Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Fire Island Sales & Rentals

    5.0 (1 review)

    Services - Fire Island Sales & Rentals

    Buyer's agent

    Listing agent

    Fire Island Sales & Rentals Photos

    You might also consider

    More like Fire Island Sales & Rentals

    Recommended Reviews - Fire Island Sales & Rentals

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration
    Photo of Rex M.
    97
    23
    1

    16 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - Fire Island Sales & Rentals

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Real Estate Agents 596 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Fire Island Real Estate

    Fire Island Real Estate

    (2 reviews)

    If you want a Fire Island expert that not only knows the market but the ins & outs of Fire Island…read moreliving/renting/construction/development/management and willingly shares her knowledge with you then look no further. Fire Island (and the greater Ocean Beach area) is a small, close-knit community not only for residents, but the professionals that service the island. Abi, of Fire Island Real Estate) is a veteran in this scene and her interactions with everyone she touches it becomes even more apparent that she's built an amazing network that she happily brings you into. Calling her just a real-estate broker is a serious deemphasis of her skill set. Abi is precise, pragmatic, honest, fair, empathetic, personable and highly approachable. She is a truly dedicated real-estate professional that demonstrates her world-class abilities in every encounter. We worked with her strictly as a potential buyer; she was contracted with multiple sellers. You might think this could become a nasty situation that culminates in multiple pitches, but Abi's approach is truly consultative - just as if she's looking to bring you into the community that will be your best fit and could possibly be your neighbor. At no point during the properties she showed us (over multiple days across a few months) did her contract with the sellers come into question as biased in any way. Abi has truly been our lifeline for an entire process of searching for a property, guiding decisions on small specifics that mean a lot (views, house height, damage from Sandy, rental vs. owner "neighborhoods" and future development of the beach/dune reclamation projects). She was available night and day, weekdays and weekends, text, cell and email. If your schedule changed and she had a conflict, she still would have you covered with her team at Fire Island Real Estate. I can't recommend Abi enough as your one-stop if you're considering buying/selling/renting in Fire Island's greater Ocean Beach area. In a magical place that is nestled off the Great South Bay of Long Island, Abi & her team Fire Island Real Estate team is a warm, welcome sunrise & sunset.

    The agency started off well with the rental but then we had an issue with the homeowner returning…read morethe security deposit in a timely manner. Our agent as well as one of the agency owners threw their hands up at it and couldn't be bothered to step in & help. They need to remember they work for the RENTER as well as the homeowner. Lots of missteps.

    Ramsay Realtors - Justin Galbraith

    Ramsay Realtors

    (8 reviews)

    The 5 star review is obviously a friend of this family business. Now, I can't speak for the whole…read moreagency, but only for Tammy Ramsay, who owns the business so there is that... If you are thinking of selling a house with Tammy, she is good for an MLS listing and that's all. If you are buying a place and she is the sellers agent, good luck and be ready for some extreme frustration. My parents just bought a place and she was the sellers agent. She didn't show the house, the owner did. She didn't show up for the inspection, the owner did. She showed up 20 minutes late for the final walk through, and didn't bother to show up for the closing. The deal took 4 months. Our buyers agent couldnt get her on the phone, she didn't answer emails or texts. She could've disappeared and we wouldn't have known better but a friend follows her on social media and there she was posting pics of her partying. Super Bowl in particular, also a day she wouldnt respond to us. The sellers themselves were not the brightest and being they basically sold their own house, they had no guidance and took the maximum time possible to get out of a house that was empty for 3 years. Shame on you Tammy for being as bad of an agent as possible. You will be reported to LIBAR and I hope they take your license and your gravy train stops. It's not that hard of a job, answer the phone.

    Tammy is very unprofessional. I was looking at a home and over heard her talking about another…read morefamily looking to make an offer. She acts like she owns the market and specific neighborhoods. She should humble herself and realize everyone has the right to buy the home of their dreams. I would never use her nor do I want to look at a home she lists. Obviously friends or family gave her 5 stars.

    Meg Smith & Associates

    Meg Smith & Associates

    (11 reviews)

    Patient, Informative, Honest, Attentive, Caring, Accountable…read more.. Meg was referred to us by a trusted friend, and it was by far the best choice we made in our house hunt. Meg took one of the most potentially stressful times in life, and filled it with nights of great sleep!! After our initial conversation, I was confident in her transparency, honesty, and compassion for our family. I trusted her whole-heartedly to guide us in the purchase of our first home - and she delivered! Her knowledge of neighborhoods, search engines, laws, shined through at each listing we viewed. Not only did she provide answers for us, she let us know the right questions to ask, and was right by our side the entire step of the way. I knew that we had the best realtor in Long Island on our side, and would HIGHLY recommend her to anyone looking to purchase property. She is the real deal. It was a privilege to work with her!!!

    Looking for the hardest-working, most dedicated real estate agent on the South Shore? Meg Smith is…read moreyour gal! She is experienced, connected, and professional. Thanks to her hard work, we received a fabulous cash offer very soon after listing our home in Bay Shore. She puts in whatever hours are necessary to make deals happen. Meg took the time to learn the details and special features of our historic home and made sure that it was shown exactly the way we wanted, which was important to us as we were out of state at the time. Hands down, we will always use Meg for future real estate transactions on the South Shore, and we recommend her to all of our friends and family. You will definitely not regret choosing Meg to be your real estate agent!

    Fire Island Sales & Rentals - realestateagents - Updated August 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...