I picked up a 16" 1/2&1/2 pizza yesterday 6:30pm which was to be 1/2 peperoni and 1/2 truffle shuffle. Getting home, the peperoni was on the side with the truffle shuffle, so the peperoni side was just cheese. The crust was very limp like wet cardboard. Not a good experience for a first-timer. read more

Great pizza! Forgot an ingredient on an online order and they were very accommodating. Very rare to find a local pizza joint with this good of gluten free options too! read more

As far as pizza goes here, they do not miss or disappoint. Fat Boys has catered pizza for a lot of parties, events and field trips I've been on over the years and it's always delicious! As far as the service goes, everyone there is super friendly and efficient and always on point! The store is also very clean and well maintained! Only complaint I have is that I had the chicken tenders once and I could not finish them, they were not very good in my opinion. I would really suggest them getting a different kind of chicken for that! read more

I Had my order delivered , Deep dish Pizza was not bad and not great. Right in the middle. Sauce was slightly sweet, common toppings that didn't deliver a lot of flavor . Was expecting , but did not get the burnt cheese edges that make a deep dish , was like a regular square pizza. Dough was soggy on bottom like oven wasn't hot enough. Pizza had some weight to it and was filling, the flavor didn't make me look forward to the next piece. After paying for delivery , fees , tip I was over $50 . Probably won't order out again. Delivery driver was really fast and very polite . read more

Wonderful pizza and staff is friendly.I just wish they had a larger sitting area to sit with family and really enjoy their good pizza! Only tiny table .Barely enough room for pizza box, plates, drinks. read more

Probably the most "meh" pizza I've had. It isn't horrible, and it isn't very good. If you're looking for pizza that's different from a generic big pizza chain, look elsewhere. Tastes mass produced for sure. read more

I always ordered online and my husband would pick up as the store is very close to our house. However the last 2 times, we were exhausted so we ordered for delivery. They delivered within 30-40 mins as stated on website. No delivery fee as long as your order is more than 12$ & if you order online, always 10% off. Both time we ordered southwest bbq chicken pizza. It becomes my favorite pizza now. It was hot (temperature wise), bbq sauce is right amount, bell pepper I usually not a fan but I ate every single piece. They have tomatoes in the pizza but I excluded it. Highly recommend to try this pizza. read more

Fat Boys Pizza - Southwest BBQ chicken pizza - Pizza Near Me - Holt, Michigan

Their food is a little pricey, though it's understandable for a smaller business. They make up for it in having their food taste great. If you're around Holt and wanting to try a new pizza place, check this one out, you won't regret it. read more

Excellent local business! The prices are fair, the food is yummy, and the delivery drivers are awesome!

We've been ordering from Fat Boys for around 15 years and their food is always delicious. But what is even more amazing is their customer service, they are always friendly and their delivery is so fast. They consistently give back to the community and are a wonderful part of Holt. read more

Pizza was great. Crust wasn't too thin, or too doughy. Pepperonis were nice and crisp. Plentiful green olives. We also got some breadsticks but probably won't again, since they looked like just a plain pizza crust cut up - which was fine! Just not my cup of tea. This place is local and close to many people... surprised it doesn't have more reviews! Also online ordering is a HUGE plus! We will definitely be back. read more

Fat Boys Pizza - 14" round with pepperoni and green olive - Pizza Near Me - Holt, Michigan

See all

This is probably the most popular pizza joint in Holt...so we em a try. We picked up a couple of pies in Oct 2020. A Judy's Salad pizza - Really good! It was light and fresh. Not heavy and greasy or guilt ridden...lol. Feta cheese, no mozzarella, lots of lettuce, banana peppers, tomatoes etc vinegar dressing ,so good. Nice change up! The other...back to our old ways - The Hog Wild...ugh, Ham, sausage, pepperoni, meat meat meat. Its good but heavy. Kind of predictable. Anyway. Next time we'll try the sandwiches...we heard they're good too. Lastly, the kid that took my phone order was pretty disinterested in doing his job...kind of a bad intro experience for this reviewer. But not a deal breaker, maybe better next time. read more

See all

They were recommended by a coworker several months ago. I ordered their Supreme and their veggie pizza. I am hooked.

Food. Good food for great guests and good group meals are here. Not really a "by the slice" type of place but rather get the whole pie it's the best pizza in town! read more

Order a pizza, 40 minutes later not even in the oven... delivery sucks.... Not good service

Ok. So the spicy bbq pizza was amazing. Nice heat, perfect crust. I'd order it again and again. My husband has a sandwich and he couldn't stop raving about it. Go get pizza and sandwiches but skip the breadsticks...they were lame. Not much to them. Thin and kinda crunchy. No beuno. Everything else was top notch! read more

I commend the employees. First time ordering from this place because i wanted to try the pizza. I ordered over the phone with no issue. Arrived at the store and received my medium cheese pizza hot and fresh out of the oven (i actually saw them take it out). So basically, the employees did everything right. The pizza was hot and correct as ordered. They get 5 stars. The only major problem was that the pizza tasted like chuck-e-cheese pizza. read more

See all

Painfully average. Same price as jets or green lantern but little caesars quality. Service seemed deliberately pedestrian. Unfortunately Holt/Lansing is all chain pizza trash. read more

RUDE RUDE RUDE!!!! I go to different places to try foods to review and recommend. Smh couldn't even experience it. The first guy I talked to nice...the 2nd guy WOW REALLY!!!!??? Refund, if you're getting smart and acting the way you are who knows what you'd do to my pizza. Disappointed...I hope you aren't the manager. It's definitely not about the price of a $1 different but when a missed order online ask about the price difference paying in person and you try to make someone feel beneath you and incompetent, YOURE the one with the issue dude! read more

Attempted to deliver an order. The old man at the counter was very rude and tried to talk down to me as if I was stupid for not reading pickup instructions even though they don't show up until you accept an order. read more

I grew up on fatboys pizza. Grew up in holt in the 90s.. was soo good. So many Friday pizza nights in the 90s.. order a large pie after school rent a video cassette a couple doors down. Had fatboys over the years.. moved away.. another town. Today.. my Saturday.. wanted to show my girlfriend how great their pizza was... ordered drove a half hour. And to my dismay they changed the cheese.. ruined it!! It's not fatboys anymore.. its just some fake.. I couldn't eat it.. tasted terrible.. 30 years and you change the recipe!!!???? Madness!!! I can't and won't recommend thus to anyone... my childhood ruined.. you were the chosen one and you squandered it!!! read more

Pizza is always on point with a very speedy delivery even on weekends. The breadsticks aren't my favorite, wish they were softer, but we still order them every time. read more

My dad worked here a long time ago, pizza is really good but the breadsticks are the best thing on the menu, I recommend going here.

Great food and service, local, fast, pan pizza, surprisingly different tasty pizza options.

We ordered a pizza from Fat Boys when we were watching a double header girls softball game. I don't remember the name of the pizza but it was totally delicious, maybe the best we've ever eaten. It was the one with everything on it. We will certainly go back to Fat Boys Pizza. I'm giving it 4 stars because ordering online and having to use a credit card but being charged extra for using the credit card. Not good. read more

Best pizza in holt by far, family owned, everyone's nice. And I have never had an issue with an order, which says something as I've ordered at least 100 times. read more

Puts me in the mind of Goodfathers pizza. Lived in Lansing for quite sometime, but just found this place last year. Great spot!!!

Best pizza in town! Love their ham, and their BBQ chicken pizzas. Their ranch is also delicious. Highly recommend.

The pizza was so delicious! Here are a few things that I appreciated about this place. First, the staff members were extremely nice and accommodating. I wanted my pizza ready at a certain time and they met that expectation. They were also extremely kind when I entered the business. Second, the food is so delicious! The pizza and bread sticks were tasty without being greasy, I really appreciated the flavor and freshness. Lastly, I greatly appreciated the organization being open late on a Saturday. I was able to order food for my roommates and I before our UFC PPV began. This is important as we did not want to order food early as we want to eat as it's actually about to begin! Thanks so much for the incredible service and food! read more

I get this pizza every paycheck. If you like spicy and love bacon then I would suggest a jalapeño bacon light on the sauce. They always have a special going on every month that doesn't change (2 large 2 toppings for $19.99) or you could always spend $16~ for 1 large. Great pizza though! read more

Good pizza! Helpful staff. If your looking for a place to find real food while supporting local business, fat boys is for you.

Fat Boy's is kinda "meh" to me. They are friendly, but slightly disorganized. The Pizza is the greasiest mess of slop I've ever had the pleasure to eat, though. If it weren't one of the most convenient places to go in Holt, I'd probably not come here. The breadsticks are soggy with oil and are probably best left to those with an appetite for pain. But don't get me wrong - it is tasty as all get out! It's just not the most appetizing looking thing I've eve seen, and makes you feel like scheduling a liposuction after your first slice of pizza. Come here once and decided if you can handle the grease. If you can, it will be deliciousness delivered fresh and hot. read more

Better than average takeout and delivery. Fast service, good prices. They seem to be the only takeout place I've seen that has consistently good pizza. Better than the chain places and consistently better than others I've tried in south Lansing. read more

Once again Fat Boys was AWESOME! We go out of our way by 20 minutes just to get pizza from here. Got the same order last 3 times and everything perfect! Made sure to tip $15 last 3x even though we were driving 20 minutes to get our $24 order. We appreciate the staff and great food! Wish you would drive to Potterville. Definitely would pay up charge and a tip. read more

I LOVE FAT BOYS PIZZA! I don't want to admit it, but I eat their pizza quite a bit. I usually order delivery, my pizza is always hot and perfectly done, usually arriving right on time or a little early. The delivery drivers are always courteous and respectful. I think they have the best pizza in town. I definitely recommend you try their Italian Herb thin crust pizza, it's delicious! read more

The pizza I got tasted like cardboard box. It used to be better than what it is now. I am very disappointed.

Just tried the meatball sub at fat boys....was ready and waiting for me to pick up...toasty...the bun was perfect n crunchy...meatballs were great...not too much sauce...was very impressed...service waz good too. read more

I had the Hog Wild with an order of cheesy bread. Phenomenal pizza - it was great all around, but the crust was possibly my favorite! Cheesy garlic bread wasn't my favorite so I'll try the reg bread sticks next time. Super quick too! read more

Always delicious, always in 15 minutes, always friendly service. When I'm getting pizza it is always from Fat Boys because they use fresh ingredients and it is always yummy. read more

Pizza is one of my favorite foods to eat and I don't like most pizza chains. I had been getting advertisements from fat boys in the mail for a while so I gave them a shot. Ordered a small pizza with pepperoni and it was delicious. On top of that, the pizza was delivered in 25 minutes. Will be ordering again and definitely recommend. read more