Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Matthew 25 Thrift Shop

    3.5 (8 reviews)

    Matthew 25 Thrift Shop Photos

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Matthew 25 Thrift Shop

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    12 days ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    4 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 1
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Maria D.
    101
    1122
    2669

    7 years ago

    Helpful 4
    Thanks 0
    Love this 4
    Oh no 1
    Photo of Jen R.
    6
    215
    53

    7 years ago

    Helpful 2
    Thanks 1
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    10 years ago

    Helpful 2
    Thanks 1
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    5 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 1
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    9 years ago

    Helpful 2
    Thanks 1
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    7 years ago

    Helpful 3
    Thanks 1
    Love this 0
    Oh no 1

    Ask the Community - Matthew 25 Thrift Shop

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Thrift Stores 2,960 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Jubilee Ministries

    Jubilee Ministries

    4.5(2 reviews)
    4.6 mi

    Great selection of clothes and vintage jewelry. They are wheelchair accessible. There are dressing…read morerooms. They sell household items as well. Good prices. They accept cash and cards. Service was good. I will get pictures and videos next time. Definitely going back.

    I'm a little peeved with myself right now. How is it that this wonderful little thrift shop is…read morenearly in my backyard and I didn't know? I'll never forgive myself. Maybe I was too preoccupied with the big box thrifts in the area; Community Aid, Salvation Army, and Goodwill to go out and explore those less known. Do yourself a favor - don't make my mistake! This little thrift store is full of treasures waiting to be discovered and supports a number of ministry projects. Easy to find off Route 72 and open till 8 pm most days this location in a residential neighborhood has its own lot. Inside you'll find displays that will rival any retail store window. The organization is thoughtfully arranged by color/size/garment and it's easy to find exactly what you're looking for. If you're a brand whore you won't be disappointed. I saw many Chico, Dress Barn, and even Michael Koors pieces, all in top notch condition. Several items still had tags attached. While their inventory isn't as plentiful as the big box thrift, it's ample. Quality and current trends were on point. Just like their Palmyra sister store the jewelry display is artfully arranged. Prices were fair. On average shirts ran from $3.99-$5.99, jeans and pants a bit higher. I scored a great pair of like new shoes for $3, Halloween items were just .25 cents apiece - regardless if it was a pair of funky glasses or a full blown costume. While there were only a few, it's worth checking out. Aside from ladies clothing which dominates the store you'll find a men's section, children's clothing, toys, housewares, a very small furniture dept. (with signs saying that area will be transformed into a Christmas area in the next few weeks), housewares, wicker, bric brack, books, + a small card & craft section. While I browsed soft music played overhead and the cashier was very eager to assist in any way she could to enhance your shopping experience. The two dressing rooms were clean, spacious, and had plenty of hooks. A 50% off coupon can be found in some of the weekly rural newspaper editions and they also offer different specials/sales events from time to time. They even accept returns on clothing only up to 14 days. Electronics are checked but you're encouraged to plug in and verify for yourself since they can't be returned. Donations are easy to unload at the dock and I overheard they welcome your donation of unwanted boxes and plastic bags. Now that I know they exist I'll be checking them out more often!

    Photos
    Jubilee Ministries
    Jubilee Ministries  - Some of my recent scores from Jubilee. Frame brand new $6.99, kids clothes only 25 cents each!!!

    Some of my recent scores from Jubilee. Frame brand new $6.99, kids clothes only 25 cents each!!!

    Jubilee Ministries

    See all

    The Salvation Army Thrift Store & Donation Center

    The Salvation Army Thrift Store & Donation Center

    3.2(32 reviews)
    6.7 mi
    $

    Standard Salvation Army. Has fitting rooms which is a nice perk. Fair prices. Friendly staff.read more

    First let me say, the employees here are always very nice. But this review is for the manager who…read moredoes the pricing specifically. I understand if you have to follow orders from corporate regarding pricing, but at some point being a willful concubine to the greed of a capitalist system wearing a mask of "doing the most good" must be taking a toll on you, right? Like you have to be aware of just how crazy you're being. Unless you've let the job bleed you dry of your baseline humanity to the point of utter apathy. Your pricing on certain items is absolutely insane! Like you're truly just out of your mind and should probably be heavily medicated. Out here acting like it's a premium antique store in the richest of neighborhoods instead of the THRIFT store that it's supposed to be. $150 for some glass coasters. $250 for an old stove. $500 for a Barbie house!?! These are all USED items that are GIVEN to you, a THRIFT store for FREE! And I understand there are operating costs of running the stores, but there's also a line that you're clearly way too comfortable crossing when it comes to the prices you put in front of every day thrift shoppers. During my visit I heard literally five customers make a remark about the insane prices you're slapping people in the face with. Read the damn room! Send this on up to your corporate masters if you truly don't have any control over your businesses pricing strategy because whether it's you or some higher managment forcing this twisted policy on the public, there's at least one ABSOLUTE PSYCHOPATH working for the Salvation Army and y'all need to know how it's making you look to the people you're supposedly in business to "help".

    Photos
    The Salvation Army Thrift Store & Donation Center
    The Salvation Army Thrift Store & Donation Center
    The Salvation Army Thrift Store & Donation Center

    See all

    Nearly-Nu Thrift Shop

    Nearly-Nu Thrift Shop

    3.0(1 review)
    4.8 mi

    I've passed this thrift store many times but never stopped in. It's right on the square and I…read moreassumed parking would be an issue so I never stopped. Recently I took a vacation day and was camping in the area and decided to check them out. Much to my surprise they have a private parking lot in the back. From the back entry there was a porch that had some free items that didn't meet their resale requirements. Inside was a vestibule with $1 clothing that had minor blemishes on. On the tags that I took the time to look at it was written what was wrong which I thought was nice. The deal of the day was ladies tops which were half off. Inside the shop I was greeted by two older ladies sitting at chairs chatting. The overall store is about the size of an efficiency apartment and is a very narrow space. The organization was done well and knick knacks were proudly displayed. There were probably about 8 customers in the tiny space, plus myself and the two clerks which felt like a crowd in such a narrow space. It was impossible to social distance. Ladies clothing and knick knacks dominated the store Children's clothing, toys, and housewares were very limited. While browsing the racks I did find several tops, all half off, as well as some jeans for $3. Prices were very reasonable. The dressing room is part of the bathroom, which seemed to also be a kitchen as it had a microwave in it, and also a toothbrush at the sink. Overall with the ladies sitting and talking at the entrance, to the personal items in the bathroom it felt like I was in someone's house. At that point I didn't know if this was a charity room thrift store, or just someone selling used, donated items for profit. However at the register they did have a sign showing how much money the store has donated to various charities over the years and it was impressive. When I told the cashier I can't believe there wasn't any Yelp reviews they had no idea what Yelp was! Probably not a regular stop for me during COVID due to the distancing aspect but worth checking out if you're not concerned.

    Photos
    Nearly-Nu Thrift Shop
    Nearly-Nu Thrift Shop - Welcome!!

    Welcome!!

    Nearly-Nu Thrift Shop

    See all

    Revive

    Revive

    4.0(1 review)
    7.0 mi

    I found out about Revive from a Facebook suggested page. I was surprised there was a thrift store…read morein downtown Ephrata that I knew nothing about considering I'm up there frequently. As per their Facebook page they are described as the owner had a dream to purchase property, have her own store, and provide affordable housing to women in need. This store is considered for profit, however she states that she uses the funds to renovate the upstairs apartments in hope to help women escape bad relationships by providing affordable housing options. I support her vision. I was lucky enough to visit the store a few weeks before Christmas when the parking meters were covered. Normally there's a fee for street parking however I'm not sure if it's because of the season or covid that street parking was free. It's a bit hard to secure downtown and difficult to back out of since the spots are slanted but not impossible. Inside the store has an overwhelming amount of stuff. Not quite hoarder level but there's alot to take in. The property is a series of small rooms, you walk thru one to get to another, with lots of nooks and crannies. It is a challenging space to set up for retail and she does what she can to make it organized. It is hard to walk thru some areas and definitely leave the stroller and big handbag at home! Some areas have nice displays and she does have a good eye for showcasing more precious items. Overall there's every department that a larger thrift store would have, just separated a bit. What surprised me was everything was yard sale prices - like .50 cents and a $1! While some of the clothing items were dated I did find some nice kids pieces that I couldn't leave without for .50 apiece! Many of the house and glasswear pieces were vintage and still priced at yard sale prices. I honestly don't know how she makes any money. On the porch was a free clothing pile which I didn't investigate. The owner was very friendly and let you walk around and explore on your own without being intrusive, but was available to help if you needed her. They are cash only so be sure to bring some and definitely allow yourself some time as this is not an in and out kind of shop. Worth adding to my thrifting rotation whenever parking is available.

    Photos
    Revive
    Revive
    Revive

    See all

    Purple Turtle Consignment Boutique

    Purple Turtle Consignment Boutique

    3.9(11 reviews)
    0.2 mi
    $$

    I have been shopping at Purple Turtle for well over 25 years. Most consignment shops come and go,…read morebut the longevity of this one speaks for itself. The selection is fantastic and everything is so organized. You are warmly welcomed when you enter the store and the sales people are so pleasant and helpful when you have questions regarding fashion. The value is second to none for high end brands and much of the merchandise is brand new with tags still on! I am often complimented on the way I dress and it's because I buy clothes at Purple Turtle that I could never afford at retail. Love this place!

    Third time I've tried to schedule an appointment over the last year to potentially consign nice…read morename brand items. Previous in store requests were months out. This time, in person, they can't schedule an appointment but I can come back Saturday (tomorrow) & then they can schedule an appointment. All that talk they could have just scheduled & never a thank you for my business. The way I was treated, If I wasn't white, I'd assume they were racist. I guess I don't look the way they want me to look? I heard them schedule an appointment while I was in the store with someone with a typical time frame. Don't waste your time unless maybe they already know you I guess. Maybe why their selection is so sad. Looks like a dodged a really large bullet reading a previous review with unable to get paid for sold items & get back their unsold items.

    Photos
    Purple Turtle Consignment Boutique - Just picked up this cute fleece (I think that's what it's called).  Actually, bought the skirt there too, over a year ago.

    See all

    Just picked up this cute fleece (I think that's what it's called). Actually, bought the skirt there too, over a year ago.

    Matthew 25 Thrift Shop - thrift_stores - Updated September 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...