Extremely Poor Property Management Experience - Fort Myers Marshall Reddick did a very poor job managing my property in Fort Myers. I relocated to California for work (RTO) and left the property in August, giving Marshall Reddick full authorization to manage everything--including tenant placement and payment of utility bills. This was by far the most horrifying property management experience I've had, and I own properties managed in other states. Over several months, I was instructed to reduce my rent five separate times due to what they claimed was a "poor market," yet the company changed real estate agents 3-4 times without my consent. Each time, they failed to run the live Facebook marketing campaign they had explicitly promised. Most alarming, I was later informed that power to the property had been shut off for three weeks before Marshall Reddick notified me. I was told this occurred due to a lack of funds, and only after the prolonged outage was I informed of a potential microbial growth issue--a serious risk to the property that should have been addressed immediately. Despite providing a 30-day notice for non-performance, Marshall Reddick ignored the notice entirely and continued to demonstrate a complete lack of accountability, communication, and urgency. This experience showed a complete disregard for: Basic property oversight Timely communication Tenant placement execution Utility management Owner fiduciary responsibility I would strongly caution any property owner--especially those managing remotely--before trusting Marshall Reddick with their investment. read more

I've had a great experience with the Florida branch of Marshall Reddick so far. They've been responsive to my requests and proactive around lease renewals. There has been a lot of turnover recently, but generally the staff has been pretty easy to work with read more

I've truly appreciate the support and experience Tyler Daigler and Marshall Reddick provide as a property management firm. They are always available for any question or request. You can be rest assured you will have complete peace of mind knowing they are in your corner taking care of everything. read more

We've have been with Marshall Reddick for many years now and happy with the service. Nick has been very thorough and always responsive. Definitely recommend!! read more

I recommend anyone that needs a property manager go with Marshall Reddick. They are always responsive, immediately solve any issues that arise and overall a pleasure to deal with. They have one of the lowest commissions and I trust them 100% they will do the right thing in my best interest. My property is in Florida and I live in NY, I haven't had any problems where I lose any sleep. Thank you Marshall Reddick! read more

Nick has been such an invaluable property manager and thought partner for me. He is punctual, professional, and comprehensive, with a structured agenda and itemized advice each time we chat. I am grateful to have him and the broader Marshall Reddick team at my side - it's truly made for a collaborative experience, especially given I ask so many questions and tend to be meticulous with my units. read more

Our duplex is being managed by Marshall Reddick. The property manager and staff at Cape Coral are excellent and top-notch. They are transparent, communicate clearly and solve problems quickly. If you do not want to worry about your property, Marshall Reddick Real Estate is the one you want to hire, and I highly recommend them. read more

My husband and I rented a home in North Port for 2 years. We paid the first year rent infull and when we bought a house I notified them 90 days out to ask if I could terminate our lease 18 days early and they said you can leave and send the keys but I still had to pay for the 18 days. I put in a maintenance request on February 23 2024 and after multiple attempts to get it fixed and multiple text messages and pictures finally on May 28 2024 Rodgers said someone was going to call me. By the end of June it was fixed. When it was time to get our deposit back they charged us $115 for a wand on the slider door for wear and tear. You can buy this for $10 at Home Depot. They also said my dog chewed the blinds and when they sent pictures there were no teeth marks just fake wood blinds. So they kept another $430 dollars. They are just money grabbing people who don't care about anything but their pockets and shame on the owner as well. DO NOT USE THEM!!!! read more

Rented for 3 years, completed lease. Never late on any payment. Got unit touched up and painted, deep cleaned; Marshall Reddick still came back and held deposit for painting and other bogus charges. They automatically charge every tenant a cleanup charge. They avoid painting between tenants by getting them to touch up. Tried to reach local agents, Cape Coral, Florida and corporate, no calls returned. Just letter holding deposit and requesting additional funds to repaint unit and items already done! Used Lindseys Handyman, LLC to give estimates, who also gets additional job. A complete racket. If you can find another vendor, try them. This company won't stand behind their customers or their word! Reporting to BBB. They have time to answer a review, but mo time to call customer back with support. read more

YOU are liars! I tell everyone to not rent or buy. Your house are full of roaches from the previous tenants and when we move out, you say we are responsible. Your lease states the renter is liable for everything? The lease is ridiculous, these homes are already a wreck. Your place are a wreck! your lawn guy doesn't come but 1 time a month and doesnt even run the weed eater. You say you pump tanks and its a lie i had cameras and i recorded and getting a lawyer!!! I even talk to the plumber and he said they did not pump! Im suing Scott Kolland, You say tenant is responsible for air if the filter is dirty? how about you service the AC on the outside and service the water systems!! Thats why we did NOT renew yall suck!!! My toilets ran over for a week before you even acted!! and basically said me and the other tenant were nasty to put junk down the toilets, when I asked the neighbor she said tank wasnt pumped like 4 years ago, so how could that have included me? it would have been the neighbor and the tenant before me!! Nothing in that place works!! Put in new toilets after a week of it leaking on my furniture? Mymom deep cleaned my apt that they state was already deep cleaned! it had roaches and want it to NOT have roaches after i left? read more

I decided to use Marshall Reddick for my rental properties after assessing their overall reviews which were good. Keep in mind, most of them are for purchasing properties. On February 7, 2024, I spoke with Chris which was very responsive and professional, he was exactly the kind of person I like doing business with. I explained to him that I am remote in California, and need a reliable and responsive company, which I thought he was a representation of. Unfortunately past that nothing went smooth. I waited days for Lydia, the property manager to get back to me. Even though she's very knowledgeable but urgency is not her priority. I still appreciated her as she was very knowledgeable. The property became available on February 27. However, the maintenance manager Jennifer did not put a lock box on the property until March 1. At that point I already lost 3 days there. Then I waited for the maintenance manager two days to get there to assess the property. I waited another 3 days for her to send me a report. She told me she will have the reports on Monday, but I didn't get them until Friday!!!. Finally we were able to assign a contractor to start the minor renovations on Tuesday March 12 so we can put it on the market by March 15th. I had my appliance guy go there on March 12th to repair the oven and Trough him I found out that the contractors never showed up!!! After at least 10 phone calls and texts to the maintenance manager Jennifer, she finally got back after I sent Email CCing Chris and Lydia,. She told me that she will call me back to find out what happened. She called back and told me that she never provided me a timeline what time they would start. I clearly know that she said first thing on Tuesday and it was already past 2 PM! I want to know which contractor starts at 3 PM? She clearly dropped the ball and didn't even apologize and pointed the fingers at me. Consequently, I received a call from Chris that they decided not to represent me. This was end of the day March 12 and I had to start from Ground Zero. I would never consider working with them. I wasted one and a half months and my nerves trying to get things done remotely! I asked Chris if I could use the same contractor as I already had lost a lot of time. he gave me the OK. To my surprise after the contractor originally agreed to work directly with me, stopped responding to my calls or texts. I reached out to the second contractor as I had gotten two quotes. The second contractor agreed to start right away, but then texted my new Management Company that she's turning down the job. After what this company made me go through and losing time the minimum they could do is just letting the contractor finish the job but clearly they interfered. This was such a bad experience I can't even describe. If you have a lot of time on your hand, and a lot of money to waste, you should maybe try them otherwise, do not expect from them to go above and beyond. You will be very disappointed. read more

I've had two positive experiences with Marshall Reddick, one purchase, one refi. Both times the team was clear and concise communicating the lending process. They were efficient and delivered on their funding commitment. Having tried other lenders, I will go to Marshall Reddick first on future deals. read more

Marshall Reddick Real Estate - Real Estate Agents Near Me - Cape Coral, Florida

Excellent customer service from Levi Mondoza and Stephanie Miller from the private lending department! They are both very knowledgeable, very responsive and easy to work with. Most importantly, they helped me close on an investment property on time! Thank you very much! read more

I was able to cash out refinance my rental property in Middleburg, Florida with the use of the Marshall Reddick Real Estate private mortgage fund. It's difficult for me to do conventional financing because I am self-employed so my tax returns are negative. Marshall Reddick private mortgage fund really helped me out when I needed it to get cash out of my rental property. read more

I rented a brand new home from this company. The house had no blinds on any of the windows and they would not allow the maintenance order for an individual to come in to put blinds on all the windows. It was a total of eight windows. I had to purchase all of the blinds and then when I moved out I refused to replace them as I paid for them. This company intern took $250 from my security deposit for the cost of blinds that I paid for in the first place. When I reached out to the company and sent an email or proof of payment that I paid for them I got no response and when I was going to the office mysteriously no one is available. I will never ever recommend this company and that's just a few things that I went through dealing with this specific management company. read more

I had the best real estate experience with Terry Duffy who specialize in Florida real estates. She's is very knowledgeable and patient. Not only she provided exceptional service, but also she truly cares about her customers. I can't wait for our home to close and start our next purchase with her. Thank you for all that you do. read more

I have completed six successful investments with Marshall Reddick since 2017. I am looking forward to funding the seventh project with the team this week. Everything has gone smoothly per the terms of our agreements. The staff is patient, professional, available and quick to respond when I call or email questions. I am extremely pleased with Marshall Reddick and their services. Sincerely, R W Taylor read more

I've been a borrower from Marshall Reddick flipping properties in FL now for two years. They'll always helped me secure financing in a smooth, professional, and timely manner. Their rates are pretty competitive in the industry. Patrick, April, and the rest of the private lending team are extremely helpful and knowledgeable on what they do. Also, their sales team is very insightful of the market, and have always had my best interest at heart... the same goes for their property management team; they helped my locate areas in high demand and messy areas to stay away from. I would highly recommend speaking to Marshall Reddick for any real estate related needs. It's refreshing to work with such professionals and knowing they always have my back!! read more

Terry Duffy helped me 5 years ago to purchase my first out-of-state investment property in Cape Coral, she is definitely a local expert. And she helped me again this year to sell it, more than doubled my initial investments. It's really a great experience working with Terry. read more

Friendly, professional and responsive property management Co. Aisy and team in the Cape Coral FL office have been great to work with. Pro-active and on top of issues including renewals read more

Marshall Reddick is a top notch service. Especially Levi Mondoza. He's friendly and professional. More importantly he gets the job done. Fantastic company to deal with! read more

Renters stay clear. They take your application and fees after already selecting a resident for the property you are asking them to consider you for. There are many of us fallen victim the the predatory business model. If I can save one more person the frustration I am glad to write this review. read more

Terry Duffy was awesome to work with. Would recommend her in a heartbeat to anyone looking to buy in FL

Jennifer Wagoner has been instrumental along with Aisy Strait in managing my property. The MR team is the best in the business and look forward to working with them again!!! read more

Marshall Reddick is SO easy to work with! User-friendly portal to start-and-maintain your loans, and everyone is extremely helpful. Especially Stephanie, she has been a true pleasure to work with. You won't be disappointed with Marshall Reddick, get started with them now! read more

Being an out of state investor requires somebody in the area that knows the local market. We have worked with Terry and the team at the Marshall Reddick office Cape Coral on other investment properties in the past and have always been very helpful. Have meet Terry and the team at MR events pre COVID, always full of enthusiasm and answer all your questions. Currently have another rental under contract and will continue to invest in the area as long as it makes financial sense. Thank you to the whole team there at MR Cape Coral. read more

Marshall reddick is the best company to work with. i was looking to rent and i only had 4 weeks to move and Jamie who's a real estate agent went above and beyond to help me find the right place, she was the best person I ever met in the real estate business, if you ever need help renting a place go to Marshall reddick and ask for Jamie, she is the best. read more

Terry Duffy was an absolute pleasure to work with in Florida. She was knowledgeable, quick on answering any questions, compared options in neighborhood and always fighting foe what is best for her client. She is trustworthy and I would highly recommend her!! Just closed on one house...one more in July! read more

Obtaining financing was a fast process under the 2 weeks ,and a great experience working with Marshall Reddick and the private lender I will definitely recommend them all to others. Transactions used to be hectic and rarely on time, but with Marshall Reddick, they always have everything together to close on or before the target date. I love working with them in my investments properties. April and Stephanie help us make our transactions as smooth as possible. Thank you all to all the team involved in this transaction and ensuring fast closings." read more

Marshall Reddick has helped me flip many houses, I could not recommend this company more to help you on your real estate ventures. They only want to see you be successful and build your portfolio. read more

Aisy and staff are great at communicating issues at the property and take a personalized approach towards ensuring your property is operating at an optimum level. They are very responsible to my requests and no problems responding to me during "off" hours. read more

Marshall Reddick manages one of my properties in California and they have been great! I brought them onto my investment team to replace another property manager who was doing a poor job, and Marshall Reddick stepped in and immediately gave me faith in managers again! More recently, I invested in a home in Florida, and a big reason was because I bought in a place Marshall Reddick has an office. The Marshall Reddick team in Cape Coral helped me with final walk thru after my new construction home was built, took care of rent-ready repairs needing to be made, and leased the home in just days after I closed on the home. With their help, I was able to build a home from scratch and have renters in, without ever visiting Cape Coral! Marshall Reddick in Cape Coral are easily accessible, they have a great team, each person specializing in a particular part of the process, and they communicate very well to keep owners aware of every step along the way. I would recommend them for anyone looking to buy either a primary or investment home. Best managers (and beyond) ever! read more

I've worked with Terry Duffy on several properties already. She has excellent work ethics. I'm very happy with my purchases in the Cape Coral area. Another big plus is Marshall Reddick real estate is also managing my property.... which is great because finding somebody that you can trust to manage your property is just as hard as finding somebody you can trust when buying a property. You will make money using them however just remember this is a long-term investment and not a short-term. read more

When it comes to property management no one beats Travis Decere's team at Marshall Reddick! Thank you Travis for taking such good care of our duplex in SW Cape Coral! read more

Do not rent from these people. They will never come out to your house to fix any problems and if they do they will come with the wrong parts or clueless as to how to fix the problem. My husband had to fix any problem that occurred because of these people. When the hot water is on the lights flicker. I complained several times over the two years and it never got fixed. When I called about a water heater that broke they asked where in the garage is it located. We don't have a garage. When they sent someone out after the weekend he came with the wrong part. They won't fix anything and when you move out they will literally suck you dry of your money. They charged us for things that were never in the house to begin with! Worst place I have ever rented from. The woman that answers the phone is extremely rude. Do not rent form these people!!! read more

I don't do many reviews, but I wanted to let everyone know that the realtor we're working with, Terry Duffy, through MR is awesome! She's always readily available by phone or text despite her very busy schedule. Terry goes above and beyond for her clients. We're out of state investors and she would make sure to visit the site with pictures on the progress of the construction as well as a video of the walk thru. She's personable and gets things done. It's a tough time right now because of COVID. Everything is delayed by months, but she manages to allay our worries. Thanks Terry for always being there for us! read more

My father suddenly got sick at the beginning of 2022. My parents live in Fort Myers, FL and I live Los Angeles. After a few months of going back and forth getting his diagnosis and prognosis, our family determined it was best to move my parents into an assisted living facility in July very quickly. I was my job to move my parents then clear the house out, make it rental ready, advertise, screen and secure tenants, all while not being from the area and all while taking care of my dying father and overwhelmed mother. Well without Aisy Strait, Maureen Mitchell and their team at Marshall Reddick that wouldn't have been possible. From the first meeting, Aisy brought all the right people I needed to see to make me feel confident the job was going to get done quickly and get done right. Once we were able to finally clear out and the work was completed the house never looked better. (Thanks Steven and Juan!) Then Maureen took over to find tenants. Right off the bat, Maureen communicated with me back and forth nonstop and within a week or so we had applicants lined up. By the way, did I mention the end of this project was during and after a hurricane? That's right, Aisy and Maureen were not only able to survive a hurricane themselves personally but they were able to get our house renovated, listed and rented also during it with limited resources. To say they are consummate professionals and I owe them tremendous thanks is an understatement. I have thoroughly enjoyed working with Aisy and Maureen and look forward to continuing our successful relationship for years to come. Thanks read more

Marshall Reddick manages two of my properties in the Cape Coral/Fort Myers area. I am an out-of-state investor and rely heavily on a solid on-the-ground management team. Both properties were already managed by Marshall Reddick when I bought them, and the transition was seamless. My property manager (Aisy) is always responsive and as an out-of-state investor, the team provided invaluable information during the greatest challenge I have faced in over 10 years as an investor: Hurricane Ian. The maintenance team has a network of contractor relationships and deals with issues quickly. Accounting/record-keeping is streamlined and easy for investors. I hope to continue to work with Marshall Reddick for years to come. read more

The team is very responsive to tenants and owners, quick turns on vacancies. Timothy and Anais were great to work with on a turnover, very responsive and professional. Very assuring for an owner who is not local. read more

I have had long lasting recurring issues with my rentals who have not perform well but Cynthia has taken over 6 months ago. I can't say it has been without challenges and it took time to build trust and recognition but she is knowledgeable, dedicated, responsive and seem to be on the top of it. I am starting to see encouraging and positive changes resulting of her handwork. read more