Always enjoyable, food is delightful as well as the margaritas. We really love the flavor of the…read moresalsa as well. We will keep coming back!

Ok. To be fair, we eat a lot of Mexican food and we don't get the most popular thing. If you just…read morewant a taco or enchilada, this might still be a good place. But the carnitas were not good. It kinda seemed like someone put them in an oven to heat and then forgot about them. Which might be why we waited 45 minutes after ordering. Hubbo liked his choripollo fine but it wasn't his favorite. We did get PLENTY of chips (crispy!) and salsa (good spice level!) and drink refills. They have a good shared system for tasks like that. We also got queso with ground beef for the chips. That was pretty good. We would try it again because we're curious about the chimichangas.

Quality of food and service is outstanding and is consistent over the years and i use it as my…read moreplace to go for special occasions.

We were seated quickly and served quickly on a Sunday afternoon. My burrito was absolutely…read moredelicious and my son liked his carne asada. My husband's dish was very very greasy. The corn dip was good but had a funny aftertaste like something sour on the end. It gave my mind an expired sour cream illusion. I'm sure it was not expired food but that is what the taste reminded me of. The waitress was so very friendly. We will be back as my burrito was delicious and service was great!

Visited for my birthday dinner and it didn't disappoint. Burra Rafael for me (so good), tequila…read moreshrimp for my husband and shrimp burra for my son. My husband said the tequila shrimp was delicious but he wished he didn't have to peel his shrimp. My son's burrito was gone in 3 minutes flat so I take that as a good sign. always great staff - so friendly.

As someone who grew up in California eating my grandma's homemade Mexican food I was throughly…read moreimpressed by Rio Tomatlan. I had very low expectations coming in and was surprised by the flavor and quality of the food here. I orders a Paloma which was refreshing and made me miss summer. I also had a sope that was the perfect thickness and wasn't overwhelmed by toppings. The salsa tasted like a less spicy version of my grandma's recipe, still delicious and flavorful. The service was a bit slow just due to an event going on, and it is a bit pricy for Mexican food, but otherwise I highly recommend

The food was delicious from the warm chips and queso dip, to my quesadillas and hard taco. Service…read morewas very good. We were in right at lunchtime on a Tuesday. Very pleased with our meal. I found the decor welcoming and clean. First time going there, will for sure return.

So the food is good. It was extremely busy in there so the service was slow. It was very clean in…read morethere.

Yum Yum Yum... I had heard about this restaurant but had not been out to try it yet. A bit of a…read moredrive for us but well worth it. I felt like you were at home - everyone seem to know each other, Sam was super attentive and friendly. Great decor and delicious food. Killers salsa wish they sold it to go. Can't wait to go back and try something new

Second visit. Been too long. Chicken Chimmichangas and Pollo Asada. Absolutely fantastic…read more Chicken was pinned, seasoned and perfectly cooked. Moist and tender. Wasn't sure we would have enough food when ordered but forgot this place doesn't mess around with portion sizes. I'm going back next week!

What an incredible experience…read more This restaurant gives meaning to the saying, "never judge a book from its cover." The reason I say that is, it's unassuming from the outside. Connected to an auto repair shop to the left and liquor store on the right. Arriving, we saw only a handful of tables that weren't cleared off from past customers. We waited by the front door not realizing you order from the window which is hidden in the corner. We were greeted by a friendly young lady and after we placed in our orders, we sat ourselves and waited for our food to arrive. The first thing to arrive was the guacamole with chips. We found the guacamole to be less chunky as we'd like, but nevertheless it was pleasant. The chips were overly salted in our opinion but did not take away from the dish. Then came the al pastor tacos. These were absolutely delicious. The pork was wonderfully marinated, and the toppings added to the entire taco rather than overpower the pork. We also opted in for the shrimp tacos, which were also quite delicious. Ordering a couple of empanadas, one steak and one al pastor, these were phenomenal. Taking a bite of each, you can identify everything inside these perfectly fried parcels. Very very good. I can confidentially say, this is the best Mexican food I've ever eaten and easily beats any of our Mexican restaurants here in Rochester. But a fair warning to future patrons. Don't expect to walk in and expect a full-service restaurant. Waiting times can be a little longer than expected as well. But the upside is receiving delicious, made-to-order food made with love and care. We'd make the trip to Sodus just to revisit this restaurant.

Amazing food with surprisingly fast service and authentic Mexican cuisine. Seriously blew me out of…read morethe water and I can't wait to go back. Also, the prices are so good I'm not sure how they stay in business, but I am certainly not complaining. Definitely worth the drive and can't recommend it enough.

Firstly, the food was delicious! Secondly, I loved the decor! The "Dia de Los Muertos" themed…read morefurniture was beautiful. Se were seated right away, the food arrived quickly and as I said, it was delicious! Prices were quite reasonable, I think it was $37 for two dinners, a beer and an iced tea. I'd absolutely recommend this place.

Service was mediocre, chips & salsa were good but pretty mild, and the carne asada tacos were good…read morebut not great. All in all pretty good Mexican food for the finger lakes.

Once you've made the trip to Casa Mezcal, you see the outside and you're not sure ... but then, you…read morego inside. It's a festival of amazing, kind service team members and a fiesta-like atmosphere. I was immediately awed by the 3 foot drink that I saw someone drinking at the bar. :) We have been there many times since, sitting in both the bar and the dining room to enjoy some AMAZING food. I've tried about 6 things and my husband too - we both LOVE this place and will continue to visit often. Check it out!!

We stopped by this restaurant on our way to Corning and visited for dinner. The restaurant seemed…read morequite busy when we arrived, but we were seated without much delay. We ordered the veggie bowl, chimichangas, and chicken with grilled vegetables, and all three dishes turned out to be delicious. The flavors were well-balanced, and the portions were satisfying. The service was a bit slow, likely due to how busy the restaurant was, but the quality of the food made up for the wait. Overall, we had a great meal and would consider stopping by again when passing through the area.