I was looking to buy a ring I thought I lost and I was so heartbroken. I found one on the…read morewebsite for Blue Marlin along with matching earrings. I was so excited. I have the necklace and wasn't aware of the earrings. And the artist Denny Wong isn't easy to find in a lot of jewelry stores. My friend from Hawaii got me into him and told me he's the Cartier of Hawaii. I'm a big fan of Steven Douglas as well. They both do a fine jewelry with sea life collections as well as other beautiful creations. Anyway I called and spoke to Aimee to be sure they had the ring and earrings. I explained I couldn't find my ring and was interested in replacing it and getting the earrings. She had them to me in 2 days. But I was preparing to get an appraisal done and found my ring. So I called her and checked to see if I could please return just the ring. She was happy I found it and was so great about the return. I told her I collect sea life jewelry - and mainly starfish. My mother had a beautiful starfish necklace she wore and I guess it was lost or stolen I had always planned on inheriting that starfish someday and was so sad when my brother told me it was gone. So I started collecting starfish and a few other sea life fine jewelry. When I told Aimee about this and I was talking about rose gold and how I have a few pieces but I hadn't found a starfish in rose gold yet - she said I have an idea. I'm going to text you a picture of one we have. Maybe we can workout and exchange since I was sending the ring back that morning. The starfish is so beautiful- I got it in just 1 day and it is so much prettier then the picture. I have an Elsa Peretti from Tiffany in yellow gold with diamonds - this rose gold starfish is even prettier and more sparkly. They're both about the same size. I definitely suggest looking at the website or if you live near there or plan on visiting Florida - take a trip over there. Or just call Aimee. It's so great when you can connect with someone who understands what you might really like. She could have just accepted the return But instead she tried and successfully found something I love. It did cost more but it's worth it I know I'll treasure this starfish! Thank you Aimee

I rarely write negative reviews, but my experience with Blue Marlin Jewelry was extremely…read moredisappointing. I brought my watch in on June 19, 2025 for what should have been a simple clasp repair. I was never given a written estimate before the work was approved. Later I was told the clasp/buckle needed replacement and I verbally approved the work based on the information provided at the time. When I came back to pick up the watch, I immediately noticed that one of the hands had fallen off the watch. This means the watch was damaged somewhere during the service process while it was out through their service chain. That should never happen when a customer leaves a watch with a jewelry store. Because of that damage, the watch had to be sent out again. From the moment I dropped it off to the moment it was finally ready, the process took about eight months. Regardless of where the delay occurred, that is an extremely long time for a customer to wait for a watch repair. What was most surprising was the way the situation was handled afterward. Despite the damage occurring while the watch was in their service process and the extremely long delay, I was still expected to pay the full amount for the buckle replacement. There was no real effort to acknowledge the customer experience or take responsibility for what happened during the process. Unfortunately, that level of professionalism and accountability was not demonstrated here. The response I received from management made it clear that the focus was on explaining their internal process rather than understanding the situation from the customer's perspective. When a business stops caring about how the customer experience feels on the other side, it becomes a serious problem. I remained patient throughout the entire eight-month process and tried to handle the situation respectfully, but the overall experience left me very disappointed. If you are considering doing business here, I strongly recommend that you get everything in writing before leaving your watch or jewelry. Based on my experience, this is not a level of service I would expect from a professional jewelry store.

I have friends that live in Marathon so I am in the Keys several times a year. We rarely go farther…read morethan a 3 mile radius.....except for fishing! This last trip it was windy so we actually drove up and down the Keys multiple times being tourists. I stopped in my favorite bookstore in Islamorada to purchase another copy of Capt Fizz's book on Treasure Salving to re-read. When we got home, I started looking up some coin information online. I have a 1 Reale pendant that I love for the shape and I started thinking about maybe getting an (authentic) 8 Reale for my husband for his upcoming birthday. After quite a bit of looking, I kept coming back to one listed by DePaula Jewelers. Not so coincidentally it was a Capt. Fizz coin! I kicked myself for not getting this idea while I was THERE and could have shopped in person. I sent an email with a couple of questions and got a response the next day. My questions were answered and I was offered an incentive to purchase. SOLD! I PayPal'd the money and my purchase was mailed immediately. Thankfully the husband went offshore fishing today so *I* got the mail. O_O. The only drawback is that now I have to wait to give the gift! It is SO cool. I feel like I got 5 star service even with an online purchase. And I like that I got to shop from my home away from home. I recommend this store for unique items and superb service.

Billy and the rest of the gang here are just awesome. They really go out of their way to help you…read more If they don't have something they will make it. Quick easy turnaround time and quality work. I get all my jewelry from these guys and have had some repair to old stuff as well. I bought a watch from them that had a problem. It was within the warranty period from the manufacturer. The manufacturer was giving me problems about fixing my watch. I contacted them and Billy had the issue resolved almost immediately. This is a great local establishment. I shop mostly at the south store here in islamorada because of close proximity to home. However don't forget to check out their other great location up in the Winn Dixie plaza. Great customer service guys. Thank you. Keep up the outstanding job.

I highly recommend Keys Pawn for the purchase of your next high end watch or unique time piece. The…read moreexperience was great and Iook forward to my next purchase with them. Melvyn over delivered in knowledge, service and value. This is my go to place going forward. I received two beautiful watches at very fair prices. Check them out,

This isn't the kind of place you can just stop in. Call before you go. I've gone 3 different times…read moreabout a week apart each time, and nobody has been there during posted hours. I won't bother trying again.

Natacha braided my hair towards the end of our trip and not only did she do an amazing job, but she…read morewas such a delight to talk to. I really enjoyed talking to her. Her shop is also filled with cute clothing, accessories, and island related gifts. Prices are about what you would expect for the island and I would definitely recommend!

So much to browse and shop. Beautiful Cool things! She even does hair braiding. The only one I've…read moreseen in Islamorada. They have unique hair clips and keys jewelry.

What a little hidden gem of a spot! My friends who own a place in the middle Keys recommended this…read morearea to stop for some cool shopping and coffee. At first we actually passed the parking lot...I'd be surprised if other people did as well! The Village Square entrance is a bit set in through a gate in a fence...very inconspicuous if you don't know it's there. So we made a u-turn and headed back...My first stop was the Miss Monroe Boutique as I was looking for a certain kind of bag that I wanted to buy. Very cute store - like a mix of Etsy and Lily Pulitzer...unique and distinct items. From there we walked around and checked out all the cool vendor stalls...My favorite was the plants - so beautiful and lush...macrame holders, etc....We also went to Cafe Moka for a coffee and a snack. We sat down in the garden to enjoy our small meal and then we headed on our way...We will definitely stop here again!

The Village Square in the Florida Keys has redefined Boho beach chic! Tucked away in a beautifully…read moreshaded and naturally landscaped retreat. Each storefront is tucked away in their own uniquely designed hideaway showcasing their local artists and treasures unique to the florida keys. Only those that have explored the "keys" know what I'm talking about and those that have not explored the "keys" I encourage you to add it to your bucket list. The service is relaxed and personally engaging and how can you put a price on the beautiful and unique artisan pieces you will get to enjoy. You can choose quality outfits and accessories from Miss Monroe boutique or botanicals from boo kee Sue botanics, enjoy a refreshing beverage at Cafe Moka or stop for a quick bite at Bad Boy Sushi or Bad Boy Burrito.

This place is huge.... And it was overwhelming. You can park on either side of the store as it is…read morelocated between the north and south one way stretches of the highway. It has a little bit of everything -- more jewelry and clothes and souvenirs than shells. How they can keep track of the inventory is daunting. Some of the prices are exceedingly high, but I guess it's cause it is a tourist area and they can get away with it. People on vacation are willing to pay more and the international tourists don't know any better. Yet, mixed in are some decent buys like the key lime juice and the Tortuga rum cakes and some cheapie bracelets. I walked the entire store -- it's about a block long with several check out counters. I got my exercise for the day. I'm not sure I'd recommend this place but you never know. You can certainly price check items to see how they stack up against other stores or you might just find the perfect souvenir of your trip.

Finally stopped here to check it out after driving by for years on the way to the keys. Tins of…read moresouvenirs. Shirts on average were about $32.99. A little high in my opinion. They have some cool shells. We ended up buying a conch shell after all these years in Florida. $19.99. Rang out quickly and were on our way.

Purchased a couple t-shirts here after I saw the repeated billboard signs. Lots of choices for…read moreswimsuits, sandals and souvenirs, too. Really friendly and helpful staff working here. Don't worry, if you miss this location there will be a few more on the freeway in both directions.

Cheap clothes plus Gulf of "America" shirts - felt like a maga superstore. Nasty place.read more

I was traveling back northbound on US1 from Homestead to Miami when I remembered I needed some more…read morepalo santo for my aura at home. Personally, I'm a incense lover and lately I've been experimenting with am different scents and blends to find the one that I vibe with the most. I was searching for a basil scent to accompany my palo santo purchase and asked for help differentiating between the blends they had. Beliza took her time to guide me through the options they have with earthy notes until I found the one suitable for me. Right before I exited, someone found the specific one I needed and gave me the rest of the batch they had as a thank hon for passing by. I was so pleased with the experience here because the staff is so kind and helpful. Cauley Square has always been a slice of rustic Miami that needs no embellishment for the gem it truly is. This place is your destination for all your crystal and mystical pieces for the Stevie Nicks within you. I can't wait to come back for more goodies on my next trip down south.

The whole area around inside and outside of the store is welcoming and makes you want to explore…read more I was in need of some stones and sage sticks to cleanse my home. I explained what I needed and was given some suggestions, then left on my own to explore. I wouldn't say that it was the cheapest, but it also wasn't the most expensive. I would come back if I needed anything else, and maybe even to get a reading.