This pizza place is the best!!! I moved out to the Elmer area 3 year ago and was concerned about…read morefinding a good pizza place. I'm a bit of connoisseur when it comes to pizza. This place is great though. I've tried all of the pizza places in my area and this one is the best in my opinion. Definitely recommend!!

Friendly atmosphere. Waitress was great. Food was delicious! We ate in, but food was so good we…read moreeven took food to go. It was a drive for us, but absolutely worth it. Will definitely go back!

Papa Luigi's is more or less my go-to whenever I'm in the area. Part of that is because it's one of…read morethe only places around that feels like a real restaurant, not just a quick stop or an afterthought. You can sit down, take your time, and actually enjoy a proper meal. The food is consistently solid, the portions are generous, and the atmosphere feels comfortable and familiar. It's the kind of place you end up coming back to without really thinking about it, because you know what you're getting and it never disappoints. If you're nearby and want an actual sit-down meal instead of fast or forgettable food, Papa Luigi's is the easy choice.

The food is always good. I love the bruschetta and marg pizzas as well as the garlic or cinnamon…read moreknots. However every time I go to the restaurant the staff is always unpleasant. Unfriendly and borderline rude. I wish the staff were more pleasant so I wouldn't feel uncomfortable ordering here!

if i had a kid, it was summer, and i wanted a meal this would be the spot! pizza was hot and gooey…read more(if thats the word for it lol), buffalo tenders were a bit soggy, garlic knots were good, pulled pork was good, tbh everything was like fine! nothing to write home about. service was nice and we were the only people in there so the food was out pretty quick. it reminded me and my boyfriend of a place in our hometown that was just like fried food and a playground and ice cream lol. 3 stars was too little but 4 stars is a bit high so a generous 3.5 for tennie hut jrs. also they love some america decor!!!

This place is great for kids! Pizza was awesome they have kids "happy meals" and the outdoor play…read morearea is amazing! The staff was so welcoming and friendly. Plenty of shade and umbrellas and multiple different play areas. Will definitely be coming back!

Always enjoy getting take out from here, really convenient location. They have great daily specials…read morethroughout the week. Causal atmosphere. Quick service & staff is always friendly.

Great food, average service. We stopped by Sunday afternoon and had some slices and fries. Ordering…read morewas quick, easy. Paid. Sat down. About 20 minutes later, we had to ask for our slices (confusion behind the counter, not crowded, just poor communication). Same was true when I ordered fries. Took way too long and the order/delivery handoff was poor The food, however, was extremely good! The slices of plain and sausage were delicious! I'd stop by again, as long as I'm not in a hurry'

I came all the way from Newark, NJ to try this place because it was highly recommended. The…read moreaccolades are well deserved!!!

We've been coming here for over 20 years and still absolutely love it. It's family-run and the…read morequality is always great. Service is superb. We love Joes :)

Just moved into the area and tried this place. Wouldn't order again. I call and the first thing the…read moreman on the phone says "ma'am you're going to have to speak up I can't hear you" in a rude tone...so I spoke up and told him my order, the whole time he asked me to repeat everything I was saying because he couldn't hear me. Meanwhile I'm basically yelling my order. My order arrived and it was wrong. The food was okay. Not amazing.

Great Pizza!! Friendly staff. Large menu with great dessert available. Definitely will continue…read moregetting my pizza here

Too cheesy and not enough sauce- tastes like cafeteria pizza - acceptable on vacation but not good…read moreeven reheated. Dough is soggy. Boneless buffalo chicken is an odd texture. Meatball sub was fair.

I came in excited to experience this venue's Phish stream on Weds 7/15/26, but what I encountered…read morewas a masterclass in how not to run a bar. The moment we arrived, we were greeted by a bartender whose hostility was immediate and inescapable. His disdain for customers was so palpable that nearly every patron at the bar was openly discussing it, people were literally afraid to order drinks from him. He met every request with eye rolling contempt, as if our very presence was an imposition. Later in the night, when I ordered a drink from a different spot at the bar, he barked at me for doing so. Apparently that wasn't "how things worked here." Never mind that the bar was nearly empty and obviously unassigned seating. The pettiness was staggering. That was my breaking point. I called him out for his abusive treatment of paying customers.. Instead of addressing the obvious problem, a manager approached me with a threat: "We know how he is, but if you don't relax, you're gonna have to leave." Let that sink in. Rather than deal with a employee with an apparent pattern of hostility, they chose to intimidate a customer for voicing a legitimate complaint. Multiple patrons actually thanked me afterward, they'd endured the same treatment all night but lacked the nerve to speak up. I documented the experience on their Instagram. They deleted it immediately. This isn't a bad night...it's a culture problem. Paulie Gees has chosen protection over accountability, and their customers are the ones paying the price. I won't be back, and I'd urge others to take their business elsewhere.

Great pizza! They are from Brooklyn, so they know their pizza. It was close to our World Cup Hotel…read more You can eat in and they have a bar. I want to go back.

Chefs kiss 10/10!!! My man grew up close to here so while traveling, we went to a few of his…read morechildhood places and this place was absolutely delicious!! The sauce and the melty cheese just combined so well!!! On half of the pizza, we got sausage and pepperoni and i have never had ground sausage on a pizza that was melted under the cheese... WOW!!! Delicious!!! That brick oven flavor with the crunchy crust... man o man!!! I hope he wants to take another drip down memory lane soon just so I can have another slice. It's 5 hours away but I'll be back!!

Love Their PIZZA ! It's perfect. That's all they do is pizza and it's perfect. The sauce is the…read morebest.

great sandwiches and soups pizza is also great they have a…read moreawesome store love the inside

The food is good, the service just really leaves a lot to be desired. I waited 90 minutes for a…read moreplain pizza, salad and sandwich. I'm happy to pay the delivery fee, and tip 20% for the driver, but seriously? 90 mins is crazy.