Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Maggies Magic Muffins

    4.1 (42 reviews)
    Closed Closed

    Maggies Magic Muffins Photos

    Business Info

    MAGGIES MAGIC MUFFINS ATMOSPHERE

    What's the vibe?
    Dogs allowed
    Outdoor seating

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Maggies Magic Muffins

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    Reviews With Photos

    Walter G.

    From the very first bite, it's easy to understand why Maggie's Magic Muffins has earned such a devoted following. There's something truly special about what Kristin has created -- not just a bakery, but a place where every muffin feels like it's been made with love, care, and a touch of enchantment. Kristin herself is a joy -- warm, genuine, and deeply passionate about her craft. Her kindness radiates through every interaction, and it's clear that she pours her heart into every batch that leaves her kitchen. She doesn't just bake muffins; she curates experiences of comfort and delight, one irresistible flavor at a time. And those muffins -- they're extraordinary. Each one is rich, moist, and bursting with flavor, the kind of treat that lingers in your memory long after the last crumb has disappeared. Whether you prefer something classic like blueberry or banana nut, or something more adventurous like raspberry white chocolate or maple bacon, Kristin has something that will make your taste buds sing. With over fifty remarkable varieties, her creativity knows no bounds -- there's truly a muffin for every mood, every craving, and every person who walks through her doors. What sets Maggie's Magic Muffins apart is the consistency of excellence. Every flavor, no matter how simple or inventive, delivers that perfect balance of sweetness, texture, and warmth that makes you feel right at home. It's comfort food elevated to an art form. If you've never tried Maggie's Magic Muffins, do yourself a favor and visit soon. Between Kristin's gracious spirit and her magical touch in the kitchen, you'll quickly discover that these are not just the best muffins you'll ever have -- they're a little taste of happiness wrapped in paper and baked to perfection.

    Saturdays choices.
    Beth S.

    Once again the greatest muffins We have ever had. The staff is always happy to assist and hreat to offer suggestions. It was late Saturday and the selection was still plentiful. I watched a Beautiful basket being set up for delivery.

    Coconut Almond Muffin Cinnamon Muffin Pistachio Muffin Blueberry Muffin

    Incredible. Impeccable. Outstanding. The best muffins you'll ever have. The pistachio muffin had a lot of actual pistachios in it which gave it a wonderful texture. Coconut almond muffin was to die for, a heavier emphasis on the almond than the coconut. Cinnamon muffin was 10/10 as well, would pair well with coffee. Not quite as sweet as the others which was good too. Blueberry muffin had a cheesecake filling which yes, you guessed it, was incredible. Highly recommend this place.

    Muffin Mania!
    Janet D.

    I wish wish wish we had these kind of specialty muffin shops in California. I mean seriously anywhere. Because I'd totally be there every day. Whenever we visit the family we have to stop here at least once or twice. So good. The service can be kinda rude (especially the older lady) but the food is delicious. This was the first time she assisted us, but it was very off-putting. Especially when she castigated a newer employee right in front of us. Big no-no. Other than that I'll be back.

    Sent from OH to NH for my 30th bday!
    Heather F.

    The amount of love I feel for this place is out of this world. I had my first Maggie's Magic Muffin back in 2008, I was visiting Ohio and was brought here because I "HAD" to try them! I was a bit skeptical, I'm not a huge muffin fan to begin with, but was the hype really worth it? Why did I HAVE to try these muffins?? Why couldn't we just go to the grocery store and get some muffins?? I'll tell you why! Maggie's Magic Muffins are by far THE most amazing muffins you'll ever have, they're fresh, moist, and so damn good! We went there three other times during my visit. My absolute favorite is the sugar cookie one. My last time in Ohio was in 2011, I got a whole box of muffins for the long 11 hour drive home, they didn't make it past the Pennsylvania border. Since then, I've had friends bring me Maggie's on planes, trains and through the mail! The most special was for my 30th birthday, our friend Jayme sent two sugar cookie muffins with candles to stick in them once they arrived! If you've never been here, GO! NOW!

    Simple sausage, egg, and cheddar wrap (I ate the other half too quickly).

    See all

    9 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    15 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Page 2 of 2

    Ask the Community - Maggies Magic Muffins

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Bakeries 800 times last month within 10 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    OH Donut Co. - Vanilla sprinkle

    OH Donut Co.

    2.8(5 reviews)
    2.9 mi

    This is such an unusual review for me. I can usually find something redeeming about any place we…read morevisit and I can't find one with OH Donut. And I mean that says a lot cause I'm a fat kid and they are a cake donut shop so like it should have been easy to find something tasty. But alas there just wasn't. For starters when you walk in the donuts are kind of secondary to all the household things they carry at Spruce locates in the same shop. So instead of the aroma of sugary goodness you're getting hit with candles and other household scents. We arrived about 2:30 and sadly they close at 3 so most of their selection for day was gone but honestly there just was not a whole lot of flavors leFt that we would have chosen anyway. We got a half dozen. 3 red velvet, a churro, a choclate bacon and a brown butter blueberry. The half dozen was $9.95. So the donuts themselves are cake donuts so they are dense. So I started with the brown butter blueberry. It had a white thick icing on top of a blueberry donut and topped with a blueberry jelly type mixture. Sadly I could not taste anything except brown sugar. And it was greasy. So I did not finish it. Tried the red velvet and was sad because it was just a cake donut with the same thick I icing that really just tasted like it had been made from milk and powdered sugar. On top of that was a red cake crumble. I ate about three bites and trashed it. And you MUST realize I am not the type to just trash something but it was that lackluster. My daughter said her chocolate bacon was ok but the donut itself was dry. We might try them one more time if we are over there when they open but I dunno. Will have to see

    I went to the Donut shop today and I was not disappointed at all. I ordered a bacon and egg…read moresandwich on a bagel and it was out of this world! Needless to say I had to get some donuts and they were excellent as well! I also got a coffee which was made fresh while I waited and the girl who waited on me was very polite! I most definitely will be going back to this goldmine!

    Photos
    OH Donut Co. - Maple Bacon

    Maple Bacon

    OH Donut Co. - S'moreo

    S'moreo

    OH Donut Co. - Storefront

    See all

    Storefront

    Maggies Magic Muffins - bakeries - Updated August 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...