After spending the day at Rocky Mountain National Park, we were looking for a nearby place to eat,…read moreand I'm so glad we stumbled across this spot. We wanted to try a variety of pizzas, so we ordered four personal-sized pizzas to share. Every pizza was excellent, but the Classic Pepperoni and the Spicy Calabrian were my favorites. The service was great, and they have a very organized system for service. Highly recommend checking this place out. It's definitely worth the hype!

After a hike in RMNP YELP led us here. We have been craving…read morea good pizza and this was definitely what we were craving. We ordered a personal for each of us so we could try different things and so glad that we did. We all had our favorite but unanimously the best pizza we tried was the Spicy Calabrian, followed by a pepperoni pizza. The flavors of Italy was really good and also the Marguerite. The crust in all of these was flavorful and perfectly crispy. The tomato sauce was really fresh you can literally taste the tomatoes! So good. The spicy Calabrian flavor was like nothing we have ever had, it was rich and spicy and yummy. We ordered a large salad with vinaigrettes and that was crisp and fresh. Overall 5 or the pizza. The robots that serve you the food are fun. Service was good and the decor and vibe was old style New York style. Great spot even better pizza for a 4.75 overall.

Great place never have to wait to be seated. Quiet atmosphere reasonable prices. Small town…read moreatmosphere.

FANTASTIC gnocchi. The sauce was perfectly done. Not overly seasoned but enough to be flavorful…read more The portion was enough to have two meals out of it. The Italian sub was also good and I don't know how they did it, but their French fries taste just like a well-known Golden Arches restaurant. They were great!

It's an easy meal to have when yo I don't want to cook. Always tastes good. Time to pick up is…read moregreat.

Absolutely the most disrespectful ownership I've ever encountered. Rude, demeaning, belittling, and…read moredown right unprofessional. They should be ashamed.

Always enjoy the food at McCarty's. I have the cowboy burger in most cases. Best burger anywhere…read more Fish and chips are pretty good too. Would definitely recommend McCartney's.

Great service. Food is well prepared. Our server was attentive not intrusive and a lot of funread more

Friendly young counterman. Lunch special just the right price. Close to NY pizza (from this New…read moreYorker). Glad they added a west Greeley location. Garden City was out of the way for us. Brighter, newer setting.

I've eaten here a few times over the last decade or so while staying in g Greeley. The pizza is…read moregood, thin crust style pizza. At some point, they eliminated Hawaiian from their menu, so if you like Hawaiian style, you're SOL. It used to be one of their best pies. We ordered some large orders of 8 or more pizzas a few times for business meetings and they got our order wrong every time. Calling to resolve issues was tedious, but they did get is taken care of. They're ok in a pinch, but I wouldn't recommend them

Amazing pizza, good prices, and friendly staff. Can't complain…read more Annoying for a pizza place where I am just picking up a pizza their default and lowest tip % is 15%, but a small gripe I suppose.

Wow! Was seriously impressed with this place! Fairly unassuming from the outside but this place has…read moresome amazing pizza. My only regret is that I live so far away. Definitely worth stopping in.

Cute little Italian restaurant hidden away in a neighborhood. Party of 4, we walked in and were…read moreseating right away. We started with the Herbed Burrata, 1/2 Wedge Salad, and the Brussel Sprouts. The Burrata is a MUST order, for all future visits!!! For our entrees we ordered the Spicy Mushroom pizza, the Sausage & Mushroom pasta, and the Vodka Cream Fettuccine with Salmon. Sooo delicious! And our sweet waitress kept our drinks full the whole time.

Good food, good service, good place. Hot honey pizza was to die for! It was ssssooooo good…read more Combination of meat and hot honey drizzle was just a perfect pairing. Fettuccine alfredo is another to die for. Worth every garlic breath after meal. Canolli top off the night perfectly. Our server Kylie F was awesome, thank you Kylie. Come visit the place, you wont be dissapointed.