We stopped around seven on a Saturday night. Inside was closed but they had a drive-through open so we had to do that. We ordered on the spot and our subs were ready almost immediately when we got up to the window. Kid at the window was pleasant. We got what we ordered and everything tasted good. This is only our first time at this location and we will try it again. Thanks! read more

This place is an absolute joke. We have been there a few times, all before 8 pm, and each time they'd have the dining room closed and doors locked. But today takes the cake. It's 730 PM on a Friday, just worked 12 hours, and these idiots straight refused service saying they were closing early today. I'm done. Will find the next closest one unless it's ran or owned by the same person. Realistically everyone just find the closest Penn Station and go there. read more

I ordered my food at 11:30 am on website; for delivery at 4; did not receive until 5. Needless to say my 1/2 hour lunch passed with no food. read more

I went through the drive-through and ordered two toasted Italian subs. When I arrived home and opened the bag, one of the subs wrapped up was just a piece of bread with a piece of cheese on it. I called the store and spoke to the manager (Heather) and she was quick to tell me that my order got mixed up with the person in front of me and that she would give me a refund (she was really quick to tell me my debit info also). I will never go to that location again. read more

Jimmy John's - Supposed to be a TOASTED ULTIMATE ITALIAN...this photo is not staged! This really happened to me! - Sandwiches Near Me - New Baltimore, Michigan

This is the second consecutive time of placing an order that they got it wrong. The last time I got home and I was missing a sandwich completely. This time I specifically ordered a slim three and I repeated myself twice at the window and they gave me a regular tuna filled with lettuce and tomato (a sandwich for my child). Unacceptable service. It should not be that difficult. read more

Kaitlyn hannah and quinn gave us dirty looks and the music was absurdly loud i could barely here connor taking my order

Terrible experience. Placed a delivery order and never received it. Got a notification 15 minutes after order thst it was "out for delivery" and then at 30 minutes I called and was told that the order was still on its way despite me living 3 minutes from location. At 50 minutes I called back and they discovered the driver left the food at wrong location despite my address being correct. The worst part is they offered to either rerun the food or just void my order...no "we're sorry" or " this is unacceptable" or any offer to give me the order for discount or no charge. Terrible, terrible customer service and they've lost a longtime customer. AVOID AT ALL COSTS. read more

OMG! A modern day miracle! The Italian sub looked and tasted just like the other 1,000 locations, and they made it in 30 seconds. And those kettle chips? Delicious. Completely predictable and average. WARNING: One huge flaw at this location. It's one of those drive-thru's that traps you in one lane. Once in, you cannot get out. Unless you drive up the curb onto the grass like one of those crazy Dukes of Hazzard guys. read more

Wow! This location was FREAKY FAST TODAY!! I accidentally ordered from the wrong location today. Totally thought I messed up my schedule. These people saved the day. 6 sandwiches is about 4.2 minutes. All made correctly. Really nice staff. Thanks guys!! read more

Jimmy John's - a bag of salt and vinegar chips - Sandwiches Near Me - New Baltimore, Michigan

Poor service and food since ownership change.. use to be good store Do not take care when making sandwiches have gotten wrong orders and very skimpy sandwiches read more

This location used to be pretty good and the service was GREAT! Today we got the wrong sandwiches, when we called we got SUPPOSEDLY a Mgr who sounded like she could care less. After matching wits with me she asked, "well what would you like me to do?" I just informed her that maybe she should make sure her employees just give the product that they ordered. After a few more minutes of the Manager having an attitude with me... I expl'd I am not having an attitude with you, and I wasn't asking for money back but She just hung up on me. Yes Hung Up on me. I WILL NEVER BE BACK and maybe to none of them based on this experience. I hope corporate reads this because you better start watching who you are putting in charge! TERRIBLE SERVICE. I will take my business elsewhere... . read more

The best sub. sandwich we have had recently, my wife had a Beach Club unwich, she said it was the best sandwich she's had from Jimmy John, l ordered a Country Club, it was very good, l would have liked a free pickle which turned out to be in my E-Mail, there were no rewards on our cell phones. will go to Subway next time in Algonac. read more

I'm leaning towards three stars but pff. I gave them four instead. I like Jimmy John's because they are simple. They never change their menu. They have the same menu throughout the States and I don't have to be asked 'what toppings do you want?' as your mouth stares at the topping station already either 1) drooling 2) thinking nothing looks good. Nope. At Jimmy John's do you do a wide range of toppings and thats why I like it. My boyfriend and I got take out yesterday afternoon for lunch. Walked in and got greeted but when it came to taking our order everyone was too busy chatting and when we said we were ready the lady closest to the register just stared at us so we repeated ourselves and she said 'you by the phone get these people' She couldn't have been any more rude. Our food came out perfect but they skim out on the mayo so next time i'll just order extra. Wasn't freaky fast but I would rather my food be made properly than someone forget to put something on my food and be in a hurry. Very clean. Bread was soft and fresh. read more

Jimmy John's - So clean and lots of space. - Sandwiches Near Me - New Baltimore, Michigan

See all

It could of and should have been better!! I get the whole understaffed thing going on now -- but come on... I was in that drive up line for almost 20 minutes - just waiting for 2 subs THEN the girl in the window called me KAREN and rolled her eyes because I mentioned that I was waiting for a while in line - oh yes, she did (I refused to ask for the manager because of the whole Karen name calling thing) anyway, That's not freaky fast!!! I gave 1 star because of that girl - the food was good, but I can do without the rude behavior! and by the way girl - MY NAME IS NOT KAREN. read more

AGAIN.....Just wrote a nasty review last Thursday, every time I order something from location JJ1974 in New Baltimore MI there is something wrong. They sent an email for a free regular size sandwich with an expiration date. So I decided to try again today. So at 12:30 in the afternoon I ordered for a later delivery time of 6:00-6:15. Here it is 6:36 NO FOOD. I called the store and they said they are really busy. HA HA, I gave them a 6 hour notice. They suck!!! And I'm pissed. If there was a zero star that's what ide give them!! read more

Quick, simple, fresh. Never been dissatisfied with the service here, and it always tastes good.

Eh, whatever. As I've eaten Jimmy John's over the past year or so I've really discovered that Jimmy John's only cares about being fast. Six dollars gives you basically a loaf of bread and a bag of chips. The meat is sliced as thin as possible, and only a little bit is put on the sandwich. It's really sad when the tomato to meat ratio is 2:1 on what is supposedly a meaty sandwich. I thought Subway skimped with their subs, but Jimmy John's may be worse, and maybe a poorer value as well. Thankfully, Jimmy John's will put hot peppers on whatever sandwich you want for free, which is nice -- I could eat a jar of them. Jimmy John's gets you a sandwich in just about sixty seconds, but it's because it doesn't take long to put single slices of paper thin meat and cheese on a piece of bread. I really wish a Tubby's was just a little closer to my house. read more

Jimmy John's - Vitos at this location may as well be vegan. Pathetic amounts of meat and cheese. - Sandwiches Near Me - New Baltimore, Michigan

Through online ordering and perhaps lack of attention on my end, my sandwich was delivered with the wrong customizations. I called and spoke with the general manager, and he had the correct order sent right to me. I appreciate your kind, understanding, and prompt customer service! read more

Had lunch today the food was great. The atmosphere was good my hat is off to the owner of this place for doing what was needed to show the staff that they are there to work and not tell the owner how to run his store. I think that this place has the Best sandwiches in town I recommend everybody eat here read more

The General Manager Chris is amazing! There was an issue with my order, and he went above & beyond to fix it. The food is always great, but bc of how he handled the situation, that's what kept us as customers read more

Owners and Franchise, Hire a new manager. I imagine this is your main source of low reviews We were just standing in line waiting and manager told employee don't wait on them they can wait. He stated we should have been more prepared and ordered our food the night before. So does that mean Jimmy Johns is preorder only now. Such horrible customer service I am completely in shock a manager behaves that way. Just sharing from one business owner to the next. You deserve to know the service your employee is providing read more

Understand businesses are doing what they can during COVID but I expect to be given the same decency. 1 star not because of the food, but because this is another place you feel guilty visiting, because the employees seem unhappy and rude. read more

It's usually good however they advertise freaky fast delivery and it's not so freaky fast. Some days it could take up to 40 minutes

The older gentleman who was managing was on point! He worked with the staff well and was vey motivated making sure things run smoothly. Very clean and tidy inside! Will return again read more

This is my go to Jimmy John's!! Always so delicious and fresh. I order the Italian Nightclub and am always pleased thanks guys!

Such a friendly atmosphere! The staff is so kind and are great kids! Awesome service, keep it up!

Very adaptive to COVID! Love the smiles here and will continue to go back, had a shortage of salami but a young girl helped me order the number 7, with less meat, and I liked that sub more ! read more

I haven't had Jimmy John's in a long while and wanted it today. Ordered up a #9, chips, and a pickle. Got home and pulled it all out and found a Band Aid wrapper in my bag. I know stuff happens but.... yuck read more

ordered a delivery at 7pm, only to be called back at 8pm when they closed to be told im to far out of range and they will not deliver nor can i pick up because they are now closed when i was quoted a 30min delivery time on the original call. read more

Once again a screwed up order through the Drive Thru.. I counted 6 employees in the building, and I was the only customer (didn't see any at the counter and I was the only car in the drive thru...and I only ordered one sub...and it was still screwed up....The first time I ate there was right after they opened, and my order got mixed up,and I can totally understand that happening (it was their 4th day open) but if they don't have their ducks in a row by now, they never will. I don't know how they make any money, with that many staff on the clock and no business...makes you kinda wonder doesn't it? read more

Wow what is the hype about Jimmy John's? It is the biggest Freaky Fast rip off. When I got my sandwiches home I was surprised at the empty bun (well almost empty). I was treating my painter to lunch, the amount of turkey on that sandwich was ridiculous. I thought I got my beach club unwich without guacamole. I called to complain and I was assured everything was weighed out and the portion of guacamole is between the cheese. When I looked hard, I did find the green coloring. Jimmy John's is the biggest rip off, I'm not sure how they stay in business. read more

Always great food and great service. Fresh ingredients. The hot cherry peppers are awesome and very hot. They are the best on any sandwhich. Best and fastest delivery and very polite drivers. A little pricy but worth the cost for fresh food. Pickles are great too. read more

Sandwich's great. Enjoy eating them at home though. Music way too loud. No, I'm not that old. Quick service.

I work at a doctors office right down the street from here and we order from here all the time because it's so convenient and fast! I had a very bad experience yesterday due to the very rude manager so I had to write this! I called and placed my Oder with a very nice kid and he repeated it back to me and all was good until the food arrived and the 3 tuna unwiches were not unwiches and some of us are doing the Keto diet and if any of you know this diet...:NO BREAD....No big deal mistakes happen so when I called I spoke to the girl that stated she was the manager and I explained and she was very nice and apologetic and said we will send the right sandwiches right over! We are very busy and before I knew it an hour had passed and I went to our front desk to see if they had come and they hadn't. I called and the same nice boy that took my order answered the phone and I knew immediately that his tone had changed! I told him who I was and I wondered the status of our delivery and he very rudely said "hold on the manager needs to speak to you". The same manager got on the phone and it was down hill from there! She stated that if we wanted new sandwiches we would have to pay for them because the receipt did not say they were unwiches! She was not the same nice manager from before! She was down right rude and very disrespectful to me! I asked to speak to her manager and she stated there was no one above her that she was the only one! I knew this was not true so after almost begging her and trying to plead with her that she was making a mistake by making this decision she stated that there was another manager named Chris but that he just left for the day. I asked for Chris's phone number and she refused and said policy would not allow her to give this to me! She then said to me I am very busy have a nice day then hung the phone up on me! I wanted to drive right over but knew that was not the right decision to make I was shooken!!!! The fact that I don't care what her receipt said the order was wrong and the fact that we got no phone call to tell us this! She treated us like we did not matter nor our business we give them everyday did not matter! I'm going to be stopping in soon as I'm able and I will speak to Chris about this! It was unprofessional and upsetting! If this young manager who by the way refused to tell me her name came across the street because she was sick we would never ever treat her the way she treated us! During the time we are so busy we cannot even leave to get lunch and most of us will not be ordering from jimmy johns for awhile! read more

Always quick service & fine sandwiches. Haven't had a bad experience to give anything less than a 4 star rating. My go to is the Italian with hot peppers, super yummy. read more

I went through the drive thru and received horrible service. It took forever to get my sandwich and the young woman working the window almost forgot my drink. The people inside were completely distracted and joking around with their coworkers. I asked for no mayo and not only did they put it on my sandwich, they also forgot to put on the vinegrette. read more

Jimmy John's - Clearly says no mayo on the receipt yet there's mayo on the sandwich, plus there's not even vinegrette. - Sandwiches Near Me - New Baltimore, Michigan

The only reason that I picked 1 star is because "0" was not an option. I parked in parking lot because we were taking the kids to ortho next door then coming back to eat. the manager (owner) comes out yelling at me in front of my kids (there was literally not 1 other car in their parking lot). My kids got regular sandwiches while I got a "slim". It tasted terrible like 2 day old bread, and was incredibly hard to chew. I figured that adding vinegar/oil would make it at least edible. I asked for a side and when they did not have any, the young employee volunteered to put it right on the sandwich. The kid took my sandwich, but then the owner told him "we don't put vinegar and oil on slims". I asked to speak to the "manager" and he came out from his hiding place in the back. He treated me like complete garbage, was condescending and just RUDE. The sandwich was inedible, so I just threw it away rather than argue. He thought this was very funny. As a teacher, I have met many bullies in my career. He has all the characteristics of a bully to both his customers and his employees. Terrible experience! Terrible customer service! Terrible food. read more

Jimmy John's in New Baltimore, MI is the biggest RIP OFF with the WORST customer service. When I got my #16 LULU sandwich home, I was surprised with all the mayo on it. I ordered without mayo , also indicated on the receipt. They were closed when I went to eat and discovered all the mayo. I drove 20 minutes back to the store the next day after they just opened up and told the manager of my order being wrong. He blew me off and said he was not going to replace or remake my sandwich the correct way as indicated on my receipt, stating no mayo. Manager was extremely RUDE and disrespectful. Jimmy John's is the biggest rip off, I'm not sure how they stay in business. The manager needs to learn Basic customer service skills. I will never be back and have told everyone I work with and know about my horrible experience. So I basically lost $8 on a useless sub and a lot of travel time and gas on the original purchase and the return trip the next day. Also, I am not supposed to eat mayo for medical reasons, besides the fact I don't Like it either. I recommend not patronizing this business, they do not stand behind their product and treat customers very poorly and don't deserve your business. read more

Ordered a delivery from the New Baltimore location one night and it took over an hour for the sandwich to get to my house. The store manager said there was only one driver and they would try to get to as soon as he can.... Once my sandwich arrived over an hour later more than half the items on the sandwich were missing. It was a Veggie sandwich so not much comes on it to begin with. When I called the Store the manager, she said I can wait for another sandwich to be delivered or accept a store credit for the same sandwich. I was not waiting anther hour for a sandwich so I accepted the credit. I called today (12/30/2016) to order the same sandwich and the 2 managers is spoke with claimed nothing was written on a "sheet of paper" and so there is no proof of my store credit... One manager said they only keep the store credit (sheet of paper) for 3 days the other manager said they keep it for a week...doesn't seem like they know what they are saying and making things up as they go along. Asked for the owners name and she provided the names of Jared and Chris. She told me I would have better luck talking to Chris since I won't get anywhere with Jared..... WOW they must think really highly of their store owners. I am soo beyond disgusted that someone thinks its okay to speak to people in the manner those 2 managers spoke to me in. They must of forgot they are in customer service, or might just hate their jobs and don't care to provide any sort of decent service. I did not yell nor did I get cruse...they hung up in my face twice and told me to call on Monday and speak to Chris about my "store credit" I was a bother to them and all I was trying to do is get a sandwich they promised. Anyone looking for a good sandwich SHOULD NOT EVERRRRR go to this Jimmy Johns. This is not the first time they have messed up my order, but this is the first time I was treated so horribly about a mistake THEY made and a mistake they PROMISED to correct that I had to voice an opinion. read more

We were frequent visitors of this restaurant and always enjoyed the food. Recently my fiancé ordered her usual Club Lulu turkey sandwich and soon after became violently ill. She went in the next morning to inform Rachel the manager of her experience. She took Rachel aside and told her she believed she had gotten food poisoning from their turkey sandwich. Rachel told her she would have Chris the General Manager call her back that night, he never called. She called again the next day and once again spoke to Rachel, who apologized and claimed Chris wasn't feeling well (he may have had the turkey) and did not come in. She promised again that he would call her. He still has not made any attempt to contact her. My fiancé only was asking for her money back, and brought back 1/2 of the sandwich that made her so sick. Way to take care of your customers! We now have returned to subway. read more