We had: Tony Soprano - delish. We all loved this one even our toddler. Hard to go wrong w food w fat, protein, sugar, salt lol. I do love hot honey on pizza Pesto cheesy bread- pretty good. Ate w the sauce. A bit bland without the sauce Margherita: not bad. Cannolis: i don't always like cannolis but these were good. Overall all 3 of us liked the food here and will prob buy again read more

Johnny started out of his garage and built a large Facebook following.....that's actually how I first heard about him. My wife loves his pizza. He's got a good system: you schedule when you want your pizza and pick it up. Honestly, I think the pizza itself is just so-so, and that's okay. The price feels fair, the overall experience works, and there's a cool culture around what he's built. We'll definitely be back and I'll make the drive again. Service is simple.....order, pick up, and head home. Everyone was nice, but don't expect a lot of interaction. read more

Johnny's NY Pizzeria is an American dream come true. From operating out of his garage, Johnny received so much love, support, and hype from our local Foodies of Rocklin/Roseville Facebook group that he was able to open his own storefront. When I finally got my first pizza after being on a waitlist for months, he had only 4 ovens. He was so diligent and fair, keeping track of a list of potential customers. We were only allowed to order a max of 2 pizzas back then. Folks got sad after having a taste of pizza heaven and then never knowing when they could order the pizza again. The crust is special with a nice chew. Not so thin a crust that it flops. Not as thick a crust as a pan pizza. Pizza is not greasy. Slices are large. I believe the large pizzas are cut into 8 slices. I just wish the pizza had more toppings. I feel like the toppings are evenly spaced out with intention, almost to decorate the pizza. $3 to add an extra topping. However, other customers seem content with amount of toppings. I recommend eating the pizza in your car as soon as you get it or taking it home to reheat. I can't get to my final destination fast enough to eat it while it's hot. Not an inexpensive pizza: $22.99 for a plain cheese pizza $24.99 for a pepperoni pizza $32.99 for a combo pizza Here's the online ordering website: https://johnnysnypizzeria.net/ Business Hours: 2:30 PM to 7:30 PM Tue to Thu 12 PM to 7:30 PM Fri 12 PM to 6:00 PM Sat Closed Sun and Mon On Fridays and Saturdays 12 PM to 3 PM, you can buy a slice of cheese or pepperoni pizza for $5. There's a 2 slice with can of soda special for $12. Once in awhile, there may be a 3rd pizza option. $5 per cannoli. The cannoli shells are from Italy! Store is located on the corner of Sunset Blvd and S Whitney Blvd where Quik Stop gas station is. He can now bake 10 pizzas at a time. No seating at Johnny's NY Pizzeria. Pickup only. Johnny has Italian-American roots. His family helps him run the pizza business. I believe his family is from Buffalo, NY or Upstate NY. They are big Buffalo Bills fans! If you're looking for authentic NY Style Pizza, give Johnny's a try. He is always working on perfecting his pizza. read more

See all

VERY LONG OVERDUE post of appreciation to Johnny's for catering our rehearsal dinner back in November for 50+ people. Got a variety of pizzas and they were all a HUGE HIT especially with our east coast family. Everything was delivered hot and fresh. So much flavor! I think we got a total of about 15 pizzas and a bunch of cheesy pesto bread. Johnny and his team had amazing communication with us throughout, very responsive, and everything delivered as promised. Highly recommend! read more

See all

Decided to finally check out Johnny's NY Pizzeria as I've heard great things about it, and my goodness do they make a good pizza! It tasted just like the pizza I got on my last trip to NY and had the perfect combination of dough to sauce to cheese and toppings ratio. Will most certainly be back in the future. I also recommend ordering ahead of time online. The only downside I would note is picking up the pizza wasn't a great experience because the person behind the register wasn't very friendly and seemed irritated when I came up to pick up my order. read more

Johnny’s NY Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Rocklin, California

One of the best pizza crusts I've ever had. Reminded me of the pizza I had in Napoli Italy. It's all to go so call ahead and bring home to enjoy. Only one size of pizza which will feed two hungry people or three not so hungry. read more

I give 5 star cz I know it will improve , some how taste. Has change not as good as used to be at first. It feels too salty and dry fast this past few times something isn't there , Johny needs to go true everything to make sure it's that same good taste read more

Johnny’s NY Pizzeria - Best pizza in California - Pizza Near Me - Rocklin, California

Attention pizza lovers, you should make an immediate point of going to Johnny's NY pizzeria. I discovered Johnny's by accident. This pizza place is located in a gas station in Rocklin, CA. Yes, they have their own store front. This is a takeaway location. Johnny's opens at noon. You can call in your order, or if you walk in, you can order in store. They also sell slices in the store. I lucked out, and ordered the lunch special. It's a great deal! Two slices and a drink for about $11.00 OMG! This pizza deserves a billion stars. It's perfect NY pizza. The slice that you fold, bite, enjoy, and eagerly ready for the next tasty bite. I ordered the Tony Soprano. It's cheesy goodness, with THE perfect pepperoni, dollops of amazing ricotta, and hot honey drizzled over the slices. It's damn delicious. My only regret was not ordering a whole pizza. I will be back, soon!! Johnny, thank you so much for creating perfect pizza, and kindly letting us in a few minutes early when we didn't know that you opened at noon. You are the pizza king! read more

See all

Saw Johnny's being recommended deep within a Reddit post for the best NY style pizza and I'm glad we listened! The $10 for two slices + a drink is such a good deal and I love that it applies to the weekends too. We took our first bites and immediately said, "oh yeah, this is New York." The crust has a good slight char on the bottom, has a good bite, and is thin crust without being too floppy. Something about the way the cheese sits on the dough and their cheese:sauce ratio is also perfect bc it's slightly fluffy and gives that cheese pull! Literally looks like we're eating pizza out of the Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles. Takeout-only but service was still super nice and friendly! You can add hot honey or ricotta (we weren't charged for the hot honey, I think!), and they supply plates, napkins, grated cheese, and chili flakes. The hot honey on their pep pizza was amazing. Such a hidden gem!! read more

Johnny’s NY Pizzeria - Applies to weekends too! - Pizza Near Me - Rocklin, California

See all

Desserts are incredible! Don't miss out! They're around until they sell out. Yummmm Add them to any order or order separately. read more

See all

The pizza is genuinely so yummy! The folks at the counter are quick to take your order and communicate well about how long the pizza will take. The only downside is that the times it's open can be a little wonky (they sometimes open a little late) but I never regret a slice I get. Also included an updated menu. read more

Johnny’s NY Pizzeria - Updated menu 6/4/26 - Pizza Near Me - Rocklin, California

This is the real deal nyc pizza. The pizza was fresh and the sauce was perfect, home made (not made of only tomato paste) cheese was typical nyc taste. Dough had the right amount of chew. read more

I've always noticed this little hole-in-the-wall spot on my way home from work, and finally decided to give it a try after work on a Friday. I called ahead to ask if they offered slices, the friendly woman who answered said they might start doing slices soon. I asked for a recommendation, and she suggested the Porky Pie if I'm a meat lover. That was all I needed to hear. The wait was about 35 minutes, which was totally fine. We picked it up and brought it home to enjoy. If you're a fan of crispy, thin-crust pizza, this is definitely a must-try in the area. The toppings were perfectly balanced and the sauce had a deep, rich flavor. I'm usually the kind of person who leaves the crust behind, mostly because it's often dry or bland -- but this crust was so good I found myself eating every bite. I'll admit, I didn't believe the other reviews that said people could finish a whole pie on their own. But after just one slice, I completely understood. You really could eat an entire pie in one sitting. read more

Johnny’s NY Pizzeria - Porky Pie - Pizza Near Me - Rocklin, California

Best pizza locally. Thin, crispy, tastes great. Highly recommend the pesto pie. Best of all affordable and fair. I just wish they had wings or something as a protien side. ** Thanks for the reply John! You should, I bet you'd do them great! Look forward to it. read more

Johnny’s NY Pizzeria - Pesto pie - Pizza Near Me - Rocklin, California

I hate being negative but it was Not my favorite pizza. The pizzas looked good but The red sauce was bland. Price was high for bland. The cheese pizza had no sauce as I preferred, and the crust was not cooked enough for me. Soft and not flavorful. read more

Johnny’s NY Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Rocklin, California

See all

Literally hole in the wall pizza joint down the street from us. Wanted to give it a shot and we are so happy we did. Johnny started this venture from his garage and now he has his own place. The location is tiny next to a gas station. This is a ghost kitchen so no seating or waiting area. The people are incredibly nice and humble with their small operation. The wait time was way longer than advertised on the app so be aware. As they told me - it is a good problem to have. Finally to the pies. They're good. Really good. Reminded me of eating pizza in NY. Definitely coming back for more. Highly recommend. read more

See all

I've been following Johnnys pizza since he's been making them from his garage. He's finally got a dedicated spot and I'm happy to support this local guy. His pizza is really good, light sauce, cheese and thin crust. Definitely reminds me of New York slice pizza and he is continuing to expand his menu. He is family owned and pretty a one man cook who makes his own dough and sauce. Try his pizza out! They also have limited hours so it is best to call in earlier in the day to get a pizza order in. He also does presales of his pizza the day before on his Facebook page and sells out of his pizza daily. Glad we can get some ny pizza on the west coast now read more

See all

Grab a slice now @ Johnny's NY Pizzeria I had the two slice lunch special and these are the best New York Slices I've had in a very long time. I'll take this place over any pizzeria in the greater Sac area. And I have tried a lot of them. read more

Johnny’s NY Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Rocklin, California

See all

The pizza is amazing especially if you appreciate NY style. The flavors burst in your mouth and the quality is excellent. The service was great and the prices are good. Run to this place read more

This was the only pizza I'd finish the whole slice of. I ate the crust, and then went back for more. The perfect amount of cheese, the crust was made so well. The seasoning was just phenomenal. The service was awesome. I had no idea what their hours were, but I called during none pizza making hours, but they made a pizza for me. I was so thankful. The ambience was just like a truly tiny pizzeria. They'll take care of you, and make the pizza nice, and super tasty! The price was amazing for the ingredients and size. Round Table should be ashamed!!! $60 for what they call pizza. We got a REAL pepperoni large (with extra pepperoni) for under $30. I will definitely be back, probably this weekend. Yum! The workers were the true perks though. Very funny and incredibly kind. read more

Went again today just to make sure it wasn't a fluke.... Even better this time. We finally have good pizza in the area! read more

Johnny’s NY Pizzeria - Pepperoni pie... a few slices didn't make it home. - Pizza Near Me - Rocklin, California

Listen, when it comes to pizza I am a snob. There. I said it. I like a creamy red sauce. I like a cheese with bite, like Wisconsin cheese, I like my pepperonis a little bit spicy and the sausage should absolutely steal the show. Now when you pair that with a thin crust it is perfection . Based on a review I read over the weekend I placed my first order today. 10/10! If I could change anything it would be to ask for a lite bake on the crust but otherwise I m a repeat customer. Again I say: the sauce and the cheese are a delightful marriage. Next time I'll go pick my pizza up vs DoorDash so I can see the place in person but wow. They really know how to do pizza . See you guys again soon. read more

Johnny’s NY Pizzeria - Pepperoni with sausage & extra cheese - Pizza Near Me - Rocklin, California

See all

Came here on 04/22/2025 after looking at things to eat in the area. Ordered my pie and ate it in the parking lot. Hello to Johnny's if you guys remember me. Best NY slice I had in Northern California. Light, crispy and full of flavors. Johnny and his mom definitely got a gem here. Keep up the good work and thank you for sharing your craft. I will sign over my 401k, 529 or whatever. Just, please, please keep taking my money and feeding me this phenomenal pizza. read more

Johnny’s NY Pizzeria - Menu as of 04/22/2025. - Pizza Near Me - Rocklin, California

See all

Small little place nothing but take out, they have a small stone oven which is a plus. The pizza was super thin which is true New Yorker. I asked for extra cheese but not as much as I'm use too. I know it New York pizza so they're not known for pineapple on there pizza but my wife and mother like pineapple, which the pineapple was not very sweet. I got on my side pepperoni, Italian sausage, onions and bell peppers it was good but still expected better. The guys there were nice and friendly, I will go again but for almost $40 for a pie that a bit steep so it will be a while. read more

I've been there twice now, and each time I got a different pizza. Each time I was delighted! Definitely coming back recommend 100%.

Good pizza by Rocklin standards, but the hoops Johnny makes you jump through to get his pizza is annoying. Hours keep changing. Tried to call a couple of Sundays ago to put in our first pickup order as we were close by, but no one picked up. Google said they were open, yelp said they were not. A simple voice mail could have cleared that up. Got it last week via door dash and enjoyed it. Today I tried to order again via door dash, but I guess Johnny has enough business today so he turned off door dash ordering at 5PM. Like I said, good pizza, but not good enough for me to plan to get a pizza, having to make an effort to get one like today only to fail read more

We really enjoyed this NY style pizza. The crust is killer. It was the best day after reheated pizza. The crust was nice and crispy. The pizza is $28 and only one size. The people working were super nice. I ordered the veggie(no onion) with a little sausage and pepperoni. I know NY style pizza is about the crust. They killed it there, but I like more toppings. That's on me, nothing against them. Next time(and there will be a next time) I will ask for double or even triple toppings. My thing. Very good and different pizza we really enjoyed. read more

Johnny’s NY Pizzeria - Veggie with Italian sausage and pepperoni. - Pizza Near Me - Rocklin, California

Great pizza! Friendly service!! Hour + wait on a Friday so you know it's good. No place to A hole in the wall next to a gas station. All about the Pizza!!! read more

Really good New York style pizza! We also tired the loaded breakfast burrito and it was delicious !! Clean, fast and friendly service! read more

Johnny’s NY Pizzeria - Breakfast Burrito - Pizza Near Me - Rocklin, California

See all

The pizza here is so good! My husband and I love a solid New York slice pizza and this place hit the spot. The slices are thin, the crust is crispy & airy, and the toppings are just the perfect amount. It's not too thick or heavy. The toppings sits perfectly on each slice without the slice falling over or apart because there's too much grease or topping. Definitely our go to spot for pizza in the future. I would also like to mention the owners of the shop are super friendly and cool. read more

Johnny’s NY Pizzeria - Porky pie & margarita - Pizza Near Me - Rocklin, California

See all

I wasn't very impressed considering the reviews this place has gotten. It is nice that he bakes your slices as you order them, but I can't justify spending roughly 5 bucks (including tax) per slice of pizza, especially when they are thin NY style pies that aren't exactly filling. Also, the selection for the slices you can order is what he's prepared beforehand. I wanted to get a combo slice when he opened but he only had cheese and pepperoni available to choose from. read more

The food was pretty tasteless and the service was very slow ... it almost tastes like when I go to little Caesar pizza. And the Ambiance is a bit dirty and you can only eat out. They don't support indoors dining. read more

Went by for lunch today and they have a special Fridays and Saturdays. 2 slices and a can of soda was $ 11.75. You have to take whatever they have ready, but you can mix and match. Service was quick. It takes just a minute to heat up your slices. I know I'll be back soon. read more

Johnny’s NY Pizzeria - 1 slice pepperoni 1 slice pesto pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Rocklin, California

See all

I've been wanting to try Johnny's for a while and tonight I finally had the opportunity to put in an order. Let me tell you it was absolutely worth the wait. When I arrived the lovely staff greeted me and asked for my name. I was a few minutes early so I got a chance to hang out and watch them flying to get pizzas made. Mine came straight out of the oven and into my happy hands. We had the Marion Cobretti and the Gaaaahlic Cheese Bread. Both were phenomenal. The crust is the perfect NY style. Crisp on the bottom with just the right amount of chew. Toppings were all definitely high quality. No sea of grease sitting on top from low quality pepperoni or sausage. We have been looking for a regular pizza place as our old standard's quality really went downhill recently. We have definitely found our new go to for our Friday night pizza. read more

Great tasting pizza, friendly staff. We got a half margarita, half combo, and an order of the pesto cheese bread sticks. Pizza was great NY style, dough was crisp on the bottom, with a good chew. Topping tasted fresh. It stands the 'fold' test. The pesto breadsticks were great too. Pesto doesn't overpower the cheese bread experience. Will be back soon read more

It's been hard to find good pizza since we moved from the East Coast. So when I heard so much praise about this place, I was excited! The people are nice. It was good to meet the owner. But, sadly, the pizza was disappointing. Toppings were average, sauce was just ok, and crust was very soggy (we picked it up at the given time and ate it within 10-12 minutes). However, this was way in the beginning when one had to grab a time slot as soon as it was released. So, we waited a few months and then tried it again. Just a cheese pizza. Sad to say, it was even more disappointing! The crust was so burnt that I had to peel it off to avoid the burnt taste. Cheese was good but sauce was bland and rather meh. Certainly not worth $20 sthg when all you get is a burnt taste. This is nothing like what we would eat in NYC or around. I'm not sure what people are raving about, but then there is a serious dearth of good pizza in the Rocklin area. Slice House in Folsom is the closest I've found to NY style pizza. read more

Johnny’s NY Pizzeria - Burnt all around and under. - Pizza Near Me - Rocklin, California

See all

Reminds me of Hard Rock Pizza Cafe. Chewy, tangy, sweet & salty: a little floppy, but amazing. The spot was ran by a man and woman who seemed very down to earth & honestly enjoyed what they were doing with their time on this earth. Great service & cozy ambiance. You can't dine in, but honestly, you could eat this pie anytime anywhere. Quality pizza.. very much worth the hype & worth a shot to have a least once in your life. read more

I was excited to try this place out after seeing it on facebook. Im always looking for New York style pizza places, as it's my favorite style. Since it's to go only, I had to drive all the way home (almost a half hour) before eating it, so I wasn't able to tell if the under carriage was crispy how I like it. Overall the pizza was good. They do have homemade ranch. It wasn't my favorite ranch, I prefer more of a buttermilk ranch, and this was a dill ranch, but at least it was homemade. I would come back again if in the area. read more

Johnny’s NY Pizzeria - Pepperoni and Canadian bacon - Pizza Near Me - Rocklin, California

Went twice during supposedly open hours...2nd time it was well lite up door wide open & 3-4 ppl inside. They let us walk in look around & just stood & stared until I started asking about a menu. THEN a guy says they are closed for the week. I even told him I came all the way there from Sacramento twice. It was also raining. You would think they would have been a bit friendlier first of all & not stand & stare like we were unwelcome & stupid for being there. But then hearing how we drove so far TWICE & it's biz hours they have posted you would think I'd be offered a coupon or something...not nice people. I owned a business for years, I always appreciated all my customers!!! read more

I felt like Dave Porntnoy trying this pizza ! Firm slice , great under carriage, great crust no flop . The cheese and the Italian sausage very good ! Would recommend if you like thin crust pizza ! read more

Johnny’s NY Pizzeria - Porkie pie ! So good ! - Pizza Near Me - Rocklin, California