We saw this on maps during our travel from the airport to our condo, and decided to give it a try. So glad we did. It is a small place, but so friendly. We were able to pick a seat, had quick service and were treated like one of the regulars (and we saw quite a few of them pop in and out). Had a very family run feel with pictures and TVs on the wall. The food was so good, a large cheese was the perfect size for me, my husband, and teenage son. Prices were affordable, and it was a nice low key lunch after a crazy travel day. We hope to get back before we leave. If you are in the area stop in (they do take out as well!) read more

Amazing , practically New York pizza. The staff is great and the pizza is great we love the crust. Can't go wrong with any pizza but Cheese or veggie is my favorite read more

If you're looking for great pizza, Little Sicily is definitely worth a visit! I ordered the Grandma pie, and it was outstanding. The sauce was absolutely delicious, and the crust was cooked to perfection--crispy, flavorful, and just right. I can't wait to go back and try another one. People were great too, I'll be back soon! read more

Little Sicily - Grandma Pie - Italian Near Me - Fort Myers, Florida

See all

Ceiling fans spin overhead as Beatles music softly plays .Nikia, our server, was amazing. The food was as good as what we get in Gateway and at a better price point. Probably why they pack them in at this establishment. Homemade Italian fare, delicious desserts and perfect service. To go or eat on site. Yes this is is the best pizza I've ever eaten in Ft Myers. Beer , wine and soft drinks available, perfect for couples, families, for anyone who likes great homemade food and service. First visit , totally exceeded my expectations... Great job by the staff at Little Sicily..., read more

See all

What a cute little family owned italian restaurant! The space is casual and inviting. The service was fast and friendly. They have a variety of dishes on the menu, including sandwiches, pizza, and pasta. The portions are huge and a value for the price! The meatballs were to die for, and the pizza crust was perfect chewy. Best pizza in Fort Myers, maybe!! read more

Little Sicily - Supreme pizza - Italian Near Me - Fort Myers, Florida

We took our visiting daughter for a bite to eat before leaving town. There are so many restaurants to choose from, but she has never been to Little Sicily so we came here. The service is quick, the ambiance is comfortable casual and the pizza is samazing! Since all three of us like meatballs and extra cheese (plus extra sauce for my daughter and her father), that's what we ordered. The crust is crisp and the toppings are fresh. So good! Little Sicily well-deserves their 5-Star Yelp rating! read more

See all

The pizza was very good with plenty of topping, good quality cheese, and fresh vegetables. The baked pasta was very tasty, and a huge serving. The salads were fresh with a nice selection of vegetables and other goodies. The deserts were very good, even on top of a full stomach. The service was first rate, a bit like getting served by family. Helpful, constantly running (I mean walking very fast) and friendly even with a slammed dining room. The restaurant is strip mall casual Italian. All glass in the front, a large menu board, and pictures on the wall with a small counter separating the kitchen from the dining area. We will be back to try the Siscillian style pizza. read more

This unassuming place in a strip mall turned out to have our favorite meal of our trip! The place was casual, small and clean. The wait staff was prompt, attentive, and very friendly. The food was the star, though. We split an order of steaming fresh garlic bread knots with dipping sauce. Give me a straw because that sauce was fresh and bright with the right amount of acidity. We also split an order of chicken parm on fettuccine. The chicken was fork tender and plenty for two hungry adults (still had some left over). It had just the right amount of mozzarella and the amazing sauce -- it didn't drown the dish. The menu had a small but decent wine selection. Will definitely make note to return here!, read more

Little Sicily - Garlic Knots - Italian Near Me - Fort Myers, Florida

Very kind staff* they were helpful and helped carry my order to car Good food and reasonable read more

I ordered a couple of slices and one meatball to go. It was so so but the sauce with the meatball is awesome. Went back the next day and got a quart of sauce to go. Some of the best I ever had. read more

The pizza was good we order the steak and cheese sandwich as well and the sandwich blew the pizza out of the water. Very good sub.

I was lucky enough that I had a TikTok video cross my for you page for little Sicily before I went on vacation to Fort Myers. Little Sicily is a great pizza spot! They have pizza by the slice so that you can try a couple different pizzas if you want. I personally tried the pepperoni pizza, the Margherita pizza, the meatball pizza, the meat, lovers pizza, and the Sicilian cheese. The Sicilian delicious but it wasn't for me. The regular slices were delicious! The crust was thin and crispy, but also chewy if that makes sense. The toppings were A1! I tried a couple of their desserts as well, and a tiramisu was so good and they give you a huge portion. The cannoli was light and crispy on the outside and a delicious filling on the inside. The ladies that work there have the best customer service and make sure you are taken care of. We went twice during our one week vacation because it is good and it was really decently priced. Our family of three got four slices of pizza, an appetizer, a salad, a dessert, and soft drinks for under 50 bucks before taxes. That's crazy! You can get a HUGE slice of pizza here cheaper than you can get a tiny a taco other places. I love Little Sicily and we will definitely be back every single time we come to the area. read more

See all

Stop by to have an early lunch at Little Sicily. Please note that Little Sicily closed on Monday despite on Yelp stated Mon 11:00 AM - 9:00 PM. The vibe here is casual and friendly. They serve NY style thin crust pizza. You can order by slices or by pie! Good selection from Cheese, Margherita, Bruschetta, Veggie, Buffalo Chicken, Chicken Bacon... to German Cheesesteak Pizza. Today, with light rain and overcast dark cloud, I had Stromboli instead of pizza. That pepper, onion, mushrooms, with ham, pepperoni and sausage in the pizza dough with cheese left me out the dark sky. The fresh ingredients and perfect cooking with a Corona that make it a wonderful meal! Beside pizza, they have pasta like linguine with clam sauce, Fettuccine Alfredo, Pasta Primavera, etc. The staff here is friendly and smiling. The restaurant is centrally located near US-41 and Six Mile Cypress. A good place to have pizza and pasta! read more

See all

Looking for a pizza place and the reviews look good so we stopped at Little Sicily. Wow, it sure did not disappoint. The meat lovers pizza goes out of this world. The only negative is that it's 2 1/2 hours away from our house.. The service was also amazing. read more

Little Sicily - Meatlovers Pizza... it was amazing! - Italian Near Me - Fort Myers, Florida

My only regret was forgetting to take pictures of all our food! Their pizza was absolutely delicious! We ended up ordering another pie! My dad also enjoyed the linguine clam pasta, my husband a Stromboli and their wings were perfection! Although they were extremely busy, they were very friendly and accommodating! read more

Little Sicily - Half pepperoni pizza - Italian Near Me - Fort Myers, Florida

Picked up a couple pizzas to go. Delicious! Will definitely come again! Generous size and the crust was tasty.

Quickly becoming my favorite pizza spot. This was my third or fourth time eating, but my first time eating in the restaurant. The pizza has always been perfect, the staff made it even better. Also they have way more than just pizza and I was eyeing other tables food and it looked great! read more

Little Sicily - Italian Near Me - Fort Myers, Florida

While visiting Fort Myers for a few days, we decided to try someplace we had not been and we're so glad we did! The pizza shop is clean, well priced, great service and great pizza. We sampled several appetizers, including garlic knots, poppers and the rice ball, all were fantastic. The rice ball, in particular, impressed us with its flavor and texture. We also tried the Margherita pizza. It did not disappoint, the crust was excellent. Though the restaurant is on the smaller side, don't let that fool you. They have plenty of seating options, including six-seat tables, four-seaters, two-seaters and a spacious bar-style seating area along the side wall. Overall, we had a great experience and will definitely be back the next time we're in town! We would suggest anyone wanting pizza that is very good, give this place a try! read more

See all

I live in SE Cape and have no problem driving to Little Sicily for pizza. It's the closest NY pizza I can find and love it.

Just finished a large pepperoni and sausage thin crust. Very good! We're from St Louis and visiting for a week. Went to Yelp looking for pizza. Little Sicily was rated #1. Great recommendation. Little family restaurant which makes you think of pizza places from years ago. Try it, you won't be sorry. read more

Little Sicily - Italian Near Me - Fort Myers, Florida

Little Sicily 11-16-24 Stopped by with some friends around 6:30pm on a Saturday. This place was neat, clean well lit and easy to park. Our waitress Katlin came over fast and took all our drink orders. She was back fast to deliver our drinks and take our food orders. I ordered the Stromboli which had Green Peper, Onion, Ham, Mushrooms, Pepperoni, and Sausage. I also added a house salad which had Spring Mix, Tomato, Onions, and Olives. My wife ordered an Italian Hoagie which came with Ham, Salami, Provolone, Lettice, Tomato, Onion, Oil, and Vinegar. She added a Tossed Salad which had Spring Mix, Roasted red Pepper, Artichokes, Olives, Tomato, Red Onion, and Cheese. She also ordered a slice of Cheese Pizza. Our friends ordered Fettuccine Alfredo and a Pasta Primavera. Our food orders came out in reasonable time, and everything was hot. My Stromboli was fantastic and packed full of meat & Cheeses. My wife's slice was very good, and her Hoagie was packed full of meats and lettuce and tomatoes. She said it was one of the best subs she ever had in this area. Our friends stated their Fettuccine Alfredo, and a Pasta Primavera was very good. This place was a pleasant surprise. Our waitress Kaitlin was amazing and on the ball for all our needs even the owner Joe came over to our table to make sure everything was ok. I give this place 5 out of 5 stars because of the great food, fantastic service, ice cold beer and reasonable prices. I believe you all need to try this place you will not be sorry. Follow Me On FB For More Reviews. Gulf Coast Terry read more

See all

Good service and good food. A great combination in atmosphere! This is where I took my friends when we wanna enjoy a good time and they good place. read more

Cute little place with fantastic pizza felt like I was at grandmas house everyone was very friendly and accommodating I will be back!

Ordered a pizza for takeout. Opted for a large, build-your-own, NY style crust. Added sausage, green pepper, onion, and extra cheese. $34+ It was decent tasting with a chewy & filling crust. We will give it another try and get one of their specialty pizzas which are priced more fairly, it seems. read more

Little Sicily - Sausage, green pepper, onion, X-cheese, NY style crust - Italian Near Me - Fort Myers, Florida

We just left this amazing quaint, friendly, delicious restaurant. Literally the best pizza ever and the garlic rolls....holy wow! Oh and the sausage...omg! If you are looking for pizza you would find in Italy, this is your place! read more

Little Sicily - Italian Near Me - Fort Myers, Florida

Horrible pizza super over priced i have had way better pizza and paid considerably less we will-not ever order from here again

Our waitress, Kaitlin, was wonderful... friendly, fun, and professional. We gave our pizzas 7/10, our entrees 7/10, and the hazelnut crumb square 10/10. read more

See all

Have gone to Little Sicily three times based upon a friend recommendation. Conveniently located. Food is very good, and given the restaurant was full each time i arrived, must mean a lot of people feel the same way. I took that as a good sign my first visit. Will be back. read more

Great pizza. We have gotten different pies for take out a few times and have also tried the rice balls(my fave), calamari, and tiramisu and it was all very good. Today we ate in and tried the chicken bacon ranch pie. read more

Little Sicily - Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza - Italian Near Me - Fort Myers, Florida

See all

We had garlic parm wings, pizza, ceasar salad and pasta. It was alll delicious. Great service.

last night the service was the pitts. our server lisa w almost managed to get amost everything wrong. we have been going there since it opened. we send everyone we know int ftm there. i know wonder what has happened. we will return but will not sit at lisa's table! joe i could not find you! read more

Nothing like NYC pizza. Great people working there. If I were ever to order again from there, I'd ask for the pizza to be well done. It's got major flop to it and it's very greasy. They need to get old school cupping pepperoni and cook it longer and it would be better in my opinion. I've been coming to Fort Myers since 92 2 to 3 times a year and I've never had a good pizza in SW Florida read more

Cheese pie tasted like home. Grandma pie was very crispy and tasty too. Will order again! read more

Well this has been my go to for pizza here in SWFL. Tonight I did take out for their chicken parm and I added some wings to the order. Everything was perfect and the service was pleasant from ordering on the phone right through pickup. The wings were cooked perfectly to my request of well done. The chicken parm at $17.95 was delicious and the portion was large enough for lunch tomorrow. The dining room was about 50 percent full at 4:00PM on a Sunday. The dining area is clean and new and is family friendly. This is casual dining at reasonable prices. read more

Working minutes away from Little Sicily is both a blessing and a curse. It's so close that I find myself visiting for a couple slices for lunch far too often. But why spend money on a Baconator down the street when I can get two big slices and a soda for $11? From slices of Meat Lovers to the German Cheesesteak to the Stuffed Lasagna Pizza to today's Meatball Parmesan the daily slices choices provide variety...even for someone who visits as often as I do. Make your way over to Little Sicily and you won't be disappointed. read more

See all

The garlic knots are excellent . Not for those who fear garlic. Vampires beware. Pizza was very good. Will be back! read more

This place blew me away! I went with low expectations, as so many places are over hyped and then just end up being meh. Not so, Little Sicily! You knocked it out of the park on all levels - service, ambiance, staff and your PIZZA. Wow! The best I have ever had. I will be coming by on a regular basis for sure. If you haven't been here yet, or were wondering if it was any good, don't wait. read more

Hands down the best pizza in Fort Myers. Not even close. As good as you can possibly expect in this town. I've been on a quest for decent pizza here since moving from brooklyn. Check my other reviews for my Pizza cred :) I am unreasonably picky about pizza. I've been to all the other local places that your friends keep suggesting, and let me tell you, this blows them out of the water. Yes, even that place. And the other one. The bake is perfect. That's really the star of the show- perfectly crisp and chewy crust. The sauce is excellent. Right amount of quality cheese (very low moisture moz). The only thing that holds this back from perfection is the dough--could use a little more flavor in those last bites of crust. Overall, a shockingly good slice of pizza. Chefs are from PA, BK, and Sicily I'm told. Service was excellent. Ambiance is cozy and casual for dine in. If you like real pizza, you need to support this business. read more

Little Sicily - Cheese pizza - Italian Near Me - Fort Myers, Florida

Delicious pizza! Love the big bacon pieces. It was a tad greasy but that's to be expected with the meat selections (pepperoni & bacon). Great service. Great food. read more

Little Sicily - Pepperoni & Bacon Pizza - Italian Near Me - Fort Myers, Florida

Las mejores pizza que he comido aquí en fort mayers estan super buenas y com un sabor delicioso. Un servicio excelente y con un excelente precio. read more