Staff here were incredibly friendly and welcoming, genuinely made the visit better. [[HIGHLIGHT]]Heads up that the space itself is small, more of a bar with a handful of tables than a full sit-down restaurant, so don't go in expecting a big dining room.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] The stromboli, though, is excellent. Hard to describe it any other way than it tastes exactly like a stromboli should; that herby, parmesan-dusted pastry crust with a great cheese pull. Simple as that sounds, nailing the "expected" flavor perfectly is harder than it sounds, and they do it right. Would recommend for a casual, no-frills Italian bite with solid service read more

Food portions, quality and service has declined and has been declining and has continued to decline - hey new ownership and management - just because you "clean up the place" doesn't equal satisfaction. You are ACTIVELY, and I mean ACTIVELY pushing out customers who don't fit your idea of clientele. You did what every other unsuccessful owner does - " let's raise the prices to drive out the riff raff ".... Sure you'll push away the most VERY loyal customers that frequented the bar/restaurant every day for the last whatever years but who cares we're making more and not having to deal with less. This is the attitude of the staff and management period, not an opinion - seen them kick out customers because they were too loud !! - without even talking to the table first !!! Just kicked them out with prejudice i might add !!- Went from great local joint whose male and female employees cared about how you're doing to - Liberty township snobsville central with all female employees as service staff - then this is the place for you Karen's. read more

Good food (especially the Stromboli) , good service - [[HIGHLIGHT]]a fun local neighborhood hangout[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]]!

Added ribeye steak to this incredible salad- so good! [[HIGHLIGHT]]A favorite place to sit and visit with friends while enjoying a beverage.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] Wonderful staff too! read more

Gabby’s Italian Restaurant - Caprese Salad with ribeye! - Pizza Near Me - Delaware, Ohio

Got home & our pizza was so burned it was not edible. Tried to call to discuss via phone was put on hold & no one ever came back. Sadly we won't be going back. read more

Gabby’s Italian Restaurant - Pizza Near Me - Delaware, Ohio

[[HIGHLIGHT]]This place has a dive bar appeal on the outside, but on the inside it's comfortable and clean establishment.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] I was greeted by staff right away. I ordered a Guinness in draft (yummy). I ordered 6-garlic/parmesan wings and a 14 in "Made Man" pizza. The wings were good 7.5/10 but the thin crust pizza was 9/10. Great place I'll be back. read more

See all

Gabby's calzones are the most popular item served. The service is always friendly, the bartenders bust it!! Thursday through Saturday, expect to wait a bit, but it is always worth the wait read more

Terrible service tonight! Never got one dinner, never got the appetizer, never got our drinks and the pizza was the wrong one and it cost $24. All wait staff, including manager was non-apologetic. Total bill $78. Dont go here! read more

Food is always great & Consistent [[HIGHLIGHT]]Used to be my Favorite place to go, chill, relax and enjoy a good Drink & Pizza.....[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] [[HIGHLIGHT]]Unfortunately it's become a Chucky Cheese Pizza feel with all the craziness with all the young kids and crying Babies.....[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] [[HIGHLIGHT]]This is more a bar pizza joint .... Not a young family joint....[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] [[HIGHLIGHT]]It's difficult to remember what Gabby's originally was and now how noisy environment with crying kids it has become...[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] [[HIGHLIGHT]]It is what it is .... But Parents need to get Babysitters and enjoy Gabbys as a couple[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] read more

My daughter and I stopped in here one afternoon wanting a quick bite. We were absolutely blown away by the quality of the stromboli and cheesy garlic bread! First of all, the patio out back is recently renovated and looks gorgeous. I can't imagine a more pleasant place to while away an afternoon. Inside, it's a bar with a small dining area - very casual but clean. Service was friendly and fast. The menu is small but there's something for everyone. I will note that they don't have many pasta dishes - my daughter was hoping for an alfredo dish. Maybe they'll add one in the future. We had to get the stromboli after reading rave reviews on Yelp, and it was a thing of beauty! Delicious and cooked to perfection. My daughter loved her cheesy garlic bread, too - it was a bit flatter and crispier than the wonderfully doughy and chewy stromboli. We will definitely be back! read more

See all

[[HIGHLIGHT]]Food is always great in the atmosphere is very cool.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] Parking is the only downfall to this place as when it is busy it is very difficult to find a place to park and it's right off of a highway which makes it even more difficult. But overall the food is amazing and I would highly recommend the Stromboli. read more

Husband and I love the smoked mozzarella sticks! Margarita made with fresh fruit squeezed at the bar. Awesome portions on the Cesar salad and calzone was great. Server was very nice and attentive. Want to return for trivia Tuesday :) read more

See all

Great food. Salad was huge and calzone was delicious. The ranch sauce was very good. Mozzarella sticks are some of the best in the city. The servers were very nice and [[HIGHLIGHT]]the location is at a pretty spot along scenic route 315.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] read more

Gabby’s Italian Restaurant - Smoked mozzarella sticks - Pizza Near Me - Delaware, Ohio

See all

Unique stop for food tucked away just off 315 & Olentangy. I've had pizza, Stromboli and wings there before! Which have all been good! Staff was very nice! The time that I walked in I was wearing hunting clothes which I believe people at times that don't understand that world get deterred from so it was appreciated that staff was curious and interested how it went! Definitely recommend trying this place out if you are near Delaware or Powell area! read more

OMG, the dough is so soft and pillowy. We hate a tough crust and this is the farthest from tough, everything was fresh and made to order. It took a while to get our food but I'll take slow, hot, fresh and delicious over quick and so-so any day. The service is decent, you can tell the 2 working tonight enjoy their jobs. [[HIGHLIGHT]]The interior is a complete 180 from what it was years ago.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] read more

Their Stromboli is amazing! They've got an open dining area around a decent sized bar area, which is, a full bar with specialty drinks, beers, seltzers, etc. The pizza looks really good as it's nice and thin and cut in triangles. We had the meatball appetizer with garlic bread and I wanted more meatballs, they were delicious! Service is good as we always had water and a fresh drink in front of us. read more

[[HIGHLIGHT]]We have eaten here numerous times and enjoy the ambiance and service.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] just went in last night for dinner only to find out that they have dropped chicken wings from their menu. very disappointed in that. Their wings had been a staple for years and were the best I have had. very sad to find that out. BRING BACK CHICKEN WINGS !!! read more

Carry out and dining in is a great experience. Their food is fantastic even when you take home a pizza it is hot and delicious. I highly recommend the Stromboli. read more

the Delaware Destroyer is a favorite but I love the Buffalo dry rub wings too! All of the wait staff are sweet too!

This place is amazing! We had the mozzarella sticks which were delicious and huge. The Stromboli and Pizza were excellent. read more

Gabby’s Italian Restaurant - Stromboli - Pizza Near Me - Delaware, Ohio

See all

Food was absolutely amazing!! I ordered a stromboli and pretzel and both were cooked to excellence! My servers name was Meadow and she was as well great!! Very polite and nice and explained the whole menu to me and recommended some options as well. My overall experience was amazing and would go back again! I absolutely love this restaurant!! read more

I love Gabby's!! An amazing place randomly off 315!! The wait was extremely long. The service was slow. I understand it is a small staff. Although, do not seat as many tables. The food was awesome. I got the chicken marinara of course, your girl's favorite. I will be back, but knowing I have no where to be after. I do not like being the type of person to nag. This could be made into a great date night or even just something casual after a sports game. You honestly make it what you want. read more

A friend of mine and his buddy were in town for a trap competition and were hungry for Italian food. I've driven past this place numerous times and never really paid attention to it. It's a nice, clean little place when you get inside. The waiter was very nice and immediately came over and dropped off food, mixed drinks and beer menu's. We all ordered a Harp's and a Delaware Destroyer Pizza. The pizza was cooked perfectly, the crust was crunchy underneath and chewy inside. The topping's were fresh and delicious. It's near where I fish all of the time, so it'll be a nice place to stop in for a beer on the way home. read more

Gabby’s Italian Restaurant - The Delaware Destroyer Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Delaware, Ohio

See all

First time in the "new" Gabby's. From the outside you would never know what a gem this restaurant is inside . Freshly renovated, clean , welcoming . We stopped by for a late lunch and were not disappointed. We had a Stromboli, garlic bread with cheese and took home some meatballs and a pizza . All were very good . The Stromboli and meatballs are now in my top 3 in central Ohio ! Stop by, be surprised and satisfy your appetite! read more

See all

We really wanted to try this place heard both good and bad since it had changed owners but not being from here it was all new to us. I was a little discouraged when placing my order the girl taking it sounded like she had people talking to her as she was trying to take my order, she was distracted every time they spoke. My husband went to pick it up 30min later and quickly realized what I was talking about. The hostess/to go stand is right next to a dine in table. The girl at the stand was balancing a paper in front of her and didn't acknowledge my husband for 3-5 minutes, he almost felt uncomfortable. The Stromboli itself was really good, I thought it was a bit spicy but good. read more

Gabby’s Italian Restaurant - The Delaware Destroyer Stromboli - Pizza Near Me - Delaware, Ohio

Gabbys is one of the places my family and I always enjoy. Whether we dine in or get pizza to go, it's always delicious. Their Stromboli is to die for. My sister and I usually share a house salad and it's always delicious and tastes fresh. The servers are great and attentive, and many different people check in on us while we dine in. [[HIGHLIGHT]]It's a small place, but very cute with a bar and quite a few tables.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] Definitely recommend for anyone thinking about trying it out! read more

We needed to go out to dinner tonight and decided on a local restaurant we have not been too. What a delight to finally try a little whole in the wall we have passed many times not realizing it was an Italian Restaurant. It is not a place to go for on a date as it is plain inside, but the food was outstanding. We had the Skinny Siciilian Stromboli and paired it with a Sauvignon Blanc wine which was a fabulous match to the food! The waitress was really nice and met our needs throughout the meal. read more

Gabby’s Italian Restaurant - Umm Umm Good! - Pizza Near Me - Delaware, Ohio

See all

I ordered online and only part of the order was ready. Staff was aggressive and rude insisting I did not order what I said I did in spite of having email confirmation. I have been a loyal customer and although their service has usually been sketchy the food was good. Drinks are Variable depending on who is making them but the food has almost always been great. We tried to work it out with a manager but they said there wasn't one and we have not received a call back. I would suggest avoiding them until they get their customer service act together. Worst service ever in my very long life. read more

We were not impressed. We came in from out of town, looking for an Italian Restaurants. Googled and seen where Gabby's was rated a 4.8. Thought Great, they must be a great place to eat, with awesome food. Walked in expecting a Italian atmosphere and found a bar atmosphere. We sat our self. The waitress came over and asked what we wanted to drink. We asked if they were still severing dinner and she said. "Ummm, yes". We placed our drink order (which was ice water w/lemon and tea (tea was unsweetened, that was the only choice. they do not have sweet tea). We also placed our food order, to which we both ordered Chicken Parmesan. We were only given forks and napkins. I asked for a knife to cut my chicken, it took the waitress about 5-10 minute to come back with a butter knife. She said she asked the kitchen and they said that was all they had. Dinner was just okay. read more

Don't see how people think this is good Italian food. Way overpriced for a place that doesn't make authentic Italian food. The pizza tastes like cardboard. Might be because the owner buys his pizza dough from a Jewish bakery in Columbus. If you don't know how to make your own pizza dough get out of the biz. If this place was on the East Coast or in Chicago it wouldn't last a month. Don't waste your money here. read more

Gabbys is a family favorite. The Stromboli is fantastic! Also, love their cauliflower crust pizza. Can barely taste the difference. Highly recommend! read more

Outstanding! We went for the first time on a Friday night. We always thought it was just a corner store so we never stopped in. I'm glad we finally did. The basil Mushroom bruschetta was oustanding.. so was the pizza, Spaghetti with tomato sauce and garlic bread. Our waitress was so informative as we asked her questions about this place. She told us, it got sold just before covid, and the new owners renovated it, opened it back up late 2021. She was so sweet. We can't wait to go back. read more

Gabby’s Italian Restaurant - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Delaware, Ohio

See all

Cute spot. Tight parking. Service was extremely slow which was challenging with young kids at our table. Definitely willing to give them another chance without the kids. read more

While I love Gabby's Stromboli, the front of house staff must all be new and have never worked in a restaurant in their life. It took over 15 minutes to get a glass of wine, despite the wine being listed on the menu, no one seemed to know what it was. The staff couldn't tell me how much the total of my food was for an exceptionally long time too. I understand being busy but this truly seemed like ameature hour. read more

Gabby’s Italian Restaurant - Raw dough - Pizza Near Me - Delaware, Ohio

My family recently dined at Gabby's Italian restaurant. [[HIGHLIGHT]]We walked in and there was plenty of seating.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] [[HIGHLIGHT]]The ambiance was great, and the food lived up to all our expectations.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] Most of us tried the pizza and my nephew had the chicken fettuccine, We were all pleased with our meals. Our waitress was Clarissa, she was incredibly friendly and very attentive throughout our meal. Made sure that we had everything we needed. [[HIGHLIGHT]]We enjoyed our visit & definitely think it's a must-try, especially, if you are looking for an intimate, cozy and amazing place for dinner[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]]. read more

I had the opportunity to stop at this staple up north today known for their Stromboli and pizza. I was pleasantly surprised with my visit. The service was wonderful, our server Emily greeted our group of grouchy gals with a smile and was happy to accommodate our requests. I went with the The Destroyer Stromboli and it didn't disappoint. With house ground sausage and oozing cheese dipped in their marinara, it made it a crave worthy experience. Don't skimp on their brunch, their french toast with bananas was decadent and a must order! As for ambiance- I loved the addition of the moose. read more

Every food you order I'd delicious! We love there Stromboli and Pizza. They also have great salads and Meatballs. We love the waitresses and the owners are wonderful! read more

Great spot. Pizza great. Wings super. Clean as a whistle as well. A winner! Not a wide menu but SOLID. read more

This is our "go to" hole in the wall in Delaware, Oh. Best pizza and strombolis in town! Definitely give it a try. A true corner bar. Nick behind the bar is the best! read more

We went to Gabby's this past Friday with two others couples who are true pizza afficiandoes. They go out for pizza very two weeks and have eaten at virtually every pizza restaurant in central Ohio. We ordered the Wise Guy and it was outstanding. One of the couples opted for a pepperoni pizza and the others ordered Stromboli They all agreed the food was delicious. We will all definitely be back read more