Eepa’s Pizzeria

(6 reviews)

0.7 mi

These guys offer pizza...both full pies to go and hot pizza by the slice. They typically have…read moreseveral choices for slices, and it's very good. Getting gas? Go to Marathon in Bayfield and grab a slice or two to go.

was unaware that it was a gas station, however ordered some pizza that was honestly good…read moreconsidering it was gas station pizza

See all

Aj's Pizza

Outstanding Pizza. Family run. Very friendly. Best pizza I've found in Colorado! Crust not too…read morethick or too thin. Adequate sauce. Lots of toppings. Reasonable price for a large pizza. Highly recommended

I love Aj's Pizza! They do not only offer hunger quenching meals for an affordable prize in the…read moreform of pizza, but they also serve wings, fries, sandwiches and more. There is so many options to choose from and on top of that all there is ice cream, who doesn't love ice cream. Aj's is also a large contributor to Bayfield's community; just stepping inside will illuminate this fact. If there were more stars to give I would.

See all

Menu 2

The Weminuche Woodfire Grill

4.0

(66 reviews)

14.7 mi

Really love this place. Great menu and great food. And it's a special treat when they have live…read moreentertainment.

Was staying in a little cabin on Vallecito and placed an order to go at Weminuche. We ordered a…read moreHawaiian pizza and a salad, but the salad was no longer on the menu, so we ended up just ordering the pizza. When I got there I saw they had peach cobbler on the menu, so I asked for it to be added to the order. The brought out the pizza right away, but it took nearly 30 min to get the peach cobbler. I had to ask to see if they could get it out earlier since I had a to go order and they did. Everyone was super friendly about it. The Hawaiian pizza was supposed to have prosciutto on it, but it looked more like thin sliced ham. And it had raw jalapenos, not pickled. Super spicy! The cobbler was great. Kinda wish they put the ice cream in a separate container cause I had to eat it before my pizza so it wouldn't melt and also stay warm. The cobbler was more like a scone on top of hot peaches, but I enjoyed it! Also attached some updated menu since their website is out of date They had live music, but it was sounding just okay .. kinda glad we ordered it to go

Half sausage half cheese pizza

Peach cobbler

See all

Johnny Pizza

(9 reviews)

10.6 mi

My cousin found Johnny's Pizza in Durango, Co and as New Yorker's we wanted to test his pizza and…read moresee how it compared to "real" New York pizza! The service was amazing and though small the place had a terrific ambiance! The owner, Johnny came to greet us and talk pizza with us. We were going to order a single slice and decided to order a 14 inch pie and boy oh boy we were happy we did. The pizza is amazing and I STRONGLY recommend that you visit Johnny's Pizza. The pizza definitely tastes like NYC pizza; the oil is dripping, the cheese was the right stringy consistency and the crust crispy but won't cut up the roof of your mouth. Personally, the crust is one of my favorite parts of the pizza! BOTTOM LINE: if you think you know great pizza you haven't tried Johnny's pizza in Durango,CO.

This is the best pizza in Durango, hands down!! The owner, Johnny, is in there all the time and…read morealways makes the experience 100% better! They have killer breakfast burritos too! As a local this is a regular spot for me always.

See all

Vallecito Lake Country Market

Huge menu of great food made to order from Mexican to burgers to full dinners. And no visit would…read morebe complete without a scoop of the best ice cream.

The food was amazing we got a variety in our group and everyone loved their food. The lady who…read moreworked there and cashed us out was very sweet and the store/restaurant was outdated but Vallecito is old just holds more character to me. Food costs seemed normal ish compared to other restaurants. Can't wait to go back

See all

Homeslice Pizza

Had the heater pizza and a regular pepperoni pizza. The crust was perfect! Made great leftovers…read moretoo! The location was a charming neighborhood spot and the service was spectacular.

I had a great experience here!! Ambience gives dive bar, Shaun our bartender/ server was super…read moreattentive and inviting definitely the life of the place, our pizza was fireeeee salad to share, 2 cold beers to wash it down if I remember correctly we didn't spend more that $40.

Sausage green slice

See all

HomeSlice Pizza

3.4

(22 reviews)

12.1 mi

If you want to wait an hour for food, and hear the bar staff arguing with the kitchen and getting…read morefrustrated with the staff. This is the place to be. While I've enjoyed the food here before. The service tonight was slow and awful, while the bartender is nice, when they come out and announce the people sitting at the bar "if you ordered food, sorry for waiting but Edgar cooks when he feels like it". And also "I'm scared to go back and check on your order" or "if I complain too much he walks out" It's not a great thing to experience. And then complains to the customer about it. Also had another bartender come in after seeing him take several shots and then work behind the bar and admit he has several shots and likes working like that. Which is a safety hazard. This visit made me feel really uncomfortable and sounds like if you come in, you might get a night where people don't want to work.

I visited Home Slice Pizza during my stay in Durango. I ordered two slices of pizza and they were…read moredelicious. They drizzle a little honey on the pie while baking. In my almost 60 years of eating pizza this was a pleasant surprise. The service great the cashier and server were very friendly. The decor was "sports bar, have a good time" type of place. When I'm in the area I'll go back for more! Thank you ladies

A wall to wall photo of dining area

The view from out front.

See all

Folks having a good time!

Fired Up Pizzeria

When you're just coming into town after a long day on the road and needing some comfort food, I'd…read morerecommend calling Fired Up Pizza for some fresh pies. Ordered one of their Vesuvius and kids pies, side salad and everything was excellent. Service was attentive for the pickup and was out the door in about a minute. Been really digging the wood fired pizzas lately as they have a nice and light, flakey, chewy crust. Full bar and a smaller dine in area if you want to sit down.

Horrible service & terrible servers. The good thing is the restaurant looks nice, but people are…read more Will never be back. Please save your money and spend it somewhere else!

Pepperoni with mushrooms, roasted garlic & arugula

The oven

12" Superior Pizza

See all

The Hideaway Grill

5.0

(1 review)

14.7 mi

The Hideaway in Vallecito Lake has just put it's first season under their belt. What a huge asset…read morethis place is to our little community. Not only is the staff amazing, the owners - Rob and Karen, are among the nicest people who have opened their restaurant to many fundraisers for locals when in need. This is a biker friendly bar that also has people of all ages and walks of life frequenting it on a regular basis. The food is always fast, excellent and the beer is the coldest you will find anywhere in the area. Great live music on weekends. Bike rally's and flat screen tv's all over the place showing the latest sporting event. A couple of warm stoves and fireplaces make this a really cozy place in colder weather and the expansive decks are great for drinks and dining as well. As a long time Vallecito resident, I am really glad they are here. We love the Hideaway - where there are no strangers, just friends you haven't met yet!

Vallecito Lake Country Market

Huge menu of great food made to order from Mexican to burgers to full dinners. And no visit would…read morebe complete without a scoop of the best ice cream.

The food was amazing we got a variety in our group and everyone loved their food. The lady who…read moreworked there and cashed us out was very sweet and the store/restaurant was outdated but Vallecito is old just holds more character to me. Food costs seemed normal ish compared to other restaurants. Can't wait to go back

See all

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

9 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Vet C.

0

7

0

7 years ago

I live in a pretty small town so...needless to say... food offerings are pretty limit. Having grown up with a LOT of Italians in Denver I'm pretty picky on pizza too.... but.....it's always worth a chance. I took the almost two hour round trip drive in the hopes and definitely wasn't disappointed. What a cool place...nice people and great pizza. I tried the White and the Margarita and they were both really good!! I had asked about take and bake because I was bringing them home for supper. The owner/chef insisted that the wood fired was the way they should be cooked and he was right. Thanks!!!! Anyway...if you are in Bayfield, Colorado, take the short jaunt into town to EEPA's Pizzeria. It's well worth it!! read more

K W.

0

1

0

7 years ago

Eepa's has a nice, relaxing, family friendly environment. The pizza options have entertaining names and the history of the business name is fun, too. I got the Mammaw, Caesar salad and both were delicious. Owner was kind enough to let us try dessert bread sticks that werent yet on the menu. Place was clean and employees seemed like they were having fun. We will come back. read more

Anna B.

0

3

0

7 years ago

We had the pizza, pepperoni egg rolls and hand cut French fries. It all was amazing. Great portion size and many options. Very fresh and homemade. The staff is very friendly and pleasant. They were very busy when we were there and still had smiles on their faces. Eepa's is a great change from the norm in a town with not a lot of good choices. read more

Ethan H.

0

1

0

7 years ago

Oi yah, the beloved land of Eepa's Pizzeria, recommended to me by my grandma. Lots of eepa going on, and a welcoming mamimama. I ordered an aya papaya burger with a side of rosier toenails and fresh squeezed warm brown milk, and all were delicious. I'll be sure to eepa hard next time I stop by. read more

Elizabeth S.

0

8

0

5 years ago

Was down visiting family and they recommended this place to grab a bite. Everything you could hope for in a small local business and I would highly recommend. There were plenty of options and everything we tried was perfect. 10/10 next time I am in town I will be stopping by for a slice read more

Jim B.

0

3

0

4 years ago

Eepas wood oven pizza does not disappoint. Good crust and tasty flavor combinations make for a nice visit. Their cheesy garlic bread is a good sharing snack. They also have Mike's Hot Honey for your crust. YUM And Crew working at Eepas is always friendly and welcoming read more

Grandma D.

0

1

0

7 years ago

Overall, great food and experience. Loved the rosier toenails were very crunchy. The warm brown milk is a must have, I hear its freshly squeezed from the indigenous Indians. The service was excellent as well, many fast eepamamas and mamimamas. read more

Molly M.

107

20

16

5 years ago

Went back for more pizzas today.... This place never ceases to amaze me. The cauliflower crust is suck a great option and they have a full bar! read more

Blake M.

46

1

0

6 years ago

Good crust, good pizza, fair price. One of the better pizza joints in the area. Will be back

Eepa’s Pizzeria - pizza - Updated July 2026

People who viewed Eepa’s Pizzeria also viewed

Homeslice Pizza

3.7

(317 reviews)

Had the heater pizza and a regular pepperoni pizza. The crust was perfect! Made great leftovers…read moretoo! The location was a charming neighborhood spot and the service was spectacular.

I had a great experience here!! Ambience gives dive bar, Shaun our bartender/ server was super…read moreattentive and inviting definitely the life of the place, our pizza was fireeeee salad to share, 2 cold beers to wash it down if I remember correctly we didn't spend more that $40.

HomeSlice Pizza

3.4

(131 reviews)

Food was delicious, service was on point in the busy hour, ambience is a great place to come great…read morea beer, enjoy a pizza and good vibes. You definitely feel the local and the traveler love here. Having traveled to many mountain and valley towns the pizza here was fire!! Also I'd like to mention Shaun was definitely the heartbeat of this place, high energy, gets to know your name, and very attentive to everyone that's here. 12 inch Pizza, side salad, 2 beers +20% tip $40!!

worst bartender in Durango works during daytimes. i've been three times when he's been working…read moreand I had horrible service all three times. David needs to sit him down and give him a course on customer service. He does not acknowledge anybody when they show up. He spends a lot of time chatting people up and won't even scan the bar. 1/2 hour wait is standard on his shift. i'm out of there anytime he's working. I'm going next-door or anywhere else. I went to JBOs after 20-mins of waiting at HS and was acknowledged and served inside of one-minute. Yay JBos, boo home slice. it's just this Bartender too. The other bartenders are great.

Father's Daughter's

3.3

(121 reviews)

Very nice server (it was the owner), and the food was awesome. My daughter has a gluten I tolerance…read moreand they took care of her no questions asked (quite rare in a pizza place). Great dinner for the whole family, and the value was fantastic.

FAN-freakin-TASTIC! Puffy gluten free crust! I got the good Greek! My daughter is peanut free and I…read moream gluten free

Roadhouse Pizza Company

4.0

(4 reviews)

Best grab and go breakfast burritos in Colorado and great grab and go burgers too. And they also…read morehave amazing NY style pizza and slices! The owner Jonny understands quality ingredients and he's doing it right!

I'm not a pizza snob or connoisseur but I have eaten a lot of pizza in my lifetime. The size of the…read morepizza was the perfect for two people. The ratios are also (to me) perfect. The crust has a crisp but a satisfying chew. The employees seemed to really enjoy their craft with the attention to detail on the presentation alone. Friendly, kind, and courteous! Great place to get take out from for a movie night with family with all the other snacks and beverages available in the convenient store section.

425 Degrees Take & Bake Pizza

4.5

(15 reviews)

•$$$

The take and bake pizzas are huge and taste delicious. The staff is always friendly and helpful…read more The ease in which you can run in and grab your pizza is great. You can also use the drive up.

A year later - still great pizza! Also a fun, funky store to check out while waiting on your pizza…read moreto be made. And as usual - friendly customer service. Oh - and there's a nice liquor store in the same parking lot.

Johnny Pizza

(9 reviews)

My cousin found Johnny's Pizza in Durango, Co and as New Yorker's we wanted to test his pizza and…read moresee how it compared to "real" New York pizza! The service was amazing and though small the place had a terrific ambiance! The owner, Johnny came to greet us and talk pizza with us. We were going to order a single slice and decided to order a 14 inch pie and boy oh boy we were happy we did. The pizza is amazing and I STRONGLY recommend that you visit Johnny's Pizza. The pizza definitely tastes like NYC pizza; the oil is dripping, the cheese was the right stringy consistency and the crust crispy but won't cut up the roof of your mouth. Personally, the crust is one of my favorite parts of the pizza! BOTTOM LINE: if you think you know great pizza you haven't tried Johnny's pizza in Durango,CO.

This is the best pizza in Durango, hands down!! The owner, Johnny, is in there all the time and…read morealways makes the experience 100% better! They have killer breakfast burritos too! As a local this is a regular spot for me always.

Papa Murphy's

3.5

(11 reviews)

•$

Best to-go heat at home pizza ever! Friendly staff and quick walk-in service. Come on in.read more

Take & bake pizza can be great--here, just expect that they won't have it done on time.read more

Hermosa Creek Grill

4.4

(166 reviews)

•$

We love this place for breakfast but lunch is also delicious. I had the Spicy turkey sandwich with…read moresweet potato fries and hubby had the reuben sandwich with regular fries. A lot of food and really good. Love watching the dogs on the patio, especially when they get a snack.

$-$$ A small breakfast/lunch nook behind a gas station on…read morethe way out of Durango, CO. My girlfriend, Wendy, and I would never have found the place without the help of her family with directions. We shared the eggs benedict, as we knew it would be way too much food for either one of us to eat. Our server was fabulous, the chefs in the kitchen were friendly and kind. The food that was served, was served hot and delicious. Ask one of the locals to point you in the direction of this little yet quaint and clean breakfast/lunch restaurant. My girlfriend, and I had a wonderful time. There's limited seating inside and out, but we enjoyed it immensely. Safe travels

Mini-Merc

(6 reviews)

These guys offer pizza...both full pies to go and hot pizza by the slice. They typically have…read moreseveral choices for slices, and it's very good. Getting gas? Go to Marathon in Bayfield and grab a slice or two to go.

was unaware that it was a gas station, however ordered some pizza that was honestly good…read moreconsidering it was gas station pizza

2nd Deli & Spirits

4.5

(59 reviews)