Joe is always straight forward and honest. We trust him and enjoy going there. Always, will try to repair any "crazy" thing I bring in. Brother and sister are both good people...... read more

I reached out looking to to buy a luxury watch. The response I received was "None". That's it!!! Great customer service LOL. Others I had reached out to, thanked me for my interest and provided some insight as to options I may have. I can tell just from their response that their customer service is terrible. I'll be happy to bring my business elsewhere and I'd suggest you do the same. read more

Quality and Honesty are the trademarks of Joseph Anthony jewelers. Custom pieces are gorgeous

Joe is a nice & interesting guy. I'd rather go to a local "Mom & Pop" small business that's family owned as opposed to all these huge faceless monolithic corporations that are destroying small businesses, buying them up, putting them out of business by pricing them out or using other hostile business tactics to dominate the "little guys." Too often we shop or order from the Amazon's, Costco's or Walmarts & even corporate franchise food companies are starting to pop up around NY. Anyway, there is something to be said about having a relationship with the store's owners & knowing them rather than dealing with an impersonal mega company. Been to the store several times over the years for watch adjustments, repairs, etc He gave me a very fair price on some jewelry & watches I sold which I was very happy about. He'll work with you. I don't know why he has some bad reviews. If you deal with Joe or one of his family, you should get great customer service & no issues. So try to support local small business even if you have to pay more. Jeff Bezos doesn't need to buy another space ship. He has plenty of money. Put it back in to the community. Hope this is informative or helpful. read more

I have been going to Joe for so many years - this review is long overdue! I just went again the other day to buy a special gift, and also get my bracelet fixed - this lovely man takes care of me every time. Been going for years, and more than anything, I really appreciate his honesty. When dealing with expensive items like these, it's nice to know there are still some people who you can trust. (lord knows, I've also seen to many you cannot trust). Highly recommend - and for me, definitely going back next week to buy myself a well deserved early bday gift! Thanks Joe - keep up the great service! 5 stars for sure!! read more

Just went to Joseph's with my daughter - all I can say is WOW - I am so impressed. Love his selection, and his prices are really fair. For years, I always went to Fortunoff when I needed a gift, but since they closed, I've never really found a Jeweler that I liked - until now. Josephs is my new go to place when I need to buy a nice gift. Bonus - turns out that he can also fix my watch, and apparently anything else that need a bit of tlc. Wonderful place. read more

They did great work I had them make a thumb print solid gold 14k with a 14k Cuban link chain and it was some of the best work I have ever seen and when you go there it's a family there they are there to work with you and make your idea a piece that you can wear and be proud of the craft read more

I have some knowledge of precious metals and current values, so I would not consider myself an uninformed seller. I sold a variety of small items to Joseph Anthony and he offered a fair price. He evaluated each item carefully and was both friendly and polite in responding to questions. There were no pressure tactics. I would highly recommend him to a friend seeking to liquidate jewelry or items containing gold or silver. It was not only a welcome surprise dealing with him, but also a pleasure. read more

This is my go-to place for beautiful pieces that Joe designs himself, unique estate finds, appraisals, as well as to fix my jewelry. Joe is always fair and consistently does excellent high quality work. Highly recommend. read more

Best jeweler on Long Island. Good prices buying or selling. Great quality work and great selection of items to purchase. Awesome. read more

Condescending attitude about watch repair. Said we 'should a more expensive watch.' Seriously?

Great place, very honest and family oriented. Would highly reccomend to anyone looking to buy or sell jewerlry, coins and/or buy precious metals. read more

My fiancé purchased my engagement ring from a jeweler in Jericho. Due to an issue with price and an uncomfortable situation that the jeweler put us in, we decided to take our friends advice and visit Joseph Anthony to purchase our wedding bands. From the moment we walked in the first time, Joseph made us feel extremely comfortable and took the time with us to make sure we were confident in our choice of bands. Since the time we purchased the engagement ring from the other jeweler, we have had a few of the stones fall out which unfortunately the jeweler would not stand behind and told us to go find a specialist who deals with my type of ring. It's a good thing we had Joseph Anthony in our corner... not only does he stand behind his own designs, but also the designs of the jeweler who sold my fiancé my engagement ring. If anyone is looking to make a special purchase please, please, please visit Jospeh Anthony. He is kind, trustworthy and sincere. He will won't steer you in the wrong direction. He is the only jeweler my fiancé and I will be using from here on out. read more

About a month ago i went to Joseph Anthony's to have my engagement ring setting fixed because i lost one of the smaller stones on the side of the ring. The jeweler told me he could fix the prong that broke and replace the stone for $200 so I left it to be fixed. I have used this jeweler before and liked him until now. After paying him the $200 the stone fell out about a month later and the prong broke again, I'm in my late 50s and careful with my jewelry. When I went back to see him today, I was very disappointed by the response I got. The jeweler, Joe, never came out from the back of the store and, instead, told his worker out loud that I broke the prong again and that there is only so much that he can do and that the setting is old and worn and I need to replace it for a cost of an additional @ $500. Had he told me a month ago that the setting was so worn that it was likely to fail again and recommended that I get a new setting then I would have. Instead, he purportedly fixed it (but not well), charged me $200 and said nothing about it being old and that it might fail again in a few weeks. Had he told me that i would have not have spent the initial $200 if the prong was likely to fail, I just would have replaced it with a new setting. I'm very disappointed in how Joe treated me today; first his rudeness in not coming to the front of the store and talking to me, second in not standing behind his work and third in not telling me when he did the initial repair that it likely wouldn't work. I will find a new jeweler. read more