Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Magic City Mercantile

    3.0 (1 review)
    Open 11:00 am - 6:00 pm
    Updated 2 months ago

    Magic City Mercantile Photos

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Magic City Mercantile

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    3 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - Magic City Mercantile

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Used, Vintage & Consignment 858 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Brooks Brothers - Outside

    Brooks Brothers

    3.4(9 reviews)
    6.0 mi
    $$$$

    My son is graduating soon so my presents all are something to help him with applications to Law…read moreSchool or his promotion at his current job. I am a sales person at my core. If I haven't learned anything while working on commissions is to never prejudge a potential customer. A few years ago I walked in a BB store to buy my other son a few suits to interview in because first impressions matter. I walked around and was finally greeted by a smirking jerk. His direct words were, "That's too nice a suit to wear to court. ". I looked at him and asked him to beg my pardon, Will you repeat that? This jerk asked me if I thought their prices were the same as JCP? I was speechless. I was not feeling well and tears rolled down my face. Not because of his I insults but it was just the acknowledgment of how hard it is to be treated right by people like him. I just didn't have it in me to even ask for the manger. I wasted time telling him my son would be going to court but not as a defendant. He would be the arresting officer. That I had been out looking for a lost foster dog the reason I looked so casual but I assured him I could pay whatever their prices were. I wanted to put my previous encounter behind me and see if that jerk was still there. Unfortunately, Jos A. Banks is where a dear friend of mine buys his clothes and I heard his reminder in my head as I stood at the door with my hand reaching out to the door. Nope, I won't darken the doorway because I'm sure they knew what an ahole that guy was from previous complaints. I turned on my heels and seemed to buy a That graduation suit elsewhere.

    Throughout my suit shopping struggles, my mom kept telling me to go to Brooks Brothers. So, the…read morehusband and I went to Brooks Brothers. On the plus side, service was good. We were promptly greeted by a gentleman, and once he found out we were looking for women's clothes, he summoned a female sales rep. She seemed to know the stock, although she did warn me that things were picked over due to their winter sale. Yet, despite her assuring me that all their pants were styled the same, I tried three different pairs and each was off in its own way. Some were lined, some weren't, some fabric seemed to show every curve (good and bad!), some didn't... Honestly, it was weird. My usual size was on the snug side, but the next size up was huge. Since they do tailoring, the sales rep was telling me that they could take in the larger size, but honestly, between a huge waist and being way too long, I was afraid that any tailoring attempts would result in Franken-pants. And then do I have to pay for said pants anyway? Not something I want to find out. Now, jackets are a lot easier to fit for me, and Brooks Brothers has some beautiful ones. I loved the gray with white pinstripes, and the check-patterned navy. But these jackets were FIVE HUNDRED DOLLARS. Like...come on! That is an INSANE amount of money! I forget how much the pants were, but we were basically looking at a close to $1,000 suit for me, with who knows how much tailoring required, some of which might be included (hemming), some of which might not be (taking in pants waist). And since we were looking at having to order some sizes, it would be another two trips to Birmingham to have everything fitted and altered, and they really wanted online orders to go through the store so they could get credit for them. Honestly, just thinking about all the guessing, ordering, fitting, waiting, and altering involved, with no real guarantee of success, makes me tired. So while appreciate the efforts they went to in trying to find something that worked for me, I think the upshot is that I'm just not a good fit for Brooks Brothers, both in body and in wallet.

    Photos
    Brooks Brothers

    See all

    Second Hand Rose

    Second Hand Rose

    2.9(21 reviews)
    5.3 mi
    $$

    Came here today to see what I could find. This is a good sized store and there really is a ton of…read morestuff. Pretty well organized but a little haphazard. The items seemed to be in good shape. They have a large selection of pretty much everything, even formal wear if you are looking for something for a special event. Lots of shoes too. The store is in a good location off the road so it is easy to pull in and out. Ample parking. Staff was nice and not pushy so I liked that. I was able to browse and look through everything. My only complaint here is pricing. Everything seemed to be priced too high in my opinion. They had nice stuff but let's face it, it's still used. And unlike other consignment shops where the price drops after the item has been there awhile, the prices here stay the same even though there are different color tags on the item. No wonder they have so much inventory! I definitely would have picked up a few things if I felt like I was getting a deal but the few things I liked would have cost me over 100 dollars. For me, the whole fun of shopping at these places is to get some great clothes at a great price. If you don't mind spending the money, they have a good selection of items and you should have no trouble finding a few things here to add to your wardrobe.

    Items that I dropped off for consignment never reached the floor, so it's no wonder they didn't…read moresell. They were designer items, in line with the items they accept. When I scheduled an appointment to pick up unsold items, they returned my items that had not reached the deadline for pickup. On another occasion, I dropped off designer items and when I inquired about the money from the item I was told I had missed the deadline and the item was donated . I don't believe that to be true. They had remarked how much they loved the item at drop off. I believe they kept the item . Just suspect that I never saw my items either times on the sales floor. Of course I paid the $10 fee , their gain, my loss, and picked up my items. BTW some still had the original tags on them, I had never worn the items. Purchased from high end stores. Disappointed.

    Photos
    Second Hand Rose
    Second Hand Rose
    Second Hand Rose

    See all

    Magic City Mercantile - vintage - Updated June 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...