Five guys tastes great and we used to go all the time. However, they have gotten WAY too expensive so we hardly go anymore. There are much more affordable burgers in the area that are just as good. read more

See all

I always feel like they have consistent, yummy burgers. Hubby goes with me, but this isn't his favorite joint. He says there just isn't anything special here. I kind of agree - I can't say there's anything special about these burgers, but it is always comforting somehow. Anyone else know what I mean? lol I tend to order online and pick up. So far, they have NEVER been made on time. Like, NEVER. We always have to wait for them to finish the order. I think they don't pay attention to the online orders until we come inside. And it's not like they're super busy in there either. Maybe one or two other customers inside when we walk in... but nothing is ever ready. So I'm still not sure with what's up with that. This last visit, I got a bun-less burger, wrapped in lettuce. They really did an overkill on the lettuce. See pic. So normally, with all this, I would have docked more stars... but for some reason, I still keep coming back. And after the long wait and peeling off half of the lettuce, the taste still lingers. So a solid 4 for me. read more

Five Guys - bun-less jr bacon cheeseburger being smothered by lettuce - Burgers Near Me - Glendale, Wisconsin

I don't really find that much special about Five Guys as the food tends to be average and not particularly well-priced as it's all about the toppings and I am a bit particular about what I put in my mouth (if only we all operated this way!). $11 with tip for a small bacon cheeseburger with mushrooms is pretty ridiculous, and adding that it wasn't ready for nearly 15 minutes after the scheduled time and I see why it's so easy to dislike this place. I watched people come in after me, order, and get their food before my online, advance order was ready. They kept calling out a number that didn't match the order number I was given online and I finally asked for the name on the order and it was my order. I also got some bonus onions (I loathe onions) on my burger. Good thing I'm not allergic... The burger was decent-tasting, but the combination of low value and slow service ensures I'm not likely to visit again anytime soon, especially with Kopp's just a few blocks south! read more

If you like burgers, and making a mess, you'll like Five Guys. Tonight was actually my first time visiting one in Milwaukee. I remember the chain fondly from elsewhere. Their food is pretty straightforward, but it's always solid, and the atmosphere doesn't lack charm for being simple. They have in-shell peanuts out front you can grab. Of course having peanuts anywhere is courting controversy. But for the non-allergic it's definitely a plus. Of course it would be a mistake to fill up on the peanuts, because Five Guys' portions are pretty large. The smallest size of fries, the "little" is easily enough for one person, maybe and then some. A small would feed 2 or 3. I always get the regular sized burger, which has two patties, though you can get a smaller one. All the toppings are free. And I like toppings, but not ketchup, so I got my burger "all the way" with no ketchup. So I had some grilled mushrooms and onions and all that good stuff. But even the lettuce tasted really fresh. And their bun is genius. It actually holds everything together. So many fancy burgers are dripping and falling apart by the time you're halfway through. This one was still holding some stuff by the end. They give you your food in a paper bag and I'm pretty sure the way fries are spilling everywhere is deliberate. Between the peanut shells, the burger, and all those fries it can get messy. But I have messy-eater problems anyway. Some might consider the price a little high, because you order the fries separately and the sandwiches, while hardly wallet-busting, aren't cheap. You're still getting a lot of food, but I get it. And my fries were maybe a little dry but I still enjoyed the meal. I'll be back when I have a hankering for a burger. read more

See all

I had to get a quick lunch and Five Guys was close. Despite prior bad experience, I went in. After spending $32 for a hot dog, cheeseburger and fries, I went to get a drink from the drink dispenser. One wasn't working AT ALL, the other one was dispensing just seltzer water--no flavor or sweetness in the drink. I tried four different drinks and none were working. I brought it to the attention of a staff member who was irritated that someone complained. At the time, there was exactly one other customer in the restaurant. He came to the machine and asked which ones I tried. I told him and his response was "Oh, I never drink any of those." He pulled up a screen and it showed practically all of the drink cartridges needed to be replaced. I told him I was actually using the OTHER machine and that he would probably have to replace all the cartridges in that machine too. He said, "I don't have to do shit." I said, "What's your name?" He said, "Why?" I said, "I'd like to know who I am talking to." He said, "I don't have to give you my name." He then scurried to the back room like a rat retreating to his lair. When will I learn this place will NEVER be worth visiting??? read more

Five Guys - Five Guys Coward Who refused to Give His Name - Burgers Near Me - Glendale, Wisconsin

The most important things to know before ordering at five guys: the little fry is enough, and order a grilled cheese with a burger patty instead of an original burger. read more

Five Guys - a hand holding a cheeseburger - Burgers Near Me - Glendale, Wisconsin

Disappointed with my food from Five guys. My burger was terrible. Fries undercook. Staff wasn't friendly. Shake just ok. All this for $25.95 unbelievable. It was a ghost town inside. Only 2 people sitting at tables. Not sure when I will return. read more

Stop #19 of 21 on our Milwaukee Burger Tour took us to Five Guys (Bayshore). Now before you get on me for including a national chain in the tour, let me just say that it was Five Guys that ignited the flame of my son's burger buds and turned him on to the delectable deliciousness dat dis debate is about! Plus, I don't care where it's from, Five Guys is the real deal, the bomb diggity, PHENOMENAL, 'nuff said. I had a bacon cheeseburger ($8.89 fried onions, ketchup, mustard), my son had a cheeseburger ($7.89, ketchup). My, my, my...the portions size/ratio of bun, beef, cheese couldn't be more perfect. The charred meat is some of the juiciest you'll ever have and the fries are solid. Overall, this burger hits that burger spot, whatever that is, it hits it, knocks it out of the park. Cheeseburger: 4.8 Bacon cheeseburger: 4.9 Overall experience: 4.65 read more

Five Guys does not disappoint. Sorry Five guys, you're delicious but absolutely, grossly overpriced. I haven't been to this one in a year, but it's crazy that prices have raised a whole $2 per item! Ugh. Still, so delicious. I never regret ordering. Everything is made to order and they're actually pretty fast. Employees were really nice. Free peanuts. So if you like nuts, well there you go. I've never been a fan of that or all the shells everywhere, but that isn't enough for me to take a star away. Delicious burgers. Delicious fries. Cant say too much about anything else because I haven't tried anything else. They're now serving milkshakes, which I reallywant to try. read more

Five Guys - Burgers Near Me - Glendale, Wisconsin

As for any resident of Wisconsin, burgers matter a lot to me. With so many burger joints around, it's hard for any one location to stick out. Five Guy's delivers on every level and more. I don't have much to add on the chain itself, Five Guy's is renowned nationwide for their juicy burgers and plentiful fries. What I can say however is that this location specifically really goes above and beyond. I've been here quite a few times and every time the staff are friendly and beyond hardworking. If you want to see the strongest work ethic around walk into this location for the lunch rush and you'll see the employees taking orders and making burgers with demonic speed and precision. One story that sticks out to me is on one of my first trips to this location I ordered my burger with my respective toppings and my cashier just kind of looked at me and said: "you know you can double all of these toppings for free right?" My mind was blown and you bet yourself that I doubled everything on that burger and I still do to this day. My final tip is that even if you've been before there's a good chance you've never tried a shake from Five Guys. Do yourself a favor and do just that. My personal favorite is strawberry with banana but you can add as many ingredients as you want: go wild! read more

Five Guys - Burgers Near Me - Glendale, Wisconsin

09/24/21 I used Uber eats to deliver my food to my hotel room. It was the worst experience. The driver delivered food to the wrong hotel room number and my bag was not sealed. Very unhappy with the service. The Driver name was Solomon. I ordered food from Five Guys WI-0505 5650 N. Port Washington Rd. I tried calling Five Guys and it's a fax number. I stayed at the Hampton inn 7065 Post Washington Rd. Room 221. Milwaukee WI. This was my first time using Uber Eats and maybe my last time. read more

Great food, and very friendly service. Easy parking too on the backside of the mall by Trader Joes.

Stale free nuts. Yeah. Expensive burger. Dosent come with fries. Last time I come here

Horrible, horrible, horrible!!! Everyone knows five guys it already well over priced, so you want to get your moneys worth!! This location is terrible, the burgers look flat and disgusting. The fries look day old re dipped in the hot grease. One 09/13/20 I spent $55 on a meal for my family and it wasn't worth it all! The milkshakes were runny, burgers flat. I didn't even have the toppings I asked for. Anything in Bayshore is crap!! I will stick to Mayfair location for everything from now on. read more

Five Guys - Old double dipped greasy fries - Burgers Near Me - Glendale, Wisconsin

Thank you Five Guys! I needed a snack, special treat. That was the best Five Guys experience I have had in a long time! Order curbside pickup, everything came out hot fresh so hot the french fries burn my mouth a little, my bad. read more

Five Guys - Little Cheeaeburger, grilled onion and mustard - Burgers Near Me - Glendale, Wisconsin

Not impressed. The burger was just OK. I ordered a bacon cheeseburger with everything on it. Mushrooms were inedible I had to pick them off. The bacon was crumbled almost like for a salad not burger type bacon. The fries were good and hot. There were 5 plus employees in the store but only 2 who were actually working. My cousin that works at Bayshore (second job) invited me and said he is buying. Kid does construction and makes $16.00 an hour. After I realized that my order alone is almost $15.00 I insisted I pay for mine. This is definitely not a $15.00 burger. read more

Five Guys - Burgers Near Me - Glendale, Wisconsin

I love Five Guys. I have never had a bad experience, ever before this. However, tonight my wife ordered three hot dogs and two bacon burgers with the works for us. We went to pick up the order, and when we got home, sat down to enjoy our meal. The hot dogs were great, but the burgers were only beef and cheese. No lettuce, no tomatoes, no bacon, no onions, anywhere to be seen. At first we thought that we had placed our order incorrectly, but the printed order receipt taped to the bag showed our order as we had expected it. I called the restaurant to ask about it and but the person on the phone didn't seem to care at all. Hugely disappointing. Huge. read more

Five Guys - Burgers Near Me - Glendale, Wisconsin

Food is consistently good which is great for any business. Ordering ahead times need to improve which is why I gave it 4 stars instead of 5. Staff are nice, place has always been clean, and consistent food = awesome. read more

Had I known that this location was going to skimp me in French fries, I never would have ordered 2 fries for $9. I even asked him if my order was correct. I could have ordered another burger for the same cost. Ugh. I'm mad and disappointed. Don't go to this location. read more

Five Guys - O m g. This was $9 In French fries. They didn't fill $9 worth of fries. Disappointed. - Burgers Near Me - Glendale, Wisconsin

See all

There are only two things Dirt needs to talk about when someone brings up 5 Guys: the burgers and the fries. You want something different, go elsewhere. First, the burgers. Dirtee likes a variety of burgers, so when you want a pub burger, you go to a pub. You want a flat patty with some flavor, 5 Guys is the place. Dirt don't do math unless it's got something in it for Dirt, so you know it's something special when he starts talking about ratios. Get a double patty, bare minimum. The goal is to stack the burger like you're trying to win in a team event. You put the worst player in front and reap the rewards by bumrushing the jabronis. In the end, the points get you championships. Basically, you double up the patty but counterbalance with the toppings. It's not that the burgers are bad - it's that the burger (though smaller than some other places) is just that good. You've gotta play your burger against itself to get the win. This is the place to do it. The toppings aren't extra money, so you stack. Don't believe me? Look at the ordering system for yourself - you can A1 that mother. Next, Dirt will sit you down and have a talk about the fries. We gonna be quiet, 'cause you know how Auntie gets when she hears us talking alone. Gotta keep some privacy 'round here. Don't buy a large. You ain't gonna eat it. They don't keep. They come in a Philly-brown bag and it looks like you're smuggling a cheese steak. But they're potatoes. Glorious potatoes. They're phenomenal, but only for the first half-hour. After that, it's past midnight and they're an ugly, bruised pumpkin, again. Eat the small and bring in the glory, then duck out and leave some change for cab fare on the table. 530 calories of peanut-fried taste. Couldn't tell you about their shakes. Never got room left to find out. The Bayshore site has never done Dirt wrong. Dirt approves. read more

Amazing food, great service, good hospitality, worth the price, food is always well done and wholesome.

Best fries you will find at a fast food chain! I've always loved fries growing up, and to see how many fries they give you in each order makes me smile! The only thing that could be better is unlimited fries read more

Horrible service! When I got up to the counter after a long wait in line the man at the counter answered his phone for a personal call and put his finger in my face when I decided to speak! Ended up leaving after waiting for his personal conversation to end for 10 whole minutes! Will not be returning to this location. read more

Clean and delicious is how I would describe five guys. The cashier immediately greeted us, and was very nice and friendly! The food took about 8 minutes, so pretty fast time. The food was a bit pricey- but really good and worth the money. I will definitely come back! I recommend this restaurant fo friends and family. read more

Five Guys - Burgers Near Me - Glendale, Wisconsin

Really good burgers and fries. Great curbside delivery. Great atmosphere when you are able to eat in.

Horrible service. Ordered for pickup and called the phone number posted outside the reataurant like eight times no one ever bothered to answer. I didn't want to go in because there were families with no one wearing masks at all. It was busy but not that busy the workers just did not care. They finally answered then put me on hold for another five minutes. Don't go here it's unsafe and you'll be hungry and annoyed if you try to order or pick up over the phone. read more

Always hot and good. Really tasty burgers. Hot dogs excellent. Hits the spot when I'm in the mood for burgers.

I really wish I could give this place four stars. And the reason I give it four stars is only because of price point, otherwise it'd be 5. But at this location they just can't seem to get the fries on point. Whether you order the Cajun or the regular it's going to have the same amount of Cajun on them. The Bayshore mall location is by far the best one in our area. And the burgers here of course they're incredible. But overall just because of the price and the lack of Cajun fries I got to give this location a 3. read more

Thier customer service was very unacceptable! when I walked up to the counter to receive my food, The person working at the counter was nowhere to be found, I asked the other workers can one of them get my order, they completly ignored me.15 minutes go by and at that point I just left. How unprofessional! read more

Ordered from Door Dash, order arrived incorrect with toppings on a $14 burger that were not ordered. I called the store, was passed around to 4 different people who all asked the same question about what was wrong with the order. I would explain and then they would pass me to another person. I could hear others laughing in the background so it was clearly a big joke to them. Then they hung up on me. They clearly had no intention of correcting their expensive mistake. My son won't eat a burger with toppings on it, even if they have been scraped off. Will never order from you again, too expensive to have to waste money on incorrect orders with no rectification by the idiots who can't read a ticket. read more

Late night wanting something fast to eat and it's convenient

Good and consist any as usual. No one can beat the fresh cut fries. read more

Five Guys - Yum Yum - Burgers Near Me - Glendale, Wisconsin

Slowest Five Guys I've ever visited. Hardly anyone in the place, me and two others, both employees. Not sure about the food yet, been waiting 15 minutes and none yet. read more

Watching three employees getting stoned outside this store is sad. Kids around...doesn't set a good example. Was going to go here to eat..but won't support this establishment. Maybe the manager should manage. Also who wants stoned people making and serving food. Mistakes are bound to happen. read more

I work in this mall and everyone I order online and set a time for pick. They are exceedingly longer than stated today it took 38 min for my pick up to be complete and it says 7 min on app. Considering the app has you pay head to be that far off from the time completely takes away from the convenience of that service. And I probably wouldn't mind if it wasn't every time I use the service. read more

I had decided to try 5 Guys after my roommate had suggested it to me. I had ordered a bacon cheeseburger ,an order of fries & a drink. First off I had wanted my burger medium rare & the cashier had told me they only cook the burgers well done. The total for all 3 was just under 14 bucks ,which I feel was a bit expensive . The burger was nothing to write home about. It was decent, but I have had better burgers at a number of different places. The fries I felt were better than the burger itself. I was a bit disappointed. I would rather have a burger from Fuddrucker's for even less than I paid here. read more

Every time I pre-order they wait until I get there to start my order?! Defeats the concept. No management either, seems like it's just being ran by workers. read more

I have been there twice tonight to get 3 burgers. Not one of them was made correctly, BOTH times. I don't know how hard it is to make a cheeseburger with ketchup, mustard, onions and pickles. The first time I got mushrooms and onions. The second time I got pickles and onions. No cheese either time. I took an hour and half driving back and forth getting crappy food that isn't even made correctly. I tried calling in between; was hung up on, put on hold only to be disconnected and the next 6 times it was either a busy signal or no one answered. The first order, the bag broke because it was wet, I have no idea why. Btw- I only live 4 miles away. I don't mind waiting if the food was made correctly , tasted the way it should and the workers weren't rude, unapologetic and have an attitude. read more

Great burgers! The large fries can feed several people. Cajun style fries are a favorite!

Best five guys in Wisconsin! i live in milwaukee and drive to bayshore all the time because there customer is just perfect. Everyone is always in a great mood, so respectful. keep up the great work read more