Spot right on the water with good food and service. They have daily happy hour until 6: $1 off drafts and wells, wine special, and beer bucket deal. They have an inside spot and an outside bar area. They have lots of live music. We also did trivia on Thursday which was really fun! read more

Let me start by saying the food is good, but it is overpriced for the quality. My husband and I split a salad, pizza and each had a cocktail and the total was $70. The pizza toppings were TINY. We are talking "minced" and sparkling sprinkled. The "wedge" was good but hardly any lettuce and smothered in dressing and candied walnuts. The drinks were fine but around $15 a piece. They charged $2.00 extra to make a whiskey an old fashioned. There was really nothing wrong about this place, just nothing special for the price. read more

Thought second time would be the charm. It's not the food per se, although thats ok. The service is just terrible. Here's an example "what's good here, like what do you like", answer: "well I make my own stuff so....(goes silent). Couple it with the outside deck ambiance of a dimly lit garage with a view and there is not a lot to be desired. Presumably their bread and butter is the outside bar?? I hate not being positive about a local establishment because I want to have great places to eat here - but get the service right. Train your staff. read more

Asked server if chicken would be hot in wrap due to being pregnant and not being able to have cold meat. She said yes it's served warm. Got it it was ice cold. Asked for it to be warmed up and she said the cooks said it was supposed to be served cold. She did take the chicken out and warmed the meat Sat outside. Once they turned lights on bugs everywhere. Some were stuck to outside of the glass drink, which completely grossed me out and made me not want to drink from it read more

Fathoms Restaurant & Bar - Pretzel - New American Near Me - Cape Coral, Florida

See all

It's sizzle dining month and I've been excited to try as many locals restaurants as possible. We decided that we would give fathoms a go, I'm not sure I've been here before last weekend. We had a reservation and a large party but we were sat right away which is nice. Our server came over to greet us and was very nice throughout dinner. Things didn't come out super fast but I never expect that too much with a big group. Good thing we love catching up and that doesn't bother us. The food was pretty decent. I started off with the Waygu meatballs which were tasty but would have used a bit more sauce and cheese. For my entree I had the lamb which did come with veggies and potatoes ( I had asked for no veggies) my potatoes not pictured were very good! For dessert I had the chocolate cake which was really more of a chocolate moose and Omgsh was it delicious. So creamy and way to eat, although a bit rich but I loved it. Great for people on vacation who want a bite to eat near the water! read more

See all

We weren't there for an early dinner tonight. Evidently they have half-price pizza on Wednesdays. However, there is no change to the menu if you do not want to have something on your pizza like green peppers. They will not substitute green peppers for basil. And, the pizza special only starts at 5 PM. The staff is not very nice. I'm in 31 year Florida Inn and I will never go there again. read more

The food was pretty good here! I wish there was a coconut shrimp appetizer but instead I got it in my Caesar Salad. The Lobster Roll was huge and loaded with meat. Restaurant is in. Great location, right on the water. read more

Fathoms Restaurant & Bar - Caesar Salad With Coconut Shrimp - New American Near Me - Cape Coral, Florida

The food is always great. Unfortunately, the indoor drinks consistently fall short, especially considering the price. The descriptions make them sound fabulous, but they arrive in plain tall glasses with little presentation and do not taste like anything special. The drinks are givin dive bar than upscale.I ordered a habanero margarita with fresh coconut purée and fresh coconut flakes. Then I ordered a skinny spicy margarita and it came and looked and tasted like the same thing, but as if they just added soda water to the first one. read more

Fathoms Restaurant & Bar - This was supposed to be a spicy margarita with puréed coconut and fresh coconut flakes. - New American Near Me - Cape Coral, Florida

We stopped for lunch and ordered a pizza and drinks. The pizza was burnt and I said something about it to the waitress and she just walked away. It was awful!. I guess this is why no one was eating here! Never again! read more

I have been eating mahi for 60 years and it was absolutely the worst mahi I've ever had dry burnt tasteless

This place is really nice and is near a bunch of fun scenic things. There is an entertainment plaza in the heart of the shopping center. And then in the back, is a breath taking harbor with all the cool boats docked and where the sunsets at the perfect angle from sitting outside. For our Appetizers we ordered the: Tsunami Rolls which were super fresh and flavorful. The Bavarian Style Soft Pretzel with a Honey Dijon Creamy Mustard was pretty good too. And the Goat Cheese Spread is phenomenal with the perfect amount of walnuts and bacon (sweet and salty ratio). My entree was the Cape Harbour Shrimp Mac & Cheese which different was a different twist on Cajun. The ubiquitous sauce was thick and creamy with the right amount of spice (not too spicy). My Family Ordered Entrees such as: Spicy Hawaiian Pizza, Burrata Caprese Salad with Chicken, and the Caesar Salad with Coconut Shrimp When getting sitting for our party of 11, we were able to get super fast and order our food. Our server was a gentlemen and knew our needs ahead of time to help us prepare the best for all of our meals as they came out. read more

See all

The food was excellent. I had the Snapper special and was fabulous. I love the Labor Day weekend no one is here and service is quick. The ambiance is cool with all the boats. You must come here and enjoy read more

Service was fine. Ate lunch w a large group on the outside patio. The food was definitely not great. The lobster roll tasted freezer burned. The caesar salad was overdressed. The fish and chips were overcooked. And the cajun mac and cheese was watery and bland. The turkey club was fine. The steak fries were fine. The calamari was just ok and the crab rangoon was also bland. Would not return to this place. read more

Fathoms is a great restaurant overlooking the water in Cape Coral. The food is wonderful. We started with Gorgonzola stuffed flatbread followed by fish and chips and pan seared grouper over risotto. Finally, we ended with a delicious Chocolate toffee cake. The fact that they were dog friendly and had heaters on the patio was a bonus on a chilly Florida night. I definitely recommend Fathoms. read more

See all

I had a wonderful experience here. The ambiance and view was fun and felt I was on the coast over looking the water. The service was quick at 4:30, before it got busy. I was very happy with arugula/prosciutto pizza and steak bites. Flavor was great and cooked perfectly, the crust on the pizza was crisp and flavorful. read more

Fathoms Restaurant & Bar - Pizza napoleon - New American Near Me - Cape Coral, Florida

I ordered an expensive ribeye and it's inedible all fat and impossible to even cut no meat at all. Very disappointing. Something definitely wrong with this meat and your 2 yr minimum sitting at a table outside is a black eye.., spending so much $$ not a good deal there. Get more tables or change that bad rule not good to be chased out or charge less for your food something should be done. read more

We were regular customers of Fathoms. We are permanent residents so we supported them during the slow season. Last night we sat outside to listen to the band. We were sitting near three outdoor tables. Servers came out to those folks ignored us. We asked about a server and were told they were too busy to serve us. And it is not even peak season yet. WOW too busy to wait on customers imagine that. It will be a long time before we go back there. read more

After getting NO SERVICE at the Paradise Tiki, we came to Fathoms and Kristin made up for it. Perfect service. Enjoyed bloodies, brews and their fantastic beet salad. read more

We tried out Fathoms last evening. They hosted a Golden Retriever Rescue event on the outside patio part of their restaurant. That was what drew us. Located in the beautiful Cape Harbor Marina is a definite plus. There is the beautiful waterfront and some shopping all in one place. Predictably on a Friday evening, there was a 45 minute wait for a table. Not a problem. There was outdoor music and a bar. The time went by pleasantly. When we got seated, we had a table overlooking the Marina, right at sunset. My husband ordered the Cajun Mac and Cheese. It was delicious! Lots of andouille sausage and shrimp in it! I got the Wagyu Burger and fries. It was not a disappointment! Juicy and very flavorful! The fries were hot, golden and crispy. Our waitress couldn't have been any nicer. This is a restaurant I will definitely go back to. read more

Wonderful outdoor area to watch the boats heading toward the gulf. Great drinks and appetizers as well

We are regulars at the outside bar. was not a good day. Sat at the bar for 10 minutes while the blonde barmaid talked to other employees on the other side of the bar. when she finally visited our side of the bar she looked at us, then turned to other people she knew that just walked up. didn't day a word to us and she left the bar to talk to these people. we left . Out of season, most bars need the business..... read more

Fathoms had always had great food. We got the grouper and scallops. Both were delicious. read more

Fathoms Restaurant & Bar - Grouper and risotto - New American Near Me - Cape Coral, Florida

See all

I had the beet salad with goat cheese which is absolutely delicious! It's my new go to meal whenever I visit. Seeing that I live within walking distance it's often. I've even brought a friend who ordered and went back with her husband so she could order it again. It's that delicious! read more

Fathoms Restaurant & Bar - Beet Salad with Goat Cheese - New American Near Me - Cape Coral, Florida

Hailey was the absolutely best!!! Our party of 6 had a great time with amazing service on the outside patio. The giant pretzel is a must and do yourself a favor and order a side of cheese to go with it. My dad ordered the lobster roll and even though it was different than the original menu, it was legit lobster crazy and delicious. The turkey club sandwich was awesome and every drink was great! We went on a Tuesday with live music at the outside bar and danced all night until 10:00!!! read more

I visited Fathoms on a beautiful Saturday in March around 5 for dinner with a group of 8. We did not have a reservation and were able to be seated outside near the water immediately. The staff was attentive from the start bringing water for all and then promptly getting our drink orders. We got two bottles of red wine. They have a nice selection with a diverse price range. My husband and I always order two items and share. We ordered the seafood pizza and the lamb sausage. The seafood pizza was not flavorful unfortunately. Probably needs a bit of garlic or infused oil and salt. The lamb sausage was really great, the lamb flavor was strong which was unexpected. I love the flavor of lamb and wished I saw it more on menus like this in unique ways. The outdoor waterfront area is a real treat. Best to sit outside on a nice day. read more

Fathoms Restaurant & Bar - New American Near Me - Cape Coral, Florida

See all

Would not go back or suggest this restaurant. Although, this is a beautiful location this restaurant misses the mark on the food. No presentation or quality of food. Ordered the short rib risotto, it was ok, no sides or even a garnish. Guess they feel "no need to go with the little extras". Quality control would be a start for improvement. We asked for bread and we were charged for it, wouldn't have minded paying for it if it was good. If there was a lower rating I would use it. Very disappointing. read more

Took the whole family here for dinner. The calamari was a great appetizer, but our entrees were good not great. We would eat here again but would likely look for other options first. read more

We came on a partly cloudy day, so it was comfortable outside to eat 1 pm lunch. Breakdown, food 4, was quite good, though medium rare burger was very rare and undercooked. Expensive at $52 for a burger, lobster roll and 2 colas without tip. service 2,, rather unfriendly and we felt neglected. Never checked back or got refills. view 5, of cape harbor is awesome. Environment 0, allow smoking. Will try it again down the road. read more

See all

We got in to Cape Coral late afternoon/early evening and by the time we got to our accommodations we were famished. Fathoms is only a few blocks and it was getting late so we came on by and glad we did. For a Saturday night it wasn't too crowded so we were seated right away and chose the outdoor seating overlooking the boat docks. The staff here are very friendly. With our drink orders taken and brought to us we order our meals. Bourbon Street Mac and cheese loaded with seafood and a shrimp risotto. Both meals were delicious and hit the spot. I'm told they have live entertainment on Tuesdays and Saturdays. May be coming back for lunch before we leave the Cape. read more

See all

I've lived in the Cape for 7 years and can't believe it's taken me that long to dine at Fathoms. Food, ambiance and service were all superb! We thoroughly enjoyed our lunch at Fathoms. We started off with their salmon ceviche and it was delicious. I had the lobster roll and that was delicious too. We ended our meal with dulce de Leche mousse which was creamy and very yummy. It was the perfect way to end our meal. I highly recommend dining at Fathoms! read more

Fathoms Restaurant & Bar - Ceviche- super fresh and tasty! - New American Near Me - Cape Coral, Florida

Food and service are excellent. They have entertainment from bands to trivia contests Great location read more

Great place on the water and service and food were excellent I would definitely recommend you crying this place.

Service either totally sucks or they can't hire enough staff. Pizza is good, though . read more

After driving all day down to Cape Coral, we want to find a place with outside seating and Fathom's came in clutch. The staff is all wearing masks and there are tons of open seats outside right off The water. It was very open and felt safe. I ordered the burger and it was pretty good! They cooked it perfectly and the onion jam was such a great addition. The French fries were nothing special. There are pizzas, salads, sammies and even a sushi roll! Lots of good-looking cocktails and a pretty decent wine list, too! read more

Fathoms Restaurant & Bar - New American Near Me - Cape Coral, Florida

Food was absolutely fine! Oysters were good. Good serving sizes and it came out fairly quick. Horrible server unfortunately! (Jennifer) Gave her $18 on accident (wanted to tip more due to our meal cost) and she came back to ask what she did wrong to earn such a low tip! Bad service from her and then being rude? Such a shame! Food was good. read more

Sitting on Fathoms porch overlooking the marina is wonderful. "DONT LOOK DOWN you will be looking at bird droppings and dirty porch. The door leading to the porch is disgusting! This restaurant could make the mark if they would hose down the porch and clean tables. If they want it be upscale to match the price make it more desirable. Tables are not attractive, put tablecloths or have candles on tables to make them inviting! Also flower planters would be attractive! We would love for this area to attract people to drive from all over to dine. PS All the porch decks in Harborer are disgusting and need to be cleaned daily.Oyster Grill,French press unsanitary for a resort area. Clean it up and people will come through out the year. Three star review read more

Great location right on the harbor. Fun place for lunch, dinner, casual atmosphere, Very good menu. Service is excellent.

Amazing service, the hostess and our server really make us feel welcome. Cold cuts and Cheese board good but looks more like a salad. Dessert decent. I don't who was on the kitchen last night. But they really need to retrain this crew about how to cook a burger. Wagyu beef burger was over cooked... twice! Blackened Mahi Sandwich over cooked dried and mushy tomatoes. Don't forget guys is a restaurant is all about the food. Drinks, wine, ambient, furniture, service, is important but is all about the food. Maybe looks just like a "remake" order but is a little more from customer perspective, Affect the Experience, moment, expectation, time and money in a Covid world. Thank you Janine for your attention and handle the complain like a Manager. (Manager never show up to apologize for the inconvenience) . Good look and hope you read this as a chance to work with the opportunities in your operation. read more

Fathoms Restaurant & Bar - New American Near Me - Cape Coral, Florida

We love that they added Michelob Ultra on draft. The best! Our food was fantastic- I had the fish special and my husband had the turkey wrap. Yum! Service was great! We had Kristin and Jen inside and Ashley outside. Looking forward to the next time! read more

We always enjoy our time at Fathom's. Food quality is consistent and there is usually musicians too!