I went into the store they had a Blackstone 36inch out door griddle advertised on offer up at $138.00, when I arrived at the store, the item had a ticket for $205.00. I ask to speak to the person in charge. When the lady came she said the girl price it wronge and she is not a big business and will not negotiate. She then took it down from the offer up on line and change the price higher. They do not offer grantee. They are very money greed and don't honor what they post on line. Beaware! read more

Forgotten Treasures - Antiques Near Me - Burlington, New Jersey

See all

Years ago this place caught my eye since they have an array of items. I re-purpose household items, vintage items, etc. Needless to say, I've been to hundreds of thrift stores and this one is easily one of the top 3 in overpriced items. I think it is quite a stretch to call this a thrift store ("Forgotten" Treasures?) because it appears that atleast half of their inventory is brand new and often equal to the cost at retail stores. I've even caught the same items cheaper in stores than this place. I honestly have no clue how they are still operating. read more

To whom it may concern, My husband and I are full-time musicians. We have been regular customers of Forgotten Treasures for years now. I recently discovered they are on Facebook, where I requested an item I saw in the store. I texted them at 11pm and they texted me right back to reserve that item, and was told they would call me first thing in the morning to purchase and pick up item. Great service. As musicians, my husband and I had performed 3 times a month at the Columbus Flea Market when they had music. This is how we discovered this store on our way to our many gigs in the area. Also, I consider ourselves flea market junkies & thrift store experts in our off-hours. Forgotten Tresures is not your average thrift store. This place is very clean. Don't expect to walk into this store to find old shoes or clothes, or rusty old pots. Forgotten Treasures is much more than that. This is a high end thrift store, NO broken-down furniture here. They constantly have brand new stuff in boxes that they assemble there, from furniture, exercise equipment, patio furniture, home health supplies, camping items. Also: makeup, kitchen items, toys, and a host of sundries. The furniture items, being already assembled, saves us a lot of hassle and time. This place has so much wonderful bargain new stuff. Through the years we have saved tons of $$$$ here. The staff is very friendly, and helpful, and I always look forward to seeing them and their beautiful gentle parrots Rex & Mushy, when they would display them. This is a must-visit store. You will never be disappointed. Signed, Two Satisfied customers, You Guys Rock!! Sue & Marty (Hitz Squad Music) read more

Super cute store. Don't let the first steps into it fool you though.... there is so much more to see once you do a complete walktrough. The workers were uber friendly and very welcoming. I only gave it 4 stars vs. 5 because there were some items I saw that I knew I could find for less in a retail store. Otherwise...it's a definite go to on your thrift shopping days :) read more

My personal experience with this business has been excellent. I have been a customer for about 3 years now. They constantly stock both new and used items and I struggle to not blow my whole paycheck on things that catch my eye. The owners have not only been helpful, but compassionate and kind to me as long as I have known them. They have lots of gently used stuff but it's pretty cool to see so many brand new things too. They put together new furniture in store so no one has to fuss with it at home. (I cannot tell you how many times I have put bookshelves together wrong, or backwards... or broke them in the process...) The variety and ever changing inventory has me coming back, among other things. By the way, place is actually organized and smells nice unlike some other Thrift locations. I am closer to a goodwill but this place posts online so I don't need to fuss. Since they moved to the new location (much bigger, brighter) they have gotten a ton of new furniture in (they still have the older and unusual pieces though!) The new stuff is half off of what they sell it for elsewhere. Definitely a unique thrift experience! read more

A friend of a friend told me about this shop. I love vintage furniture and I was looking for possibly a new lamp or two and some end tables. My daughter is super well behaved and loves to come searching for great deals with me. Almost 2 weeks ago we started out on our thrifting adventure weekend and ended up dropping by Forgotten Treasures since we ended up in the area. I have to say they could have picked a better store to set up shop in. Not sure if they rent or own, but if they rent it they should look for a different lay out next year. It was a pretty clean store, but the lay out was very....odd. There is a whole other section that is practically hidden. This is where the adventure begins... They have a parrot. A big parrot. You must pass this parrot when you go to access the "extra room." My daughter was so frightened because it was OUT of it's cage and ON TOP of it! Luckily my child knows better than to go up to ANY animal to "pet it" or anything. Word of advice to the owners would be to keep it locked up. Someone might get close one day and get a good chunk of their finger removed by that thing. Just a very bad idea in my opinion, especially where it's located. Simply locking the cage would've made her and I feel a little safer. I was intimidated too. It was NOT a small bird. So, we're browsing around. I start looking at prices... WOAH! I thought...but, fair enough, this is not just a thrift store and they most likely know that typically older items are more valuable. I gave them the benefit of the doubt. Like any seasoned shopper/bargain hunter I pulled out my phone to check my eValuator app to cross price a few things that caught my eye. Every item I checked was being sold for WAY more than it's worth, or at least for way more than I could buy it for from other places. I also noticed new items that were more expensive than retail. I ended up just checking items I wasn't even interested in but stopped at about 8 or so things that I looked up. (It can take some time to get the wording right to find exactly what it is. I've gotten good at it, but it's still a bit time consuming.) Maybe there is a good deal in there? I didn't stay to check every item. My daughter kept asking if the parrot could fly at her (she was still scared even after we walked away from it) and I was a bit upset with the prices. All in all I would say stay away unless they start slashing prices. It's really not worth it. There are plenty of other thrift shops that you can get great deals from. If you have money to blow then go for it, just watch out for the bird! read more

I was looking for extra storage to put in the bathroom. A friend told me about this store so I thought I would give it a try. The women there, I believe her name is colleen, was extremely helpful, she greeted me as I walked in and showed me some cabinets I could put in the bathroom. I ended up buying a cabinet you put above your toilet. I would definitely shop there again! read more

This store is in no way a Thrift Store - Their prices are sky high - some higher than other stores. NOT a bargin place what so ever.