Loved having lunch here! Our server, Lily was amazing. So attentive and great with our kids. Eggs Benedict was perfect and best coleslaw I've ever had! We will definitely eat here again. read more

I really enjoy this diner because of the friendly service and the great food varieties. The breakfast is really fresh and tasty. Your food comes out hot. Even the burgers taste fresh off the grill. I'm big fan of Calamari they have that as while. Thanks for the great service.. The diner is really big in space if you wanted to have an event. read more

See all

This diner was a beacon of warmth on a frigid day. We were stuck without a car waiting for tire replacements at Costco on a 7 degree day when we were lucky to stumble across the Sherwood Diner. It was early so we ordered breakfast, it was the perfect fix for my bone-deep chill! I'm pretty picky with my diner food but this was fantastic and the staff were very kind and fast. read more

Old original decor Diner that definitely needs updating, with that said the waitstaff is fantastic and the hamburgers are delicious. When you sit down they bring you complimentary macaroni salad, coleslaw, pickles, and a bread basket filled with a warm dinner rolls, breadsticks, and crackers. Looking at other tables the sandwiches look pretty amazing as well. But the Cheeseburger deluxe is my go to. read more

See all

Pretty standard diner with all of the normal things. They make a good Burger and great wraps. The service is super prompt and friendly.

Probably been here 10 times for breakfast and aside from the bad attitude one waitress always seems to have (the dark skinned lady) the food has always been great ! I have tried a bunch of different breakfast options from the banana walnut pancakes (good but huge) to the corned beef hash and eggs (always add avocado and I like my eggs runny) The waffle is probably my go to. Its crunchy and soft inside every single time ! And I have been to numerous diners who will either burn my waffle or its just super soft . It's pretty cheap as well. I dont have any bad words for the place read more

I've been a customer of this Restaurant for years and am sitting here now, after having enjoyed their delicious Turkey Burger Deluxe. Over the years this Restaurant has never changed. Always the most Friendly staff ever. The food never misses a beat, and if it's not on the menu, and they have the ingredients, they'll make it for you. If you've not had an opportunity to visit, please do. You will be pleasantly surprised! Kudos Sherwood! read more

The Sherwood never disappoints. Staff are the best. Good portions, good quality food served fresh. The surrounding area has plenty of shops and businesses, gas station stations, restaurants etc etc. public transportation is also available. Minutes from JFK airport. read more

See all

Sherwood Diner has the feel and menu you expect with a classic diner, but I've had much better food and service at other diners. The first time I went, I ordered the French toast (kind of a diner staple). It barely had any flavor to it, and honestly looked like a few pieces of very slightly cooked toast with some syrup haphazardly thrown on a plate. The second time, I got an omelette, which again was pretty underwhelming. The third time, I got French onion soup and a pizza bagel. Being in New York which is known for both pizza and bagels, I expected it to be pretty good. It seemed like something I could've thrown together in a microwave at home. Our waitress this trip was also pretty rude. She acted like I was dumb when I asked a question. When my mother-in-law's order came out incorrectly, she said that we ordered incorrectly and it wasn't her fault. My mother-in-law ended up just eating the wrong order to avoid a scene. I almost gave two stars, but gave the benefit of the doubt with 3 because my family does like this place. Overall, I'm not expecting anything gourmet, but I think the quality and cozy feel you expect from a diner could be better. read more

Came here for breakfast and got a nice, big booth. Immediately given waters. The menu had a decent selection, and we started with a fruit bowl which was pretty big and had a nice fruit variety. I also got a bacon, egg, and cheese sandwich and it came packed with those ingredients. It was a super filling breakfast sandwich. The coffee was good, and there was great service getting refills and not too long to wait for the food. Overall, no complaints. Great place for breakfast. read more

Sherwood Diner - American Near Me - Lawrence, New York

See all

Not the best Father's Day in terms of food but it's okay . The omelet order totally wrong for my son. The lox hollandaise came without the HOLLANDAISE!! After they brought it that is what it looked like ans that's how neat the bowl was. The utensils were dirty, the waitress brought the water with our napkins dipped inside them . But the check was competes by the owner. read more

My boyfriend took me out for a late breakfast here after previously having a bad experience. (They told him the turkey was fresh when it was clearly not. The waitress asked if he wanted to see it in the kitchen, so they walk to the kitchen door. There he heard the cook laughed, and she then came back refused to show him.) He decided to give them another try. There was a woman standing at the hostess stand waiting to be helped. We came in and stood behind her. They told us to seat ourselves, which I found odd because they completely ignored the woman in front of us. She was annoyed by this and I don't blame her. I got an egg sandwich on a roll which was clearly not fresh. It was so dry and stale. The rest of my food was mediocre. My cup of tea smelled like old fryer oil or Like fried seafood. I will not be returning. read more

Its a classic diner. There are few of those around anymore. The breadsticks were terrific. Pancakes always good. Caesar salad is a big portion: usually fresh although this past visit was less so read more

I've been coming to this dinner since I was a kid, so 50+ years. It got an extra star because now that I live in Florida I really do miss a good diner. It just doesn't exist there. Service was pleasant and attentive. We came in for breakfast and the omelet is huge. It's basic breakfast fare Erich in all honesty no one should screw up. Food came out hot and was good. I was even asked if I wanted my toast buttered. I don't know the last time I didn't have to butter my own bread. It's the little things that make me happy. I wish I could have had some good old French fries with brown gravy because that was my usual late night fare when I was in my late teens. Maybe next time I'm in town. read more

See all

My first impression was great when I visited with my husband , he ordered an omelet and I had a chicken sandwich I rated the the place 5 out of 5 . I recommended this diner to my friend , so we visited last week Tuesday to have a midday snack she ordered a turkey wrap, when the order arrived, the smell of the turkey meat was aweful, it was very rank she could not eat it . I ordered the Pita bread grill sandwich which tasted excellent . I still love the place but I'm a bit dissappointed with the turkey wrap and my friend's first visit was not impressive . Other than that , the staff was friendly and the atmosphere was relaxing as usual , I would definitely visit again and reorder the grill sandwhich . Staff: 5 Ambience:5 Turkey Wrap: 0 read more

This place is always great! I have been going there for years. I moved to Florida 6 years ago but now come back to NY once a month. I visit this place when I can. always a great meal with great device and a great smile! read more

*AVOID THIS PLACE* Went to the Sherwood Diner for the first time on Sunday morning for the first time in many years, do yourself a favor and don't bother! Decided to stop for breakfast on a whim and wish I went to the local bagel store instead. The service is grossly inadequate and the bucktooth waitress standing at the counter barking orders into the kitchen and wearing a mask half in her face, what's the point of that? I sat at the counter, there was no dedicated waiter / server and waited a long time for a menu. Ordered an iced coffee and waited another five minutes for it to come, as the same bucktooth waitress ordered another waiter to get it for me. My food was overcooked and terrible. (Eggs Benedict). This place is terrible!! read more

I've been here several times and each time I've given them the benefit of the doubt. But what do I expect from a diner. As much as I love my diner food from time to time I will definitely not being coming back here. The service has been very poor. The waitress disappeared several times and we had to look for her all the time when we needed things. The brunch menu is basic. And the drinks were disgusting. We honestly just stuck to water. The ambiance was nothing special but very welcoming depending who's at the front. I really loved this place but the quality seems to have gone down. read more

I frequent this establishment on doordash. I mean the product is great, BUT if im being transparent the orders arent being looked at fully. If ya order a burger deluxe it should hsve options for fries OR onion rings but no such luck. I put in notes and i guess they are overlooked. I mean they great food and service but dint expect the changes you request. This morning , son ordered my breakfast french toast deluxe no ham sub with more sausage. Ya think ya listen, nope of course no ham, but yet again didnt substitute the ham fir sausage as asked AND I CALLED UP AND THE SAID OK!!!! I think i need to just find another diner close by... JUST KNOW FOOD HERE IS GREAT THEY JUST DONT FOLLOW THE REQUESTS WELL read more

Lovely spacious Diner, people are super nice. Come here all the time with my mom to eat some warm breakfast. They are very quick here as well, my mother loves their omelettes and their hot chocolate. Great place to meet up and unwind with anyone. read more

Cheap, friendly, tasty. Service is hot or miss but I can't wait to go back. Pickles, health salad, and Mac salad on the table.

The giant bucktooth waitress looked hideous as I watched her water down my second glass of OJ. I ordered soft scrambled eggs and instead received sawdust eggs with a slice of rubbery cheese on top. Nothing about my order was correct and the food and service was horrible. PLEASE DO NOT EAT HERE IT SHOULD BE SHUT DOWN AND THE BUILDING DEMOLISHED. read more

I went to pick up an order here and noticed a bag just sitting on the table near where people would sit if they were waiting for a table. I thought this was an unusual place to keep someone's order because anyone could just get up and walk away with the food. Most of the time orders are kept near the register. So I asked the guy who was at the register (looked like the manager or owner) if the bag was mine. His response was "I DONT KNOW LOOK AT THE NAME ON THE BAG... LOOK AT YOUR PHONE AND LOOK AT THE NAME IN THE BAG". He mistook me for a delivery person and I mistook this restaurant as worthy of my hard earned money. We both were wrong. read more

I love diners pretty much anytime so I was excited to try this on right near JFK. Let's start with the good: Service is excellent with nice staff and quick coffee refills. The scrambled eggs and bacon were exactly what I was looking for and the home fries were classic New Jersey (New York in this case) and on point. Unfortunately my silverware was dirty with food still stuck to the fork... really yucky... read more

I've been coming here since childhood . Honestly , it's no frills and no fuss . You know what you're getting when you come here : good breakfast , fast service . Very chill and laid back the staff doesn't rush you. It is what it is . Pancakes were yummy , just wish the manager wore a mask . read more

Sherwood Diner - Golden Brown Pancakes Deluxe - American Near Me - Lawrence, New York

I have lots of memories at this diner. The service is always good and the food always come in large portions. This is a very lowkey spot and great for eating before you go out to drink! Their breakfast are also amazing like their omelets. read more

Sherwood Diner - American Near Me - Lawrence, New York

See all

Used to be great. Not anymore. Ordered a Reuben recently for takeout. I know I should've checked the bag. No dressing, leathery corned beef and VERY under cooked fries. From a DINER. They did however include plenty of packets of a cheap, terrible unknown brand of Ketchup. When a diner won't spend the extra money for Heinz you know they are skimping in other areas. I am trying to support local businesses, but I will never go there again. read more

Ordered take out from here again recently and I'm so impressed! The person who took my order was so friendly and refreshing. When my boyfriend went to pick up, the staff was friendly in person as well. The food was accurate, fresh and tasty! No complaints! read more

Ordered rack of lamb to go, received itty bitty charcoaled burnt lamb. Don't understand how th hey could serve meat like this. I guess they figured since it was to go they could put as anything involved the tin. Never again. The best bfg thing on the menu is the free elbow macaroni salad they serve when you dine in. We gave this place several tries, in and take away, still haven't found that special item. read more

See all

Really good diner spot for lunch! I had their chicken salad wrap (pictured) and it was very fresh (I personally enjoy a lot of mayo, so if you do too, I would ask the server to add mayo to it). Their fries are tasty - they were crunchy and fresh as well (best fries I've ever had at a diner). The chicken panini on the lunch menu was also very delicious! Their lunch menu is a steal - you get an entree, drink and dessert for one price! As soon as we were seated, the waiter brought out pickles, their homemade coleslaw and homemade macaroni as appetizer style side dishes and they were all very tasty. The coleslaw was tangy but different. The pickles were crunchy and fresh. The macaroni wasn't my favorite but it complimented the coleslaw. The hospitality in here was very warm and I would definitely visit again! read more

Sherwood Diner - American Near Me - Lawrence, New York

I come here because it is the closest diner to my house. The food is not that great but what do you expect from a diner. Staff is pretty friendly depending who you get. read more

Sherwood Diner - French fries, chicken tenders, buffalo wings and bacon, eggs and cheese. - American Near Me - Lawrence, New York

Wow, this place really sucks. From the service.... asking for ice water three times, not getting silver wear for my daughter (i ended up eating an omelette with a tea spoon) to zero refills on coffee and tea water.. to the raw onions in the omelette and home fries. 30 minutes for food to come out. This place is a disaster. read more

It was a 90+ degree day and we chose this eatery for Sunday breakfast. First of, it was HOT a inside the diner. The waiters were literally sweating as they served ya food! We asked for the AC to be turned up but don't think the manager met our request. The bathroom was in poor condition. A waitress used the stall next to me. The soap dispenser was not working. She turned and left the bathroom WITHOUT washing her hands. That occurred AFTER I ate. The food was unremarkable. We had french toast and eggs and omelets band eggs and bacon and french fries. The french toast was over cooked. The fries were cool in temp. Our waitress was attentive and nice. Prices were reasonable. read more

I just tried to have a meal and the Sherwood Diner a very unpleasant experience first the men's room smelled like urine up my nose so hard that it almost made me cry second the waiter is on another planet he is not paying attention I told him don't cut my wrap and and he cut my wrap and aluminum was in my food the french fries that he gave will not hot they look like they've been sitting in the basket for 5 maybe 10 minutes or longer I think the french fries will not cooked at all much and he served me a half a cup of coffee from the beginning serve my wife a cup of soup with a cup that was totally completely and noticeably cracked I rate this place the lowest rating I can possibly give it which is disgusting don't eat in it unless you want to throw up read more

I've been going to the Sherwood diner for over 20 years live in the neighborhood. I ordered a Slovakia beef sandwich and they actually cut up a pork cutlet and tried to fake me out, really disappointed never been fooled like that. Ed Atlantic Beach New York read more

First time in New York. Visiting from Florida. This is what I have to say... 1. The food was great!! 2. The quick service in getting my food was great. 3. Patricia was awful. I'm surprised her eyes didn't pop out of her head with how hard she rolled them lmao. 4. The other staff, I assume were the owners, should probably stick to admin work and not front counter, seating lmao. read more

Pretty good place. I grew up with this diner around when I lived in far rockaway. It was our favorite diner. Now that I moved to lynbrook it's still good just miss the old days. Still good food. Good service. Can't complain! read more

Ordered Belgian waffles with strawberries and the strawberries had mole with a dead fruit fly on it. At first I thought it was part of the strawberry but I zoomed in with my phone camera and it was a freaking bug. I was very upset and disgusted since I ate a few already without realizing. I told the waiter who didn't care but asked if I wanted another one like it was no big deal and kept trying to take the plate away with the molded strawberries claiming he was going to show the manager. I yelled at him and demanded he leave the plate with the molded strawberry on the table and have the manager come to the table to see it. The manager came and didn't have anything to say. Not even an apology. I will never eat here again, this place is dirty and run down. Please save your time/money and eat elsewhere. read more

See all

Food is iconic diner food and made so well. A family owned business definitely worth a visit!

Maybe this diner ought to update there site the covid excuse is lame already been a year get it together! No reason why you guys cannot update your site how you have listed close at 12am but instead closed at 10pm drove all the way from the beach just for them to turn off the light when I get there for 945 terrible!!! Not even 10 yet read more

Sherwood Diner - American Near Me - Lawrence, New York