I've known about this place for a little while now but I don't get out to Endicott too often. I…read moreoffered to take a friend of mine out for her birthday and this was the place she picked, and it was also her first time here. We both heard mixed reviews but in the end we both had a pretty good experience. We each started off with a cocktail, she got the biscotti one and I got some sort of margarita, both of which were made with house made gelato. We traded sips and both of them were great! I'm usually disappointed when I get cocktails anywhere anymore but these were very good. You're going to get a sugar rush before you get drunk off one, but they were still a great way to start off the meal. We each ordered a pizza too. I got just a plain one and overall i thought it had a very good flavor. the cheese was interesting, it was a little creamier than usual mozz but it worked out great. The sauce was also very good, it was a little sweet with enough seasoning to make it stand out. The dough had a nice neutral bread flavor, but I wish it was stretched a little different, the crust was huge but the part with the sauce and cheese on it was super thin and floppy. The pizzas are on the small side, and I don't think they use a wood fired oven, but it was still good. I would like to try a regular entree next time, but I would definitely like to have their pizza again. The restaurant itself is on the small side but it's pretty nice on the inside, not too upscale but a little nicer than casual. I've seen a lot of complaints on here about the service but I had zero issues with it, our server was nice and the busser kept a good eye on our waters and was quick with refills. the prices were about what I was expecting, $50 for 2 pizzas and 2 drinks All in all I had a very pleasant experience, if you're hesitant about going, give it a shot.

Came here for an early supper and got the Chenango with Greek pasta salad. So so good!read more

We took our family to Joey's for dinner last Sunday. They had pizzeria-style seating (which was…read moregreat) so they had us sit down anywhere. I had veal Marsala which was delicious, and husband enjoyed the red clam sauce... the service was excellent, despite having only one server for the dining room. Terrific! Thanks for the food and service.

Joey's was the only pizza place in the area with GF crust, so we ended up here by default. I'm glad…read morewe did though! Both the GF crust and the normal crust pizzas were super yummy, and the staff was all very friendly. Definitely would recommend for pizza.

This is a little gem in Endwell known by all the locals in the area. Since moving to this…read moreneighborhood, a summer night ritual is ice cream at Wolfie's. I'm a fool for ice cream sandwiches....they make their own cookie crust with Hershey's vanilla ice cream. I've never had one better. Mint chocolate chip is a killer too.

maple walnut was soft. black raspberry not much flavor. not typical for hershey brands. strange…read more to pricey for what you get

Always friendly service from all, TU,! Amazing burgers and servings of ice cream (large soft-serve…read morechocolate ) is the bom.com!

Recently moved here, definitely recommend to anyone around. Good food and good prices!read more

Cute, small. Limited outdoor seating. Lots of flavors and options. HUGE portions, reasonable…read moreprices. I got the Mint Green (mint chocolate chip) which tasted great. A better quality version of baskin Robbin's. Kids got lemon flavored soft serve. It was also good. Refreshing. Lemon flavor was very subtle. More like vanilla with a hint of lemon. Melted quick on a hot day so be careful. Would return!

Good ice cream with a ton of options. The place has a random and weird vibe that is kinda fun. Corn…read morehole and multiple benches make for a good hang out spot

This store is great! However, their employee, Alex, is an incredibly rude staff member! I will be…read moreavoiding this store in the future because this employee was horrible!

Today I was thinking about a spicy Italian hot sub yum, so I get one $10.79. I get home and take a…read morebite wait , what no pepperoni? Discusted and disappointed !!! Never again.

Always a nice experience when visiting Sweetest Thing. I've only ever had their bubble tea which…read moreis not authentic but does the trick when you're fixing for a bubble tea in this area. People I've brought here like their ice cream, and they have a whole buffet of toppings which is amazing! They lose two stars because, in the bathroom, they also have supplies stored in there, such as ice cream cups and other containers used to serve food. They are in bags/boxes, but it's still gross that they are kept in a bathroom. I understand that there isn't much room in the establishment, but this really isn't acceptable.

Good selection and fairly priced. Great local place…read more The guy behind the counter (owner?) made us feel at home and the place is kitschy in its decor. Plenty of seats.

Friendly staff, delicious treats. Several indoor tables and picnic tables outside. They also have…read morea drive through and off-street parking. They have a counter with a jigsaw puzzle going. It was a fun stop, happy we came across it in our travels. We'll definitely be back!

The ice cream prices are a little higher here but they give u a massive serving for what u order I…read moregot a small which was supposed to be 2 scoops but it was more like 5 it was so huge I couldn't finish it and had to throw some away the biggest thing that sucks here is the time they operate this place like it's summer hours and I think they should stay open later possibly until 10 or 11 pm I know a lot of ppl who have said if it was open later they would of went I've tried the Italian ice which I guess is homemade it's good and I've tried the ice cream which is just regular but it's good not bad not great I think they need maybe a bright light up sign to let ppl know it is there and open for business it needs that wow factor .good location just need more signage

The older lady that works there with dark hair is RUDE. She was judging our order with a rude,…read moresnotty tone. I'm sorry - do you not want our money lady?? Sorry if I order "a lot" of something. Those were her words. She said it 3 different times as if she couldn't fathom extra topping. It was a VERY simple order, and an easy way for her to make an extra large sale. Even if it was hard, I shouldn't feel talked down to. You're not my mom, you don't need to judge the amount I order. Regardless, It wasn't all for me - I was taking it home. I didn't tell her that because it's not her business, and I don't owe her an explanation, but good god she was rude over something so simple. I didn't say anything, I'm not going to cause a scene in front of children. She needs an attitude check. Not very professional at all.

Love this place! I used to work here and I come back for ice cream all the time!…read more Owner is a nice lady, employees are usually pretty friendly and down to earth, and the ice cream is tasty! If you're looking for a nice, friendly small business to support, with plenty of different delicious flavors - then choose here!