dont give you a receipt unless you ask and then they act like its a chore! I really like the pizza, but I will go to a different Pudgies with better service..

I love Pudgie's Pizza and have my whole life but, lately, it's been terrible. The Vestal location,…read morein particular, it absolutely NOT worth the money. The crust used to be thick and chewy and now, it's thinner than thin crust and crunchy. It will definitely be a long time before I order again. Seriously disappointing... If you are looking for better quality, order from the Binghamton location. At least Binghamton, the pizza actually stays in pizza form instead of flopping all over the place like some disgusting sauce-covered rag doll. I haven't been this unsatisfied by food in a long time.

This is really good NY Style Pizza. We have the 18" meat lovers pizza and a half dozen garlic…read moreknots. Both the Pizza and the knots were excellent. My new local favorite for pizza. Next time we will try some subs.

I would not even entertain this place with a star review. Worse pizza in town. Overrated and over…read morepriced when a large pizza is only 6 slices and can't feed a family of 3 and a baby. The pizza tasted mediocre at best with really funky sauce. I will never buy a pizza here again- should have just heated up a frozen pizza.

Always a go-to when I come into town! Love the pizza, wings, Pudgie burger, etc.... Love dipping…read morethe pizza in the wing sauce, can't ever go wrong. The price seems kinda steep, but like anyone one who comes into town, I'll pay it for some Pudgies! We got the medium wing sauce, and it's not too hot and not too mild, just right! And the pizza, always on point.

The best grilled ham and cheese and Pudgie burger... Other than that I'm not a fan... Slices are…read morejust ok and so is about everything else and they're over priced for what you get...