In terms of value/price + convenience this is 4-5 stars, but in terms of actual flavor of the pizza, a solid "3" ("Good" in my book). Old school booth dining, fast service, pay at the counter before you sit. Friendly crew working, prepping the pizza right in front of you. Buy it by the slice, thin or thick crust--I got a slice of each, very filling (esp that thick crust). $2 draft beer including craft--this is a beer/drinking/college town for sure, it seems. If I were 20 years younger in college I'd be a regular, as a tourist this was cool for a cheap quick dinner before a concert. read more

See all

This location is located in the heart of downtown Athens. There's plenty of seating and orders are made right in front of you. They sell by the slice or pie. I only bought a slice because I parked near by and my niece needed to use the bathroom and our actually destination was too far. I didn't eat the pizza right away so it could be the fact I didn't eat it fresh but my slice wasn't worth 5$ in my opinion. Proably a great place to soak up a night out of drinking, it's located by a bar. The inside looks like it has history but definitely could use some renovations but considering it's a collage town and most customers are already a few beers in , it's just right read more

Little Italy - Pizza Near Me - Athens, Georgia

Visiting from Atlanta and wanted to try this place. Was not disappointed Great atmosphere Great food Just a good time! read more

Little Italy - Meat Stromboli - Pizza Near Me - Athens, Georgia

See all

Nice by the slice joint; not the fastest but good quality. Plenty of booths to stretch out in and enjoy a beer. Or twelve.

Old school Athens, hole in the wall sandwich and pizza shop that's been around for years. I always get thin crust pizza- its the best ever and if you get some jalapeños, be sure to be prepared for heat. In town for a visit, stopped by to grab a couple slices of my fav thin and crispy slices of pepperoni, black olive and mushroom and it was sooo good!! Huge slices, the whole pies are huge as well and price points are for college students. Affordable pizza, sandwiches, antipasto , cold beer, its all here. If you haven't tried it, come in and have a bite and see. Highly recommend!! read more

Little Italy - Ahhhhh - Pizza Near Me - Athens, Georgia

Real Italian/New York pizza! This is not some phony soggy southern pizza, this is good. They make amazing Italian subs you should definitely get one if you go. Ultimately, I one hundred percent recommend and would get food from here considering the nice New York vibe and the outstanding astonishing food!!!!!! read more

Pretty delicious pizza late night after a good concert at the Ga theater. I highly recommend the mushroom or anchovy pizza! So delicious

Ordered pizza to go and it was so yummy! The staff was very nice and it was a cute little pizza joint. I think it'll take about 20-25~ mins for the pizza to be done after you place it! But it was hot n fresh read more

Little Italy - Pizza Near Me - Athens, Georgia

Little Italy in Athans Georgia is a retro Italian sandwich shop with good sandwiches and pizza right in the heart of UGA. After doing a charity walk in the AM, I went to lunch with my best friend Melody (also a Yelper) and her family. We enjoyed a good lunch before heading back home. I am sure this place has many a student visiting this establishment for a quick bit t read more

See all

I can't believe a single slice with 2 toppings cost me $7 the last time I was in there. I used to get three slices for that several years ago. The inside still looks more or less the same, with the exception of the installation of the Covid guards. Service isn't stellar, but they've never really been known for their friendliness, haha. It was almost like one of their signature traits, how blunt the pizza slingers were. If you're wanting some nostalgia from when Athens was still the grungy Athens I knew, stop in, but if you want pizza, I would recommend ordering a whole pie for just a little bit more. read more

I love this place so much. I've been there at least 50 times, but have only ever had their pizza and Italian special sandwich because they're so good that I don't consider getting anything else. It's a quick place to go to for lunch and also a charming atmosphere that's great for a sit down dinner with friends. I'd recommend ordering a whole pizza because the crust is perfect when you eat it right out of the oven. read more

Super, large pizza slices. Customize by adding your own toppings. I added green peppers and onions. The veggies were plentiful and tasted so fresh. Busy place due to it's proximity to UGA. Cash price is lower than price for using plastic. read more

Little Italy - Miller Lite draft (tiny cup!) - Pizza Near Me - Athens, Georgia

See all

The best pizza & subs in Athens!!! Hands down the freshest. Delicious subs with amazing bread. Bottle beer or pitcher, and it's open late......after the bars close. This place has been Athens downtown "go to spot" since it opened in 1997. Awesome customer service. read more

See all

This place is nothing if not consistent, I would stay away from the subs as they're pretty mediocre. The pizza is slightly better. Service is pretty fast for the amount of people in there late at night. Probably would stick to some other place for food though. read more

Little Italy is a great place in downtown Athens across the street from South end of the the UGA campus. They serve hot and cold sandwiches, pizza by the slice and whole pies, and salads; think antipasto. There might be other items on the menu I don't recall. I got the Meatball Parm, which was quite good. You can order a 6 inch or a 12 inch sandwich. The 12 inch is big enough to share, and it's conveniently cut in half. Beer and soft drinks are offered. Pro tip: If you want something stronger after your meal, the quite excellent Road House is right next door. It opens at 2:00 p.m. A little bit late lunch followed by a stop at The Road House next door is where it's at if one is at liberty to do so. The service was friendly and prompt. I went there around 1:00 p.m., and it wasn't busy. At night, however, it gets packed with UGA kids when they are done drinking at one or more of the numerous bars in downtown Athens. The place is quite roomy with lots of tables and booths. As depicted in my pics, the love for the UGA Dawgs is strong here. It's a legit very reasonably priced pizzeria. Cheers! read more

See all

This is the one spot in Athens that genuinely has NY style pizza. I got 2 simple slices of thin slice cheese pizza and for the portion, the price was fair. The pizza was cooked to perfection and had just the right amounts of flavor. I also got a veggie sub which was SO good and filled with lots of veggies and cheese. Both meals were very filling and the service was quick and friendly! The atmosphere of the place has a very downtown diner vibe, but it's a good spot to come hangout with friends. If you're ever craving some greasy NY goodness, then this is your spot! Will be visiting again! read more

See all

Great after a night out since they are open late. I like how you can buy just a slice and still add whatever toppings you want.

Ordered on Uber eats after it being highly recommended from friends. I was honestly disappointed. I ordered a slice with pepperoni and extra cheese. It barely had any cheese or sauce.... we also ordered an Italian hoagie. The bread was so hard on the outside, no onions, not enough mayo or vinaigrette. I didn't even taste vinaigrette to be honest. I think there was just a little oil. It just wasn't good if you have ever had a good hoagie. But I just spent the last 10 years living in Philly and last three in South Philly. It was not nasty and they put a lot of meat in it but it tasted like bologna. Just not good to me and I won't order again. Packaged well big portion hoagie. Pizza was a scam to me. read more

Love this place and the food owners a really cool guy also . Only one bad experience I had was with a rude employe but they were let go I believe . read more

Usually the pizza is great and hits the spot, but tonight I don't know what happened. Granted, my pizza was an odd slice: pepperoni and pineapple (don't judge), but what I got was clearly a piece of pepperoni pizza that had been sitting out that they just put some pineapple on from a can in the fridge or something, because it was cold. The pineapple was colder than the pizza. And the cheese on he pizza reminded me of Junior High lunch on Tuesdays. Next time just put the pepperoni pineapple slice in the oven for two minutes read more

Little Italy is a small Italian pizza place in Athens that offers slices of pizza and are unique amount of toppings and different things if you can get on the pizza overall pretty good place for slice of pizza read more

Little Italy - Pizza Near Me - Athens, Georgia

See all

Hands down the best pizza I've had in Georgia. As a New Yorker, it's hard to impress and this shop IMPRESSES! Thank you...finally.

GROSS GROSS GROSS. idk why in the world people suggest this place, maybe because they are high or drunk college kids with no culture and don't know any better . It's over priced and just gross for what you're paying for, little Caesars does a better job in my opinion. And just for the record I am a pizza expert. Jersey born and raised and grew up on NY pizza. read more

1/2 a star really, "deep dish" pizza undercooked, not enough sauce or cheese. Total waste of 15 bucks. Called to complain was told to return it & they'd make a replacement- I live 20+ miles away so that's not possible I understand some people may try to get free food that's not me. Thin crust just ok, Stromboli 3 stars. We had Little Italy in Commerce GA for many years, always excellent. Athens location you need a new cook or a better way to handle complaints. read more

See all

10/10 pizza and the workers are nice too. Will come again, currently eating standing over the box like a wretched bog creature read more

Little Italy - Large pepperoni, cat for scale - Pizza Near Me - Athens, Georgia

This little hidden gem is one of the best places to get pizza in Athens! (And maybe all of Georgia too!!) It doesn't look all that nice and you think the pizza isn't great but once you try it you will always be back for more!! Once you walk in you're greeted with fresh, fired smelling pizza making your mouth water. They have many different options like whole, half, and slice pizzas, subs, and stromboli's. I got a slice of the classic cheese pizza and the piece was as big as my head!! The crust was nice, golden brown with flaky edges and the pizza sauce was delicious!! I love how they top the pizza of with flakes of Italian seasonings. It is clean inside for the most part and pretty good amount of seating! All in all I will definitely be coming back! read more

Little Italy - Thin Crust Cheese Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Athens, Georgia

I guess Antico's and Varuni's in Atlanta spoiled us.. However, considering the oven available at Little Italy's, it's a decent place to eat pizza at in a college town!! It offers the hand tossed and the Sicilian crust choices. Their slices are HUGE! So make sure you're really hungry, if you're going for that attractive deal that includes a sub (go for the meatball sandwich; it's good!) and the pizza combo. It is no Little Italy but I say, you definitely get your money's worth.. regardless of your budget! read more

Little Italy - Normal crust. half veggie/half pepperoni Medium Pizza (16") - Pizza Near Me - Athens, Georgia

Pizza is amazing! Subs are sooo good! The staff works hard and does an excellent job! The place is a cute hole in the wall from the outside but once you're inside it's a great size place that can have a good number of people. This is a fun and cute place read more

I wish we were able to give starts for different categories, since we are not, so I will describe a little. We had a large pizza with 4 toppings of our choice and the pizza was pretty good, crust was fresh and baked to right point, so that would get 4/5 starts. The place it self is pretty old, and could use some TLC. For a College town pizza place is ok. read more

Little Italy - Sitting area decor - Pizza Near Me - Athens, Georgia

Too bad they got rid of the lunch special for two slices of cheese and a drink. I stopped by today and two slices of cheese and an ice tea was $12.37. Rip off for average pizza. read more

food was AMAZINGGGG. I ate it and it was so buss got more a lot of pizza which was so worth it. The service was great, it was our first time here and the nice man who took our order was super attentive and helpful with with how it worked and answered our questions, even joked with us which made the whole experience more enjoyable and the place is super chill, laid back, and authentic, would definitely recommend and come again; wish i lived in athens just to be able to come again ! read more

Little Italy - Thin Crust Cheese Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Athens, Georgia

See all

Lowkey pizza/beer spot. Nothing fancy, doesn't look the cleanest, workers were bare handed, front door was wide open welcoming flies etc...They were even very short handed and had signs of Help Wanted everywhere and online. But....I was very IMPRESSEDPizza was very hot fresh and tasty and my salad was crispy and fresh. I'll definitely return read more

Little Italy - Antipasto Salad - Pizza Near Me - Athens, Georgia

See all

I'm originally from the New York New Jersey area, finally found a place which comes damn close to the pizza from up there, the slice was fresh and hot the cheese was fresh and the flavor & taste were on spot, the service was good it was actually busy when I was there but it went smoothly the environment is welcoming, would recommend this place to anyone read more

Holy cow! This place is spot on! Definitely a go-to spot for pizza! The quality and service is superb! Forget the chains around and be sure to send your business to Little Italy Pizzeria! We ordered 5 large pies and had them ready for pick up in less than thirty minutes after graduation! Impeccable timing! The pies were loved by all and the New Yorkers in our group approved! Delivery isn't available after 10 as the service they use stops at that time. Don't let that hold you back though! Incredible! We especially loved the Yankee accents around the restaurant! These people know pizza and are the real deal! read more

See all

The pizza by the slice is so good. I love the three meat! I love this hole in the wall restaurant. My fiance and I had one of our first few dates here YEARS ago! Staff is so fun I wish parking was a little better but honestly I'd walk a mile if I had to. read more

For something basic, as pizza, I expect more ... I lived in NY for 16 years, then DC for 20. I think I know pizza. I have traveled the world, eating and drinking. The pizza here is BASIC, little flavor, and not as NY as the name would suggest. My kids ate the pepperoni but said the cheese tasted "old." Overall this is a basic local pizza shop with little to offer for authentic flavor. read more

The food is delicious and I like it. Service is not perfect but is not bad. Ambiance is a different type.

Looks like a small place but it goes back and has large tables with a big screen. I order an xl with pepperoni/ pineapple and the other half black olives and banana peppers. The crust is light and the sauce is great. Stop by and grab a slice read more

Little Italy - a slice of pizza with olives and pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Athens, Georgia

My wife and I came to Athens for a concert at the Georgia Theater. We wanted something quick before the concert and she remembered that she'd grab meatball subs from Little Italy Pizzeria during her college days so we headed here. The service was fine. Not friendly - but the food was delivered quickly. The bathrooms were what we'd expect from a hole in the wall in a college town (grungy and disgusting). She ordered her meatball sub and I ordered my sausage sub. We couldn't finish them. They were absolutely disgusting. I honestly can't TELL you what about my sub was disgusting - I can just say that when I took a bite my throat convulsed and tried to reject the food. Maybe it was the grease? Maybe it was some strange instinct trying to protect me? Whatever - it was horrible. We took a few bites and walked out reflecting on how our standards vs when we were in college were vastly different than what they are now. read more

Little Italy - Absolutely disgusting sausage sandwich - Pizza Near Me - Athens, Georgia

See all

The line was long at 1:45 am. We ordered the pesto sauce pizza. It was great!!! We will be back