Cancel

Open app

Search

Finlay’s Irish Pub

4.5 (4 reviews)
Closed 4:00 pm - 11:00 PM
Updated 3 months ago

Order Finlay’s Irish Pub Takeout or Delivery

Finlay’s Irish Pub Photos

You might also consider

More like Finlay’s Irish Pub

Recommended Reviews - Finlay’s Irish Pub

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

1 month ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

23 days ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

3 months ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 2
Oh no 0

22 days ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

You might also consider

Verify this business for free

People searched for Irish Pub 149 times last month within 10 miles of this business.

Verify this business

RoHo's Muncie

RoHo's Muncie

4.9
(7 reviews)
16.6 mi

Our first trip to Roho. A very laid back vibe with wonderfully welcoming service. I'd rate the…read moreservice and the ambiance 5 stars. The custom drinks and martinis were excellent. Our party of four ordered four different drinks - and then everyone so much loved their choice, we all reordered the exact same drink for round two. I'd give the bar list and bartender 5 stars. We sampled 3 different flatbreads. Two of them lacked flavor, one was not crispy, but very undercooked. I've seen this complaint more than a few times in reviews so it seems like something they'd address. Snack mix was good. Crostini delicious. Salad nice - although one small piece of avocado on what was billed as an avocado and blackberry salad was a disappointment. I'd rate the food 3 stars. Overall we enjoyed the vibe, the drinks and the mellow live music.

I was told by a Muncie native to visit RoHo's, but I was told verbally, so in my brain, it sounded…read morelike rojo's (Spanish plural for red). No, it's RoHo's, as in the first two letters of the owners' names: Rogers and Howell. Clever! When I visited RoHo's, the place was hopping. It was comedy night, and I could barely find a seat. I ended up sitting on a couch with three women I didn't know, but they were people who were beautiful and amazing, and did amazing things in the community. I lucked out! The service here is so efficient and friendly. Despite the crush of people, I managed to get my French 77 quickly. It was well balanced and very tasty, and made me feel so much better about being surrounded by strangers. Mostly, though, RoHo's specializes in martinis. The entrance to RoHo's is unassuming, so you might miss it if you're not looking sharp. So, look sharp!

Photos
RoHo's Muncie
RoHo's Muncie
RoHo's Muncie

See all

Ron Lahody Trust Your Butcher Steakhouse

Ron Lahody Trust Your Butcher Steakhouse

4.1
(167 reviews)
16.6 mi
$$$

We were a party of seven and we had a great time here. The cocktails were amazing, and the steaks…read morewere scrumptious. We had a very engaging and helpful server named Nick.

I was in Muncie staying at downtown's Courtyard by Marriott working on one of my seemingly endless…read moreprojects. As our weekend wound down, we all decided we wanted to go out for a special dinner. The suggestion came to check out Ron Lahody's Trust Your Butcher Steakhouse. It's about four blocks, easily within walking distance for most and with street parking around for those not able to walk that distance, from the Courtyard and I have to admit I was in for something a bit more premium. Lahody grew up around the meat business, though entered it a bit later after some time in the Marines, graduating from Ball State, working in the family business, and then spending 22 years in home remodeling. Finally, he opened Lahody meats in 2008 and then years later made it to the actual steakhouse business. Lahody still owns Lahody Meats in Muncie, recently opened a steakhouse in Anderson, and yet this spot is the original. As a wheelchair user, I was definitely looking for something wheelchair friendly. Downtown Muncie tends to be older and you can never be certain. I'd gone wheeling around the area the day before and was pretty sure this would be safe. We made our reservation for the end of our work day and then headed over to the steakhouse. I instantly fell in love with the place. It's intimate yet finely decorated. It has the traditional steakhouse vibe with a wood, warm environment, a nicely done bar area, and a couple spots that were clearly made for accessibility. We were placed in one of those booth/tables - small yet nicely sized and none of us ever felt over-cramped. I sat at the end of the booth while my friends took the inside seats. Our server, whose name I have unfortunately forgotten, was wonderful from beginning to end. The young woman was very friendly and helpful. Service was nicely paced, attentive, and never intrusive. It's worth noting that while you can eat somewhat modestly here, and they do have specials, this really is a higher-end steakhouse designed for premium dining. We ordered a couple appetizers at $15 each - candied bacon and green tomatoes. I had never tried candied bacon and kind of fell in love with it. My two peers enjoyed the green tomatoes. My peers enjoyed alcohol, a couple brews each with a solid variety available, and I enjoyed my usual unsweetened iced tea. We all ordered steaks, a definite rarity for me. One peer went for filet mignon. Myself and the other for a New York Strip. You get two sides with a steak. I saw they had roasted potatoes, an absolute favorite of mine, and I doubled an order for my two sides. Lahody himself was in-house. He's an older gent, silver-haired yet impeccably dressed. He was introducing himself to customers and sitting at the end of the bar when I left. When he thanked you for coming, the gratitude felt sincere. Service? Top-notch. Accessibility? I didn't visit the restroom, however, everything was accessible and comfortable. The steak? Oh my, I haven't had a steak this good in a long time. It was cooked as ordered and prepared beautifully. The roasted potatoes were nicely seasoned and simply sublime. This was a definite splurge for me, however, as we were celebrating finishing up a non-profit film it felt like a beautiful way to celebrate with friends in an environment where I felt welcome. There's no question I'll return.

Photos
View from upper level of dining room and bar
View from upper level of dining room and bar
Signature ribeye with asparagus and loaded potato
Signature ribeye with asparagus and loaded potato
Bone in filet with corn and sprouts

See all

Bone in filet with corn and sprouts
San Jose Taqueria and Restaurant

San Jose Taqueria and Restaurant

4.7
(25 reviews)
3.4 mi

Excited to try this place after reading previous reviews. It was pretty slow at 6:30, which puzzled…read moreme based on the reviews. The salsa was a bit watery, but fantastic - fresh. Overall, the fajitas were decent. Plenty on the portion size (especially for the price) but there was a noticeable amount of meat that had unchewable bits in it. Just not an appetizing finish. Beans and rice were typical side fare. Service was prompt and attentive. Don't overlook the strip mall location, it's got a huge menu and people seemed happy with what they got

This place was recommended to me. Now I don't live in Anderson, but they said it's fantastic and…read moreworth the drive. So, on a random Tuesday, I made the trip. It is right on the Main Street in Anderson near all the car dealerships, Michaels, etc. It's in a strip mall, so plenty of parking. I wasn't sure what to expect when I went in because of this, wasn't sure if it would be take out only, or if they would actually have seating but it's an actual restaurant with plenty of seating. As soon as we walked in, we were greeted and sat. The staff all stopped by to say hello and very friendly. No sooner than we sat down our server (who was also the person that sat us) obtained our drink order and thanked us for coming in. We ordered pretty quickly and the food came out just as quick. I must say the salsa is 10/10. Tacos, solid, although you can't really go wrong with tacos and fajitas, hard to mess those up. It is a solid taco spot. We ordered taco platter which included 3 tacos, and the fajitas and one drink and the bill came up with tip around $40, so not super cheap but reasonable for the amount of food you get. The reason for my 5 is less about the food and more about the service.

Photos
Inside
Inside
Chips & salsa
Chips & salsa
44 oz margarita, Uber on the way

See all

44 oz margarita, Uber on the way

Finlay’s Irish Pub - irish_pubs - Updated July 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...