Very helpful and friendly staff! Matched the paint color I needed perfectly! Paint has excellent…read morecoverage, smooth application, low-odor and dries quickly.

From the owner: Your local Sherwin-Williams Paint Store in East Islip, NY, provides expert advice, premium…read morecoatings, paint matching, and professional-grade supplies to help bring complex urban projects to life. Connect with our team for expert recommendations, the right coatings and tools, and personalized support that helps you achieve professional results. As a convenient paint store near you, we offer online color tools, color consultation, wallpaper and application resources, brushes, and information on paint recycling, along with high-quality paints and options to order paint online.

My husband and I were there last Sunday and the staff was friendly. Answered questions my husband…read morehad, overall, if you need paint I strongly recommend this place!

Great spot, went there after having a bad experience with an ace hardware in my quest for Benjamin…read moreMoore paint. The gentlemen here was helpful, efficient, hand matched a paint off a drywall patch I brought in and even gave me a discount, presumably because I spent a decent amount - or just to generate more future business. Either way, great experience and I will return for here for my paint related needs.

Local Ace hardware has everything you need for small and large jobs. I tend to go here for paint…read moresupplies when I'm ready to change the paint color in my house. They have Benjamin Moore which I prefer. Friendly and helpful employees and convenient for my job. It's a win!

I ordered a new Weber gas grill on their website. I tried to order by phone directly from the…read morestore but they only do orders less than $100. I was anxious about getting the grill and called the store 3 different times to check on the order. I indicated that it should be fully assembled and delivered to the freight ferry (there are no cars/vehicles where I live for the summer). I called on Friday to check and it was there but in the warehouse. I called shin on Monday to check on it again to make sure it was being assembled and was told it would be finished and delivered to freight ferry yet Monday or Tuesday. I called on Tuesday late in day because I hadn't gotten notice from the freight office that it was being delivered. I was told it was all ready to go Today, Wednesday I got notification from the freight office that I was receiving a box. I called the store to find out what was going on and they told me that I didn't ask to have it assembled! I did on the order form and in each of the phone calls I made. While the persons I have talked to have always been polite, a grill in a box is NOT WHAT I ORDERED. And, why I gad to wait three days before I was shipped the box is still a mystery!! They offered no remedy to fix the issue. It was just My Problem! I will be doing no further business with Costello's Ave Hardware EVER! And you should consider looking for another place to take your business too!

Attended a workshop 12/12/25 as a gift from my daughter and had a great time…read more Relaxing and creative. Met some nice and kind people and with a total of six of us it was quiet and calming. Exactly what was needed. I will be checking out future workshops.

Beautiful store and the owner is very nice and knowledgeable. Prices are reasonable. She also…read moreoffers workshops which is really cool.

Do you ever wonder the frequent occasions in one's lifetime we would face the challenge of choosing…read morea paint color? As a homeowner, I have been mystified by the quest to find the perfect paint color. It seems there are just too many paints color options. The reason I believe it has become so much more difficult is because there are too many shades of colors. Such as the color white, one would be surprised the number of shades of white one can explore. Once you have decided to refresh your homes appearance with new colors, the next challenge is all the various retail stores to choose from and the choice of manufacture. Our retail paint store choice has always been Aboff's Paints, and our paint manufacturer Benjamin Moore. The service that we have received from Aboff's has always been outstanding. Our problem has always been choice of paint color, not paint manufacturer. Unfortunately, Benjamin Moore, has over 3,500 colors to choose from, which is incredible. Aboff's has been complimentary in most cases on our final choices, which does help a little bit.

They are racist, sexist, rude, and incompetent…read more I needed white paint for a bedroom, and they sold me an eggshell finish. When my painter saw the two gallons of paint, he immediately asked why the finish was in eggshell and that the walls would be super shiny. This is more for a bathroom. I called Aboff's and told them about the situation and asked if there was any way they could take it back as the paints totaled $98.00. Instead of apologizing about the inconvenience, the worker started raising his voice and said eggshell is his most popular finish and that's what he would use on his walls and that if I wanted a flat finish I should have said so. But I do not work at a paint store and do not have knowledge on this stuff, and that is why I specifically told them that it was for a bedroom and asked them what to get. Even if the finish is a personal choice, the way they spoke to me and handled the issue was horrible. Never going back.

Jeff is consistently our " go to" and a primary reason we shop at this Aboff's location! He is…read moregenerous with his knowledge about the products he sells and he is patient while attending to our painting project's needs and concerns. Excellent service.

Great spot to grab paint for fixing up things around the house. The staff was really helpful in…read moregiving us advice on how much paint to buy and what we would need to paint our entire attic and molding. They also gave us some samples for other areas of the house we would like to paint. Nice local store!

Joe did a professional job in my house. Completed the work in one day…read more Would recommend him.

Joe just crown molded & painted my family a fairy tale nursery for our first child due in 2022! My…read morewife was over the moon with the finished product of both the nursery & downstairs bathroom! He also went above and beyond improving the existing doors to the room with a beautiful trim to each door. I wasn't expecting that. He also touched up the downstairs where I attempted to paint. He goes above and beyond your expectations. He should have his own show on HGTV. I'd def hire him again.

Learn some manners. Unfriendly staff always. If you want continued business be kind to your…read moreclients. Thanks but no thanks . Customer service is just as important as the product

Another trip to buy paint and was lucky to have Andre assist me with the purchase. He came to my…read morerescue! Thanks Andre - see you next time