Service was on point. Waitress was prompt and not bothersome! Hush puppies were excellent and food was delivered quickly and correct. Good slaw, but needs to be cold for best taste. Baked potato was done to a turn. Butter and sour cream was on table in abundance and convenience! Shrimp was cooked perfectly. Beautiful light golden brown! Best I have had in years. I ordered a small and got 9 butterflied shrimp! Everything appears clean and cared for with the exception of the entrance doors which need replacement and are well weathered. One other observation. The sign next to the entrance is not designed well. It is hard to see and is camouflaged into the background vegetation. A more modern sign with some "pop" may draw attention to this restaurant and German architecture! read more

Nice old building with European design attributes. Front door needs some work. Appears sun damaged. Interior, although somewhat dated, was clean and well cared for. Service was prompt and was consistent throughout the meal. Drinks were delivered quickly with hush puppies, which were excellent! Didn't have to wait long for main meal. My wife had flounder and sweet potato, which she liked very much and they had brown sugar for her sweet potato! She really appreciated that because most places do not have brown sugar. My meal was excellent! I had fantail shrimp, although they were actually butterflied shrimp, and they were prepared great. Soft, tender and cooked to a perfect gold color. Best I have had in a long time. Baked potato was cooked well and I like that the butter and sour cream is in a basket on the table so you don't have to beg waiter for more! I'll be back! read more

The food is on point, every time. I love that I can choose between fried and broiled seafood platter! The staff is always nice and helpful. While the interior could be brightened up and updated, it is clean and welcoming. read more

I got a takeout broiled seafood platter, it was horrible the crab cake and clam cake was burnt to a crisp, half charcoal, a couple oysters and three shrimp and a couple scallops and a little piece of flounder, it was the worst i have ever gotten their, my last time placing an order at Fishermen's Feast read more

Horrible owners, horrible food, hair in chicken tender batter. Owners yelled at our server blaming her for their wrong doing. Sour cream was bad. Everyone is sick throwing up. Will never ever be back, needs to be shut down. Will be contacting health department on Monday. read more

Fisherman's Feast - Seafood Near Me - Shelby, North Carolina

If you want to feel like your at a seafood joint at Myrtle Beach then this is the place. Nets on the booths, dated paint colors, etc. Sorry but it's true. Now I did enjoy my food, but the ambiance is lacking here and for 10-20 a plate that should be improved upon. Our server was ok but she seemed to be new so I'll give her some grace. Would I come back? Meh maybe it's just a dated seafood joint that serves good food but I feel there maybe better options around? I could be wrong though read more

See all

Fresh food, had a large group & service was good and waitress kept an eye on our drinks so no one went without!

Food was great, prices are ok , will go back k again. Service was good, but we were the only ones there so it should have been. I do think it needs a little updating though. read more

I wanted to take my Mom to one of her favorite Italian restaurants in town but it was closed being a Sunday night. She had never been to Fisherman's Feast so we wound up eating dinner here. The waitress was excellent. She was on top of everything, especially for being the only one on the floor. There were about 3-4 girls behind the counter who did phone orders and cashing customers out. A few looked pretty young, so that's probably why there was only one waitress. They have specials nightly which are good deals. So I decided to get the Baby Flounder. Been here a few times before and the food was always pretty good. My Mom enjoyed her onion rings and the hush puppies that came out. We both agreed the fish was sliced super thin making it hard on the edges and drying out the fish. The batter is light and normally there is no problems. One star gone for the fish but the baked potato I had was very good and so was the coleslaw. And because the waitress was super nice made it good. I guess maybe we will have to try it again sometime down the road and hope it gets back to the way it was. Some previous pictures included from previous visits since this is my first review I based it over all. Try this place , I've had the oysters before and the are very good too. read more

See all

I had the catfish basket and thought it was fantastic. The only reason they lose a star is because the difference between the small basket and large basket was one piece of fish. I also like my hush puppies to be a little more crisp. But I definitely recommend you give them a try. read more

The food was hot and delicious and the service was on point and friendly. I've dined in once and had take out once and nothing disappointed. Give it a try! read more

I love everything about it. The food is excellent, the waitresses are very friendly, and the atmosphere is good. It's so clean and love eating in a clean place. I recommend coming here. read more

Sometimes you catch a "yay" but others are a definite "nay"!!! Always check your bag before leaving is my advice to you!!!!

Love it We have been dying to try this place for the longest time just never gave ourselves an excuse to. My birthday is tomorrow so I went ahead and went for it. The appetizer was jumbo shrimp taste amazing, my six year old absolutely loves her chicken tenders and hush puppies are to die for. I got the sampler number one through 11.25 and we're very happy, and my six-year-old wants to add that she loves her fries read more

See all

You cannot miss the restaurant it looks like a huge Gothic mansion and it actually was at one time. They have been around for years and are well established. We usually go on Thursday when they have a perch dinner. We have been there eight times six times the dinner was made perfect It is RACE FRIENDLY #racefriendly and dress code is casual There is three banquet rooms where we have noticed people having birthday parties as well as others gatherings. Is moderately priced. Not too high but yet not cheap. The only thing I really don't care for is the sweet tea my brother-in-law loves it to me it's disgusting. #tourism #tourists #shelbync #shelbynorthcarolina #nc #northcarolina #fish #restaurant read more

Got a carry out order our meal was hot and fresh. It was very good!! We will be going back.

If you like fried food without seasoning , this is the place. Alot of older folks. The hush puppies where the only good i can speak of. I can't even remember what I originally ordered bc they brought me the wrong thing. Needless to say I won't returning. read more

I've live near Fisherman Feast and have eaten there many times over the years Good food and service! Highly recommend. Wish the would remodel. read more

Went to have dinner last night with the family. The restaurant seemed old and outdated. Food was great I recommend the catfish fillet. The waiter was extremely excellent. She always made an effort to check and make sure our drinks where full, food was good, and answered any Qs we had. read more

We ordered take out. When got home with the food I discovered my broiled fisherman's platter with scallops was missing the shrimp, oysters, deviled crab and stuffed clams. The flounder and scallops and baked potato were all very good, but I paid for a lot of food that I did not get. I've always had good food and service here, but from now on I will check any take out order before I leave with it. I recommend you do the same. Very disappointed on this order. read more

This is not our favorite seafood restaurant but for take away it was very fast and it tasted decent. We got a seafood platter and it had enough for two people after I added another baked potato. read more

My Mom wanted to try Fisherman's Feast since she had heard good things about it. So we went Saturday evening. It was not that good. The service was poor. We waited on our waitress ten minutes before she finally came to get our drink and food order. After she brought us or drinks and hush puppies, we only saw her twice after that. When she brought the food and the last time for one drink refill. After we finished eating, we waited on our bill for over ten minutes. They were not that busy. We finally went to pay, and the cashier had to hunt our waitress down outside to get our bill. I got the fisherman's fried platter. The oysters were fried extremely crispy. They had no oyster taste. My flounder was fried so hard on one end, it broke off. The other end was oily and tough. The shrimp was cooked fine. I do not recommend this place. read more

I eat seafood on a regular basis, and, this is one of the best places around shelby to eat. Fresh hushpuppies, and flounder were my choices. It's an all around great resturant. read more

My family and I have been wanting to eat here for awhile. So tonight we ordered take out. Very very disappointed. Our order was wrong to begin with, which we had a very large order, so I can understand if they miss something. I got 2 large trout plates and 1 small one, and a cajun jumbo shrimp plate and a kids chicken tenders and 4 deviled crab. After plating up our food we settled down to enjoy what looked like a great meal. It was horrible!! The trout was so bland, even with the salt and pepper we ordered on all 3 plates. It was over cooked and tasted like farm raised not wild caught. And for that price, it should have been wild caught. The cajun shrimp didn't taste cajun at all and was rubbery and over cooked. And drowning in onions. The deviled crab wasn't seasoned well either, not much flavor to it at all. The slaw was nasty it looked old and gray. And had a bitter after taste. The kids tenders was so bad my r year old grandson wouldn't even eat them and that's his favorite thing to eat. We fed the dogs the tenders and all the rest we trashed it. $70 worth of food trashed. Lesson learned, we will never go here again. read more

Good service, good food. Good location. Don't get to Shelby often but whenever I do Fisherman's Feast is the best place for very good seafood. read more