Seeing all of Ann's horrible reviews on yelp, Google and other sites makes me feel so validated…read more I had the unfortunate experience of having one visit with Ann. She is one of the rudest condescending dismissive doctors I've ever encountered. My main doctor is Dr. O'Connell who is wonderful I had no problem with any other doctors at the practice she was one of two horrible doctors out of the 15 that are there. This woman has no business being a doctor or being around women who are having babies. She has a horrendous bedside manner and I'm going to do everything in my power to report her to patient relations at prentice and escalate even farther up. I feel so validated seeing all these other negative reviews about this horrible woman. You can clearly tell she hates her job and hates woman. She is an abusive bully

Do not seek care from Drs. Ann Starr or Stephanie Cai if you expect informed consent in your care,…read moreany level of patient autonomy, or a minimal respect & compassion from your providers. I always understood & appreciated that it is impossible to expect any birth to go according to plan. For this reason I did not have a birth plan & was generally not opposed to medical intervention. My only expectation was that medical intervention would be used with my informed consent & in the best interests of myself & my baby. In other words the bar was low & shockingly these care providers could not meet even these minimal standards of care. I was induced at 37 wks. My induction started with a foley balloon. Dr. Cai was the resident on call & Dr. Starr was the attending on call. I was only 1 cm dilated & station -2 at the start of the induction. When the balloon was removed, I measured 5.5 cm but still station -2. Dr. Cai informed me that she wanted to start pitocin & simultaneously break my water (an amniotomy). She did not inform me of any risks of pitocin or an amniotomy. I elected to start pitocin but requested delaying the amniotomy as the baby was still at station -2 & I was not experiencing any contractions. I wanted to wait until labor was further along because of the risk of infection once the water is broken. Dr. Cai appeared visibly annoyed by this request & rather than explain why she felt the need to do the amniotomy, she merely stated that she would give me another hour without the amniotomy but that Dr. Starr would likely not agree to wait any longer. Because I was still recovering from the foley balloon process, my husband had taken over this conversation with Dr. Cai. Within 45 minutes of this conversation, my husband left the room to get coffee & magically Dr. Cai appeared & started to put gloves on, informing me that she was going to do the amniotomy. She did not explain the medical necessity at this time for the amniotomy. She also did not explain the risks of an amniotomy. I asked her again if we could wait as I was still -2 & no contractions. She said that Dr. Starr was not willing to wait any longer. I asked if we could at least wait for my husband to return. Her response was "Well how long is he going to be?". I informed her that he was just getting coffee & she "generously" agreed to give him a few minutes to return (she literally said we could give him "a few minutes"). When he returned she completed the amniotomy. Again, she did not inform us of any risks of the amniotomy. An hour or so after the amniotomy, decelerations in our baby's heart rate were observed over the course of a 45 minute period. I was not aware of this until I received a copy of Dr. Cai's notes after the delivery. Without any explanation, Dr. Cai appeared & did a cervical check that was so painful I was lifting my body off of the bed & whimpering. She immediately called an emergency code. This is the first time that we were introduced to Dr. Starr. We were informed that our baby's heart rate had dropped because the umbilical cord had prolapsed (they did not explain the significance of a cord prolapse) & I needed an emergency C section to save our baby's life. An anesthesiologist informed me that I would need to be intubated for the surgery. The last thing I remember thinking is whether or not I would wake up with a healthy baby. I did not see the birth of our daughter. My husband did not see the birth of our daughter. When they whisked me away to surgery, Dr. Cai took this time to inform my husband that he needed to get all of our things out of the delivery room. Following surgery, Dr. Starr would not look me in the eyes when she nonchalantly informed me that my incision was off center & callously noted that we would never know if it was the timing of the amniotomy that resulted in the cord prolapse. A cord prolapse is a rare obstetric emergency considered to have a high rate of potential fetal morbidity & mortality. Cord prolapse is a known risk of an amniotomy that is performed when the baby is not well descended (i.e., less than 6 cm dilation & -2 station). There are numerous studies & supportive scholarly articles that have demonstrated this causal relationship. We've since learned it is best & standard practice in other hospitals to inform a patient of the increased risk of cord prolapse from an amniotomy. At my 6 week postpartum appointment, I asked for an explanation of the medical necessity for the timing of the amniotomy during my delivery. I was informed that it was merely intended to speed up labor. I was informed that drs make judgment calls with these procedures & there can be rare complications from those decisions (e.g., cord prolapse). Maternal health care in the U.S. is notoriously in crisis. I imagine that most if not all female OBs go into this practice with the hopes of leaving the field a better place than they found it. Dr. Ann Starr & Dr. Stephanie Cai are the problem not the solution.

Dr. Marino was insightful and an excellent guide, supporting me through some dramatic changes In my…read morelife. I highly recommend her.

She's obviously a smart woman based on our brief conversation over the phone, but when I arrived at…read moreher office I knocked on the door, because I couldn't see through it I didn't know there was a waiting room and I didn't want to barge in if it led to her office and she was with a patient. I walk in and she comes out of her office saying "aren't you anxious?" She asked me why I knocked and then gestured sarcastically and said "can't you see we have a waiting room?" I left and will speak to someone else. It was hard enough to muster up the courage to speak to a complete stranger about my problems, agree to pay cash, and then be met with someone who isn't welcoming or understanding at all. I'm a full grown man and I'm not a pussy but I don't need that shit, of course I'm anxious why on earth do you think I'm here lady? I'm really bummed out about it because I wanted to talk to someone and she didn't even introduce herself or say nice to meet you.

I was a new patient seeing Dr. Seema Venkatachalam - Malkani from the Northwest Specialists for…read moreWomen. And unfortunately, I was running 10 minutes late due to an accident on the xpressway. So, when I checked in, the office staff receptionist (Bethany) bluntly asked, "Did you call to let anyone know that you were going to be late for your appointment?" Well, I didn't think that 10 minutes was a big deal. So, "No, I did not". Her rude response was, "Well, I am not sure that the Dr. will be able to see you." So, I thought ... WOW!!! This is not a place that welcomes new patients nor is customer service friendly in ANY way. In this day and age where a patient can go to ANY doctor, it would make sense to treat your patients with a decent "bedside manner" versus an initial condescending attitude -- it would probably be a better approach. Bethany then gets on the phone as if to make a phone call and proceeds to start to talking (without looking at me). So, after she is almost done with her long rant, I then ask "Are you talking to me? I thought that you were talking to someone else because I wasn't sure why you would be on phone (and not even look at me, or get my attention) when you want me to hear what you are saying?" Again... HOW RUDE!! I'm not sure where Bethany learned her "receptionist skills", but she definitely needs some more in-servicing. Bethany then proceeds to continue her line of questioning to ask me if I brought my paperwork with me to which I responded: "I'm sorry. I don't remember getting any paperwork. Did you send me something because No, I didn't bring anything." Her response is that the scheduling people usually tell patients to go on-line to download the paperwork. Lesson #2 for Bethany = It would make sense to email patients a link for paperwork or send them the PDF file of paperwork to make it easy for them to do whatever it is that they are supposed to do. I'm a pretty compliant patient, being an RN myself. So, I would have no problems filling out the paperwork ahead of time rather than rudely belittling me, again.... I too would like to be seen expeditiously, and I respect that doctors are busy as well. So, make it easy for both of us!! Now I am frustrated. I tell her that I don't want to fill out the paperwork unless the doctor is able to see me. She makes a few phone calls and can't get any answers, leaves the desk, and returns to say that the doctor will see me and to have a seat. After 15 minutes, Bethany calls me back to the desk to let me know that the doctor is NOT able to see me now. Really?? Lesson #3 for Bethany = Don't lie to your patients. It doesn't give them a sense of comfort to know that staff just make up stuff without asking the doctor directly. THEN... she proceeds to ask me if I'd like to make another appointment to see the doctor. SERIOUSLY?? The only reason that I was willing to switch OB-GYN doctors is because my friend made the recommendation. (That is the best form of advertisement -- FREE!). With the multitude of doctors available in the Chgoland area, I would definitely go elsewhere and steer clear of this organization, unless you want to be treated in a demeaning manner. I too worked in a few surgeons' and doctor's offices. And not ONCE did I make anyone feel not welcomed. I realize patients are late. And Doctors are late for a multitude of reasons too. It happens. That's part of life. There's no need to be rude!

She rushed my birth, broke my water when I was only at 4 cm, baby got jammed the wrong way in the…read morebirth canal. Them she performed a csection which left me with a deformed scar and permanent nerve damage. She never once checked on me during my 6 day stay in the hospital or gave me a referral for treating the nerve damage. Hands down the worst experience I have had with a doctor. She needs to find another profession. I should note I was able to have all my 3 other children vaginally after I switched off from this butcher.

Dr. Bicalho is the best doctor I have ever had. I have been going to her for 10 years and am so…read morehappy with her service. She is so helpful, informative, and caring regardless of the situation or questions I come in with. If you are looking for a OBGYN look no further. Before she was my doctor (when I was in my teens and early 20s) I had always dreaded these appointments. She makes every patient feel comforted and taken care of. I am so thankful to have her as my doctor and will be going to her forever.

I feel like Dr Bicalho is a very competent doctor... With a horrible bedside manner. Her office is…read morealways terribly busy and for this she is always rushing in and rushing out. Take a breath to ask another question and she is gone. During my last annual visit, I apparently had a minor infection. I learned this when Walgreens called to tell me my prescription was ready. Even after I called the office, I received no apologies and no one seemed to know what was going on. My other major complaint is how she handled me during a time period when I had a serious and very painful pelvic problem that still needed diagnosing. She treated me like a child who was exaggerating a minor wound and then gave me a precautionary tale of opiate abuse. Then as she exited the room, she very nonchalantly asked if I had seen my psychiatrist (you have one, right?) about the "pain". First of all the pain was real and a not a manifestation of a psychiatric problem, second of all, I think it is a highly unprofessional way of deducing information from a patient. I don't have a psychiatrist! (So nope, havent seen him/her) But in that one misguided sentence I understood how she felt about me and my supposed pain. I have since been diagnosed with a very real, very painful disorder that could have even been " caught" by her MONTHS before (Fully within her scope of practice). The pieces of a great Dr are all there, but for some reason, at least with me, they just don't click.

I have never come across a more competent, caring and friendly doctor than Sigal Klipstein, M.D…read more She has the best bed-side manner of anyone I have encountered. She has a degree in medical ethics as well so she is capable of advising on a variety of issues associated with reproductive assistance. The practice is growing and they are refining their processes, with a beautiful new office in Deerfield. The nursing staff is kind and knowledgeable, including helping to navigate insurance pitfalls. We had seen several other Repro offices and this one is by far the best, in large part because of Dr. Klipstein.

At my visit I was informed it was to be my last. Dr. Rosenzweig was closing his small private…read morepractice because of the Covid 19 pandemic; he was going into semi retirement. This was before any vaccine was in the works. He was one of four doctors I lost around that time. The office mngr. made sure I had access to 14 yrs. of medical records and referred me to another Urogynecologist that had trained under Dr. R.

Dr. Rosenzweig has gone above and beyond to identify what is going on with my gynecology issues…read more His office staff and nurse are always welcoming. When I call to ask questions, I get to speak to the doctor directly. I never have to wait. I would recommend him to anyone.

Dr. Wehrmann is adequate as a doctor, but her office is completely incompetent…read more Her office ordered my wife to get a routine ultrasound and blood test but it turns out that they sent her to the incorrect hospital. What's more, they failed to write a formal referral. Now we are stuck with medical bills in excess of $1,000 that insurance will not pay due to their administrative error. We don't have the resources to pay this bill so as a result our credit will be ruined for years. What's worse is that her office has failed to take any responsibility for this situation or provide assistance in any way. Instead, they turn around and blame us for their mistake. This behavior is abhorrent. Our advice: stay far away from this doctor's office. There are plenty of doctors available who are at least able to run a competent operation. After all, if you cannot rely on your doctor to take care of the simplest and most routine paperwork, how can you have any faith that the doctor will competently care for your health or the health of your child?

I went to Dr. Wehrmann for an annual exam after my insurance switched and I couldn't go to my…read moreprevious gynecologist anymore. It was very in and out (the whole thing took about 30 minutes including filling out new patient paperwork, waiting in the waiting and exam rooms, and the actual exam). It was totally routine, so I can't rate a complicated/problematic visit, but for a typical yearly exam, it was great! Dr. Wehrmann is very nice, professional, and speedy! I'll be back, but hopefully not until next year. :)

Dr. Mullen has been my primary care physician since I moved to this city in 2005. She is smart,…read morekind, and considerate, and most of all she *remembers* me. It really DOES mean a lot that she doesn't have to consult my chart to remember any part of my medical history. She spends time with her patients--I don't feel hurried or minimized. I cannot recommend her enough.

Dr. Mullan's expertise and common sense approach to patient care has literally saved my wife's…read morelife. My wife had a stroke at age 50 and was wasting away due, in my opinion, in part to her previous health care providers apparently viewing her as a lost cause. Dr. Mullan accurately diagnosed my wife's issues and then addressed them systematically. I agree with previous poster's characterization that Dr. Mullan is " wonderful, smart, caring, & thoughtful". We also utilize Dr. Mullan's on call associates from time to time & they have been very competent & helpful. The current office staff seems fine to me and the receptionist for last 3+ years is cheerful and courteous.