Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    First Florida Underwriters

    5.0 (2 reviews)
    Open • 9:00 am - 5:00 pm

    Services - First Florida Underwriters

    Homeowner or property

    Car and truck insurance

    RV insurance

    First Florida Underwriters Photos

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - First Florida Underwriters

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    7 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    11 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - First Florida Underwriters

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Home & Rental Insurance 117 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Bush-Thompson Insurance

    Bush-Thompson Insurance

    (4 reviews)

    Westside

    I'd give this company zero stars if I could. I am writing this on a Wednesday morning. Last…read moreFriday afternoon I called - as a potential customer - looking for a quote on homeowner's insurance. I was told that only one person could help me, and that she was out until Tuesday. I left my name and number and was told to expect a call. Yesterday came and went. I called back this morning and reached "Pam." She had a very demanding attitude, and put me on hold twice before even getting to the business at hand. She asked/demanded if I wanted a quote from her - or not. I told her I was wondering if she was going to apologize for no one returning my call, and she stated "No, ma'am, I am not." I cannot imagine the difficulties I would have with this firm if I purchased their product and then had to make a claim. I wanted to deal with a local business, but certainly not with Pam at Bush-Thompson. She sounds hideous!

    I am greatly disappointed in the lack of service in regards to obtaining a quote on both auto and…read morehome insurance to compare with my current policy. In July, 2017, I talked with Patty at the Orange Park office and I followed up by emailing my policy coverages and accident history to her per our phone conversation. Never heard a word back. Seven months later, in February, 2018, I utilized their website in submitting a request for both homeowner and automobile coverage. I waited 5 days for a call which never came. So I called the office on Friday Feb. 23 and was transferred to Patty. Left a voice message requesting a return call, which has not occurred as of March 3. I can only surmise that this company does not either want or care about potential new business. Possibly, either the emails or submittal button on-line not working properly are the culprit. Whatever the case, the system is dysfunctional from technology to the human element. A rating of 1 is a stretch, it should really be zero if that rating existed.

    Ron McCann - State Farm Insurance Agent - State Farm Agent

    Ron McCann - State Farm Insurance Agent

    (2 reviews)

    Westside

    I had been a customer of this business for over 30 years. That relationship ultimately ended due to…read morea failure to ensure that my insurance premium was paid. The issue arose when the insurance company was changed and proper follow-up was not completed. I contacted the office more than 30 days ago to have the matter corrected. At that time, I was told that they had contacted the mortgage company and provided the required insurance information. However, approximately one month later, I received another letter from the mortgage company stating that there was no insurance coverage on the property. I contacted the office again and requested that, since they indicated they would be emailing the mortgage company, I be copied on the correspondence. When I received the email, it was sent only to me and not to the mortgage company. Additionally, it contained incorrect information: it referenced the wrong insurance policy and the wrong property. The information was being sent to the incorrect insurance company. Specifically, the house that does not have a mortgage was listed with policy information intended for the house that does have a mortgage. At that point, I simply wanted the issue to be properly handled and resolved by their office. However, in their response dated 12/15/2025, they did not state that they would take responsibility for resolving the matter. As a result, I no longer had confidence that the issue would be addressed correctly or at all. Due to these repeated errors, lack of follow-up, and loss of trust, the matter remained unresolved and ultimately led to the termination of a long-standing business relationship.

    My family has used him for almost everything for two decades. He truly cares about his customers…read moreand provides wonderful service. Highly recommend!

    Allstate Insurance: Roderick Crabbe

    Allstate Insurance: Roderick Crabbe

    (1 review)

    Westside

    This guy is an incompetent idiot and should not be trusted to handle your insurance policy. We gave…read morehim information to submit to the insurance company on January 21st and he told us, "I'm sorry, it fell through the cracks, and I am going to "try" to fix it before I go on vacation next week." That was on Friday, February 12th, 2016, almost a month after we sent him all of our information. Now, our policy is in cancellation status and we have to fix this again because of his incompetence. Please don't trust him to take care of your insurance.

    From the owner: Contact my Agency to get a Quick, Personalized Insurance Quote Today! A great rate is just a call…read moreor click away. My dad always told me, "The early bird gets the worm." To me, that means working hard, being prepared, being on time and knowing your craft. I've always believed you can make a huge difference in people's lives if you just ask the right questions, and that's what I try to do every day at my agency.After receiving my bachelor's degree from the University of Florida and my master's degree in Sports Management from Barry University, I began representing Allstate in 2012. I took over the Orange Park, Florida, agency when my mentor retired in 2015. I love being a dad. My wife of 13 years, Jennifer, and I have two sons, Trevor, 12, and Elias, 8. We enjoy watching the Jacksonville Jaguars as well as AA minor league games and going to South Beach Park in Jacksonville Beach. Our agency, specializes in automobile, homeowners and life insurance. I work hard to be an Allstate representative to customers in my community.

    First Florida Underwriters - homeinsurance - Updated September 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...