Lucky Boy is not much of a Greek name but maybe for a horse? See previous Yelpers review. When my fellow co-workers in VA told me that Lucky Boy was a superb place for lunch I sort of drew a blank stare. But they were sure right. From the time I walked in to the time I left. Nothing but smiling faces and excellent service. Started off with the hummus plate, moved on to soup du jour and then main coursed it with a slouvaki sandwhich. Perfect choice for lunch appetite. Cost was around $12 total and I was full and happy. Will be sure to thank my co-workers for the good tip! Parking is a challenge when they are busy for lunch or dinner. read more

My first experience here was horrible but I decided to give it another chance & its been an amazing one. I'm very happy we decided to. The food is always fresh & great. The service is 100% the servers remember us every time we walk in always asking how we are & how's everything. The first time we came here my partner & I had just purchased a Python Snake & they remembered & always asking how he is. We always get here for lunch but we're dying to try the dinner. So we'll be back real soon for dinner. read more

Lucky Boy Restaurant - Greek Near Me - Lawrence, New York

See all

Had lunch with my friend and tried their chicken parmesan and it was delicious and well portion size. Tasty Mnnnarggiana sauce The flan made with bread was also very good. Will be back again to try something else. read more

Lucky Boy Restaurant - Greek Near Me - Lawrence, New York

See all

I visit NYC every two weeks and eat out regularly, but this is one of the best dinners I have ever had. Bridget was our server and was so passionate about her work and the restaurants food. I got the Greek lasagna and it was phenomenal. The pies/desserts were amazing. Highly recommend this place. read more

Our family of 15 went to a late lunch after a family funeral at a nearby cemetery. I made the reservation with only Yelp reviews to go on, since we were all from out of town. WOW! The staff in this little non-descript restaurant bent over backwards to serve us and make sure we were happy. They did not seem to mind that we stayed for over 2 hours. Several of us had the Gyro Special with lamb, chicken, salad and pita. The falafel salad was also quite good and enormous! The desserts are all home made and well worth the calories! We all left very full and grateful to be able to have a wonderful meal after a sad occasion. read more

This place is Good. Good people, good food at Good prices. No messing around here, this is authentic greek that will fill you up for Lunch. Ordered a huge takeout order today and all the food was on point, salmon cooked right and the pita bread it comes with was finished in a few minutes. In a location surrounded by BK, popeyes and chains, it stands out as a real quality place that'll take care of ya. read more

Wow what a surprise. All the specials were amazing and our waitress Bridgette really new her stuff! Don't judge a book by its cover. Go enjoy!!!! read more

Great Big Salads. I recommend the Greek salad with Salmon. Everything is super fresh & wonderful. Homemade pies too. Funny little place near JFK. read more

Ordered for takeout. Guy over the phone said 20 minutes. When we arrived 20 minutes later, BAM, food was ready. Parking is kinda weird. There seems to be a small parking lot on the side of the restaurant but there's no ramp to pull in. And by 'no ramp' I mean the curb does not indent for your car to pull in. Seeing that I drive a sedan and was not in the mood to lose my front bumper, I just pulled up down the street. Onto the food -- I ordered the gyro special. Everything was very good except for the tzatziki sauce. That is where I had to take a star off. It wasn't as thick and creamy as I am accustomed to. Not that I'm a tzatziki connoisseur or anything but I like it when my sauce clings to the meat. It had a cole slaw style consistency. Aside from that, everything else tastes great. Normally I wouldn't take a star off just for sauce but I feel for a gyro of sorts, the tzatziki sauce in particular should really bring the plate together. then again what do I know LOL. read more

Lucky boy... Lucky us! What a find! Staying over night close to JFK airport, this restaurant stood up to the great reviews that led us there. Dear Bridget :), thank you so much for your kindness, warmth, authenticity and generosity! Our family shared a souvlaki pita, 2 Greek salads (included with main dishes), a gyro plate and a moussaka, with hot bread, pitas, oil & butter (come with everything else) and a slice of coconut pie. Portions are huge, various sides are offered, veggies are abundant, everything tasted great, fresh and homemade. We honestly couldn't have asked for more and would definitely be regulars if we had the chance of living any closer. If you like authentic restaurants with a family feel and great food, go and feel that you are lucky too. read more

This ain't the prettiest place and it's in a weird spot but holy cannoli is the food good lol. Best spinach pie in the planet. Unbelievable service,reasonable prices. If you're lucky you might get Bridget as your waitress...she's frickin awesome! read more

Another gem small but big flavor I've been going there since the 70s I know Greek food having word 15 yes in bayside Astoria when h comes to 5towns none to be found Lucky boys always on point very consistent the food is pretty much the same and authentic Greek type of style cooking another good goodies as well if you're going to answer my friend Bridget is well worth the ride it's right across the street from Costco's it's rather small with the food is worth it if you're going to the beach when you want to get a nice Greek salad with grilled chicken to take on the beach get it to go enjoy it read more

What a great dive, I was on my way to chipotle and I stopped here instead. I ordered the vegetable pie with a side order of steamed veggies. Everything was excellent and the food around me looked great. I would 100% come back here again for a home cooked meal. Even though I am a vegetarian so my options are limited, I want to try he spinach pie next time. I wish I was in the mood to try their coconut cream pie but I was too full. My only disappointment was the price of steamed vegetables, it was way over priced for an order of veggies. Other than that all the prices for everything else are on point. read more

Lucky Boy Restaurant - Vegetable pie with a side of steamed veggies. - Greek Near Me - Lawrence, New York

See all

Love love love going here. Food always fresh and portions are huge. The desserts homemade and delicious. Staff is alway welcoming . read more

Lucky Boy Restaurant - Greek Near Me - Lawrence, New York

My family and I have been ordering from Lucky Boy since I can remember. It's been over 20 years and we've had Lucky Boy almost every weekend of my life. While we rarely eat in the actual restaurant it is a nice place. It is small so if you're looking to have a sit down dinner I suggest going earlier due to the limited amount of tables. Whenever we go in to pick up our order there is always a line of people waiting to be seated! Only downside is it is a pain in the butt to park. The food is great and they always listen to special instructions. Order the homemade bread!!! read more

The food is great and the staff are the nicest. The food is always fresh. Best fish dishes and love the chicken kabobs and gyros

This restaurant was a great find. The service was outstanding and the food was amazing! We had spinach pie which was flaky and full of spinach and mozzarella! Then I had the eggplant parmigiana hero which was huge and cooked to perfection! My friend had the sausage and peppers hero which she enjoyed. Then for dessert we couldn't pass up the coconut pie and banana pie!! Delicious!! read more

Lucky Boy Restaurant - Greek Near Me - Lawrence, New York

See all

The outside appearance might throw you initially but, inside is definitely clean and nice. Waiter was absolutely perfect. The Greek salad is so good and more than enough. I also ordered some mussels in garlic sauce which was sooooo good as well. For dinner i had the salmon with rice and veggies which was a huge portion that i had to take home. Love this lil spot and can't wait to visit again ! read more

Went here on a whim while staying near JFK. You gotta go. The locals will talk your ears off and the food was amazing.

This place is just the best. It is always a pleasure to walk in there. Great food, outstanding homemade deserts, the owners are great, the waitresses are the best, and the rest of the staff are all super friendly. You are guaranteed to feel at home there. Lucky Boy has been around for over 30 years and represents everything good that The 5 Towns used to be. I recommend the lamb shank, chicken Parmesan, they make a great piece of grilled salmon. Homemade soups are fantastic! All of them. The homemade bread they put on the table is the best I've ever had. Muscles in red sauce, homemade sweet potato wedges, the burgers, bread pudding. The list goes on and on. If you are in the area, definitely go! read more

Long time Greek BYOB dinette in Lawrence for me was a complete misfire. Warm bread served with a lite olive oil dip with a hunk of butter...? Butter with olive oil? Why would you do that? Next was an enormous Caesar salad. However, no croutons! That's the best part of a Caesar and they completely omitted it! Plus, the dressing kind of just tasted like garlic and oil. I came in just wanting a gyro but we got suckered into ordering one of the specials. The waitress made each of them sound delicious, truly a great sales person. Using words like "outrageous" to sell the dishes. The one I ordered sounded interesting, curry chicken. It came with a kind of rice and boiled veggies. I hate to say this, but was a notch above airline food. The curry sauce was virtually flavorless and the rice was a grainy textured disaster. What fared better (slightly) was the Greek sausage and meatball special with zucchini pasta. The sausage was delicious, the chicken and spinach meatball was pretty good but the zucchini pasta was underwhelming and the marinara sauce was way too heavy on the garlic. When it was all said and done, I felt like a sucker. Both entrees weren't good and at $24.95 each, I felt a bit ripped off. Portions are large for the price but to only be able to eat so little of it makes it a waste. $70 for two with drinks and tip for a disappointing meal. Yet, many people absolutely love this place. The staff are welcoming and friendly. Again, our waitress surely knows how to up sell. Unfortunately, she up sold an inferior product. Maybe their simple dishes are great but their dinner specials, expensive and not good. read more

See all

This place is a hidden gem, off the beaten path. Food is fresh and always exceptional. The portions are big and the service is great. The only complaint is parking can be difficult. I could eat here everyday. read more

authentic, local eatery with quality food and outstanding service!

I LOVE this place! From the unlikely name and exterior (think little 'dive' Chinese restaurant because that's what I thought when I first saw it) to the fresh Greek food to the bustling crowd of local regulars and the friendly staff that never seems to change, you can count on a great meal at a reasonable price. I'm a big fan of the salads here. My favorite is the Baby Greens salad with Salmon on top. It is Greek style (in that it still has the peppers, cucumbers, black olives and feta) which I LOVE and the portions! Ha! The first time they brought a salad out to me here I laughed out loud because the bowl is the same size as my large mixing bowl in my kitchen! Full disclosure, I have had better sauces: hummus and tsaziki, but the huge portions, fresh foods, fish cooked to perfection more than makes up for that. Probably not a place I would drive ling distances out of my way to come to if you are in the area (and with Costco right across the street many are) believe me, it's a great little find. read more

Been coming here my whole life. Best food around anywhere. The owner and staff are amazing. Ceaser salad is abnormally incredible, dream of that garlicky dressing. Top w charred salmon or grilled calamari and it's heaven. Save room for coconut cream pie and/or chocolate pudding pie. The homemade desserts are an event in and of themselves. Come early, don't dress up, and enjoy every (inexpensive) bite. read more

Wow! I can't believe this place has been sitting right under my nose for the past many years and I've NEVER even thought about stepping inside the door.... actually I never noticed it even though its right across the street from Costco where I've found myself at on a number of occasions. It was only when one of my friends went here (After a another friend raved about it to him) that I decided to join him for dinner there. Since he first ate here, he's been coming back nearly every friday and saturday for dinner or lunch, and as extreme as that might sound, I kind of get it. Lucky Boy is not your average Long Island restaurant; in fact if you looked at it, you may think otherwise and just pass it over. From the basic exterior, to the poor location and parking; you'd expect nothing out of the ordinary. The inside is fairly small and it has an old yet plain decor, which is fine but won't win any awards. Now what is it about Lucky Boy that makes this possibly the best restaurant in at least a 5 mile radius? Two words: The food. Like many others have been saying on here, everything that Lucky Boy makes is from scratch, and it shows when you take that first bite into the warm, delicious pita and semolina bread they bring out to you. If I wasn't starving I could make a nice little meal out of that alone. From my two experiences here I've ordered the gyro special and the cheeseburger platter both of which went way beyond my already semi-high expectations. Portions are big with each meal and came with a big bowl of greek salad (Full of plenty fresh veggies and feta cheese) and a couple of generously portioned sides. With the burger I had humongous, crispy steak fries, and onion rings with a similar girth, both of which being fantastic. Its even more impressive that I wanted to eat the onion rings since I'm in general very indifferent of them. The burger was juicy but not fatty and had a great ratio of bun to meat, meaning I didn't have to worry about toppings sliding out or not having anything to hold onto. The gyro platter was equally tasty with loads of gyro strips and some shish-kebab. Despite how full I was getting I resolved to nearly lick my plate clean since just letting a fry go uneaten here would be nothing short of a travesty. I did not try any of the dessert items but I can tell you that they all are homemade and you're given a large portion. My friends swear that any of these dishes are delicious and I plan on trying one of them eventually... if I'm daring enough I'll go on to sample the entire dessert menu over time. I also must mention that the staff is extremely friendly and on both occasions I've met the owners who really do their best to make sure you are both comfortable and satisfied with your meal. The rest of the staff is great too and they give a very welcoming vibe. Lastly, the prices are for the most part reasonable, especially for some of their regular specials like the gyro platter and more. Some of the pricer dinner items compensate for their price with large portions that may ultimately give you a second day of leftovers if you don't have the strength to take it all down. I let Lucky Boy slip by me for so many years and wish I could go back in time and tell myself 10 years ago what this place was like, and though I have no Deloreon to take me back, I can make sure you know to not pass this place up. If you thought about coming here, or never even heard of this place, seek it out and go; you'll be glad you did. read more

Honestly, when I first saw this place from the street I thought that the other reviewers were crazy. But after I went in, I realized how busy this place got. The gyro and souvlaki portions were HUGE! While I have yet to try their dinner specials, which honestly seem overpriced, I will definitely come back again. It's SO much better than Greek Town in Rockville Centre. read more

This place is a hidden gem with unbelievable food and truly friendly service. Almost every time (they're not open Sundays) that we are traveling back to the city from my in-laws in the five towns, we order pick up. They never disappoint and consistently have fantastic off menu specials. It's a small restaurant so be prepared to wait if you want to sit down, but know it's worth the wait! First class all the way. read more

I have eaten here numerous times and they never dissapoint. Large portions, food is fresh. On many holiday occasions I have ordered whole pies of chocolate pudding pie and coconut custard pie. They are to die for! read more

4 stars for great 'home cooking' and generous portions. One star taken away for the plain diner atmosphere and always a looong wait. The place is small, seems popular with locals all stopping to chat with one another and lingering while there's a crowd. Extensive menu. Most specials are oddly $27.95. They aren't Greek but there are Greek items. The chicken meatballs over zucchini linguini is popular. Grilled corn is great. Most seafood dishes are really good. read more

I LOVEEE Lucky Boy ..... My family has been coming here for over 20 years and the quality and service has always been excellent and top notch.. On my last visit I ordered kalamari with salad my son ordered bacon cheeseburger w French fries,wife ordered gyro and so did my other son ..... The waiters brought over pita bread and a topping for it ... Not too long after our food arrived .... My salad was excellent and was garnished with feta cheese the kalamaris were excellent and the marinara sauce was full with flavor.... My son said he really enjoyed his burger and also the fries are not those frozen ones .... They are freshly made by the chef .... My son said his gyro was great and very filling my wife said the meat was excellently marinated ... As a dessert I ordered a pudin dessert that was so good! Very nice workers , fast service, delicious food , yup this is as good as it gets read more

Best Mediterranean spot around. I cannot stress how good they are. Apparently, a lot of people feel the same way. Try what's on the chalkboard. If your not feeling adventurous, go with he gyro. read more

Went back 2x since my original review-gyro was great-svc still rocks and their pies are so amazing i had a banana cream pie special ordered for my bday. Choc cream pie is also damn tasty! read more

The food is "OK"...what really annoys me is that this place gets so packed, you can't even walk. It's located on a main street, so there is NEVER any parking, Even in the backlot. Don't go there at lunch! It takes about 45 minutes to make your food, and you wont even be seated right away. Honestly, i give it 2 stars because the food is "OK", but i've had better. I think it's a little pricey honestly...and it's not worth it for the frustration you go through finding parking, and being packed in like a sardine. Not worth it. Will not return. read more

I had really no other choice to eat here but was surprised to find such good food and service behind doors that open into such a busy street in an average neighborhood. I had fresh trout and spinach and potato the same as if I had prepared it for myself in my own kitchen. Fresh bread and great olive oil or butter. Washed it down with a Heineken. I'm stuffed and I had a generous portion so, a complete portion for leftovers tomorrow lunchtime. Could have been 5 stars except the place sorely needs a deep cleaning and or a facelift or just new tables that aren't tacky. Stop by lucky boy. $40pp read more

My family and I ate there tonight after reading the great reviews on Yelp. First, I have to say the staff was awesome! We had a party of 6 and had to wait for about 20 mins before we were seated, and one of the gentlemen behind the counter presented us with a plate of gyro meat to try. It was beyond flavorful! My 1 year old fussed at me to give him more, which the people behind the counter found to be hilarious. So, here is where it goes left... We ordered the fried zucchini and it had no flavor at all. Just breaded and fried. The sauce was even bland. For an entrée I ordered the chicken souvlaki and it was also bland. To say I was disappointed is putting it mildly. My expectations were pretty high after reading the reviews. After tasting the gyro meat I just new this experience would be great, and I was let down. I'm still giving Lucky Boy 3 stars bc the staff was extremely welcoming, the dessert I ordered (some apple pastry) was absolutely delicious and I can tell the Gyro is where it's at for this place. Just stick to the Gyro and you shouldn't be let down. read more

I have been in and out of the area for the last few months and am LUCKY to stumble on this restaurant. If you are looking for 5 star decor and servers in suits this place is NOT FOR YOU. If you want a family owned, absolutely homemade menu with attentive bus boys and servers that actually listen, THIS PLACE IS FOR YOU! The parking is in the rear of the building and seating is limited so come prepared to wait a few minutes. But having a glass of wine and fellowshipping with complete strangers passes the time perfectly. This place by far has some of the best food in the area hands down. You owe it to yourself to stop here. I will be back and will tell everyone I know to stop in. read more

Lucky boy is a Greek restaurant in Five Towns. It's at a location where you can almost drive past it and not notice it. If you just got in from a flight at JFK this is a great spot to grab a bite to eat. They have consistently good food. I typically order the same things when I go. Nothing fancy. Sometimes a salad which are pretty big or gyro, fries, or burger. What I really love is there coconut cream pie. It's a must-have. If you plan on going definitely order one to stay, and one to go. Actually, most of their desserts are really good. The apple crisp was also delicious. It gets pretty busy but has a family atmosphere. Customer service is good as well. Parking isn't amazing at all. If you go on the weekend the parking lot can get packed fast. I never had a complaint and plan on visiting again. Now I'm thinking about that coconut cream pie... read more

Yummy, homemade and absolutely delicious.....I eat here at least once a week......the owner and staff are so nice.....everything on the menu is homemade, no processed frozen food here! The owner makes you feel like you are one of the family! I love you Lucky Boy........ read more

This my to go to spot for lunch. Awesome service even if the place is super crowded . Try the Stuffed eggplant, it's definitely one of the best things in their menu. read more