Food and service was very good. We went right after the lunch crowd and the restaurant was a little dirty, but I will give them a pass because of the time we went. I will go again, and try the breakfast menu. read more

See all

Very good food The only thing I didn't like about the place all you can eat pizza used to be at $10 now it jumped it up to 13 that's a hike there's other places around are cheaper than them and just as good but if you want convenience that's a good place to go people are nice too read more

Good specials. Great weekend breakfast buffet. Good prices. Friendly staff Nice neighborhood restaurant read more

We ordered this pizza during our girls stay at a nearby air bnb. Delivery was fairly quick and the pizzas were still hot when we received them. The veggie pizzas were AHMAZING! I am sad I didn't take any picture, I usually do. The veggie pizza had zucchini on it and I am here for it! Why I have never seen that, I am unsure but I will definitely be doing it at home. We got the pizza again over the weekend and it was just as amazing. Don't hesitate, order the pizza!! read more

Smashed the breakfast buffet at Goodfella's this morning. You should get there before 8:00 if you expect to get a seat. There is nothing else like this in the Henryville/Sellersburg area. They keep your coffee hot and topped off. Old school excellent service you will find pretty much nowhere these days. read more

See all

The place is a small hole in the wall clean and very nicely decorated with old gangster movie posters and small knick knacks from coffee signs biblical quotes to old Easter wreaths and even some trophies. The food was on point perfect size portions and very tasty . Service was a nice southern style loads of hospitality. A good spot to grab something to eat since everything came out fast . read more

See all

Plate special isn't what they show on facebook?picture shows actual amount of coleslaw for Friday plate special. It wasn't even half the amount in pictures. Sad read more

I love this place. I plan to eat here every Friday that I can. They have a bonus lunch buffet from 10-2 that ranges from $10-12 drink included. They have coke products. This day was thanksgiving style. Dressing with a lot of turkey stock, juicy turkey, Smokey tender ham, whipped smooth potatoes, meaty gravy. The whole time I was there they kept bringing out random food. They brought out some good chicken strips when I was getting desert. The butter cake they had was excellent. Every day they have pizza, which was also good. The cheese was very generous and had a great flavor. read more

Goodfella's Pizza - Ham butter cake pizza - Pizza Near Me - Henryville, Indiana

Outstanding business- we come in or order online frequently. The owners are incredible and the food is so well prepared. The fact that I have to submit 85 characters is really ridiculous. read more

Food and service was very good! Prices very reasonable. Restaurant was very clean! We' ll come back! read more

Order was fulfilled to our expectations! Never had a bad experience while ordering here.

Great food with tons of options other than pizza. They also have a good gluten free pizza

Somethings are good. Buffets are good if you're there on time. A few hours in and sometimes it seems things are slow coming out. The meatloaf special is good but the peice of meatloaf seems to have shrunk. Definitely not worth $12 anymore. read more

My husband and I always try to eat at a local restaurant when we travel. Decided to stop at Goodfella's because we liked the name. So glad we stopped. The pizza was GREAT! Service was just as good and it was so clean! Couldn't ask for more. Highly recommend stopping if you're in the area read more

We ordered a Supreme Pizza, but yet only half of it was a Supreme. Not sure why they decided to only put toppings on half of it. The crust was supposed to be regular or hand tossed and it looked like thin and wasn't even cooked all the way and was still doughy. One star was being generous. Disgusting! read more

Best restaurant in town. Love to see more friendly and good restaurants come to town for more options. But Goodfella's is our place for pizza and calzones. read more

Best grinders ever! We like the breakfast buffet. They need to build on! Their fries are so good too!

It was very good but not what it used to be. I had a chicken bacon ranch grinder and the buns were burnt. We we finally received our food the fries were cold. read more

Driving back to Chicago from a long road trip, we needed some dinner. Happened to be near this exit when I opened Yelp and found this to be nearby ... and with a high rating. If I could give them ten stars I would. Checked to see the close time, had about an hour before close so ordered by phone intending to slam it before they closed. When we arrived we were cheerfully greeted by Rachel, the server who was closing. She was scrubbing down the doors, and the effort showed. The place was spotless. She assured us we didn't have to rush. We had a large pizza, salads and fried pickles. All was amazing but I have to talk about the pizza. I am originally from New York, and in the 20 years I've yet to find a pizza that matches the type of "New York style crust" I love. These guys delivered. Perfect thickness ... not thin, not deep dish, just fabulous. Truly a delicious pie. If I could have them deliver to Chicago I'd order from them every week. Rachel was also amazing. Delivered our order, asked if we needed anything, made certain we were not bothered by here cleaning the dining room while we ate (we were not). Overall a positive experience all around. Go eat a pizza there today! read more

Goodfella's Pizza - The outside of Goodfellas. - Pizza Near Me - Henryville, Indiana

Breakfast buffet is always great and we love the pizza too. The dining room is not very big so expect it to be full for breakfast buffet or if you come for dinner after a school event, but they do a good job and it never feels too crammed together. Thanks Goodfellas! read more

Stopped in based on previous yelp reviews. It did not disappoint for what we were after. A quick reasonable bite. They got us in and out and happened to have a pizza buffet. Nice salad with olives and bacon toppings. A wide variety of fresh hot pizza. The chicken and tomato was so smoky and good. The bbq was great also. The spaghetti offered was OK, the sauce was nice and tomatoey with a little sweetness. I liked it. They even brought out a dessert pizza. Cherry and apple, cooked fresh. It was good. It's not fancy but good quality, nice staff and very clean! Bathrooms were extremely clean! Had Tv's playing basketball games which was nice and was not overly loud. Very open dinking room but comfortable. Seemed like they sold a lot of carry out pizza and the customers seemed happy to be picking up their food. So appears like a good local spot. We were traveling through. We will remember this place next time we run through the little town. It was very reasonable. read more

Nice to have a family restaurant in our area! It is alway clean and inviting. On the weekends they have a breakfast buffet. There is always a good variety of food but they overcook the biscuits and sweet rolls. They use to have half inch think bologna slices but they got rid of those so that's disappointing. I picked up lunch one day and was over charged so I've never went back. Sad their long time employee thinks she can cheat the customers. I hope a couple bucks was worth a repeat customer's business. read more

Always so good! Big Stromboli and pizza fans! Delivery is always timely and the staff are great! Dining in is also great!!

Stopped on Sunday on our way home from weekend vacation. Excellent service and such friendly people! Pizza, cheese sticks and salad all great!! read more

Love this restaurant!!!!! Sooo awesome!!! Pizza is awesome, lovely seating area and fast service!

Good local food and will deliver. Amazing customer service. It's our family's go to for pizza night at home. Sandwiches, salads, and desert are great too. read more

Horrible..! Me an my daughter came up from louisville ky came in at 7:00pm an its 7:58pm havent been help an everyone else jumped us in line cause the girl let them so we left an never got to order I wouldn't recommend anyone with rainbow hair or being a single mom to eat here the are rude an my little girl is starving hungry now I have to find her another place to eat. Will never come back an will post on my eaters blog also..!!! read more

Friendly local people. Baked potato pizza is really good. Breakfast buffet is pretty good as well.

Good enough to make me pull a Jimmy Two Times and come back for seconds. For a small town pizzeria, I was surprised and delighted to enjoy the delicious pie served here. I particularly enjoyed their well-rounded sauce with just a touch of sweetness. Their New York style crust was also cooked to perfection. You can tell they care and use quality ingredients. read more

Placed a to-go order. When my husband brought it home he didn't have any toppings on his sandwich and I was missing my sauce for my onion petals. I called and spoke with the manager and was told that toppings are only put on a sandwich per request. However the menu I was looking at was from their Facebook page. When I told the manager that, she told me that I must be looking at an old menu. Wow, the customer doesn't matter to this business! My family and I will drive out of the way not to go here any more. read more

Well worth the trip to Henryville love there pizza and sandwiches. Also the employees are very friendly and eager to please all in all very nice place to eat. read more

Goodfella's Pizza - This was a take out night with my daughter very enjoyable - Pizza Near Me - Henryville, Indiana

I love this little small town restaurant. The pizza + breakfast buffet is always really good and I think it's priced very reasonably. The staff, for the most part, is friendly. Food is pretty consistent which can be hard to find surprisingly, especially at a small restaurant. There are a couple things on the menu I don't "love" such as the baked spaghetti but it's probably just my personal preference.. you can't like everything. If you go here I definitely recommend pizza. read more

Great food. Buffet breakfast. Clean and friendly. The boneless wings are delicious. The grinders are good. The chicken bacon ranch pizza is to die for. Dessert pizzas are awesome also. Fish sandwich is a hit too. Lunch specials range from chili to meatloaf. Always great. read more

It's been an hour and a half and my pizza is still not here......that's enough for me not to order from this place again.....the pizza is good but I didn't pay 25 bucks plus tip for it to be cold..... read more

OMG, if you love cheese, this place is for you! I had an amazing calzone and my son LOVED the pizza. Worth the stop. read more

Goodfella's Pizza - Calzone, hand tossed pizza and cheese bread. - Pizza Near Me - Henryville, Indiana

What can I say other than this place knows what they are and they do it well. Prices are a tad high but I understand margins and am willing to pay to help a local business. The breakfast buffet hits the spot for me and in the evenings they supply a great carry out pizza and breadsticks that surpasses the chains. Ultimately I'm happy there is a local option and will continue to frequent this place. read more

Nothing fancy, but great food! Really great prices and large portions. Great place for groups as they have an extensive menu. My husband and I really like the thin crust pep pizza or chicken Alfredo pizza. If in Henryville and craving pizza, this is a great option! read more

Yummy chicken alfredo pizza with bacon! Love the thin crust! We stopped in while driving home from vacation, & it was ready quickly. Not a fan of the water, though. The women's restroom was nice and clean. read more

It's been a while since we've been here. I forgot how amazingly delicious their pizza is. The thin crust all meat pizza is definitely my favorite. Highly recommended. Friendly staff, reasonable prices and the pizza came out quick. read more

Love this place! They have tons of choices even if you don't want pizza. The prices are awesome. You can get a ton of food for a reasonable price. Their desert pizzas are the best! I also love their strombolis! read more