This is a must-stop on any visit near Cedarburg. The selection of fine art, ceramics, jewelry,…read morecards and other gifts is excellent and prices are great too. I picked up some reusable paper towels as a Christmas gift and then could not resist a whole series of snowman cards, prints and an accompanying book from a local artist. This is also a working space so you may get to catch someone painting while you're here. Start at the coffee shop downstairs if you're coming in the morning, or end at the bar for a craft beer if it's afternoon. Highly recommend this space for shopping or taking a break between visits to local wineries!

From the owner: Fine arts, arts and crafts studios on the second floor of the Grafton Arts Mill. Artists in…read moreresidence produce original work.

Michaels is the best arts and crafts store! I go there all the time for markers and notebooks,…read moretheir employees are so nice and helpful so you can get what you need. and their products are also so nice and stay in shape for a long time. Michaels is a 100% recommend!

If you think that member coupon is actually going to take 20% off guess again - even if their store…read moreitem is regularly priced (and they deem it a "Great Buy") the coupon doesn't count - bait for sure. Getting to the point that I do t want to shop there at all anymore - ugh!!!

We LOVE going here for Beanie Boos! :) We also go to D&D Cards whenever we have a kid's birthday…read moreparty. We buy cards, bags, tissues, Beanie Boos... and the ladies will put our items all together nicely in a bag with ribbon. Super friendly and helpful. LOTS of stuffed animals and up-to-date Beanie Boos that the kids love.

From the owner: Greeting Cards, Gifts, Wrapping Paper, Holiday Party Products, Balloons, Collectible Figurines, Ty…read moreBeanie Boos,

We always stop when we're in Port Washington. Nice quality items and we usually end up finding a…read morefuture gift.

Don't pay attention to the bad reviews, the store is under different ownership now! It is still a…read moresmall/family run business though! The staff is extremely friendly and helpful. I haven't ordered invitations from them, but have bought gifts for friends (and myself)! I love all the customization goodies they offer. You can truly find something for everyone at The Paperie!

Super friendly and helpful staff. I love the gift selection too. This place is a gem.read more

This is a super fun locally owned small business for both young and old! The shop owner is a gem…read morewho thoroughly enjoys their business and it shows! They are friendly and extremely helpful. I've come here several times now for neat gifts and creative projects, as well as fun little things for my own office. Each time I've been here I have found it well organized, easy to shop, and affordable. They have everything from silly putty and books to puzzles and craft kits. If you like supporting small businesses then give them a whirl while you enjoy the shops of Cedarburg!

A charming local toy store with great service, unique finds, and a warm neighborhood vibe.read more

We love Blue Eagle Pottery and recently purchased a few more pieces online. The service was…read moreoutstanding and I was able to chat about Bob Blue and learn a little about him. The personal touch was so refreshing. Thank you, Andy, for taking so much time with me! Helen Dietz Raleigh, NC

Despite being in a touristy setting, this is really a nice shop. The shop is located in Cedar…read moreCreek Settlement, a massive stone woolen mill built on Cedar Creek in 1865. The building was converted in the 1970s to primarily tourist retail. The shop is situated in an "airy second floor loft with 18-foot ceilings and huge windows overlooking Cedar Creek." If you can get past all the tourists, this really is a beautiful building and pottery shop, with lots of absolutely gorgeous pottery, as well as other artwork, from artisans throughout the United States. The prices are quite reasonable, considering the quality of the goods as well as the location. If you visit one store in Cedarburg, I definitely recommend stopping here.