This was our 3rd time here in the past few years. They…read morehave truly upped their game with a new chef and menu. Four of us had dinner at the Inn and had an amazing experience. The service was friendly, attentive, and prompt from the moment we sat down. We started with some incredible cocktails and shared the smoked maple flash-fried Brussels sprouts, which were outstanding. Between the four of us, we had the Filet Mignon, Iberico pork tenderloin, day boat scallops, and the lemongrass-infused striped bass. Every single dish was cooked perfectly and packed with flavor. It's rare that everyone at the table loves what they ordered, but that was definitely the case. Chef Dylan Taylor's new menu is fantastic, and it really shows. Everything felt fresh, creative, and thoughtfully prepared without being overdone. The dining room is elegant but still feels warm and comfortable. And a special shoutout to owner George, who was incredibly warm and welcoming. You can tell he genuinely cares about making sure everyone has a great experience. From the food and cocktails to the service and atmosphere, everything was spot on. We can't wait to come back and would highly recommend the Pitcher Inn if you're in the Mad River Valley.

TLDR: perhaps the best meal I've had in Vermont, and a great choice for anyone in the area…read more The dining room at The Pitcher Inn has a 3-course or 4-course pre fixe menus available for dinner, and you can chose any combination in the menu (except the entrees more than once). 3-courses was filling for me. Dinner started with an anchovy amuse-bouche that had a nice savory taste. They even offered a free glass of champagne for my birthday. The grilled octopus was nice and light, and the cauliflower was okay with the dish. It was a smaller potion, but left room for the remaining courses. The tagliatelle was cooked well and the tomatoes and mushrooms added nicely to the dish. This was a nice sized portion, and definitely filling. The chocolate raspberry tart was more on the chocolatey side. Maybe my least favorite course from those I had, but nonetheless still good. The check came with petit four which was a nice touch. My waiter, Sergiu, was delightful and made me feel welcome the entire time. I really enjoyed my dinner here and would look to return.

Arrived for lunch on a Thursday. Tried making a reservation on their website using Resy but as…read morenoted elsewhere they are actually not using it. Need to change website. Extremely noisy environment-VERY ANNOYING-making conversation impossible. Terrible acoustics. Service was OK, but food was tasteless and boring. Seems like no spices were used in anything. Absolutely bland and not worth eating. Avoid lunchtime in particular. Seems to be a gathering places for older female customers who are all screeching at each other simultaneously.

So we were celebrating our anniversary and driving to Montreal, we needed one night in VT and chose…read morehere. We wished we were here longer, we may see if there's a room on the way back to break up our trip. The property itself is beautiful, very historic. The rooms are clean, also beautifully decorated. The staff- this is where my 5 stars come into play, so accommodating, pleasant. We arrived at 8pm on a Sunday, well the town is pretty much shut down, they recommended a fabulous dinner spot still open. Then around 1130 when I realized there is no coffeemaker or microwave so I can have tea before bed, I found myself at the desk and she was beyond accommodating, she got me some hot water from the kitchen.. seems simple and small but you saved me a very sleepless night. This place including the staff are top notch!!

Adorable Inn in the center of Middlebury, VT. Close to everything and the staff is wonderful. I…read morehave stayed here many times, and each time it is better and better. The owner is constantly making improvements such as new furniture for the rooms, updating the mattresses, adding keyless entry locks, or even finding a gorgeous antique or new piece of art. It definitely shows that this Inn is a labor of love! You will not be disappointed!

Wonderful hotel in the heart of Middlebury. The staff is very responsive and helpful. The location…read moreis ideal, a short walk to downtown and to campus. I loved the amenities, like Lake Champlain chocolates and a small bottle of maple syrup, all the amazing parts of Vermont were there to welcome me in my room. I also thought the self-check in was great so I didn't have to see a single person during my entire stay so I felt safe COVID wise. Highly recommend!

Sorry to inform everyone, but this wonderful place has closed. 2026…read moreThe owners will be greatly missed.

Beds were comfortable, the hosts lovely and we would highly recommend. Location was also very nice.read more

Super impressed with the accommodations…read more Note: 1st, 2nd and 3rd floors are only accessible by stairs, no elevators. Would recommend bringing a tote bag for one or two night stays if you don't want to haul your suitcase up 3 flights of stairs. Suite was very cleaned, smelled decent, and the suite provided a home feel. No TVs in bedrooms, only living room. There are a few spots out back to park your car, but honestly, I felt safer parking out on the Main St. with lights on the street. Check-in and check-out was simply, no contact. Easy to find and everything was in working condition. I would definitely stay here again.

My daughter and I visited for the first time and fell in love with the Inn and the sweet town it is…read morelocated in. The prices for this lovely space are excellent and the accommodations are clean and just as lovely. We stayed in the Deerleap Suite and it felt like home. The Bartlett Falls are just down the street and you have access to several restaurants including the charming Snap's Cafe. But if you want to prepare your own dinner, the suite is fully furnished and has a great kitchen. There's a grocery store in town, too. Highly recommend this place!!!!