Great sandwiches! There are two great vegetarian options. I ordered a different sandwich with no…read moremeat and it was also good. They have a wide sandwich selection (hot and cold) with quality breads, meats, and cheeses. Their deli sides are also varied: broccoli salad, egg salad, potato salad, cole slaw, and others. The shop is well stocked with fresh meats and vegetables. It even has offerings from local businesses such as Amelia's and 4 Birds Bakery. There is a space to eat inside. Employees were friendly.

Though we live in Carmel, this was our first time visiting Joe's butcher shop in Fish market. We…read morecame in search of fresh fish for dinner. Trying to eat somewhat healthy is in part due to New Year's resolutions and in part due to my wife's health. We are going to give it a try! Hope we have some success! I was impressed with the butcher shop and fish market. They had a good selection of beef, pork, chicken, and fish. They also had a nice deli area. In the middle of the store, they had limited supply of groceries needed to cook the protein items they sell. There is also a prepackaged fresh and frozen area with ready to take and eat meals. It had a small grocery store type atmosphere. The individuals behind the counter were very helpful and knowledgeable. They cut our fish fillet for us. He also provided a good recipe and means to cook the fish at home. That was very much appreciated.... Particularly since we are new to this whole healthy eating concept. Wish us luck! The prices here appear to be a little more expensive than your average grocery store. However, we are hoping that the fish is better quality and fresher in nature. We will definitely be returning.

Yorktown, IN needs a grocery. You would be welcome. Love…read moreyour fresh cut smoked pork chops! Friendly, helpful folk.

Oh my, this place is amazing. I finally went into this store and I will be returning often. The…read morechicken and potato wedges were delicious. I couldn't believe the fresh meat. When you see it you just want it all. Trying to make up your mind for a few things is not going to happen. I had a young man help me the whole time. His service was polite, helpful so nice. Every person had a person helping them. Great service !! The different meats were amazing. Plus the different food was every where. I have been craving breaded tenderloin and they had them. So good. There's nothing like good fresh meats. Plus vegetables and spices so much in this store. If you don't go you're missing out. I so regret not stopping in there sooner. I can't tell you just how this place has changed my meat and supplies have changed. This is the place to go. I will be returning there soon.

Looking for a butcher shop near us without astronomical pricing. We understand the difference…read morebetween the butcher shops and large chain stores with quality and are open to paying some extra. With this we ended up at Smith Family Farms Market on Saturday and purchased 3 beef filets for grilling on Father's Day. The service was great and the people were very friendly and helpful. BUT, the best part was the steaks. These were by far the best steaks we had grilled in a long while. They melted in your mouth they were so tender. I braised them over high heat for 1 1/2 to 2 minutes on each side. Then grilled them for 8 minutes on each side. They were very thick and turned out beautiful with slight pink center (temperature was about 150° - 155°). As said they were so tender.. We've found a new go to. Our thanks to the people at Smiths for making our Father's Day meal special!!!

This review is for Either Friday or Saturday Oct 8/9, 2021…read more I will say we tried them because they had 5 stars, but sadly only 19 people have reviewed the place, so either they have had more who do not use yelp or others do not leave reviews, which may have made up a difference, for as long they have been in business. I usually like to look thins up before trying local business, especially family owned one's out. I am giving two dates because right now I do not recall which date my partner went in to give these folks a try. Since moving down here we have been looking for a new butcher to shop at as our business was with another local butcher where we lived, so we were could frequent the butcher over store products as 9 times out of 10 butches product is fresher and better depending where you go. So like stated we wanted to give this location a try for the first time. Due to my current health situation with esrd, we tend to not go My partnered had picked up some jerky, a pork shoulder, and Italian sausages. So overall the jerky was ok, and everyone makes their jerky different, but I personally did not care for it, in cased asked why, it was too tough than what I am use to from others. The Italian Sausages, I will say I loved, and will definitely get more if and when we stop in again. Now the reason for 3 stars, I based on both the Pork shoulder and how customer service was handled. I would have given an extra star, but issue was not handled appropriately. I understand this is family ran, I understand how a business is to be ran as I had one for several years, I have as well watched a butcher work their business up north where I am from. The way this location handled issues when my partner called in is not customer service like. I am unsure if regulars get better care than new customers is all I am going to say there. My partner phoned in and the following happen: "She informed about the pork shoulder, was told "we have never had that kind of issue here" Rather than I am sorry and own up to the issue as if we were making something up, we got that and a store credit. So the way the pork shoulder was packaged was as follows: Saran wrap like plastic, and then wrapped in the white like paper. When unwrapping it on Sat or Sunday as it was never frozen, it was suppose to be fresh, I asked what the foul smell was, it was the pork shoulder. I am unsure if the meat was just going bad and this is why this was pushed over the tenderloin we wanted or what the issue was. To owners and staff, we may give you a try again in the near future, and then I will update this review, but until then this is my honest review of our experience of our first time with you guys. I wish it had gone better.

This is long -but it is that special. Please help me spread the word…read more This place is so understated and deceiving -in a good way! It looks like a meat packing house from the out-side. But when you step in, it's a homage to the art of meat preparation. The owner Steve is a gem. You can tell this is not only a quality business but also a passion project that he has continued from his father. My daughter is a recent Purdue graduate from '25 class. We are not local, but from NJ. She found this place as part of a local walk and stopped by to pick up a gift certificate to give as a thank you gift.. She noticed they do catering- and thank goodness!. We rented an Airbnb for her graduation so family can stay with us and had planned to have a caterer. But the caterer I booked 4 months prior to graduation cancelled on me one week prior to the event! I was left high and dry. My daughter remembered that Beutlers caters! Steve literally saved us when all others could not or would not. He was not only empathetic to our situation, but he made sure we had an amazing feast and thought of everything to ensure we had the celebration we envisioned. The food was so incredibly good. My family was raving about it all weekend long. Truly THE best pulled Pork and Beef brisket we've ever had. And for a family that doesn't even like beans, they couldn't stop eating it! So good, it should be illegal. We had leftovers for days. Best of all, Steve told me he prepped all the food himself. His TLC was evident. He made sure we had everything needed, even lovely serving baskets and lighters for sternos! My only regret is that my daughter graduated, and I have no known future opportunities to call on Steve again to work his magic. I hope this review gains traction. I'm on a mission to ensure that word gets out about this rare gem of a place and the incredible owner behind it all, Steve Beutler. Heartfelt thank you Steve.

Awesome service. Really nice people. Don't forget the cookies. From liver to steaks. Fat, bones…read moreand tenderloins. Lots of yummy meat must haves. Feed you and your pets. I love the decor also. Tin shed vibes.

I bought a quarter beef off CL and the seller used Legacy Meat to process the meat. Cuts were of…read moregood size and packaged properly unlike the company I used before who put 3 steaks in one package.

I stopped in to their grand reopening and was treated to excellent product…read more The Bacon Sausage and Steaks were far superior to grocery store product. Take the diversion and discover rural indiana.

Just happened to be driving by and we decided to stop in. Definitely a great idea because this…read moreplace is really nice! Lots of great sauces and snack charcuterie board type items. Really had such a great selection. The working area was very clean and organized. Friendly staff. Margaret was very nice and ready to help us offering in case we had questions. We live on other side of Indy but definitely coming back for other items in the future.

Moody Butcher is a really clean and organized store with good quality products. The atmosphere…read morefeels upscale and well put together. However, it's definitely on the expensive side. Great for specialty items or occasional shopping, but probably not the most practical place for one person to shop weekly on a budget

I bought a prime rib for Easter dinner and everyone remarked that they've never had better - better…read morethan eating out! Excellent service!!

Went here for the first time today. Was introduced to Banter's sausages from my in-laws. Clean and…read morenot smelly at all. Reasonable prices. Fantastic customer service. I am disabled in a wheelchair and they were very kind and patient with me. I will be back. Thank you foe a great experience. -

I'm updating my review to say this is the best butcher in the Indianapolis area. They have ruined…read moreme for grocery store meats. I stop in about once a week to pick up my meals for the week. The staff is welcoming and treats you like family. The selection of high quality meats is wide. We love the smoked pork chops, specialty boxed burgers, breakfast sausage, chicken, Faroe Island Salmon and every now and then, we treat ourselves to a steak. The gourmet mushrooms are delicious as well. And I generally pick up some candy to spoil the grandkids. They also carry cheeses, a few deli meats, wines, craft beers, vegetables and gourmet pastas and pickles. You can get just about everything the you need for a nice dinner. The store is upscale and spotless. There is one small table if you want to sit and eat some cheese or have them make a sandwich. They have a private parking lot so you don't have to mess with Z'ville parking.

We love everything we get at Moody's except the beef. We continue to be disappointed by all the…read morebeef products. Most recently we got beef shish kabobs and the meat was tough. They need a new beef source.

Good meat. There thick cut pork chops great Looking forward…read moretrying there sausage . Diner will be good to night

Try to stop calling yourself a butcher and meat market. We ordered a half hog which we were told…read morewould be around 150 pounds of meat but when delivered it was only 85 pounds. Bad meat cuts and the sausage mad my family sick.

Ordered my Xmas ham from them. I ordered a WHOLE SEMI-BONELESS HAM.. What I got was a WHOLE SLICED…read moreBONELESS HAM.. I live in Anderson and there was no time to take it back. It would not have been so bad but I ordered on the phone with a man and the woman that does the ordering called me to verify what I wanted. So much for that. I believe they sold the ham to another customer and put my name on this one. Whatever not again.

Solid meats. Hamburger sales are frequent and cheap. Steaks are good other than the NY strips are…read morecut way too thin in their deals.