First time trying this place. It was on a Saturday afternoon. I'm guessing it was considered busy. We ordered a small pizza for $17. My wife also ordered a chicken sandwich. We said water for our drink and they wanted to charge for water so we decided against that. We dined in. My wife's chicken sandwich came out pretty quickly. About 40 minutes later my pizza was delivered to our table. The noise of the place was terrible. The steel chairs on the hard floors echoed throughout the dining area. The pizza was delicious! Definitely one of the best pizza pies I've had. Little soggy in the center but overall it was great! My wife liked the chicken sandwich but the dressing was a little heavy, which made it a little too salty for her taste. We're excited to try different items next time! Pros: Food was great. Cons: WAIT TIME Noise Price read more

The Rustic Chicken Pizza was second to none! Absolutely delicious and highly recommended.

Pizza and bread sticks to go...amazing toppings, sauce, and cheese. So good that we always have to pick up pizza here when we are in town. Highly recommend. read more

We ordered online, which I would say was the best online ordering experience I've ever had. The detail that went into their website, you can edit everything so well and customize your order down to a T! They thought of everything. They are very busy, so pick up was like an hour and 20 after we replaced and then we still had to wait 20 minutes when we got there. But it was very much worth it and I would just plan for the wait. The French fries were bomb. Good fries, cooked well, great toppings and well distributed so you didn't get a bunch of naked fries. The cheese was good, not some crappy cheese sauce. It was like shredded. The pizza was delicious. It was a thicker crust and it had great flavor. Even the smaller pizzas you could split in 2 so you can try 2 different specialty pizzas. We got half Romeo (but switched out the sauce for white olive oil sauce) and half right primo pepperoni. The Primo was the bomb. The red sauce was so good, pepperoni cups were plentiful. The Romeo was different since it was a seasonal, had pistachios on it so had to try it. I thought it was good but didn't compare to the Primo. Also ordered garlic parm boneless wings that would be a problem if we lived here. The tiramisu was good, but I'm a connoisseur so I'm a little more picky. I thought it needed more espresso flavor like a wet layer at the bottom. I would 100% come back here. Great take out to go back to the Airbnb! read more

Park Street Pizza - Fries, boneless wings, pizza - Pizza Near Me - Sugarcreek, Ohio

My first time coming into the restaurant and riding pizza for myself but not the first time trying the pizza. That alone should tell you something of the quality. I placed a carry out order online. When I arrived a bit early I was greeted and offered a cup for water while I waited. How thoughtful! I took a peek at the sizable dining area and waiting area. Definitely would dine in at some point. The pizzas were finished right on time and I had an hour drive home with them so I had to grab photos in the box while they were fresh and hot. I've gotta say the smell got me and I tried a slice of each one on the drive. Delicious! You can tell they use fresh ingredients. It's a different quality. Also soft and good flavored crust. Love the hefty amount of cheese and enough sauce you can actually taste it. I ordered the Park Street Deluxe slightly modified, the Colossal Italian and the Primo Pepperoni. Hard to pick a favorite but I think it was a toss up between the Deluxe and the Italian. This seems to be a place with the more variety the better the taste. My recommendation is to stop and enjoy some good quality, good tasting pizza. Their salads are also very good. I didn't have them on this order but have tried them previously. read more

See all

Best pizza I have ever had..and I have had a lot of pizza! If you are in the area this is definitely a must eat! read more

Park Street Pizza - Pepperoni pizza, black olive pizza, breadsticks - Pizza Near Me - Sugarcreek, Ohio

Very good pizza. Wide variety of options. Vegan selections. Courteous staff. Great location.

I ordered on the phone. I had to give them my name three times, even spelling it the last time. When I got there, they couldn't find my order. They had totally missed spelled it, but found it by my phone number. We didn't like the crust, & that was the biggest part of it. The sauce wasn't bad. I wouldn't get a pizza there again. read more

This pizza place is incredible! This is top 5 best pizza I have ever had and I have eaten a lot of pizza! I got the Colossal Italian and the Primo Pepperoni. The Colossal Italian had very fresh and delicious sausage on it, especially the spicy sausage! The Primo Pepperoni had old world pepperoni and lots of cheese! The sauce is incredible here because it is a nice balanced sauce that is savory but also has a hint of sweetness to it. The fresh garlic and basil really adds something amazing! The crust is not crust you will toss aside either! The staff was very helpful and courteous in explaining the toppings to me and accommodating not putting spicy sausage on the entire pizza because my wife can't eat spicy food. The restaurant had a cool ambience and feel to it. Overall, this is a must stop for any pizza lover and if you live distance away....its worth the drive! Don't miss this pizza gem in Amish country! Incredible! read more

The pizza was delicious! The pizza was ready for our pickup when it was supposed to be. Service was excellent. The restaurant was very quaint and efficient- a great experience. read more

Maybe the best pizza I've ever had! 1st timer, had I believe it was called the "Gemmy"? Local Italian sausage, fresh ricotta, amazing pepperoni with a honey drizzle. The crust was perfect. The worst part was that the closest place is 2 hrs from my house :( read more

Excellent service, unhurried atmosphere, great veggie options, overall a fantastic experience. Definite must go if in the area. Well done Park Street Pizza! read more

Park Street Pizza - Plant based chicken wings - Pizza Near Me - Sugarcreek, Ohio

See all

The best pizza in Sugarcreek !!! Fast friendly, always hot and tasty . Highly recommend to anyone in the area or visiting Amish country read more

Park Street is efficient. I walked into a long and wide waiting area to the registers where I was greeted by smiling and friendly staff against a backdrop of busy, hardworking staff making pizzas and other menu items. As I briefly observed the staff work as I placed my order they appeared to work well as a team, enjoy what they were doing, and efficient and orderly in their work. After I placed my order I was given a pager and cups with my drink order. One drink that is available for free that got me so excited is sparking water. On the drink counter there is a water/sparkling water dispenser that is free for patrons. They have booth and table seating. The wooden booths are oversized and very comfortable. The interior is a mix of industrial, modern, and country that is typical of the area. Light comes through the many windows on the wall and vaulted ceiling. Plenty of seating. Indoor seating can accommodate about 50 people and their patio seats around 60. Their largest table seats 6 but I imagine they would combine some tables if you had a larger party. I ordered a large Deluxe pizza. The crust light, airy, and crispy. The red sauce was sweet and mild. The cheese had a creamy taste and was stingy. It was delicious. I recommend it heartily. read more

See all

We kept hearing great things about Park Street Pizza in Sugarcreek, so we decided to check it out. We've driven past this place many times over the years without ever noticing it. It's a small spot with great pizza\! We heard it gets really busy, and it certainly did--we arrived at 3:30 PM, and by 4:00 PM, it was packed with more people pulling in. read more

Park Street Pizza - Primo Pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - Sugarcreek, Ohio

When we lived in Sugarcreek, Park Street was something we ordered every Wednesday or Thursday night. We moved away 9 years ago. We were in Sugarcreek tonight and placed a to-go order. My wife ordered a gluten-free Veggie Patch and I kept it simple with a sausage pizza. Quality and flavor are still top notch. Park Street blows away all of the pizzas in the town where we live. (*except for Dola Jeans, which is in the Park Street family). read more

Sometimes ya just don't feel like eating a pie. Tonight was split a salad & a chicken sandwich- just spectacular flavors!

EVERYTHING ,, about this pizza shop is AMAZING !!,, the service pretty fast & Always nice servers/employees!!,, line may get little long' but they try their best to get everyone thru fast as possible and trust me it's worth the wait even if there is one ,, it's never Too long",,! all the ingredients are fresh picked from local farms. The Dough and sauce I believe R made daily. The pepperoni is delicious hot crispy and tasty and you just can't beat this pizza almost anything you can get gluten-free. The boxes they put your pizza In R Even Cute lol" They're recycled Pizza boxes and their logo is a TRACTOR, made from Pizza cutter and such to make it look like a tractor. Love it. We've had their PIZZA ,, Italian sandwiches, their wings,down to fountain pop ,!" ITS ALL delicious.!! read more

Park Street Pizza - Pic of Park Street Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Sugarcreek, Ohio

Visiting the area for the weekend and had the opportunity to eat here. The pizza was great! We built our own with old world pep, sausage and mush. The place was hopping and was told it might be a 35 minute wait and it turned out to be much much shorter. Service at the counter was good and very friendly as well as helpful. Restaurant was clean and well kept. They actually kept tables clean too. Two unisex bathrooms bother my wife a little and I certainly prefer Pepsi product but neither is a show stopper. Would definitely come back here again. read more

Best Italian sub I ever had and I am 77! Plus, this business hires lots of local students to give them a positive first job experience.

Park Street Pizza is our favorite place for pizza! We've never been disappointed! Great food made with high quality ingredients!

I basically never miss stopping here while on a visit to Amish country I take everyone and they all become fans Excellent salads and pizza. We tried the Brussel sprouts this time too and loved those as well. (Of course) Just found out you can get a take and bake! That's a game changer to taking pizza the hour home! read more

Park Street Pizza - One for there, one to go! - Pizza Near Me - Sugarcreek, Ohio

Hands down the best pizza and drive almost 2 hours to get it. service is always the best and great staff. restaurant is always clean and A easy location to get to. read more

Husband and I live around 2 hours away and while we don't make the drive just for food of any kind; we absolutely include Park Street Pizza in our list of stops when in the area! Great salads, great pizza! Good amount of seating inside and outside and adorable bathrooms. read more

Pizza and breadsticks were absolutely delicious salads looks delicious- will try one the next time

Heard about all the hype in Berlin about this place and guess what...IT WAS SO GOOD! This was one of the best pizzas i've ever eaten. Customer service was great, even with the long line. If i'm ever in the area i will definitely be going back for round two! read more

Park Street Pizza - pesto pizza - Pizza Near Me - Sugarcreek, Ohio

excellent service and fantastic food and great staff we loved the farm house salad and bone in wings besides all there pizza

Easy online ordering the pizza was fantastic. The wings were delicious. Highly recommend trying Park St., pizza.

Small family owned business that is environmentally friendly & uses local produce & cheese!! Pizza is the best around, they have vegetarian and gluten free options too! Service is always with a smile! read more

Great little pizza joint. The ingredients were fresh and the pizza was hot oughta the oven. Good service. Lotta locals.

Pricey but worth it Very good quality, clean, awesome staff, and love option to split pizza ...even if little extra Love support of local farmers for fresh ingredients Excellent bathrooms read more

Usually when we're down that way I only eat at Der Dutchman. This place was recommended to us by friends a few years ago and we finally tried it today. I've been missing out! The place was hopping on a Saturday afternoon. We got a table quickly and the food came out reasonably fast as well. Pizza, salad and breadsticks were great. We're in the area a few times per year and will be back for sure. read more

Park Street Pizza - Pizza and breadsticks - Pizza Near Me - Sugarcreek, Ohio

Friendly staff and the rustic chicken pesto pizza is phenomenal, as are the boneless bbq wings.

The staff was friendly and the pizza was fantastic! We ordered the rustic chicken pizza and it was delicious. Will definitely come back whenever we are in the area. read more

Park Street Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Sugarcreek, Ohio

This was our 2nd visit to Park Street and it confirmed that you can absolutely find a top notch pizza shop right in the heart of Amish Country! Yelpers know best so trust them when they rate this place a 4.8! Everything about Park Street is high quality!! The staff is friendly and helpful & their service is 2nd to none!! The dining area is spotless! But the star of the show is the pizza, it's simply the best!! We will always make Park Street a must visit when we are in the area! read more

First time here. Wasn't expecting such a nice new well decorated building. Great parking & outdoor seating. We loved everything about the place and the food! Service was very friendly and helpful. We had the deluxe pizza, pepperoni pizza, and mozzarella sticks. read more

Park Street Pizza - medium deluxe pizza - Pizza Near Me - Sugarcreek, Ohio

Very nice atmosphere. I loved the decor and look of the interior and exterior. The open kitchen concept was nice. The staff was very welcoming, helpful and friendly! The staff works so well together. They are like a well oiled machine. The food was wonderful! I had a salad and my hubby had wings to start. The wings were pretty amazing! The salad was good and fresh. We then had the pepperoni pizza. Oh my goodness! It checked all the boxes. The sauce is so good. We went on a Saturday at 5 pm. It was pretty busy. We did wait about 45 minutes for a table. It was worth the wait. Food didn't take that long. I would definitely go back when I'm in town. read more

See all

Loved the pizza! Adorable little pizza shop too!! Stays open late!! That's a rare find around here!! read more

See all

Excellent service! Extremely Clean! Fabulously Friendly! Perfect Primo Pepperoni Pizza!!!! Our first time in but not our last! read more

Park Street Pizza - 14" Primo Pepperoni Pizza, a must have! - Pizza Near Me - Sugarcreek, Ohio

By far the best pizza, breadsticks and salads in the area. The service is impeccable on phone orders as well as in person. They have a beautiful dining area, which is always spotless! The kitchen is visible and just as neat and clean as the dining area. Employees are always dressed appropriately. Rating is definitely a 10+. read more