It has been years since we had an insurance agent who went to great effort to take care of us, make…read moreus feel like our business mattered, and seemed to care that we were comfortable and all questions answered. Stacy, in the St Augustine office accomplished this......as a first time client of Allstate, because of Stacy, I am totally impressed.

I've been with Allstate for over 20 years and Linda Ventura is, by far, the best agent I've ever…read morehad! She definitely goes over and beyond what's expected!

Insurance recommendation: I've recently moved both my home and car insurance to Oldest City…read moreInsurance and couldn't be happier! Mark van Gemert is a gem and he worked diligently to ensure that I was getting exactly the coverage I need at the most reasonable rate. It is a family ran business with both his wife and daughter working in office, and the communication between them and myself made for a seamless transition. If you're looking for an agent who will listen to your needs and work hard to earn your business, definitely give Mark and family a shot. Their info is: Oldest City Insurance 904-824-7283 and www.oldestcityinsurance.com.

From the owner: A-Auto Insurance is a full service agency catering to the growing needs of its residents since…read more1984. We have helped your friends and family protect themselves against the many risks of driving, owning or renting your home, owning some fun toys like boats, golf carts, RV's, and motorcycles as well as business insurance and liability umbrella policy's, all at some of the best rates in town. Come down and visit with Mark for a hassle free, no sales pitch risk assessment today.

I was shopping for homeowners insurance and had a short interview with a representative at VyStar…read moreCredit Union. I was told a sales rep would be reaching out to me, but no one ever followed up. Since I never heard back from anyone, I ended up going with another company. Honestly, unbelievable customer service.

Shapiro Insurance Group was a LIFE SAVER! Our previous insurance company in Florida filed for…read morebankruptsy and I had to quickly find another insurer for our rental property. Mary Ann Bailey with Shapiro was able to insure the property at a reasonable rate very quickly. We feel very fortunate to have such a GREAT COMPANY taking care of us!

The owner of this Brightway location goes above and beyond to satisfy her customers. She provides…read morecompetitive quotes and is willing to shop around to find the best possible rate. We have used Anastasia Ryan for years and will continue to use her for all of our insurance needs.--

Terrible customer service. Don't call back. Fails to follow simple instructions like "cancel my…read morepolicy" so you have to call the carrier directly. Avoid if you don't want to waste a ton of time calling and re-calling.

They have been a great source of information for my home in St. Augustine Shores. They also check…read morein periodically to see what other coverage i might need, but they are always helpful and never pushy. I will stay with them and find no need to shop around.

Six months ago, St. Augustine, Benchmark Ins. Agency for Progressive lied to me. They would not…read morelower my 6 month Insurance fee because of my age so I paid it. Instead of Benchmark Progressive this 6 months I went to State Farm. They lowered my 6 month fee by over $200! Be ware of Benchmark Ins. Agency! Kaitlyn Dugger - State Farm Chrisi Sapp 4255 Us Highway 1 S Suite 9 St. Augustine, FL 904-770-4897

Kim is very professional, helpful and knowledgeable. She can answer any questions you have about…read moreinsurance. Highly recommended!!

From the owner: Whether you're looking for homeowners insurance, auto insurance, renters insurance, or another…read morekind, I'm here to help you understand the insurance coverage you may want. Serving the St Augustine, FL area since 2020, I can help you understand your coverage options so you can protect what matters most to you. Stop by in person, reach out online or call to get a free quote today.

I have been a customer of Herbie Wiles for the last few years and I must admit I had a less than…read morepositive experience to begin with. Since then, I can't say enough about these people. Doug Wiles is a class act. Expect nothing but the best service and advice from him. I can tell you I couldn't recommend anyone any higher. Truly, a gentleman of the first order and his folks do a great job as well. L thanks DOUG. It's nice to know. I have a team like yours behind me. Work with these people with confidence.

run away from this place they have been over charging me for home owners ins for over three years…read more hiking the price 1000.00 to 1200.00 dollars a year for 3 yrs straight. when i asked them if they could find a better rate they said they could not.

There are just a few things I demand from my Insurance Agent!…read more1. Honesty 2. Availability at any time 3. Compassion 4. Low pressure sales tactics I can honestly say Perry Unwalla has all these qualities I would never hesitate trusting him with my Life (insurance that is!) If you are looking for a great Insurance Agent in St. Augustine I would definitely consider Giving Perry a look into!

Initially, We thought they were through and explained what we needed. This year, our circumstances…read morechanged. We called, spoke to a representative and talking to him was like pulling teeth. Extracting info from him was laborious to the point of infuriating. We told the agent we were going to drop State Farm, he didn't care; said nothing. Called the office, tried to get another agent before cancelling, she never called back. Called a third time and explained our frustration. They just don't care. Even after telling them we were shopping around and would be dropping them, they didn't try to keep me as a client. Looks like they don't need business. Glad to find out they do not value customers before having to depend on them. You've been warned!