Goodfella&#x27;s Pizza

Mazerella's Upper Crust Pizza and Pasta in Sellersburg, indiana. The Service is Spectacular, the…read moreFood delicious and perfectly prepared. I would recommend a few line squirts across top of Barbecue Chicken pizza with some Kinders BBQ Sauce. Otherwise Abience could use a little help, maybe different paint and more TVs. Otherwise, they are a 5 Star Business. Fantastic product and Service.

Had a great meal here tonight at Mazerella's. I had the Buffalo Chicken (Crustless Style), my…read morecompanions had the: Grilled Chicken Alfredo - He said the chicken was so incredibly tender and delicious and the garlic bread was also tasty And the Maz Combo Pizza - She said it was "super good" And my crustless was wonderful. The flavors were are balanced, the cheese has awesome pull and it was a great portion size. You order at the window and take a seat. They will bring your food out to you. They have soft drinks in a cooler in bottles and cans and a soda fountain. Our food was delivered hot and delicious in less than 15 mins. We will be back!

Thin Crust pizza

See all

Sherrilli’s Pizzeria

3.7(13 reviews)

9.5 mi

Owners have been very kind reaching out to me after a misunderstanding on an order. They are…read moreworking to clear up the misunderstanding with the menu item.

Two years ago I left this place a 5 star review. Today not so much. I ordered a 1/2!sausage and 1/2…read morecheese only. When o got home there were 4 small cheese only pieces on the edges. The rest was sausage. Too far to go back. And when I looked at my receipt I was charged a .50 delivery fee. I picked it up!!!If you order from here be sure to check your order before you leave.

Burnt pizza (2)

Pepperoni and sausage 14 inch. This reminds me of the old Steve's Pizza king and the blackened crust, delicious!!!!

See all

Extra sides & funny signs

Brittany's Brick Oven Pizza

4.9(101 reviews)

24.7 mi

Superb pizza and bread sticks! The small salad was of a generous portion and all the ingredients…read morewere fresh. The balsamic vinaigrette dressing tasted homemade. The restaurant was well staffed and all of the staff that serviced our table were extremely nice, attentive and friendly. Sweet and kind I'd say. The restaurant was busy with table seated guests and the staff was processing carry out orders efficiently. Quite possibly the best pizza this seasoned citizen has ever had! Excellent overall experience! Tidy and clean restaurant and bathroom too! A real delight!

"Brick Oven", I instantly know it'll be delicious. We got three separate personal pies, all…read moredelicious. Tons of toppings with the perfect crisp. And only $8-10 a pie! The breadsticks were okay, kinda plain but we still finished them! They have different featured desserts, and like 8 options. We struggled to decide but we got a chocolate cake (OMG YUM) and a peanut butter pie that was huge. Super cheap desserts, too! Small little place, but the staff were overly friendly. Just what we wanted and were looking for! Highly recommend. We were traveling through, but if I was local I would be here weekly.

Inside

Hungry as a bar of Pizza in the front. Gluten-free cheese pizza in the back

See all

Outside

Chicago City Pizza

4.4(25 reviews)

9.9 mi

Food was great. Large portions. Be ready for leftovers. Great staff and atmosphere. A bit pricey…read morecompared to the area but for what you get it's definitely worth it. We got 2 12 inch pizzas and have food for the week.

My wife and I stopped by for a date night after hearing good things about Chicago City Pizza, and…read moreit was worth checking out. The pizza was tasty, the service was good, and the location is convenient. It's a small place inside, but that adds to the cozy small town feel. We also liked the train running around the restaurant and having a TV on while we ate. If you're looking for a laid back local pizza spot, it's definitely worth a visit.

20.0 mi•Downtown, Medical Center

See all

Parlour - Downtown Louisville

4.0(201 reviews)

Very good food, definitely stands out with the pizza and pints being everywhere in Louisville. My…read moreonly suggestion was it was freezing in there. Special thanks to the manager who cleared up one small error on our ticket. She was a beautiful lady with long hair and glasses.

Shall we get our pizza on!…read more The pizza journey of this restaurant continues from Jeffersonville, Indiana to Louisville Kentucky. Now do you want something unique and special. It's delicious and hot!! It makes you want to keep repeating and retuning. What makes this place so special is the sauce. Is it all in the sauce ! Yes truly it is. That red sauce in the pizza and doused in cheese. Wow! If you have experienced their pizza you can know how it's tastes. Now being sensitive to spice, something's the special sauce can trigger your stomach issues and sensitivity. But take those antacids to not have it set off. The pizza here is absolutely delicious. Again the key ingredient, "the sauce," so make sure and ask for extra. The cheese bread is delicious too. We have dined in and taken it to go. The service is stellar . The restaurant is a sit in place with a bar. Bring the family. It's a great place to gather and socialize. Eat pizza and drink. Just enjoy the ride of life.

Weclome to Parlour

See all

Good beer from Louisville

French Licks

4.5(67 reviews)

46.1 mi

If I could give this place 10 stars, I would…read more I wish my stomach was big enough to eat my pizza twice. We came in at 1pm on a Wednesday to only one employee working, which worried us initially since we had a party of 6 but she got to us quickly and had our food ready in under 15 minutes. Highly recommend the cheeseburger pizza. It was LOADED with toppings and the most delicious pickles I've ever tasted. My iced coffee was delicious as well. Everyone left full and happy.

Pizza-amazing, ice cream-amazing, staff-amazing! Nothing bad to say about this quaint little…read moreplace! The menu is simple, the staff is beyond friendly and helpful. Very inviting environment ! Dining room only seats 50 people but the atmosphere is so cool and unique! Prices are great! And you can even get "adult" milkshakes with your favorite liquor added in. Just a fun place! Plan to go back many times! Also family friendly as well! Definitely recommend this little gem I'd you are in French Lick , Indiana. You won't be disappointed!

S'mores ice cream- delicious!

See all

Menu June 16, 2023

Chicago's Pizza

3.9(85 reviews)

45.8 mi

Great friendly service, clean environment and great pizza !! Deep Dish all the way!! The price was…read morevery competitive to other pizza places!

Great service and the pizza was really really good. I was pleasantly surprised and we will return…read morewhen we are in the area.

Pepperoni cheese sticks

My pie

See all

Jumbo Veggie with banana peppers.

The Drake

4.4(13 reviews)

24.9 mi

Convivial atmosphere. Righteous pie. Good music. Bartender is kinda spicy. In the very best way…read more 10/10.

Just a mediocre bar where the locals hang out, nothing that special and the pizza wasn't really…read morethat good either, meh.

Only bottoms up draft system in Madison In

Chicken Bacon Ranch 12" pizza

See all

Chicken tenders rolled in flour and buttermilk and cooked golden brown.

Fire Oven Pizza

4.4(83 reviews)

26.8 mi•Okolona

This place lets you pick what you want on pizza and puts it in fire oven. Made to order it's…read moregreat!!! Not a Military friendly restaurant.

Great service, super fast, and very laid back. We ordered 3 pizzas from here to go and they were…read moreready in about 15 minutes. If I was going to back I would get one of the Indian style pizzas. The smell of tikka masala was just fabulous and I'm so sad we didn't get to try it. The Hawaiian was my favorite of the pizzas we got. The pizzas were a good size for the price. I assumed they would be a personal size with the inexpensive price but we had lots of leftovers ordering 3 pizzas for 3 people

Chicken Tikka Masala Pizza

See all

Tequila & Mezcal

4.9(16 reviews)

0.2 mi

This is one of my favorite Mexican restaurants. I would highly recommend to anyone. My husband and…read moreI come here often and they have great food, drinks, atmosphere, and service. This place definitely checks all of the boxes and has become a staple. It is family friendly and we will always recommend this restaurant!!

Awesome food and super Friendly staff. I recommend the carnitas...it's amazing. Parking can be…read moretight during busy times but worth it.

View of the inside

Enchiladas Bandera

See all

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

9 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Bella L.

0

2

0

12 years ago

If you live in Henryville and you haven't tried Goodfella's then you should probably fix that. I absolutely love this restaurant. The food is great. I always get the cheese pizza (I know, not very exciting) and the green bean crispers (insert drool emoji here). There's more than just pizza on the menu though and the lunch specials are usually a big hit. The prices are great for the amount of food you get in exchange and the servers are super friendly and welcoming. I would highly recommend to anyone. read more

Melissa B.

0

1

0

6 years ago

This is an awesome place to eat. We get delivery and carry out a lot. The food is amazing and the employees are very kind, friendly and very polite. The chef salad cannot be beat. I take it to work a lot and everyone wants to know where I got it. I personally cannot eat all of it. Everything is fresh, well made, and rarely any issues, and when there was a an issue they fixed it immediately. No problems. I love this restaurant and highly recommend it to anyone. read more

Julie B.

0

5

3

3 years ago

Haven and the team serve fresh, hot and delicious food for breakfas, lunch and dinner. Buffet, outstanding specials. Fast, friendly service. up from Florida and felt at home at Goodfella's. almost forgot to mention their fountain drinks cost half as much as back home, nice price! see you next time read more

Clyde L.

22

27

7

10 years ago

Phenomenonal pizza. I am extremely impressed and definitely wasn't expecting pizza this good in the area. Everything was right from the sauce to the cheese to crust. Highly recommend. read more

Jeff S.

0

2

0

10 years ago

Love Goodfellas! The pizza is great, the Calzones are unbelievable and the sandwiches rock. Breakfast is great too largest and best pancakes around! read more

Alisson C.

0

2

0

3 years ago

Awesome pizza!! delicious and they also have dessert pizzas!! the service is also great and the people are so kind! my family and I love it!

Peter R.

0

1

0

6 years ago

Great food. Subs and pizza are fantastic. Very friendly staff and also helpful. Highly recommend.

Makayla S.

55

1

0

7 years ago

thin crust chicken bacon ranch pizza and baked potato pizza was amazing! whole family loved it

Michele S.

7

37

12

12 years ago

Great food and staff was friendly! Food came out fast and hot. This place was very clean to.

Goodfella's Pizza - pizza - Updated September 2026

People who viewed Goodfella's Pizza also viewed

Teena's Pizza

3.1

(17 reviews)

I'm glad I hadn't previously driven by this place, or I may have never ordered from here. I…read moreinitially missed the building and drove by, even with Google maps. It looks sketch, and I briefly reconsidered my choice. But I'm glad I went in! Yelp was zero help in finding this gem, so props to Barstool's One Bite app. I have struggled (to put it mildly) to find even decent pizza around these parts, but this was sooooo worth the drive! The sticks were fantastic and the pizza was even better. I threw my half of the pizza down my gullet so fast, my throat was struggling to keep up. I wish I would've ordered a larger size. Don't let the looks of the building deter you. There is delicious pizza out here in BFE.

In the area starving & looking for a place to eat, Teena's Pizza showed up my Yelp app and it was…read morenearby. The is parking & the building is small. Surprisingly there was plenty of seating for the 10 of us. The staff were nice and I ordered 8in buffalo chicken pizza, fried dill pickles & large drinks. They have fountain drinks & 2 liters drink options. They ordered the largest cheese pizza & it came with free breadsticks. We did have to wait for a decent time but they were fairly busy with people picking up call in orders. The fried dill pickles & breadsticks came out and they were hot and fresh. I loved the pickles they were crispy & seasoned & had a dipping sauce. Also did I mention it brick oven pizza style, so once our pizzas came out a few minutes later not & fresh out the oven. You can see the crisp on the bottom & crust. The buffalo chicken pizza was good not hot buffalo sauce but still packed some flavors. 8 inches wasn't a big pizza almost a personal size but still plenty and our other group devoured their cheese pizza. It the huge and delicious. They didn't have a trash can and we were told to leave our stuff for clean up. They have one small bathroom but it was well stocked & clean. We were pleasantly surprised by the location size, service and food. Don't sleep on local places you never know until you try it.

Mamma Rosa's Restaurant

4.1

(29 reviews)

Good little Italian restaurant. Quick to take your order and get your food. I had the chicken parm…read more With spaghetti. Not the best I've had. The chicken is chicken strips covered in a slightly tangy marinara sauce without any cheese topping. The spaghetti is really good tho. My wife had the baked spaghetti with their marinara sauce. She liked it. We don't think we'll be back.

Good food at a fair price. Service was quick and food came out in a reasonable time. The restaurant…read morehas that small town midwestern feel.

Pizza King

3.3

(84 reviews)

waiter was good, food was good, i was mean. i didnt get a…read morecup of chicken, very happy good time

Takeout order was extremely fast from online submission and then picked up in 15 minutes. Love the…read morethin crispy oven baked crust and this version of chopped pepperoni as well as other toppings. Plenty of free parking and convenient location off of Charlestown Road and I-265 interchange. Staff at reception and pickup counter were both welcoming and helpful.

Chicago City Pizza

4.4

(25 reviews)

Food was great. Large portions. Be ready for leftovers. Great staff and atmosphere. A bit pricey…read morecompared to the area but for what you get it's definitely worth it. We got 2 12 inch pizzas and have food for the week.

My wife and I stopped by for a date night after hearing good things about Chicago City Pizza, and…read moreit was worth checking out. The pizza was tasty, the service was good, and the location is convenient. It's a small place inside, but that adds to the cozy small town feel. We also liked the train running around the restaurant and having a TV on while we ate. If you're looking for a laid back local pizza spot, it's definitely worth a visit.

Sherrilli’s Pizzeria

3.7

(13 reviews)

Owners have been very kind reaching out to me after a misunderstanding on an order. They are…read moreworking to clear up the misunderstanding with the menu item.

Two years ago I left this place a 5 star review. Today not so much. I ordered a 1/2!sausage and 1/2…read morecheese only. When o got home there were 4 small cheese only pieces on the edges. The rest was sausage. Too far to go back. And when I looked at my receipt I was charged a .50 delivery fee. I picked it up!!!If you order from here be sure to check your order before you leave.

Jendy's Pizzeria

4.0

(36 reviews)

The wings were absolutely fantastic. I mean 5 star good. Never saw that coming. A really cool…read morelittle pizza joint out in the country that had great service and a great vibe.

Just moved to this area I called in an order and picked it up at the drive-through. Service was…read morevery friendly and the pizza was good. The only thing I can complain about is, I had asked for no sausage on the Jendy's classic pizza which normally does come with sausage and they accidentally put it on there. Other than that everything was fine. I hear they have a lunch buffet, which I will probably try one day. I do recommend you try Jendy's pizzeria in Hanover, Indiana.

Old School NY Pizza

3.6

(73 reviews)

Sitting at a table next to the sidewalk, enjoying a slice of pizza -- what a lovely experience in…read moreNorton Commons! This is the kind of neighborhood experience that NC is made for. My MIL lives in NC, and we met up for dinner while family was visiting. We got a long table out front and were able to decide on a few pizzas to try, including a basic cheese (for the kids), pepperoni and sausage and the chicken pesto. Each was good, with the chicken pesto my favorite. The flavors worked really well together. We didn't have to wait too long for our pizzas and could also enjoy a glass of beer -- the adults, not the kids ;-) -- to round out the evening. NC boasts several restaurants now, but I would definitely come here again.

Let me start by saying the smell of this place is a 5 out of 5, and the food that we had were…read moredelicious! The reason for the low score comes from ambience and timing. We went on a Thursday rainy night and sat in the enclosed patio which is a nice set-up that we quickly learned is where they accommodate all large parties. The noise grew very loud to the point it seemed like tables across the patio were trying to battle to be heard. We got there ahead of the six person party and the 8 person party. However the timing was very off for the restaurant this night. We chose pizza thinking it would be quick and painless. We were here for almost 3 hours, we ordered two sodas, a salad to split, one large pizza and that's it. We had to flag people down for soda refills and after placing our order for the pizza about 15 min after sitting down, we then waited about an hour and 45 min before it arrived. Everything tasted amazing and it is obviously a hot local spot! But from my experience if you want quick food with a more chill ambience I would suggest other restaurants in this area. If you have a rowdy crowd ready to have some fun drinks and an absolute need for pizza they have you covered!

Charlestown Pizza Company

4.1

(80 reviews)

Nice place; haven't been back for awhile. Heard new owners had taken over…read more We ordered 2 super fly Thai each a tad differ items added. Met Sean one of the owners. He came by and talked with us, how he got started, his philosophy on running his business and making a good product. The pizzeria is decorated with an array of local items, a table laminated with a lot of history. Lots of nostalgia. Pizzas were good also.

The server at the restaurant was very kind and attentive. It's a small pizza joint in Charlestown,…read moreIndiana. We were in town for a Cub Scout summer camp and decided to try out some local cuisine. We ordered dough bites for an appetizer and I chose a pot pie-like dish while also ordering a small cheese pizza for the children. The dough bites were quite plain--essentially just rolled-up dough that was baked without any seasoning. They would have tasted much better if they had been topped with some butter and Parmesan salt. The pizza, however, was pretty good and was a suitable size for the kids, with plenty of cheese. I had expected to receive a pie filled with 11 different types of ingredients covered by a crust. Instead, I got a hot bowl of the ingredients I selected, topped with just a small piece of dough. I would have preferred it if they had made a proper pie crust, filled it with the toppings, and then covered it with more dough, possibly with some butter and Parmesan cheese. Overall, we would return to this restaurant primarily for the excellent service. The server was very friendly, and I really enjoyed the cheese pizza.

Marco's Pizza & Sub

3.1

(17 reviews)