This was some really good, very affordable hand-tossed pizza! We got the red pie with spinach and…read morericotta -- the spinach was seasoned well and the sauce was delicious. The crust was just the right amount of chew.

Itsa gooda pie! You go. You try for yourself. NYC stylevthin crust great dough, sauce is great,…read moreperfect amount if cheese, generous toppings. Sausage and peppers or sausage and mushrooms my go-to, but everything AND anchovies is KING. Only suggestion is more selection of multi-toppong special pizzas that includes price breaks.

Great pizza. We always get a meaty pizza. They are delicious…read more Good Food. Great Service.

I enjoyed the pizza considering the crust very good but, our waitress seemed to hate us and made us…read morequestion if we had done something wrong resulting in her bad mood. Inside the restaurant the tables were dirty and the lighting was very dark.

Food was good. Veal Parmigiana with pasta and extra sauce. Food was hot, lots of cheese…read more Spouse had NICK'S SPECIAL Chicken shrimp and sun-dried tomatoes served with alfredo sauce. Shrimp was very good and Alfredo sauce was good, chicken was diced and just ok. Ordered soup, no soup but took the salad instead. Ordered on line so no issues but heard others had phone issues. Would order a pizza or two to try. 3.5 stars equal 4.

You get a lot for your buck like the Stromboli wow! Don't…read morelet the name disconnect- in Oneida it's called Artanis Pizzeria

Just got our order cancelled because the pizza oven was supposedly suddenly broken. We were given…read moreno notice or offer to even get us the items that weren't pizza. Definitely getting the feeling they just didn't feel like making the order. Their hours are super unpredictable too. We did like the food here. Too bad we're never going back.

The food is decent! The pizza is on the smaller side but tastes good. Has lots of cheese and the…read morecrust is chewy. The wings are flavorful yet smaller. The taters or very yummy. They play Disney movies on the projector, so it's a family favorite. The service is very efficient and extremely friendly. The ambiance is rustic, comfortable and family style. Wooden benches with wooden table that have carved names. I recommend this place if you are in the area. We like to go every month or so.

This place was outstanding. Great personality, the service/staff was solid and the food was even…read morebetter. Definitely recommend the Garlic Knots appetizer. It was a treat to find.

Well I would call bs on the negative reviews here. We are new to Sherrill, and were given several…read moresuggestions for pizza. Tried them and were not impressed. We ordered from NY pizza and it has been the best we have found in town. Just enough crisp on crust. Fresh mushrooms, not canned, great cheese and the crust had the perfect yeast flavor.Mind you the price is a little higher then we are use to , but that seems typical for all pizza places in town.

I knew I would like this place before I walked in. They had one of those old school signs that…read moremight be 50 years old. Walked in and was greeted by multiple friendly employees. The inside is just the old school look and familiar feel. It was lunch and they had a bunch of flavors of pie ready. I was lucky enough to have a fresh plain cheese come out of the oven. Sauce was good and a little sweet. It was a little floppy but not enough to ruin it. If I lived in this area, this would be my regular spot.

Place is fantastic. Food is great, prices are fair, ambience is casual and relaxed. Very surprised…read moreat how great the food was! Wings are awesome, pizza and their homemade sauce is even better. Literally drive by this place 2x a day and never stopped. Glad I finally did!

We have stopped here several times and the food is always good. We come with 2 toddlers and a…read morenewborn and the staff is so nice to them. They offer them coloring books and take time to talk to them, too. Good beer selection and overall awesome service.