Would go as far to say this is the best pizza oven in WV. Crust is unmatched and sauce pulls it all together with the extra cheese. This is a unique pizza you can't find at home. Line is always out the door for a reason. read more

I was so disappointed! We are visiting from out of town, absolutely so disappointed with how expensive a tray of pizza was I wish the pizza came with cheese. It was all crust and sauce. Called to ask about getting more cheese, all they said is they do their pizza differently than the other locations in town. Wish I would have known that I would have gone to another location, than at least we would have gotten the good pizza we were use to. read more

Dicarlo's Original Pizza - 'Cheese' pizza - Pizza Near Me - Wellsburg, West Virginia

See all

I grew up on DiCarlo's Original Pizza located in Wellsburg, WV, so I am quite familiar with the taste and quality associated with DiCarlo's. From their website they provide the following information: For nearly 60 years, DiCarlo's very unique combination of hot crust - cold cheese has been successfully satisfying their devoted customers.Only DiCarlo's initially flash-bakes its crust and sauce in a special brick oven, and when the steaming crust emerges, it is adorned with cold creamy provolone cheese, making the taste indescribable! Orginal DiCarlo's Pizza uses NO frozen products. Fresh dough mixed daily in all of our stores. Our very own signature sauce made from superior-tasting, fresh tomatoes and combined with our unique spice mixture. We pride ourselves in using only the finest quality 100% provolone cheese, never pre-shredded. Only 100% meats - no fillers. We use products free of MSG. I can assure you that this pizza is quality and delicious. It is pizza served either by the slice at 90 cents per slice, or you can opt for a boxed square which usually will run you around 13.99 for a box of 16 slices. You can only order takeout at this location. Their pizza is good enough to take home and enjoy! If you get it "DiCarlo's style", it is with cold cheese on top. I prefer it this way, but to each their own. This is their signature style and it really adds to the flavor. They will happily melt the cheese for those of you that request it that way. I give it 2 thumbs way up! Great pizza! read more

If you like the raw cheese on top your pizza then this is the best hands down!! Talk like a local and Order a Reg Pepperoni and and cheese on top!! read more

Great place to order delivery or takeout. Fast service, fair price, and excellent pizza. Not much of a "dine-in" experience, but I don't think the guys would mind if you hang out and shoot the sheet while you have a slice. read more

You either hate it or love. Ohio valley pizza is not for me, but there is almost a cult following with Dicarlos. Good crisp crust and good pepperoni read more

They are awesome! Love the pizza! Crust is to die for! The guys welcome our pup every time we go!

I know people that come from states away to get this pizza. It has always been a staple in our family. We have had it on all occasions from birthdays to movie nights and sleepovers with the kids. Dicarlos pizza will always be a favorite in my family. read more

Hometown pizza. Seriously you can't find pizza like this anywhere. Square thick pizza. Delicious sauce. Timeless. I seriously do not believe they have ever changed their recipe after all these years. I'm 41 and I was a baby eating this stuff. Been around for years. An Ohio valley exclusive. read more

I grew up on this pizza and whenever I am back in Wellsburg, I make it a top priority to indulge in this deliciousness. It's always outstanding! read more

The pizza here is always head and shoulders above any other pizza I have ever had it has yet to disappoint the flavor is one of a kind the service is fast and fair and when I lived out of town it was the reason I came to visit we could not come to wellsburg without stopping at dicarlos read more

This is our go-to place for pizza when we're in the area. The pizza has a unique flavor that I've not encountered anywhere else. The crust is crispy, the sauce is flavorful, and the pepperoni and cheese ratio is spot on. It's the only pizza I ever crave. Keep it up. read more

Where to start...Firstly, parking is absolutely atrocious! Parking lot is tiny, coupled with construction in the main rd had to pull on the curb, and risk an accident. They had just opened at 5pm and everyone including their momma was there and blocking the parking lot entrance...Besides that, we ordered a tray/16 slice. It came in two boxes, and was sloppily shoved on top of each other, and they were very skimpy with the cheese; Which is one of the main reasons people like them. Dicarlo's is a huge local favorite, but this branch is tarnishing that with poor service, and mediocre food. Highly unlikely to return to this specific branch....:( read more

This is the best pizza in the world, the crust is semi thick and crunchy. The sauce is just right. The dough is cooked with very light sauce. The trays of dough gets moved between different levels in the oven during the cooking process. Once it's moved to the top level more sauce is added and some cheese. The toppings are added cold when removed. The extra cheese is a must have. This location is different from the other Dicarlos locations in the area, in my opinion it is leaps and bounds above the others. Here you get pizza only, no subs, no pepperoni rolls or salad. If you can do pizza like this you need no other side dishes. read more

So good. Authentic Ohio Valley style pizza and yes that's a thing. Not for everyone but if you've spent any time here, you'll grow to love it. read more

This is by far the very best DiCarlo's in the Ohio Valley. I live in Wheeling and neither DiCarlo's here compare. The crust is always crispy and their cheese is the BEST. We drive to Wellsburg sometimes just for the pizza!!!! Love it! read more

Great local pizza shop. This is like no other pizza your use to getting. The cheese and pizza goes on after it is cooked, thus the toppings are cold when you get the box. Upside the pepperoni is not greasy read more

Have to get extra cheese on the side. Love to coat on the cold cheese on hot pizza. Never greasy although sometimes some center cut slices can get flimsy. read more

I would die for a piece of dicarlos right now , I'm in Florida ,I go home every year and my family has it waiting for us when we pull in we text each other from the time we leave Florida to our arrival time into wellsburg, best pizza ever read more