Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Long Island Athletic Supply

    5.0 (1 review)
    Closed 10:00 am - 5:00 pm

    Long Island Athletic Supply Photos

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Long Island Athletic Supply

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    10 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - Long Island Athletic Supply

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Sporting Goods 2,230 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Monkey Sports

    Monkey Sports

    3.0
    (6 reviews)
    2.3 mi
    $$

    shopping at Monkey Sports in Farmingdale should be a straightforward and enjoyable experience, and…read moreto be fair, many of the employees here are helpful, professional, and knowledgeable. Unfortunately, the entire experience is ruined by the store manager, Ryan Maloney. He is, without a doubt, the worst part of this store--clueless, unprofessional, and completely unfit for his role. as a manager, you'd expect him to have at least a basic understanding of the products, yet he seems to know absolutely nothing. Ask him a question about any type of gear, and you'll either get a completely incorrect answer or some bizarre, unhelpful remark that makes you wonder if he even knows what's in his own store. While other employees go out of their way to assist customers, Ryan seems more interested in making everything more difficult. to make matters worse, his demeanor is just plain uncomfortable. Instead of being professional and customer-friendly, he makes weird, off-putting comments that leave you wondering if he's deliberately trying to confuse or irritate people. What really crossed the line was when he made unsettling remarks toward both me and my son. Rather than focusing on helping us find what we needed, he seemed more interested in making awkward, unnecessary comments that had nothing to do with our shopping experience. It was uncomfortable, unprofessional, and completely unacceptable. on top of all that, he doesn't even seem capable of managing basic store operations. At one point, he actually pulled one of his employees away from helping another customer just so they could assist him with something--completely disregarding the fact that the customer had been waiting for help. Instead of leading by example, he comes off as lazy, unorganized, and completely out of his depth. and his appearance--because if you're expecting a manager who looks even remotely presentable, you're out of luck. Ryan strolls around the store in cheap Walmart sweatpants like he just rolled out of bed. It's honestly a shame because the rest of the staff here are great--they know their stuff, they're friendly, and they actually care about customer service. But with Ryan Maloney in charge, the entire store suffers. If Monkey Sports wants to maintain its reputation, they should seriously reconsider who they have running the place. Until then, I'd highly recommend taking your business elsewhere.

    do yourself a favor and save the 30 dollars on a glove break in. I got it back with almost no…read moredifference in stiffness and when I asked about it I was told it's not going to get broken in anymore than it already is. I've never bought any products from them but it seems like young kids working there and if they don't feel like fulfilling the hands on service that the store offers, then they give a poor effort and tell you it's not going to get any better. Terrible service

    Photos
    Monkey Sports

    See all

    Runner's Edge - Farmingdale

    Runner's Edge - Farmingdale

    4.6
    (119 reviews)
    0.8 mi
    $$

    My daughter was convinced that part of my bad back and bad knee problems are due to my shoes, so…read moreshe "dragged" me to this store when we were visiting. I begrudgingly went, and to my shock and surprise, it ended with me loving the shoes I got because it feels like I'm walking on clouds. I don't know if my back or knee feel any better, but my feet sure do !! The shoes don't necessarily flatter my feet or overall look, but when I step into them, I no longer care. Clouds, clouds, and more clouds... is what I feel... and that's fine by me. The sales approach is completely different from what I've been given, which isn't much of anything, to be honest, and these sales associates know their "shit." They really do, and to be further honest, I think that what other Yelpers have viewed as "rude" or "condescending" was just the sales people ripping apart all preconceived ideas and trying to teach us how to TRULY get properly fit for a shoe, be it for walking or running or whatever. It was an education for sure, and I can see why some would be put off by it. I didn't want to hear some of what they said, but they weren't wrong, either, and my feet are happy once again. Maybe I'll order another pair in another color.

    I started running recently and wanted to get shoes for daily runs that would fit my wide feet and…read moregive support for my flat arch and instability. Runner's Edge came to mind as my dad and brother had both gotten fittings there before. I went in the middle of a random weekday thinking the store would be less busy, but there were many customers in there being fitted. Jarod was the associate who helped me. He asked questions about my intended use for the shoes and had me try out a few pairs after measuring my feet. He made adjustments and picked different pairs out from the back as I told him how the shoes felt. I landed on the Saucony Guide 19, which was not shoes that I had in mind or come across during my research. But they are super comfy and I love running in them. I saw they had a lot of gels and other running gear in the store. Would love to revisit when I start preparing for longer runs!

    Photos
    Runner's Edge - Farmingdale
    Runner's Edge - Farmingdale
    Runner's Edge - Farmingdale

    See all

    Walmart Supercenter

    Walmart Supercenter

    1.9
    (172 reviews)
    2.2 mi
    $$

    In April, BTS collaborated with Korean food companies Paldo and Hy to launch Arih, a consumer…read morepackaged goods brand that blends Korean and Western flavors. Arih products are sold exclusively at Walmart. The brand's title is inspired by the Korean name, "Ari," which means "fine" and "beautiful," and the letter "H," which is intended to represent happiness, harmony, and health. As a BTS ARMY fan, trying the ARIH "Modern Noodle" line was an absolute must. The product comes in seven flavors: Black Pepper Tteokbokki, Gochujang Butter, K-Super Spicy Seaweed, Spicy Seaweed, Soy Sauce Butter, Truffle Bulgogi, and Vongole. I placed a pickup order at Walmart Supercenter in Farmingdale, NY by first simply placing an order online and choosing a timeslot for pickup. The next day, I received an e-mail that my curbside pickup was ready and I received a text message with a link to select I'm on my way when I'm heading to Walmart. Once I parked in one of the Curbside Pickup parking spots, I selected I've parked and entered the spot number and color of the vehicle. Within 5 minutes, a Walmart associate brought out my items in Walmart bags. I showed a barcode to the associate and the associate scanned it before handing over my order. I can't wait to try the Black Pepper Tteokbokki, Gochujang Butter, Soy Sauce Butter, Truffle Bulgogi, and Vongole Arih noodles. The online process to place a pickup order was easy to use and the pickup process was seamless on the day of.

    There are no Walmarts in the city at all so coming here is a treat. For me at least…read more It's gigantic ha but it does get quite busy. The parking lot can be a little hectic but it's big . Super centers usually have a huge fresh food/grocery section. As well as clothes, home stuff, gardening, auto etc etc. Most super centers are truly a one stop shop and this one is no exception.

    Photos
    Walmart Supercenter
    Walmart Supercenter
    Walmart Supercenter

    See all

    Long Island Athletic Supply - sportgoods - Updated July 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...