First of all, this is Great Amercian Cookies and Marble Slab Creamery, so we came for the ice cream. The place was clean and the staff were awesome! There were multiple ice cream flavors and plenty of mix-on options. Serving size was huge, and they had a free cookie special. Ice creams were 5 stars! It's already our favorite ice cream spot, and so far, I've yet to find a "creation" that I haven't enjoyed. The cookies were 3 stars. The pecan caramel cookie was extremely salty and did not make you want to go back for a second bite. The white chocolate coconut was pretty good, but I thought it was a white chocolate macadamia nut. I've had their cookies in the past, so I'm hoping this was an off day. read more

Rode 35 minutes for them to have maybe four cookie trays available shit sad waste of my time it's the middle of the day why don't you I have all cookies read more

Horrible service. Not first time. Cookie cake 45 minutes late being finished. No one at counter for minutes. Several customers gave up and left. People.. go to the one in McDonough ! So much better!! read more

Praying my trainer doesn't read this! Fantastic cookies... I couldn't even leave the parking lot before having one. The treats are worth the calories and I'm so glad this spot was recommended. read more

See all

My husband and I stopped in for a sweet treat. He went over to sample ice cream as I looked at the variety of cookies. The young lady serve him sample ice creams with trash SPOONS. Once I realized it it was already too late. I asked to speak to the manager (Jordan) she stated she was the AGM and the young lady was new. This is very concerning my husband could now be infected with any germs from the previous customer who used these spoons. Jordan did not charge us for the cookie slice or ice cream but this is way more concerning than a couple dollars. The establishment stated they will not compensate for this HUGE error on their behalf from lack of training and safety. read more

I ordered my cake on the 25th of November an when she asked what time for pick I said 11 as I always do. she looked an said it'll have to be 12 I thought okay cool still give plenty of time to pick it up an make it To the place we were throwing the party. We get there at about 12:35ish my husband goes in a The girl decorating the cakes informs him it wasnt ready with no explanation and an attitude. He comes out I go in An I ask an again she already has an Attitude she then proceeds to inform they had a Huge order come in just that morning Again keep in mind I ordered and paid for mine on the 25th I picked up on the 10th of December. She said they had to push everyone back because of this which to me is wild Why would you push advanced paid Orders for a fresh one? so anyway she tells me it's going no to be another 15 to 20 mins I'm annoyed But being calm an stand an wait when I shouldn't have to I was told 12 not 1:11 that's when I finally got the cake. During that time the other lady is walking around like a lost puppy neither apologized for the inconvenience or anything. I ask the lady walking around at 12:55 how much longer she had said 15 to 20 she said oh I think she's almost done at this point I explain how unhappy I am because my party is at 1:30 in McDonough at woodys if you've ever done a party you only get an hr in the party rooms I tell her this going to make me late an cut into our party time This is my daughters 1st birthday party she looks me straight in the face an says that's not our problem so when I ask why they took an order over prepaid she then argue that she took my order last week as If that makes a differenc. So they don't give a damn that they made us late an told me one time an it wasn't that an that they didn't even call an Tell me it would be late. needless to say I spent over $300 to only get 30 mins in the party room when I paid an hr because my cake wasn't ready when I was told it would be. I also asked for 1 Jelly bean to be drawn on the cake and this Girl drew 3 colorful circles and the cake Tasted under cooked! Its obvious they could careless about being on time and even trying to make it look good! read more

Great American Cookies - Wtf are those that is not a Jelly bean! Not even shaped like it! - Bakeries Near Me - Conyers, Georgia

This was the first time coming here. The lady who helped me was so pleasant and polite. The cookies were delicious. We will be back.

Very disappointed. Placed my order in person and stressed how I wanted it and prepaid. Went to pick up the cake and it was missing the extra icing so they told me to come back. I had my son go pick up the cake and this is what $42 look like. I asked for a refund, and since my son didn't have the card they refuse to issue a refund and said I need to come back tomorrow. BEWARE!!! read more

Great American Cookies - Cookie cake - Bakeries Near Me - Conyers, Georgia

Waited 2 hours for an ice cream cake that was preordered 2 days before and when I got there at the pick up time they decided they were going to finally start making it. They also can't tell the difference between Chocolate and Vanilla. We were given a melted blob of ice cream and it wasn't even the right cake. The manager and the assistant manager said we're on our own because they don't want to fix their mistakes. read more

We love our Great American Cookie store!! They always have tasty treats and make the best cookie cakes for all of our events!! The last two we got were awesome! One was for my birthday that was Friends themed! And then another was for our Kids for Wishes Paint Night fundraiser for Make A Wish GA! We always love the creations that they make for us! read more

Great American Cookies - Loooooooooved my Friends themed birthday cookie cake!!!! They did amazing!! - Bakeries Near Me - Conyers, Georgia

See all

Our cookies were old.... point blank period stale no love came on Sunday mid afternoon. Will definitely not return even if it was free

I arrived to pick up a custom cookie cake and pointed out to the cashier that the name was written correctly on the order form but spelled incorrectly on the cake. I also pointed out there were random smears of white icing all over the cake. The cashier said, and I quote, "yea she did mess that up." Also, the "1" in "18th" was oddly shaped. I requested they A. Give me a refund and keep the cake B. Provide a partial refund and I keep the cake or C. Remake it. They refused to do any of the above and would only remake it if I paid again. Only corrected the name which further smeared the icing. Customer service at its worst! read more

I WANT MY Money BACK!!! Paid and placed the order online... never received the order... came to the store twice... first time no shipment, 2nd time... lights out and the phone number is disconnected!! I called the same number yesterday!!! read more

I go all the time nice ppl and great cookies! Every Tuesday it's a special and I prefer this location over the mall one. Love the cheesecake brownie read more

Terrible! After coming to this location on four separate occasions, I have decided that I will not be back. This location has inconsistent selections of standard Great American Cookie selections, incompetent staff, and stale cookie cakes. I have never been more disappointed in a Great American Cookie location. Highly disappointed! read more

Best cookies in Conyers, very professional staff and a joy to go to! Got my wife's birthday cookie cake, went with the sugar cookie with icing and it was AMAZING! Thought it was going to run me upwards of $50-60, it was around $35 and worth every penny! Can't say enough good things about GAC, we go a few times a month on our diet cheat day and have never been unsatisfied! read more

I have never had a soft cookie here. I Use To Come Often as it's near my home always trying to give this location a chance even coming at different times. Cookies are never soft. This stores does not throw away and replace cookies hourly. It seems they make a batch & keep them until they are sold. Great customer service but I can't eat and enjoy that. read more

This location was supposed to have our son's birthday cake ready at 1:30. At 2:15, the cake is still not ready. We are going to be late to our own party because of their poor planning. If you are looking for a cake at a certain time, I suggest going elsewhere or putting your pickup time hours in advanced. read more

Walked in today for the first time and was greeted by Rebekah "hello, how can I help you? Explained this was my first time in the store and just wanted to see what all you have to offer. Noticed the new purple letters Marble Slab Creamery on the way to ice cream, Rebekah explained to me the marble slab, sizes of the ice creams, toppings and cones! Then we went and picked out the buy 5 get 1 free deal! Was hard to choose from the flavors since I am watching my figure! Lol The store is clean and the staff is friendly!! Looking forward to coming back for ice cream!! read more