The food was very good. Fresh, hot and very well seasoned. Our server was a little older gal who…read morewas excellent and treated us right. My only critique is it felt like an icebox in there, but it wouldn't stop me from going back.

This has been on our list of "restaurants we need to try" for a while. Now I wish we'd tried it…read moresooner. The service really stands out out (not always the case in Key West) and the food was fantastic. We have a new Key West favorite.

This was our 2nd trip to Key West and our 2nd trip the Red Shoe Bistro. We made a reservation and…read moreshared that we were visiting for our anniversary. The staff went above and beyond to give is a special night. We had beautiful window seats and received complimentary glasses of sparkling wine. The service was outstanding and the food was divine. Best restaurant in Key West, hands down. What inventive dishes!!! There isn't a "bad" thing on the menu. We would highly recommend this establishment again and again! Thank you so much for a memorable evening!​

Beware! This restaurant may ruin all other Key West dining experiences for you--it's THAT GOOD!…read more We chose the 6 PM seating and were welcomed by a happy, energetic hostess who immediately set the tone for a fun evening. Then, we were served by John, the owner and master of the house! From the daily specials and thoughtful drink options to the first bite--a crostini topped with farmer's cheese and herbs--we knew we were in for something special. The Shrimp & Mango Toast appetizer was honestly one of the best things I've ever eaten. The ingredients didn't necessarily make sense on paper, but together? AMAZING. We could have eaten another order! Both couples ordered the grilled Caesar salad, to share and it was perfectly portioned. The grilled romaine had a wonderful sweetness, topped with crispy Parmesan and a dressing with the perfect lemon-to-anchovy balance. WOW! For entrées, our table tried the bacon-wrapped ricotta-stuffed chicken, signature Yellowtail Snapper, Beef Stroganoff, and Key West Pink Shrimp with chili glaze over creamy risotto. We cleaned our plates and LOVED every bite. I rarely order dessert, but after a meal this good, we had to try their award-winning Key Lime Pie. It was truly the best I've ever had. I don't need to try another! And lastly--use the restroom! The retro ambiance and fabulous décor are part of the experience. Fantastic food, wonderful service, and a memorable Key West evening. Do not miss this place!

Freshest food I've had my weekend in the keys. My friends were on their BOGO mimosas and I ordered…read morethe CONCH FRITTERS!! The staff is family and took care of us front and back. Chill atmosphere, shady back yard vibes and food that is worth it. Island Tingz m

Came here with some friends after decompressing from the Key West races & it was the perfect pick…read moreme up to keep the party going! Service was absolutely friendly & quick! I ordered their iced coffee w/lavender which hit just right. Loved that they accommodated the dietary needs of our party & were not hesitant to serve it up w/a smile. They also have a cute seating area that is very shaded & in the part of the keys that is more laid back & lowkey!

I do recommend this restaurant. My wife and I love crab and mostly any sea food. But this place…read morehad the best seasoning you can choose we had the old garlic recipe it was awesome. 3 others to choose from. Also had 4 spice levels. Service was good a fun. I will definitely recommend to friends and family.

This restaurant is located on the second floor. It has your classic seafood boil decor inside. I…read moredid find it strange they did not offer whole shrimp vs. headless shrimp. I was also shocked with the price at $32 per pound for that shrimp. Seasoning was decent, but it really didn't taste fresh and felt frozen. Service was ok. Our server didn't check up on us too often. I always had to ask for a refill on my soda. Would I go back to this place, probably not. I can get a better seafood boil in Miami.

Kaya has great Key West Vibes. We brought fish we caught that day on a charter trip and the chef…read moreprepared it for us 3 different ways. The dishes were amazing and delicious. To top it off, we had the most amazing server. Renata so friendly and very knowledgeable about the food and entertainment available at Kaya. Next time we are in Key West we will return and hope Renata will be there to serve and entertain us with her stories and hospitality.

We had such a great experience at Kaya! We brought in our fresh-caught mahi mahi for their…read morehook-and-cook, and they turned it into an incredible three-course meal for only $20 per person. Everything was flavorful and beautifully prepared--a really fun way to enjoy our catch. William, our server, was fantastic and truly added to the experience. He was attentive and thorough, explained everything, answered all of our questions, and even brought us a magazine to show us a review featuring the dish we were having. That extra attention made the evening feel special. Great food, an awesome hook-and-cook experience, and exceptional service from William. We would absolutely recommend Kaya!

While staying at Pier House, our group of 10 decided to dine here on a whim. We were given a table…read moreon the veranda which was very nice. WHAT I TRIED: Blackened Hog Fish Tacos- fresh and perfectly cooked. Conch Fritters- also just right with the most delicious key lime mustard sauce! Strawberry Lime Lemonade- very nice with muddled strawberries. Not overly sweet. My friends ordered the caribbean cobb salad, the white conch chowder, and crab/spinach dip. Two enthusiastic thumbs up from everyone. Our waiter, I think his name was Alvaro, single-handedly tended to our table. He took the orders, filled our glasses, double checked the orders were correct, brought out our food and extra anything we requested all while remaining cool, calm, collected, respectful, and poised. So refreshing! BY. HIM. SELF. Great hire! He definitively brought the experience full circle. ALSO unlike other restaurants on the key (cough Firefly, cough Santiago's Bodega) he easily and efficiently split our bill into several ones without ANY hesitation. Easy peasy. What a concept! I will be back to try their dinner menu the next time I'm in town!

Poolside bar is good. Great for a quick bite for lunch or snacks. Harbor View Restaurant was odd to…read moresay the least. We made a reservation for 1:00 on Monday 9/7 and arrived a few minutes before 1:00 to be told they were closed due to it not being busy enough to stay open. Breakfast the next day was sub par. Way overpriced for basic tasteless eggs and potatoes. Servers were pleasant and attentive but the food was just bland. We would not dine there again.

We arrived at seven and they lost the first order and nothing came till after 830…read more Literally the worst worst service I've ever had anywhere in 25 years. Avoid this restaurant at all costs. Would've left it zero stars had that been an option. Only reason that this restaurant can stay in business is it has a captive audience.

Delicious dinner at sunset. At happy hour, small plates are dicounted. We had the snapper caprese…read moreand grouper small plates and they were exceptional. Our server, George was attentive and made recommendations. The carrot cake was a perfect ending to our meal. I'm not sure why this restaurant doesn't have reviews, unless people want to keep it a secret. We were here two years ago and it was great then...it just keeps getting better.

I stumbled across this spot earlier in the day after breakfast nearby and was intrigued by the sign…read moreadvertising Caribbean food and jerk chicken, one of my favorites. While I was checking it out, the bouncer at the bar next door told me it was worth a visit, which sealed the deal. Later that evening, I convinced my friends to go with me. They were expecting a full sit-down dinner, but this is more of a counter-service spot with 6-7 bar stools inside. The setup is simple: place your order at the counter, then either grab a stool or head to the bar next door, where they'll bring your food when it's ready. We chose the bar's patio, which gave us a clear view of the restaurant. It was reassuring to see other groups having their meals delivered over too--it felt like we had discovered the right local gem. The wait was about 25-30 minutes, but that only confirmed everything was being made fresh. And let me tell you, it was absolutely worth it. Our group ordered two jerk chicken plates with plantains, mac n' cheese, and slaw; one oxtail with black beans, rice, and mac n' cheese; and one jerk burger with fries. Every single dish was a hit. The jerk chicken had that perfect smoky spice and heat from the scotch bonnet peppers, balanced with bold Caribbean flavors. The oxtail was tender and flavorful, and even the sides like mac n' cheese and plantains stood out. All in all, this was easily one of the best Caribbean meals I've had anywhere. A true must try when in Key West.

I was told by one of the locals to try the jerk. I was off and decided to try the jerk. I decided…read moreto try the jerk chicken wings with rice the service was awesome and I would definitely return. The ambiance was nice and the music was very eclectic and the live band was great. When you're in Key West, FL make your way to The Jerk. To all my Yelpers let's continue to eat our way through the world #foodie4life.