I would have given this place four stars put on going up to five after the counter the previous poor reviews. This place is serving solid, thin crust pizza. It would hold its own anywhere not just an El Dorado. I will definitely be coming back. The armadillo egg appetizer was also delicious. Service was quick and courteous. Ambience a little bit rundown, but charming in its way. read more

See all

Love this place. The pizza is like no other in these parts. Amazing, brick oven crust and crazy affordable. The staff are good of ink and have always treated well. It has a rustic feel with amazing, vintage stuff, including vintage Klipsch speakers. It's a must when we're in El Dorado read more

Not much was open on a Sunday evening in downtown El Dorado so we decided that pizza was a safe bet. We saw that some of the higher rated pizza joints in town were closed so we stopped here. It seemed pretty dead but later we realized we had entered into the back room not the main dining area. Eventually this section also filled up. What appeared to be the lone waitress did a fine job keep things moving though it did take a bit to get our pizza (must have been all of those people in the front room!). The pizza was thin crust which is our preference with sausage (mainly) and some pepperoni, onions and mushrooms for $17 (medium). It was decent not great. It seemed a bit small. The sauce lacked flavor. Overall it was fine. read more

Main Street Pizza - Wall display - Pizza Near Me - El Dorado, Arkansas

Amazing Pizza...Really good The service was great and the entire staff were very friendly.. Definitely will be going back on my next trip to El Dorado.. read more

Saturday after Thanksgiving. Please no more turkey! We were in town and both craving pizza. So one place to call! Main Street pizza. read more

Main Street Pizza - Pro supreme thin crust. Take out. Excellent pizza. - Pizza Near Me - El Dorado, Arkansas

Where's the sauce? This is my real criticism of Main Street pizza. There's no sauce. I love the thin, crispy crust and The variety of toppings. The service is a little ow and unprofessional. But not awful. Ambiance. I mean, meh. read more

Excellent thin crust pizza! Great smoked chicken salad that is HUGE! Service is attentive, depending on how busy they are. read more

The pizza was okay. Nothing to rave about. Definitely not a fan of the cracker thin crust. It was lackluster, not entirely that flavorful. I probably won't be returning here. read more

I had a small thin crust pro pizza, called in my order, it was ready when I got there. It was hot, just the right amount of sauce and loaded with toppings. Everyone is nice and dinning room is clean, a little dark inside. It is an older building so lighting could be updated. This will not keep me from returning. Love the Pizza! read more

Good pizza, decent service, laid back atmosphere. Went after work between lunch and dinner rushes. read more

for eldorado pizza, it was very good! the service was very good & friendly. the salad was good, the cheese sticks were really good, & the pizza was worth it! read more

Extremely slow took hour to get food with only two other people there. Pizza was ok wouldn't recommend to anyone

Great brick oven pizza! We like the rustic quality with no harsh lighting. I always look forward to their fountain drinks accompanied by endless peanuts-in-shell before our pizza arrives. Kid friendly! read more

Best pizza in town, also great salad bat (pre covid). They serve thin cut specialty pizza, small size, oven baked. Perfectly cooked & served, there's a delay but that's to be expected, when they're cooking each other as orders are placed. Definitely worth a visit. read more

Went on a recommendation from hotel staff. Pizza toppings were ok, but the pizza dough wasn't cooked as well as other brick oven pizza joints. The dough itself was different to my taste. Ordered a hot muffalatta (sp) sandwich and that was the highlight. The place itself needs some major attention. Every table had napkins to balance them. Free peanuts were a little old. Staff was okay and I was seen to in a prompt manner for refills and other items. Small salad bar but everything seemed fresh. I'd go back but not for a sit down or ordering a pizza. Just another sandwich as a takeout order. read more

we waited at least an hour before our food even came out then the sandwhich was soggy and they didn't even use the right cheese they were also doing togo orders before taking care of customers in house never coming to this place again the server was nice but she barely came to the table read more

My favorite pizza place in town! The cheese sticks with wildcat sauce is a must when you go

Best pizza in town!!! Our favorite is the Meat to Please. Great crust, perfectly cooked, and always ready on time.

We ordered pizza here because our favorite spot was closed and we wanted something other than fast-food pizza; we should have just gone with the fast food. We really felt the poor quality did not match the high price of the pies. The pizzas we ordered were very thin and very sparsely topped (with the exception of cheese) so it felt like we were eating crackers. We may just have been unlucky, but we were certainly disappointed. read more

Ok i ordered a Muffalotta andit was only $4.00. There was very little meat in it more lettuce than anything but i guess for $4.00 what could you expect. The small pizza was ok nothing special. Staff was nice and friendly. On my next visit to El Dorado i will go some place else read more

A must go to when I come back to visit my hometown. Great pizza and cold beer. What else do u need in life?

If you are in need of a cleanse by all means, this is your place. Myself and two coworkers ate lunch here 7/27/21. All three of us ordered separate 10 inch pizzas and ALL 3 of us had diarrhea all night. read more

Best pizza ever anywhere!!! I've tried the spinach Alfredo and several different pizza places and nowhere can fix it like Main Street...and the ranch dressing is to die for!! The boss hawg pizza is amazing too bc of the homemade sauce!! No pizza like it anywhere!!!! read more

Love the cracker thin crust & cold beer! Great local place! The cheese sticks are my favorite. Enjoy visiting every time I'm in ELDO!

Nothing too special here. Great for groups. Sweet beer specials. The pizza is not bad not great... so it's safe and average. I enjoyed their special chicken pizza named after their local school. read more

Main Street Pizza - Cute - Pizza Near Me - El Dorado, Arkansas

See all

Struggling between putting one or two stars, but I guess I'm feeling generous. I've eaten here several times (every time because I was invited to meet someone there, so someone else picked....I wouldn't pick this spot) and have never been impressed. At all. By anything. The salads are big, so they have that going for them. But the toppings are limited. They shred their lettuce as opposed to pulling it...and that's a personal preference of mine. I just like my bites to be even. But big salads with shredded lettuce aren't enough to make me crave this place. If you like shredded lettuce mounded with mozzarella cheese, onions and black olives, this is your place. But don't expect much more above that. The pizzas are okay. Nothing fabulous. Just ehh. Same with the sandwiches. The service has always been tolerable, at best. The last time I was there it was like the waitress forgot we were there. I'm never overly critical of servers because I've been one and everyone has a bad day. But it's just never been good when I've visited. Drinks are always flat and syrupy. Place is dirty. I'm not sure what the draw is here and how they attract a crowd big enough to keep them in business, but maybe these other patrons are getting different service and food than I am. read more

Disappointed. Dirty. Unprofessional. $40 n received flat sodas, the pizza had little to no sauce, And the BBQ hot sub looked like sliced turkey covered with cheap bottled BBQ sauce. There was a brick oven but folks...it didn't make up for all the downfall of this place. Won't be returning. read more

See all

Ok NASTY is the word. Crust is like a very thin cracker. Dirty floors, rude staff, cook does not wear gloves and when he sticks his whole hand in to get cheese or whatever then puts hand in salad bar to grab something. TONGS people and gloves please. One would think about precautions that should be taken. I guess it's for you if you want to contract food poison or God forbid Covid then come on down. I for one will not return and they don't even deserve a star but had to put something. Totally disgusted. read more

Main Street Pizza is a great gem in El Dorado, AR. The pizza was delicious, and the salad was the best I ever had. I was visiting from Houston, TX which is home to many pizzerias. I feel Main Street is top quality. read more

Dirty, Dark and Dingy with poor service. The pizza is ok but definitely not the best. Prices are high for what you get.

Awful! I usually try to find something nice to say, but can't about this place. Wish I'd read reviews first. Too expensive for small portions. The salad I ordered was so awful I couldn't eat it. Threw it in the trash. The so- called balsamic dressing was nasty. My husbands pizza was sub par and about 6 inches across. Very "rustic" ;) and disorganized place. Never again!! read more

Best crust around. When I come through El Dorado it's almost always a stop I make. Plenty of toppings and great selections.

Waited more than five minutes before I asked one of the servers if she could take my order. She had to go get a beer. After another five minutes a server finally came by to take our order to tell us they were out of cheese. There is a difference between a hole in the wall atmosphere and an actually whole in the wall. To bad there is not a lower ranking than one star. read more

The restaurant was the filthiest restaurant I have seen. Hasn't been cleaned in years! Fans used to move air behind the counter were covered in greasy dust 1" thick. I left before ordering. They proclaim their pizzas are cooked in a brick oven. Ha Ha. Pizza oven is a run of the mill pizza oven with brich paneling surrounding it. Must not have Health and Safety enforcement in ElDorado. Place should be shuttered. read more

Food is great so sad the service and some of the staff is so rude. Had half my food left to eat and ask for another beer and was told they were closing. We had only ordered one beer. It seems to always be something at this place. Closing time is 900 and this was 8. Yes it had snowed that day but streets were clear no reason to close early. Have arrived there 40 minutes before closing time and they have refused my order. Just sad way to run a restaurant read more

The pizza is Awesome here!!! The service is horrible!!! It's best to call your order in and just take it back to your place, because your going to have to fix your drink anyway. read more

I was here several times for lunch and it's a simple place with a small menu, but the food tastes good, is reasonably priced, and the service is polite albeit not very friendly. I've been here every trip to El Dorado and haven't been disappointed. read more

It's a good place. Nothing out of the ordinary. I had the Big Porker and was Really not that big. Now my wife and daughter cheer a huge salad and they said it was good. read more

Never go in to sit and eat here. For reasons other reviewers have mentioned. I always call in and pick up. Never had a sandwich or salad from here, but pizza is decent. They don't use whey in the crust. So they have that going for them. Which is nice. read more

Sat down at a table after being told to sit anywhere, waited 10 minutes for a server to show up, none came, got up and left.