5 star experience! I think bartender is DAN, but I'm not 100% sure on his name. I asked him to smile for a photo for me. Upon arriving he was friendly and went out of his way to see if they had a specific wine I wanted. (It was a long shot, but he tried and it was appreciated) He kept checking in on us to see if we wanted anything else. He even redid another pumpkin rim sugar glass half way through my beer! This bartender was ON IT. I wasn't expecting to get such great service from this dive bar (I considered this a dive bar because I used to frequent when I was younger). Super impressed coming in 15 years later. Bathroom was clean too. All around, giving 5 stars! read more

See all

Great local pub in the heart of Babylon. I've been coming here over 20 years and each time is a great experience.

This is truly a special place, service is phenomenal all around, staff is great especially the bathroom attendant Stephen he truly went above and beyond to make my experience something I will never forget. read more

A spacious and clean Irish pub dive bar. Coming in at 4:30pm on a rainy Saturday, two gentlemen at the bar were attentive and welcoming. Menus for food are QR code, but we weren't really sure about specialty drink selection if they had one. Then again it's a dive bar. Lots of draft options. We put in food which came out pretty quickly. Though you pick it up from this small window where the lower the food to you in the dining area. The flat bread was more like a burrata and bruschetta on toast? The name of the app is misleading though the description is right. The fried pickles were SO delicious. Crunchy, not too greasy, and there was a generous portion. Highly recommend. No frills. Exactly what you expect. read more

Mary Carroll's - Burrata Flatbread - Bars Near Me - Babylon, New York

See all

Friendly fun place to go with friends. Bartenders were attentive and friendly and the crowd was a nice mix of all ages.

While babylon village has ample bars/pubs/restaurants to suit just about everyone's tastes, only 1 has a place that stays open late! Metered parking on Deer Park Ave in front- municipal lot behind. All the wood n such gives the inside a bit of a cabin/lodge feel. During warm weather months, an outdoor area and "back bar" to address the overflow. *was there for post Pride event- last summer and this place was jammed! Local bar feel and vibe, lots of locals and as stated, late night hours draw in a younger crowd so us "mature" folk who may not want to be surrounded by 20sumthins be advised. However, a great spot to catch your favorite sports teams on the tube, plenty of televisions to croon your neck at. Full bar and lots of taps. Decent pub fare as well. Priced accordingly and clean. read more

See all

A friend and I went for a happy hour and appetizers night. We were immediately greeted by the bartender. Drinks were promptly served and food was ready quickly. The food tasted fresh and was delicious. We had such a great time. I love the decor of this place and the old bar stools. There are tons of seating options and the staff is so friendly!! read more

Great for late night bites. Typical bar food menu. The mozzarella sticks weren't as great as I hoped, the cheese just didn't seem to melt. The calamari was good. I wouldn't recommend coming here for just food but overall it is a great bar to have some drinks at. read more

Mary Carroll's - Mozzarella Sticks - Bars Near Me - Babylon, New York

See all

After a long day of work, this is a great spot for friends to hang out, the drink selection is adequate, and the bartender is friendly. read more

Mary Carroll's - Bar area - Bars Near Me - Babylon, New York

See all

This place claims the friendliest bartender and lives up to the claim. The decor is charming and comfy. Patrons were excitedly watching the Mets advance in the playoffs this evening. There is a nice selection on the menu, something for all tastes. The food was amazing. Highly recommend this place. read more

Yeah, well, come hate us on Yelp is their motto and I know why people do but you go to scary Mary's when the nights winding down to give it a bit of a shock to the system, or you go for the wings or your bartenders or just for some good wholesome fun. I just like that you can poo inside of a giant Guinness glass when needed. read more

See all

To start off you must first encounter Louisa and Anthony who are the sweetest couple you would ever meet. They both helped me scan in and get a free drink. On top of that when ordering the bartender was very nice and helpful. After enjoying a free drink on them I was inclined to get some food. I enjoyed the fried pickles and mozzarella sticks. Both items were delicious and was very hot! I will definitely be going back only because the sweetest couple I have ever met spoke so highly of the bar and its patrons. Being that they are regulars that enjoy the ambiance the bar provides for great service for food and drink I would only go back knowing I would encounter them or people like them again. The read more

Best fish and chips in town and shepherds pie the pretzels are awesome The service is great. Dan is the best bartender. read more

Mary Carroll's - Best fish and chips in town - Bars Near Me - Babylon, New York

See all

We came here for a late night to meet up with friends to grab some drinks for a friend's birthday. Mary Carroll's has that laid back bar feel where the locals hang out. Friends and family meet up to chill and grab a few beers. We stayed more towards the front of the bar where there is hightop tables across from the bar. The are three sections of beer on tap at the bar. So the selection has a good variety. Not sure what to get? The bartender can give you suggestions based on your usual drink of choice. They are friendly and happy to help. I haven't tried the food, so I can not say how it is. We came early in the night, but as the night got longer the crowd started to roll in. Overall it's a good place to grab a beer and catch up with friends. read more

Mary Carroll's - What's on tap - Bars Near Me - Babylon, New York

I wish I could like this place on just the Bavarian Pretzels alone. I usually order a pretzel to be delivered from DoorDash but this time i decided to have a drink and the bar and eat the pretzel there. As soon as I walked in I could smell something rancid and sour. I'm not sure if the beer lines need to be cleaned or the whole place needs a deep cleaning. I was with a friend and since we were already there my friend wanted to stay for 1 drink. The bartender was very friendly and accommodating. We ordered a glass of wine each and a pretzel. The wine glasses had spots on them and the wine tasted terrible. The pretzel came out quickly and was hot and fresh. The beer cheese was melted to perfection. I tried the wine again since I had food to try and mask the awful taste after each sip but could only finish 1/3rd of the glass. We left after devouring the pretzel and paying the bill. I didn't feel so great once I got home and wound up throwing up the wine and pretzel. I'd definitely order the pretzel again but I'll stick to wine at my own home. read more

I love what they did for outdoor seating. A bunch of sand dumped out back for a beach feel. The umbrellas are good shade. There wasn't any waitstaff, so you just go up to the bartender inside with a mask on and order drinks and food through him. The sangria and the bourbon lemonade were so delicious and refreshing. Plenty of alcohol in both of them for a nice buzz and not over the top drunk. There was a customer who brought his golden retriever, as dogs are allowed in the sand. He was SOOO cute!!!! So much fun to pet a dog when there is alcohol involved LOL read more

I love Mary Carroll's. I just wish the bathroom situation was better and I still wish they'd bring back their garlic butter fries!

Long Guuuyyland Pub. Clientele is the average "Mike" having a social gathering, on a pub crawl or just looking to get wickey wriggity wrecked! It might take a while to get a drink certain nights but the bartenders are all friendly, especially the ladies that work there who let me try a bunch of different things when I just wasn't in the mood for a beer (and had to drive everyone). Overall selection of drinks was OK. If you're hungry - Order food at the bar and wait for it to drop from the ceiling by a member of the kitchen staff that gives you the ole stink eye. Quality of food is what you'd expect of a neighborhood pub. The more you drink, the better it tastes, I suppose! Open late with ample room inside for your drunk antics before you stumble back to the train. read more

Best pretzel on long island! Devoured it all and left no crumbs, if you ain't get this you're doing it wrong read more

Mary Carroll's - Beat pretzel on Long Island!!! Ate the whole thing and left no crumbs! Must come on down for one - Bars Near Me - Babylon, New York

I had ordered food at this place 4 times a week for the last year or so. They never pick up their phone and you have to call them 25 times for anyone to pickup, if they even do that. I got so tired of doing that i started using uber eats. Terrible customer service i will never be eating here again. read more

It's a pretty good bar in the heart of Babylon Village. They have some local brews on tap, as well as a beer garden. The food options are much improved from the early years. Good place for happy hour or late nights. It gets pretty crowded on weekends. read more

decided to come to mary carroll's for my birthday as it seemed pretty laid back. me and some friends got there around 8ish (as im getting to be quite a grandma and love to get home before midnight). there were a few groups but nothing too busy. the bartenders were all friendly and all my drinks were made well and quickly. i also tried their disco fries which were exceptionally good (but i was also pretty tipsy at that point)! i cant speak to how busy it gets later on in the night but if youre looking for a bar to start your night, this is it. only downside, as another reviewer stated, the bathroom situation is not great. the tiniest bathrooms and almost never have toilet paper. as long as you dont go to the bathroom often, this is a great chill bar read more

I have been a patron of Mary's for about 3 years and it hads always been amazing service. One time I had a little too much to drink and I made a mistake by taking a beer from the tap on the side of the bar. I understand that I made a mistake but the amount of disrespect that the bar tender Francis has given is unforgivable. I have gone in 3 times and tried to talk to a manager or someone in charge but every time I go in Francis has prevented me from apologizing. He has thrown me out before I am able to speak to a manager / owner to reconcile the prior incident. I have tried to pay for the beers that I took and have offered compensation for the beers that I mistakenly took but my offer has fallen on deaf ears. I would like to talk to the owner / manager of this establishment but I keep getting the runaround every time I go in. If the owner / manager sees this please contact me at noahr666222@gmail.com read more

If you want absolutely no service and have to go fetch your own food then this place is for you. I can see this being a fun place to just get drunk with other young 20 somethings but it's not the place to go for dinner. I got boneless wings that were so dry and the breading was hard to bite through. I also got disco fries but the gravy was bland and the fries were a strange cut. My husband got the steak sandwich which he thought was good but it's been so long since we've been out to eat so he was probably desperate. I would definitely recommend Lily Flanagan's, Local, or Babylon burger bar over this. I wish this place had better food since I follow them on Instagram and they seem to be very pro Babylon village businesses but I think they need to spend more time on improving their menu and food quality for me to support them. read more

4 stars.. but a five star pretzel!!!! Im a local out here and the best pretzel is from this bar, a must try

It's such a great late night bar to meet new people! The only problem is the bartenders are the biggest cock blockers I've ever seen in the bar business. TBH I'd probably do the same if I was in their shoes and could get away with it. read more

Open late and the kitchen stays open later then most other bars in Babylon. I was able to order wings at 3am. I suggest the hickory smoked bbq wings. But the sweet chili wings where delicious also. read more

Mary Carroll's - Bars Near Me - Babylon, New York

Came for a nice time during the Saint Patrick's parade celebration and was greeted with a $20 cover. Totally ridiculous! Nothing special for the cover, won't be coming back. Going to spread the word read more

You know your night has taken a turn for the worst when you end up at Mary's. This bar is for the late night crowd (although it is nice that they are open so late). The space is large, so it's good for a group and there's a bit of outdoor seating in the alleyway behind the building. Drinks are standard, the crowd is not the best, and the bathrooms are so so small. If you know what you're in for, Mary's does the job. If not, be warned. read more

This bar looks as one would expect an authentic bar from Ireland to look. It only gets my two stars because of its authenticity and decor. The owner comes straight from Ireland. The crowd is typical mostly regular drunks who are loud and smoke. The food is all fried bar foods-what you'd expect of a bar. Not the place to go for a wholesome family meal though. The bartenders are knowledgeable as most of them have been there for quite some time. They don't do any activities here but they have sports on TV when appropriate and feature big pull down screens out back. read more

The beach style seating in the parking lot was nice, but the food was very expensive for what you got. But you have to make money especially during covid. I have good pre covid memories here, so I'll give 4 stars. read more

I couldn't believe what I saw when I arrived.... the bar is Bee infested and the staff was making excuses for the filth as if it's okay to eat in a dirty bug infused area. Take your pick the dirty sand box in the back parking lot or sticky tables inside with bees stinging you. I am giving this 1 star because my Chicken Caesar wrap was bomb and the chef deserves it. I now understand why the Huntington location was shut down. A bad ran business is visible in any town. read more

Holly is the best bartender! Made me a delicious pineapple martini!! She is very polite and friendly and helped me pick out a drink I liked! Would definitely recommend this bar if you're in Babylon village! read more

Mary Carroll's - Bars Near Me - Babylon, New York

I was visiting here from DC. I accidentally spilled my first drink after immediately getting it and I asked the bartenders to replace it. One of them laughed at me and kept my card and made me pay for it. I then asked the other bartender if he would replace it and he immediately ignored me. They are rude. I was a bartender for 7 years. It was my first drink of the night. 14$ they charged me for nothing. I wouldn't recommend. They treated me like dirt. read more

Great selection of spirits and beer, but their food menu is limited and shortcutted. Clientele gets rowdy and crowded in the evening (which is expected). Nice place during the day, but not the best experience in the evening. Food options are limited, and all fried. read more

Mary Carroll's - Lots of space! - Bars Near Me - Babylon, New York

the best bar on the island hands down ! great drinks and great atmosphere because it's ran by the kindest people it's a staple of the south shore not just babylon village and you are truly missing out if you don't go to mary's, side note they have the best food too and i highly recommend the disco fries with gravy (the best gravy i've ever had ) read more

I have lived in the area much of my life and have never been. It's a little dark inside, and it seems like you can be there at any time and find people at the bar. The bartender working was very nice to my girl and our friends, so the review is going to be a little rosier than it would normally be. Also, the nice weather and outdoor area were a big plus. It was crowded with a slightly rowdy crowd. A drunk mother laid down to pet a stranger's friendly dog out back. To sum it up, it's a place for a cheap drink. Take it for what it is. You like that, you will like it. read more

I will never go back to this place after this weekend. Bouncers from the start out their hands on one of my friends and when I stepped in to see what was going on, they grabbed me to throw me out the bar. The reason was they said my friend "looked drunk", when the guy was completely fine. The bouncer then tried to assault me and throw me out the bar when I decided to not let anything escalate and left the bar on my own. I was with 10 people that night sorry Mary Carrols but your tough guy fake cop bouncers cost you 10 customers in the future. Hope your paying them well cause that was a lot of money out your cash register. read more

I'm a regular here so I may be a bit biased but no joke I just had the best wings EVER. And the bartenders ROCK.

I've had better. (See my reviews of most other bars.) I've had worse. (See my review of the Mary Carroll's in Huntington.) read more