Cancel

Open app

Search

Hershey Shake Shop

5.0 (2 reviews)

Hershey Shake Shop Photos

Business Info

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - Hershey Shake Shop

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

3 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

6 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

Ask the Community - Hershey Shake Shop

You might also consider

Verify this business for free

People searched for Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt 1,801 times last month within 10 miles of this business.

Verify this business

The Salty Scoop

The Salty Scoop

4.8(6 reviews)
1.9 mi

Came to Seaside for the day. Finished off the day with a trip to the Salty Scoop. Place is spotless…read morethe help is friendly and I got a cup of sugar free vanilla with a shot of hot fudge. it seems that every time we come to Seaside now we have to drive over to the salty scoop. Sal E New Rochelle

I am extremely happy that another ice cream shop has taken over this location. We were really…read morebummed when Charlie's closed, as we've had a summer home here since the 90s and Charlie's was always a place to go and grab a special treat. Not to mention, I love supporting a small business such as the local ice cream parlor down the shore. The new owners definitely put a fair amount of work into this place to distinguish it from the old Charlie's. The ice cream shop is completely rebranded - the decor is modernized, sleek, and clean, which leaves an upscale feel to the place. I particularly love the mermaid scale wallpaper - very cute and beachy. It's also very brave of the Salty Scoop to market both ice cream and coffee because those are two very different things that are sold at different times of the day. However, while I am glad that there is an ice cream parlor here, I can't see myself or my family regularly returning to the Salty Scoop like we did Charlie's. For one, they offer a lot less flavors then other local ice cream parlors in the area. While their flavors are eclectic and interesting, the selection seems a little sparse compared to their biggest competitors (the place has two other local shops both north and south of it). But the biggest flaw of the Salty Scoop is its lack of soft ice cream. I'm not really sure why the owners have decided against having a soft ice cream machine - perhaps its because they want to showcase their fun hard flavors? - but I think it's a huge missed opportunity, especially considering this is an ice cream establishment down the shore. Last year, the Salty Scoop opened late in the season, and it had me wondering if they would add in a soft ice cream machine this year - not so. It just leaves me scratching my head. We usually keep ice cream in our freezers so hard ice cream is not something my family seeks. And while the ice cream here tastes fine, IMO it's not out-of-this world amazing that would keep me hooked and coming back for more (like, say, a gelateria). In addition, considering the whole kitsch to this place is 'cones and coffee,' I was a little disappointed to see there are basically two separate menus for ice cream and coffee. You can do A LOT with ice cream and coffee, especially in this modern social media age where a single, cool-sounding item can go viral online. (How about offering a coffee-cream shake that combines coffee and one of the fun flavors of ice cream?) One last thing - I noticed they added a branded Playa Bowls menu to their selection, which is an interesting move to get customers in on their part. While it is nice to have more selection, it yet again leaves me scratching my head and wondering what the true identity of the Salty Scoop is. Regardless, I really hope this place does well and makes it - especially since there is steep competition in the area when it comes to ice cream! The property would truly feel empty without an ice cream parlor. Bottom line - if you're a local in the area that is craving a scoop of ice cream, this will scratch that itch, although you may need to go elsewhere if you're seeking a little more selection.

Photos
The Salty Scoop
The Salty Scoop
The Salty Scoop

See all

Kohr's Frozen Custard the Original

Kohr's Frozen Custard the Original

4.5(60 reviews)
0.1 mi
•$

Charging more, serving less…read more While staying in the area for a week each year, we used to look forward to Kohr's custard every day. (Sometimes twice a day) Sadly, halfway through our recent week, nobody wanted it anymore. Their product tastes the same, but portions have gotten small. Prices went up, and I don't mind that, but don't skimp on what you serve. It's just disappointing. There's even one server at this location that is really stingy. You barely get a swirl and a half on top of your cone. Ironically, I got a picture of him chowing down on a cone in the back! Last year, the regular size was satisfying and the large was a monster that you had fun finishing with your kids. This year, the regular cone is significantly smaller than prior years and large was similar to the regular. We switched to Summer Sweets in Lavallette for our daily fix and were much happier. Great flavors of ice cream, nice portions and it's actually cheaper than Kohr's.

Good place to get soft ice cream on the NJ shore boardwalk. They have consustently good ice cream…read more Orange/vanilla has been our favorite for years. I would definitely continue to go back when I stoped by the Seaside boardwalk. Their service is always great. And it has traditional look of ice cream place on the pier. I revommend. Right next to great candy shop, too.

Photos
Kohr's Frozen Custard the Original
Kohr's Frozen Custard the Original
Kohr's Frozen Custard the Original - Particularly stingy server - avoid. Ironically, he was feasting on a cone here.

See all

Particularly stingy server - avoid. Ironically, he was feasting on a cone here.

Hershey Shake Shop - icecream - Updated June 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...