Newly remodeled for 2025! Check it out. The food here is very good pub fare. Fresh cut fries are…read morevery good. The wings are a tad pricey, but done very well. I particularly liked the ragin' Cajun wing sauce. I wish I knew the recipe. It is very close to a place I used to frequent. The Rueben was pretty solid as well, though I wish they put a bit more cheese on it and added the dressing instead of keep in it separate. I look forward to trying this again in the near future

my husband and I had lunch there today. I had the pulled pork sandwich and french fries it was…read moredelicious. Homemade smoked flavor was so good. My husband had a bacon cheeseburger that was just huge and so juicy and good. we are from Niles and had heard that Nikki was the new owner and fixed the place up it was really nice inside all clean and fresh loved it!! we will go back anytime we're in Geneva

PHENOMENAL service-- great food, great prices…read more High tide is the perfect stop for filling fried food and well-priced drinks. The prices are significantly lower than the surrounding businesses; they take pride in not price-gouging. The onion rings were legitimately delicious. They have many vegetarian and vegan options for fried veggies of all sorts and grilled cheese and veggie wraps. What made our experience phenomenal was the service. The bar manager was incredibly friendly and helpful. I asked her for area recommendations and she went so far as to pull out a magazine and circle her recommendations (including notes like "great pizza" and "go here then stop over there"). She was so kind that we're planning a trip back to Ashtabula only to heed her recommendations. The bar does not have a direct view of the lake.

They have the best deep fried green beans! Laid back bar. Staff is friendly. Refreshing stop to…read moremake when the strip is super busy.

The service was excellent. We had the salmon and the walleye and both were good portions and were…read moredelicious!

Four of us stopped in for a drink. We enjoyed our drinks and conversation with the bartender. We…read morehad ordered a pour of Buffalo Trace, Widow Jane, a beer and a Manhattan. She wasn't sure how to make the manhattan but eventually poured a nice drink. We got our bill and the two special pours of bourbon and the beer were 28 dollars. For the simple Manhattan we were charged 30 dollars. We told her this was crazy but she refused to listen. We paid the bill but I will never set foot in this place again. What could have been a good memory of Geneva on the Lake and GOTL brewery was completely ruined. If you do go to this place, and I recommend you don't, make sure you ask the price of anything you order.

Good food. Fun vibe. Great music. We got drinks - house shots were fun. Loaded fries were awesome.read more

Great food and great atmosphere. Love the open building in the summer. The staff was very friendly…read moreand our friends even had their dog with them table side.

Wife and I came here years ago and had a really super meal...this time, not so much. Kinda like a…read moredivey style seafood restaurant, but the real "star of the show" is the shooting gallery behind the bar. It is an original piece of equipment from the famed Coney Island amusement park in New York City from the early 1900's. It was brought to Geneva-On-The-Lake in the late 1930's and installed in its current location as part of a small amusement gallery where it was eventually covered over and forgotten. Some time in the early 2000's (during a renovation of the space) it was uncovered and brought back to life. It still works to this day, and the owners were delighted to crank it up for us to see. As for the food, sadly the meal left a lot to be desired. The house salad to start was just fine topped with a balsamic dressing, but the smoked lobster dip and the lobster lasagna were just not good. You could hardly taste any lobster in the dip, and the lasagna was too oily, did not have enough cream sauce and did not taste super fresh. The other couple dining with us that evening was also less than impressed with their meal selections...so although the nostalgia factor was high, our dining expectations were not met.

We had dinner here our first night in town, and I think we have mixed feelings as a group. It's…read morekind of a divey seafood place right on the strip. When we walked in, it was pretty empty, but did end up filling up. They have some local wines, which was nice, and an interesting menu. The decor is a mish mash, with a creepy lobster tank that may be inhabited by the Babadook, and a still functioning shooting gallery wall behind the bar. No shooting, but they turn it on about every 20 minutes and all the pieces move while creaking and squeaking. I ordered the Apple Salad and the walleye special, and was pleasantly surprised with both. The salad had a house honey lavender dressing that went well with the apples and carrots, seemed fresh, and was a nice portion size. The walleye was a generous portion, well cooked, cajun style, and served with garlic and oil spaghetti. I enjoyed my entree quite a bit. My friends were less enthused with their entrees, both prepared well, but smaller portion sizes. It's an interesting place, and maybe worth a visit for a drink or appetizer. Again, I did enjoy my food, but the overall experience was interesting.

Smash burger oh yum Great staff, great food, Halloween and…read moreXmas crawl stop here fun stuff... also pool league night on Thursday

I have been going to GOTL since I was little. Had the absolute worst service on the strip here…read moretoday. And the owner was present and was more concerned about playing guitar than the lack of customer service we got here this afternoon.