Just realized it's been 5 years since my last review so I thought I'd give an update one. First and…read moreforemost I've been coming here since I was kid and I know this bakery very well. Our Order: A bakers dozen (for a family get together) 2 jelly filled, 2 honey glazed, 2 apple fritters, and 6 white iced cream filled donuts. Execution of Our Order: Every donut was made fresh that morning. All the donuts got outstanding reviews from those who ate them. I absolutely love their donuts they were flaky, sweet, and tasted amazing. Seating: There are no seats here you will have to take the goodies to go. Staff and Services: Staff are always sweet and very welcoming. Their also very helpful if your not quite sure what you might want or if you wanna try something new. Drink Menu: They don't serve drinks here Food Menu: They have a very nice sized displays with multiple options. There is something for everyone here. They even have vegan options. Prices: $ Cleanliness: The establishment is always super clean Ombiance: Quiet and relaxed Overall Experience: Amazing Rating: 10/10 Recommendation: I definitely recommend if you're in it near circleville to come visit this amazing bakery you will not be disappointed. Family Friendly: Absolutely Stroller/Wheelchair Friendly: Yes

I can't believe I forgot to review this AMAZING place when I noticed the photos on my phone…read more I went during the pumpkin show and my advise is to go early or not during the show because in my photo, you'll see a big line wraps out the door and down a long ways. Worth the wait, though. Amazing doughnuts that are so soft and makes you wanna eat a full dozen before you leave.

Cake Tasting Cake included the following: * Chocolate…read more* White Almond * Red Velvet * Vanilla * Small Water Bottles (2) * Forks (2) * Napkins The staff that gave us the cakes was pretty nice. Shauna was prompt with emails. Ambiance was of a typical boba/bakery place.

Cute shop, yummy cupcakes, and great friendly service!…read more I was driving through the area and decided to bring some cupcakes in for my parents. After a quick search I found High Five Cakes that was on my way. Upon arrival I found meter parking close by. The shop was crowded for a Sunday (always a good sign) and I was warmly greeted when I walked in. There was a variety of cupcakes in the display cases and I picked up 7 cupcakes (a box of 6 and 1 for the road). I selected the Confetti, Death by Chocolate, Coconut Cream Egg, Strawberry, and Sugar Cookie Dough. Price point is $3 a cupcake which is a higher price point than I pay at similar shops in my metro area but was worth it. Besides love supporting small businesses and it's a really nice little shop. High Five cakes have boba teas, macarons, and other treats as well. Definitely would recommend.

This is the best bakery around! We live halfway between Waverly and Chillicothe and it is worth…read morethe drive every time!

Always delicious no matter what you order! Fresh and visually appealing. Order ahead online…read more We've ordered a variety of items for several large events and been extremely pleased.

I ordered them for a baby shower today. Everybody ranted and raved how great they tasted!! I…read morecouldn't be happier on my decision to have them bake my three dozen cupcakes for the event. I'll definitely spread the word to everyone I know to have Fantasy Cupcakes bake for their upcoming events! Thank you Fantasy Cupcakes, you're the best!!!

I consider myself a cupcake connoisseur so I was apprehensive about this place when I walked in and…read moresaw dog treats amongst the offerings. Could they make cupcakes for me and Fido?? Answer: Yes! The prices were a bit steep for the size of the cupcake, but I liked that they offered mini and full size treats. They had a wide assortment of flavors including seasonal. My favorite was the raspberry merlot seasonal. I tried a mini which was the perfect bite with a blend of raspberry filling and chocolate ganache. I loved how all of the cupcakes had some type of surprise middle, like the unexpected ball of cookie dough in the middle of the chocolate chip cookie dough. I want to go back and try the cake pops and the frosted sugar cookies but definitely a great cupcake experience.

My out-of-state aunt found Kelly's online and ordered a dozen Lavender cupcakes to be delivered to…read moreme on my birthday. Kelly delivered with a smile on Sunday morning, and the cupcakes were absolutely fresh and delicious. I am keeping her in mind for any future baking orders I will have!

Highly recommend Sweet Kelly's Cupcakes! She is so great to work with, super responsive and was…read moreable to create the perfect cupcakes for our gender reveal. Not only did they look amazing they tasted incredible! We ordered chocolate and buttercream frosting and they were so so good! The cake is perfectly moist and delicious. We devoured them up. She bakes out of her home and it was super easy to coordinate dropping off the gender reveal envelope and later picking up the cupcakes. Will definitely order from her again. Thanks, Kelly for making our moment extra special!

***UPDATE*** (10/19/2017) Oh my gawd, Becky, JALT's Buckeye…read moreCupcake is TO DIE FOR. The Buckeye ON TOP of the icing is, well, every bit as dreamy as they get! Pronounced peanut butter taste, not cheap sugar. This particular cupcake was made with the common eggs, flour, etc, and mad props to Sherri, cause this little gem was a moist, flavorful nugget of dessert heaven! Next party I need to bring dessert, I'm calling for a dozen of these morsels! Yep, damn straight skippy, I forgot to take a pic. However, my stomach doesn't give a care about how that makes you feel, cause it's completely satisfied.

The cupcakes were not only beautiful but absolutely delicious! I was blessed by having her make…read moreseveral dozen for my son's Graduation party. They were absolutely a great big hit with everyone! Thoughtfully packaged.

Made the trip to Valley Farmhouse Bakery for hot cocoa flights I saw on Instagram, sadly they did…read morenot have them and had a coffee flight this month. This was a busy bakery with good looking pastries. They have a drive-thru and walk-in service. There was a cold cooler of custom made cakes ready for pick up. The cakes looked pretty neat! This is a large open space and was cold inside. I ended up getting some items to go because it was too cold to take off my coat. I ordered a ham and cheese sandwich, peanut butter filled cupcake, a long john donut, and a chai tea. The chai tea latte was good. The rest of the food was meh. I didn't finish eating the rest of the cupcake and the sandwich was very basic and kind of tasted funny. Sadly this was not quite what I was hoping for on a cold wintery day and a trek from the Columbus area.

Absolutely amazing. The best sugar cookie (the almond extract makes them perfect) ever and they are…read morealways decorated with whatever adorable theme of the season. I just picked up a carrot cake cookie, OMG hands down the best carrot cake I have ever had. Do yourself a favor and travel to London to support this local gem.

I always feel bad posting reviews for bakeries because I'm not big on sweets. But nevertheless,…read morehere is my review of the place and the cream puff. The place is clean, cute and nicely decorated with some fun stuff for kids to play. There is plenty of parking right outside and the lady in the store was friendly and helpful. Unfortunately, there weren't many thing on display, which, to me, is a part of the fun of visiting bakeries. Cream puff was nice and big and heavy! LOVED the outside crust-flavorful, crunchy, airy and yum! The custard wasn't too sweet and you can taste the good egg flavor. It was really good and I would buy it again, though I wish there was a bit less custard. I had to leave some over because it was too much. However, maybe I felt that it was too much because I'm not a big dessert person. You might find it a balanced ratio, but either way, worth the try!

We were in desperate need of a birthday cake at short notice. I like to use local (not grocery…read morestore chains) when it comes to baked goods and called Friday for a cake to pick up Saturday. They were very accommodating over the phone and the cake was picked up at the appointed time which was terrific. Unfortunately I was very disappointed in the product. The appearance and taste of it was very amateurish, frankly I could've done better myself and I was actually surprised that a professional would have allowed it to leave the bakery. I will return and try their pies and other products before I completely write them off, but would never order another cake from them.

I ordered some cupcakes for my boyfriend to be delivered on Valentine's Day this year. Mind you,…read morethis order was placed THE DAY BEFORE VALENTINE'S DAY because time has a habit of escaping from me! Fate Cakes had an incredibly quick turnaround. They would be able to deliver the next day, so that was perfect. (Right before Valentine's Day, no less! Seriously impressive) Plus, I saw they had a deal on the website where you'd get free shipping ordering within a certain timeframe, so I went for it! Upon checkout, the free shipping deal didn't go through. I thought that was strange since I was definitely within the timeframe. So, I gave them a call (with no expectations - I was totally fine having to pay shipping anyways... at the very least, I just wanted to let them know that the deal wasn't working so they could take it down). The woman I spoke with was great. I showed her where the deal was written on the website, and she explained to me it was actually supposed to be taken off the website before that day, as the deal had expired. But, she honored it anyways and refunded me the shipping cost! Above and beyond expectations and a pleasant surprise - that is exceptional customer service! The cupcakes? Ridiculously scrumptious. 100% worth it. I will absolutely be ordering again.

Great customer service experience, Marie is great to work with. Our cake was beautiful, reasonably…read morepriced and delicious. We will definitely get cakes here again! The best buttercream I've ever had.