Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Keithley Pines Historic Cabins

    5.0 (2 reviews)
    Open Open 24 hours

    Keithley Pines Historic Cabins Photos

    You might also consider

    More like Keithley Pines Historic Cabins

    Recommended Reviews - Keithley Pines Historic Cabins

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    5 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Lisa H.
    62
    69
    23

    8 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - Keithley Pines Historic Cabins

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Vacation Rentals 264 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Renjoy -  Short Term Rental Management

    Renjoy - Short Term Rental Management

    2.5
    (13 reviews)
    4.0 mi

    The team at Renjoy always goes above and beyond. They have been managing my property for years and…read moreits always in prestine condition. I would highly recommend using them.

    We booked a VRBO in COS back in May. The unit is managed by Renjoy and we could NOT have been more…read moredisappointed. The hot tub was fully broken (one of the main reasons we picked the rental) and the house was filthy. See pix I uploaded. - The worst mattresses imaginable. Guests chose sofas and floor over the terrible beds! - Filthy carpet - Mildew in primary bath - Teensy tiny primary shower and bathroom - DIRTY kitchen cabinets, drawers and silverware - Dusty, dirty screened porch and outdoor furniture - BROKEN hottub cover - Inoperable hottub I never called or complained about the crime that was their "housekeeping," but I did call about the hottub. They do everything they can to push you to (what feels like) an AI chatbot in their app. Trying to find and connect by phone was a nightmare. And, when I did, the agent wanted me to take a million photos; flip a circuit breaker; and basically be the on-site maintenance person before she would call and send someone out. It was infuriating. On the plus side, the maintenance person was a great and was determined to get us up and running no matter what! I have stayed in dozens of short-term rentals. I own a short-term rental in Colorado. I would NEVER stay in another place managed by Renjoy or consider them as managers of my property.

    Photos
    Our annual Fall Fest is always a big hit for our team members, vendors, and property owners!
    Our annual Fall Fest is always a big hit for our team members, vendors, and property owners!
    Renjoy hosts short term rental advocacy events as a part of COSTRA
    Renjoy hosts short term rental advocacy events as a part of COSTRA
    Whitewater Villa kitchen in Buena Vista. Airbnb Luxe property!

    See all

    Whitewater Villa kitchen in Buena Vista. Airbnb Luxe property!
    Cascade Escapes

    Cascade Escapes

    4.6
    (9 reviews)
    5.4 mi

    This place made me decide to never rent from a personal rental company ever again…read more I believe this rental was once nice but it is in desperate need of some TLC. To start, it was dirty. The renter confirmed that they do the cleaning themselves and it's evident. Pillow cases had stains on them, fridge and freezer had crumbs and hair in them. There should be a professional cleaner going in and sanitizing after every guest. Several things were broken (and honestly, dangerous). The door locks are also not in good shape. There is no deadbolt on the front or back door. The front door lock was literally being held together by BAND AIDS! Yes BANDAIDS. Ironically enough they had a sign next to the front door warning about bears in the area LOL. The patio fairy lights were not working. There's a floodlight that is on a minute timer so we kept having to move around if we wanted any lighting in the front porch or in the backyard where the hot tub is. If you get into the hot tub after dark, good luck, bring your own lights unless you want complete darkness. We specifically rented this cabin for the hot tub but it did not work. We followed the instructions posted. The "heating" light was on. We waited 45 minutes and the temperature didn't move a single degree. When we raised these concerns to Sandy and Bob, they were sarcastic and rude. Even after seeing the pictures with the proof. They claimed that all of our issues were because the home was "historic". Historic does NOT mean dirty and broken and unsafe. Imagine going to a historic museum and seeing things held together with band aids?! So just know that if you book and have any issues, they will not give a care in the world!

    This is by far the best, most homey and quaint properties to make your visit to the springs area…read morethe best. The hosts are the sweetest, warmest and most endearing people you'll ever meet. Their properties are always sparkling clean and stocked with everything you need. They're knowledgeable and will help you in any way. We first stayed at one of their properties in Cascade in 1999. From the moment we met them, we were endeared to them and as these 20 years have rolled by, they remain some of our best friends. You will not regret making Cascade Escapes your vacation destination!

    Photos
    Random nail sticking out of the doorknob
    Random nail sticking out of the doorknob
    Hot tub showing "heat" light on but temperature never changed
    Hot tub showing "heat" light on but temperature never changed
    This sign was literally next to the front door, where the lock was held together by one singular band aid that had been cut in half

    See all

    This sign was literally next to the front door, where the lock was held together by one singular band aid that had been cut in half
    Joyouscircles

    Joyouscircles

    1.5
    (6 reviews)
    3.9 mi

    Before renting -- be sure to read the Rental Agreement... It states that no refunds will be given…read moreif the home is dirty or household appliances are broken when you arrive!!!! This doesn't sound like a joyful vacation! 23. Other There are no refunds of money if an item like a hot tub, stove, oven, washer, dryer, or household item is broken or not working at time of arrival or if the home is not clean. A small credit for another night stay at a later time may apply based on issues. Read more: http://www.joyousvacations.com/rental-agreement/#ixzz4ol3gJ2QY

    I stayed at the Riverview lodge. Joyous vacation rentals advertises false information about 100% of…read morethe property. Pictures of the home, if shows a kids bunk room with 3 beds. That does not exist. Shows a hot tub, it has on with stairs broken through it. I received a email letting me know it will have trash bags, toilet paper, aluminum foil, etc-had none of this. The properly was filthy, trash is trash cans, dirty bathrooms, oven, fridge, coffee pot, etc. The thermostat had a note that says dont go above 60.... Its winter time, neither of the electric fireplaces work(yes I know how yo work them, i have my own in my home, the igniters were broken and the guy tells me to stick a flame somewhere in the area) not doing that with such old stuff, it would blow up knowing my luck. The water situation was even better, they have limited water. After arriving and turning on pump i was warned to not flush toilets and to only shower as a emergency. Once the water is gone then thats it.. I was very disappointed with this cabin, every year we go to different ones and this was the worst. Hopefully people read the review, the man Charles uses the excuse that he is in Florida and it is not his fault.. Great property manager... I will never take my family to this companies homes again... Dennis

    Keithley Pines Historic Cabins - vacation_rentals - Updated August 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...