Kathy and I would visit Bob Condrik when he owned it. The atmosphere was like a pirates den and…read moremight get kidnapped to work on Black Beard the pirates boat. Falling off the bar stool was fun. We were drunken female sailors. Lol before DWI laws. Drinking age 18.

Friendly authentic people. I enjoyed the short time I spent in this comforting environment.read more

What a nasty people, The person who answered the phone does not deserve to keep working there. If…read morethey continue like this, they're going to drive all the customers away.

Had the best bartender ever Michelle, super friendly and accommodating! Had a great time until two…read morepatrons walked in an older man and heavier woman with rectangular glasses and a bad attitude ordered drinks and tried to pay in Pennie's and dimes. After watching Michelle politely inform them that she can not accept the change being that their register does not have coin currency the customers became irate calling her white trash and continued to berated her while she apologized for the inconvenience. In my personal opinion I salute her self control and professionalism because it couldn't have been me. I would have immediately denied service and banned them. If you decide to come enjoy this bar please bring your respect and leave your coin purse at home.

I tripped over an overweight homeless, fuckin, jerk named pat. He puked on my shoe, and I…read morereprimanded him, saying, "hey, dirty person, don't touch me or any person in here that you're not worthy of touching!" he obliged, and smoked crack in the women's bathroom. I think he died in the parking lot. Good times.

JC's Restaurant has gotten better and more popular as the years come. I've been a fan of JC's for…read morequite some time now and their quality always impresses me. Listen when you're in Mastic, you have to stop by and get their Mussels! Yes Mussels! Especially in their spicy diablo sauce. You get a whole bowl full of 20 or more mussels for cheap! And they come with a side of garlic bread that soaks in perfectly with the sauce. Totally mouth watering! I also highly recommend getting their chicken parm! Thick cut chicken cutlets, with their hearty marinara sauce and topped with mozzarella cheese and sprinkled with Parmesan cheese. Truly a delicacy every time I'm in town.

Linnea have my family and I exceptional service. We left very happy with how the service was and…read morethe food was amazing. And we loved that desserts are in-house made. They were also very delicious. It's a nice relaxed place to come eat at. Everything was also pretty clean. Thank you to Linnea for the best service! We will be returning

I stopped in with a friend for a cocktail and to shoot some pool. We were in town in the off season…read moreand did some shopping around town before coming here. The bar tender was very pleasant and we had some nice conversation. The place was quiet with just a few other customers at the bar. Nice music was playing. The kitchen was still open but we didn't order food. The place recently changed ownership and so there was fresh paint making it look nice. Basically a casual laid back kind of place.

We went there two times when we were in Greenport for my niece's wedding Fun vibe w/ good drinks…read moreat reasonable prices. And they have a cigarette machine! Very old school.. and I don't smoke

I landed upon Greath South Bar last night after searching high and low online for a Tuesday night…read moreopen mic on Long Island. Sign up was at 7:00pm and the mic started at 7:30. Now I've pervious performed at and attended over 100 open mics, at different bars, venues, houses etc, and believe me when I say this was one of my all-time favorite. All the musicians were super talented, the host was a pro's pro, and the audience were incredibly supportive & engaging. The space just felt warm, friendly and had a calm yet electric buzz the entire evening. Also, the bartender, Penny, really seemed to set the tone for the entire bar. She is extremely welcoming, witty and just an all-around positive person. You can tell she really enjoys her job and makes sure that her patrons are having a good time. I was sticking to non-alcoholic ginger beer all night and she only charged me $2 each, how kind is that?! All in all, a true gem of a bar with an open mic that I will 1,000% return to.

Bartenders are amazing. Super friendly. Quick service and great prices. Terry and Angie are always…read moreamazing.

Have eaten here for years. Staff is woderful but food needs to be checked. For the love of God;…read moreupdate the menu. Just brought home takeout that was is not good.

We so looked forward to enjoying dinner here. Calamari was tough and tiny pieces , sauce mediocre…read more Fettuccine was oily and bland. Spaghetti and clam sauce- flat and tasteless Tortellini was soupy and tasteless . New ownership did not follow old recipes... Not going back...very very disappointed

Absolutely rock solid dive bar in Hampton Bays with everything you could want…read more Darts? Check. Pool? Check. Giant jenga? Check. Juke box? Check. Drunk food? Check. Came here on a random Tuesday night and nonetheless was greeted by an enthusiastic bartender who upsold me to a double and took great care of me and my parents who had apparently been here 40 years prior on a date? The vibe of this place is super fun, lots of eclectic artwork on the ceiling that my mom swears was here some 40 years ago. They do have some selection food options but we did not partake. Don't let the semi sketch exterior of this place fool you, it's a welcoming atmosphere at reasonable dive bar prices - honestly maybe the last affordable bar that exists in the Hamptons.

This place is a dive bar. Not a good dive bar, a bad dive bar. Liquor prices aren't cheap, they're…read morefairly expensive for a shitty dive bar. When you ask for a check after you're done drinking, they just tell you the price without giving you a check.They go over to the cash register and they hand you a check that is not itemized.It just gives you a total without an itemized summary of how many drinks you have. They told me my total was $49.95. I was gonna pay with cash but decided to pay with credit card and they told me if i pay with a credit card it was $4.00 extra. All bars and restaurants charge either 3 or 4 percent for using a credit card which should amount to $1.50. What a rip off. STAY AWAY FROM ThIS RIP-OFF bar.

This wonderful place is my "Cheers" I absolutely love everything about Dive Bar....the entire staff…read moreare amazing and top notch and the food is great across the entire menu. I love to say that "even the napkins are good" On this Saturday, I shared a table with my good friend and we both enjoyed a wonderful visit with good conversation. Adding to our good time, was Sally (one of our favorite servers) Next week, my niece and I will be coming to Dive Bar for her first time ever and I know she can't wait? I have the best time telling all of my friends and family about Dive Bar, love it so much Whether you're a seasoned veteran visitor like me or a newcomer.....Dive Bar hits the mark all the time ? Some of the best burgers and wings in West Haven

First time trying them was yesterday, Sunday 7/26/2026 afternoon for lunch. There were no tables…read moreavailable so sat at the bar. Super cute sports bar across from the water with great views. We ordered the steak tacos and wings with hot sauce. Nice size wings, cooked perfectly and so tasty. Tacos had lots of very tender beef and just amazing flavor. The tacos have pickled carrots onions and radishes on it with peppery lettuce. The restaurant was busy so a bit noisy but able to talk easily. Both Cara and Krista were friendly and professional. We will definitely be back to try more menu items. Parking was a bit tight.

All the food was absolutely delicious, the fish ceviche was amazing (we went back a few nights…read morelater for more) the chicken quesadillas and chicken tacos we delicious. Staff was super friendly and attentive. Not expensive at all. Definitely recommend

I am bestowing 3 stars because I believe that with time this place could develop into a decent…read moresummer experience. Firstly, the venue is up on a hill with steep steps and a very long ramp way for those of us unable to make it up those steps. When you arrive at the top and enter there is a small dining room with 4 tables and a window to order your food. Prices are high for what you get. Fried Calamari @ $13.75 was small with tiny pieces of Calamari served with a cold Marinara sauce...Fish and Chips was also small portion of fish with lots of fries. At $15.50 it was a poor choice. The Best thing we had was the Blue Burger cooked rare...was good eating! Unfortunatly the sweet young girls serving and taking orders didnt have a clue...need more training and time on the job! There is a sandy patio wrap around that could seat diners but only used for some benches to look at the water. They need to ramp up their service and food to make it a destination during the summer months as the only attraction close by is the Mastic Beach Yacht club next door. As it currently stands, I would not return as I can get better for the money elsewhere.