1. Fantasy Jewelers

    1. Fantasy Jewelers

    0

    West Babylon, NY

    Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Fantasy Jewelers

    1.0 (1 review)
    Closed 9:00 am - 6:30 pm

    Fantasy Jewelers Photos

    Recommended Reviews - Fantasy Jewelers

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration
    Photo of Charlie S.
    145
    55
    40

    9 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - Fantasy Jewelers

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Jewelry 3,735 times last month within 20 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    East Islip Jewelers - 2a) Prongs- no good

    East Islip Jewelers

    3.8(10 reviews)
    8.3 mi

    I took my late sister's silver ring in because the large agate stone was moving and I wanted it…read moresecured. Vanessa suggested adding prongs. The prongs did not look good. I used AI to get alternatives. I brought in a picture of a partial bezel that looked good and would secure the stone. Vanessa said we need to make a new ring. I agreed. When I picked it up, I was aghast that a completely new ring was made, not like the old ring and not like the ring in the picture. They actually rubbed out the details in the picture I gave her. When I reprinted it I saw the details they did not do. It looks like a man's ring now! Vanessa said they tried twice and cannot make me happy and she returned all my money. There was no effort to fix their mistake. Just go and good luck with what is now, a man's ring!

    I am not a jewelry person but i wanted some custom work done to a cross that was given to me as a…read morechild from a family member who passed away. They took my family members ash diamond and made it look perfect in the cross. Vanessa the rep who helped me when i walked in was very welcoming and did not make me feel weird about the request. John the jeweler who did the work did a phenomenal job. I couldn't be happier. Not only did it come out great but the cleaning they did to it made it look brand new again. It was literally almost black with tarnish. I will be going back whenever i need it cleaned. I would recommend them to anyone.

    Photos
    East Islip Jewelers
    East Islip Jewelers - 1) My original ring

    1) My original ring

    East Islip Jewelers

    See all

    Benny Jewelry

    Benny Jewelry

    3.0(4 reviews)
    0.4 mi
    $$

    I would definitely recommend buying jewelry from Benny. I live in west Babylon and went to all the…read morefancy jewelry places in the town of Babylon and they were very over priced and pushy. I even had the one lady calling me every day trying to get me to go back in. I ended up going to Benny and had a request for a custom ring. Not only did he say he can do it but he said he could make it with a bigger stone and better metal for not much more then a competitor was selling it for. I gave him a down payment and he got started. Shortly after I got injured at work and fell short on cash. He aloud me to give him a small amount of money every pay check until it was paid off. I had one more payment to make on the ring then found out through a friend that my Gf didn't like the ring I was picking out. I asked Benny if I could change the order even though he had already got the diamond, mold and had even poured the metal to cast the ring. He looked at me and said "No problem" no questions asked and after all that work he let me cancel that order and I put the money I had already given him into buying a beautiful ring that he had in the shop and my Gf loves it! He is an honest and understanding man and I feel that he truly holds the buyers best interest as apposed to just trying to make a quick buck off people. Go to Benny!

    Got here today (Thursday 4:30pm) and was greeted with a closed store, all dark and locked up. Is it…read moreme? Or is this sign in the window just a little off? Nice way of doing business

    Photos
    Benny Jewelry - Love, live, Laughter

    Love, live, Laughter

    Benny Jewelry - Benny Jewelry is honest, professional & works with you to find what you want. I had a great experience. I recommend him, love my ring

    Benny Jewelry is honest, professional & works with you to find what you want. I had a great experience. I recommend him, love my ring

    Benny Jewelry - The beautiful ring I got my Fiancé!

    See all

    The beautiful ring I got my Fiancé!

    Fantasy Jewelers - jewelry - Updated September 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...